tor-relays
Threads by month
- ----- 2025 -----
- May
- April
- March
- February
- January
- ----- 2024 -----
- December
- November
- October
- September
- August
- July
- June
- May
- April
- March
- February
- January
- ----- 2023 -----
- December
- November
- October
- September
- August
- July
- June
- May
- April
- March
- February
- January
- ----- 2022 -----
- December
- November
- October
- September
- August
- July
- June
- May
- April
- March
- February
- January
- ----- 2021 -----
- December
- November
- October
- September
- August
- July
- June
- May
- April
- March
- February
- January
- ----- 2020 -----
- December
- November
- October
- September
- August
- July
- June
- May
- April
- March
- February
- January
- ----- 2019 -----
- December
- November
- October
- September
- August
- July
- June
- May
- April
- March
- February
- January
- ----- 2018 -----
- December
- November
- October
- September
- August
- July
- June
- May
- April
- March
- February
- January
- ----- 2017 -----
- December
- November
- October
- September
- August
- July
- June
- May
- April
- March
- February
- January
- ----- 2016 -----
- December
- November
- October
- September
- August
- July
- June
- May
- April
- March
- February
- January
- ----- 2015 -----
- December
- November
- October
- September
- August
- July
- June
- May
- April
- March
- February
- January
- ----- 2014 -----
- December
- November
- October
- September
- August
- July
- June
- May
- April
- March
- February
- January
- ----- 2013 -----
- December
- November
- October
- September
- August
- July
- June
- May
- April
- March
- February
- January
- ----- 2012 -----
- December
- November
- October
- September
- August
- July
- June
- May
- April
- March
- February
- January
- ----- 2011 -----
- December
- November
- October
- September
- August
- July
- June
- May
- April
- March
- February
- 9 participants
- 4889 discussions
We are thinking of running a Tor Exit Node. Does anybody have a list
of questions to ask before purchasing a VPS or colocation? I came up
with some basic questions:
- Do you allow a Tor exit node? [with explanation]
- What are the policies for handling abuse complaints?
- How much uplink bandwidth do you provide?
Any other questions one should ask?
Thanks.
17
49

07 Oct '19
As previously written on 2019-09-03
https://lists.torproject.org/pipermail/tor-relays/2019-September/017711.html
the Tor directory authorities are about to remove
relays from the network if they run end-of-life versions of tor.
Here is the list of affected relays that will be **removed**
from the network as of **next week** unless they upgrade
to a supported version of tor.
A daily updated list can be found at:
https://nusenu.github.io/OrNetStats/eolrelays
If you find yourself on this list please update your tor version.
Data as of 2019-10-04 09:00 UTC
+------------------+---------------------+-----------------+--------------------------------------------------------------+
| consensus_weight | nickname | IP | contact |
+------------------+---------------------+-----------------+--------------------------------------------------------------+
| 192000 | Unnamed | 213.239.204.62 | NULL |
| 167000 | Unnamed | 144.76.107.124 | NULL |
| 164000 | Unnamed | 78.46.151.57 | NULL |
| 160000 | Unnamed | 136.243.69.205 | NULL |
| 150000 | Unnamed | 145.239.255.86 | NULL |
| 150000 | drjohn | 51.75.144.67 | NULL |
| 148000 | Unnamed | 136.243.131.29 | NULL |
| 147000 | SergeiK | 95.154.221.3 | NULL |
| 140000 | privacypte | 51.75.144.69 | NULL |
| 131000 | cryptocrax0r | 51.75.144.68 | NULL |
| 130000 | manningftw | 145.239.6.188 | NULL |
| 130000 | martinsrelay | 54.36.164.176 | NULL |
| 130000 | Unnamed | 51.68.206.35 | NULL |
| 125000 | torrelay01 | 78.129.150.54 | NULL |
| 124000 | BigBen | 95.154.221.4 | NULL |
| 123000 | privacyguardian | 51.68.206.28 | NULL |
| 123000 | sheldon | 95.154.221.6 | NULL |
| 121000 | Unnamed | 136.243.39.148 | NULL |
| 120000 | skywalker | 78.129.150.72 | NULL |
| 117000 | Unnamed | 78.129.150.63 | NULL |
| 117000 | drakeforce1 | 145.239.6.189 | NULL |
| 111000 | z0rb4l2 | 148.251.11.21 | 1Q5fZnsG5BSizXmJbrq8FsACnd6kSTBju7 |
| 110000 | Unnamed | 148.251.51.66 | NULL |
| 110000 | Unnamed | 78.129.150.83 | NULL |
| 110000 | Unnamed | 176.9.92.184 | NULL |
| 110000 | Unnamed | 144.76.79.84 | NULL |
| 110000 | UbuntuTor | 95.154.221.2 | NULL |
| 110000 | Unnamed | 136.243.82.132 | NULL |
| 109000 | Unnamed | 78.129.180.14 | NULL |
| 107000 | Unnamed | 5.9.148.164 | NULL |
| 103000 | Unnamed | 78.46.79.4 | NULL |
| 101000 | m247 | 89.238.128.124 | NULL |
| 99000 | Freiheit | 144.76.57.165 | NULL |
| 94000 | Bananenbakker | 192.42.132.106 | IP-Eend <tor AT ip-eend dot nl> |
| 91100 | Unnamed | 176.9.46.72 | NULL |
| 83000 | Unnamed | 34.241.138.212 | NULL |
| 82500 | AliceInWunderland | 5.9.143.167 | NULL |
| 77000 | Unnamed | 144.76.61.209 | NULL |
| 74800 | as44194a36s01 | 77.87.50.6 | NULL |
| 74500 | as44194l10502 | 77.87.49.6 | NULL |
| 70000 | drachenklaue | 94.130.68.230 | tor(a)alexdpsg.net |
| 70000 | VivaLuxx | 91.121.224.10 | NULL |
| 68000 | GothamsPlanet | 79.137.112.4 | NULL |
| 64400 | TheDarkLord | 79.137.106.154 | NULL |
| 64000 | as44194l10501 | 77.87.49.6 | NULL |
| 59000 | Unnamed | 78.129.186.88 | NULL |
| 58400 | Unnamed | 95.154.194.110 | NULL |
| 54000 | locksat | 62.210.93.142 | Boris Nagaev <bnagaev(a)gmail.com> |
| 52000 | Unnamed | 176.9.92.102 | NULL |
| 50200 | TorMeSoftly | 79.137.112.5 | NULL |
| 49400 | Alienzone | 213.32.119.219 | NULL |
| 48000 | Unnamed | 176.9.92.102 | NULL |
| 44000 | Fithnovember | 79.137.116.43 | NULL |
| 43500 | Unnamed | 159.69.93.175 | NULL |
| 42000 | jacktheripper | 167.114.35.107 | NULL |
| 41000 | Unnamed | 91.211.247.247 | NULL |
| 41000 | bongocarl | 85.214.86.123 | NULL |
| 37000 | Unnamed | 91.211.247.246 | NULL |
| 35000 | Default | 79.137.69.3 | NULL |
| 35000 | versailles1 | 78.129.208.40 | NULL |
| 34000 | Torrelay8967573 | 94.16.112.123 | Jan.kaerger.jkr(a)gmail.com |
| 33000 | circusdirector | 167.114.219.61 | NULL |
| 32800 | Unnamed | 87.117.247.6 | NULL |
| 32000 | freedomtower01 | 167.114.35.102 | NULL |
| 31100 | vr241tor | 89.144.12.17 | NULL |
| 31000 | manningisfree | 78.129.208.184 | NULL |
| 29600 | watchthewatcher | 87.117.247.207 | NULL |
| 29000 | Unnamed | 130.225.254.103 | staff(a)dotsrc.org |
| 28700 | Unnamed | 109.169.86.118 | NULL |
| 27700 | Unnamed | 130.225.254.103 | staff(a)dotsrc.org |
| 27200 | hellzone | 149.56.25.84 | NULL |
| 26000 | servbr9 | 137.74.40.76 | Servbr Admin <servbr [AT] mail [DOT] md> |
| 24000 | Default | 79.137.68.107 | NULL |
| 24000 | Rebel | 51.68.170.247 | NULL |
| 23200 | bigboss99 | 87.120.36.157 | NULL |
| 22500 | Relay751 | 137.74.112.46 | Donate : 1BcGs8GAJwVQ6BpTN9BtRcKvGWzLnmcXwK |
| 22400 | KarmaCorner | 37.252.187.172 | admin(a)dornercorner.com |
| 22100 | freedomnet51 | 51.158.173.218 | freedomnet51(a)reelnetwork.eu |
| 22000 | Arrow | 51.68.185.141 | NULL |
| 22000 | Unnamed | 107.170.113.212 | NULL |
| 21800 | ServbrNuremberg | 51.75.68.24 | NULL |
| 21000 | servbr7 | 193.70.43.102 | Servbr Admin <servbr [AT] mail [DOT] md> |
| 20800 | dvbhorst | 195.201.138.156 | horst(a)faust-home.de |
| 20500 | ServbrDusseldorf | 54.37.74.60 | NULL |
| 20000 | servbr8 | 91.134.140.21 | Servbr Admin <servbr [AT] mail [DOT] md> |
| 20000 | voidray | 163.172.56.248 | tor(at)0day.rocks |
| 19300 | servbr10 | 193.70.43.20 | Servbr Admin <servbr [AT] mail [DOT] md> |
| 19300 | ServbrRome | 145.239.76.11 | NULL |
| 18600 | H4ck3rm4n0m3g4 | 173.212.226.76 | tor AT renz DOT cloud |
| 18600 | wonderland | 94.130.186.49 | NULL |
| 18400 | Chief | 145.239.0.204 | NULL |
| 18200 | VocbulrySlogn | 45.76.134.212 | NULL |
| 18200 | ServbrMunich | 51.75.68.7 | NULL |
| 18000 | Pipi | 54.37.207.84 | NULL |
| 18000 | ServbrStuttgart | 51.38.112.240 | NULL |
| 18000 | toryimby123 | 51.15.59.115 | NULL |
| 18000 | courage | 94.16.123.169 | NULL |
| 18000 | ididnteditheconfig | 95.211.214.150 | NULL |
| 18000 | servbr6 | 79.137.33.131 | Servbr Admin <servbr [AT] mail [DOT] md> |
| 17500 | bettyrootTorRelay4 | 79.137.85.71 | NULL |
| 17000 | mcrelay | 46.38.234.52 | Marvin Moloczek <tor(a)moloczek.com> |
| 17000 | borderline | 178.32.47.140 | NULL |
| 17000 | Killer | 51.68.170.74 | NULL |
| 17000 | Phillipus2 | 91.106.132.151 | 345345455675675(at)byom(dot)de [tor-relay.co] |
| 16800 | ServbrQuebec | 142.44.243.241 | NULL |
| 16400 | lehlbauern | 173.249.25.217 | tor [at] skeeerus [dot] club [tor-relay.co] |
| 16400 | foertel1 | 95.216.145.16 | 0xF85959ECB7238802 foertel <mehl(a)foertel.com> |
| 16300 | coconuts | 80.241.213.86 | NULL |
| 16000 | servbr4 | 37.59.108.97 | Servbr Admin <servbr [AT] mail [DOT] md> |
| 16000 | MS3cTOR621 | 158.69.212.109 | NULL |
| 16000 | ENC0c210f748b604128 | 212.129.57.254 | Itzhak Daniel <itzhak+tor(a)itk98.net> |
| 15900 | servbr12 | 54.37.74.139 | Servbr Admin <servbr [AT] mail [DOT] md> |
| 15400 | BadAx0r | 149.202.170.60 | tor(a)meriot.fr |
| 15300 | VCS | 144.217.13.141 | NULL |
| 15300 | servbr5 | 51.255.203.235 | Servbr Admin <servbr [AT] mail [DOT] md> |
| 15000 | MS3c491 | 144.217.90.68 | NULL |
| 15000 | iotator | 173.249.19.206 | NULL |
| 15000 | Beauty | 51.75.153.17 | NULL |
| 14800 | idabwells | 5.189.138.9 | <idabwells AT systemli dot org> |
| 14400 | ninov1 | 94.16.114.105 | nino [dash] tor [at] ninov [dot] de (gpg B8D657E6343B295AE4C |
| 14200 | stormwind | 178.132.0.6 | NULL |
| 14100 | polisen1 | 165.22.86.8 | sanderp(a)lavabit.com |
| 14100 | Cyberman | 51.15.73.133 | Torchwood <contact [at] pakitow [dot] eu> |
| 14000 | torhole | 188.165.5.14 | NULL |
| 14000 | Butch | 51.75.82.166 | NULL |
| 14000 | Ms3cTor88 | 54.39.148.232 | NULL |
| 14000 | Dazzle | 54.37.207.82 | NULL |
| 13800 | Blazer218 | 144.76.92.176 | Igel <Igel(a)Hyperboria.ca> |
| 13700 | Unnamed | 185.21.100.163 | NULL |
| 13600 | MS3cTOR493 | 54.39.148.233 | NULL |
| 13500 | VERITAS | 18.25.133.37 | 0xA711D81A m_price-at-mit-dot-edu 12fymnTuJsMEgUeRKUsGqckS3j |
| 13000 | ggggg2 | 46.4.174.52 | hannesexner91+tor(a)googlemail.com |
| 13000 | MS3c490 | 158.69.217.87 | NULL |
| 13000 | fury | 51.15.73.97 | NULL |
| 13000 | MS3c494 | 54.39.148.234 | NULL |
| 13000 | Dash | 54.37.200.155 | NULL |
| 13000 | olympushasfallen | 188.165.138.6 | NULL |
| 13000 | Servify1 | 178.78.192.88 | tor(a)servify.se |
| 12500 | rogemedic | 208.38.243.113 | Rogemedic <admin(a)waltersnet.noip.us> |
| 12400 | Unnamed | 62.141.41.110 | NULL |
| 12400 | MS3cTOR526 | 144.217.166.19 | NULL |
| 12300 | NewYorkInternet0 | 63.165.242.42 | NULL |
| 12200 | MS3cTOR528 | 144.217.166.59 | NULL |
| 12200 | OurHelperForU | 109.74.11.81 | isorry(a)no.no |
| 12200 | MS3cTOR527 | 144.217.166.26 | NULL |
| 12100 | o9k | 136.243.243.6 | tor a.t o9k d.o.t cc - 18HDgR3KrfqQUxiW9tL4w5XdutmdW44BY6 |
| 12000 | toracy | 144.217.15.164 | NULL |
| 12000 | mrtjay | 188.165.19.61 | NULL |
| 12000 | ServbrCalgary | 192.99.245.76 | NULL |
| 12000 | MS3cTOR525 | 144.217.165.223 | NULL |
| 12000 | NewYorkInternet1 | 63.165.242.34 | NULL |
| 11700 | Cicolina | 46.229.238.172 | root(a)cicolina.org |
| 11700 | trumpnetwork | 188.165.28.152 | NULL |
| 11700 | ratni | 37.187.103.213 | Pierre <pierre+tor at ratni dot v4v dot be> |
| 11600 | RiverRaid | 192.99.245.119 | NULL |
| 11600 | Dyonisius | 185.61.149.173 | NULL |
| 11300 | BABELFISH | 185.248.160.65 | ronald.dunno(a)mail.ru |
| 11100 | finn | 87.98.245.84 | 0x112CA89F scholzi100 <tor(a)scholzi100.de> 1436DgS4kboHciWPp4 |
| 11000 | AMMIT911 | 209.250.230.247 | NULL |
| 11000 | KD8HLN | 158.69.222.218 | Kd8hln.com Jeffschefke(a)gmail.com |
| 11000 | DarkOVH | 151.80.147.153 | julles.reneau(a)post.com |
| 11000 | fredTorrefactor | 37.187.102.5 | rhfred(a)disroot.org |
| 11000 | Srv1MuchRelay | 173.249.3.81 | ohello(a)tuta.io |
| 11000 | MS3cTOR524 | 144.217.7.154 | NULL |
| 10800 | MS3cTOR200 | 158.69.113.76 | NULL |
| 10700 | PieceOfShitSrv | 144.76.165.201 | ${CONTACT_GPG_FINGERPRINT} ${CONTACT_NAME} ${CONTACT_EMAIL} |
| 10600 | easyrider | 51.83.47.110 | NULL |
| 10500 | StealthSTOSE | 213.64.65.106 | NULL |
| 10400 | TORdashRELAYdotUS | 50.21.183.46 | support @ TORdashRELAYdotUS |
| 10100 | bennobaksteen | 37.187.115.47 | NULL |
| 10000 | madnight | 195.201.103.59 | madnight madnight <danon(a)gmx.de> |
| 10000 | Ms3cTOR621 | 158.69.212.107 | NULL |
| 10000 | Shrimp | 51.75.153.19 | NULL |
| 10000 | myNiceRelay | 172.98.77.212 | lagartobostero(a)hotmail.com |
| 9740 | Rocket147 | 167.114.113.134 | <pdestor(a)lelantos.org> |
| 9500 | ankerman | 51.38.107.117 | NULL |
| 9490 | kuazal8 | 173.249.44.27 | alexkovalev(dot)1990(at)mail(dot)ru [tor-relay.co] |
| 9420 | Servify4 | 178.78.192.89 | tor(a)servify.se |
| 9270 | Digger | 54.37.200.157 | NULL |
| 9220 | Servify3 | 178.78.192.89 | tor(a)servify.se |
| 9220 | Perseus | 185.86.150.214 | NULL |
| 9140 | hosTor2 | 104.236.92.66 | NULL |
| 8940 | Smasher | 51.68.186.59 | NULL |
| 8900 | Metis | 5.135.186.73 | 0xBE6B3636 walafc0 <tor AT walafc0 dot orgy minus the y> |
| 8700 | default | 161.97.195.50 | NULL |
| 8700 | Geoff2 | 178.254.31.125 | tor at cybercyber dot wtf |
| 8600 | deinemudda | 163.172.213.201 | 0xB3AC4F40BC396055 Stephan Henrichs <stiepen <twentytwo as n |
| 8540 | jabbenbabben | 88.206.149.198 | jabbenbabben(a)gmail.com |
| 8490 | Unnamed | 192.99.63.44 | NULL |
| 8410 | proteus | 51.77.150.255 | NULL |
| 8370 | Spurjo | 194.34.134.115 | purjosipuli(at)airmail(dot)cc |
| 8350 | ExpressSktebord | 45.77.69.166 | NULL |
| 8350 | alchimist | 137.74.189.95 | NULL |
| 8200 | theboss | 94.23.173.93 | NULL |
| 8130 | Ms3cTOR57 | 167.114.185.246 | NULL |
| 8100 | MkoTorRelayMiddle | 109.239.49.192 | m-ko dev(a)m-ko.de |
| 8060 | beefyboi | 81.171.29.146 | holdmybeertor(a)protonmail.com |
| 7900 | tjwtechsvr1 | 195.154.165.64 | 0xECDFEA8B27994D63 Timothy Werner <timothy (@T) tjw (D0T) mo |
| 7800 | Buster | 54.37.207.37 | NULL |
| 7710 | PutoElQueLee293884 | 50.39.175.88 | NULL |
| 7710 | hosTor1 | 104.236.93.66 | NULL |
| 7700 | wjbrelay | 192.155.88.116 | NULL |
| 7590 | romaniaBEST52 | 198.50.159.82 | romaleromane67(at)gmail(dot)com [tor-relay.co] |
| 7500 | Unnamed | 51.15.112.209 | NULL |
| 7450 | RARvolt | 145.239.89.186 | Anonymous |
| 7410 | Pitch | 51.38.107.122 | NULL |
| 7300 | nostradamus | 51.75.143.241 | NULL |
| 7260 | Unnamed | 62.115.168.177 | NULL |
| 7230 | biscoint | 159.89.135.134 | Anonymous |
| 7200 | gratinee | 173.213.108.116 | Joe Gratz <firstname AT firstnamelastname dot net> |
| 7200 | DockerTorrelay | 185.35.200.250 | Anonymous |
| 7200 | icosadev | 192.184.81.117 | ICOSADEV TOR <icosadev(a)gmail.com> |
| 7190 | dr4kster | 195.210.28.72 | dopice(a)mailinator.com |
| 7170 | Unnamed | 83.220.174.128 | NULL |
| 6900 | Landslide | 51.75.85.114 | NULL |
| 6890 | einsteinmaxwell | 46.38.238.209 | human(a)google.com |
| 6870 | Shade | 51.68.182.30 | NULL |
| 6740 | casalserugo | 37.187.180.112 | Anonima Casalserugo <anonima.casalserugo(a)gmail.com> |
| 6620 | london742 | 95.216.140.157 | edgar.tor.uk(a)gmail.com |
| 6600 | whatthedeuce | 149.56.141.15 | NULL |
| 6500 | Memo | 145.239.1.97 | NULL |
| 6460 | dsfknvdsz | 46.4.25.214 | NULL |
| 6390 | bahamut | 173.255.221.96 | Tor Daemon <tor AT 4cloure dot com> |
| 6380 | 00was00 | 78.142.19.43 | was.small(a)was.info |
| 6300 | Geoff4 | 31.31.74.177 | tor at cybercyber dot wtf |
| 6260 | Unnamed | 37.120.184.242 | NULL |
| 6200 | lewwerDuarUesSlaav | 91.219.237.244 | Administrator admin(a)tor-hu.neuromorph.de |
| 6120 | Unnamed | 85.217.171.231 | NULL |
| 6070 | kellogs | 51.75.65.10 | NULL |
| 6030 | Unnamed | 84.203.103.5 | NULL |
| 6000 | frcy | 85.10.243.199 | srv at frcy dot org |
| 5800 | jumpnet | 199.127.226.150 | www.tocici.com <nospam AT tocici dot com> |
| 5600 | anonkaisx | 151.80.115.180 | Kai <anon AT kai dot sx> |
| 5590 | c17h13cln4 | 50.116.7.186 | NULL |
| 5560 | jooVa1mi | 188.116.152.7 | NULL |
| 5510 | pbx | 94.140.116.167 | tor(a)remus.be |
| 5490 | piecoopdotnet | 74.82.47.194 | amuse <tor-amuse%foofus.com> |
| 5400 | Hank | 137.74.25.175 | Random Person <489f0b2d at opayq dot com> |
| 5380 | somerandomguyontor | 64.180.147.227 | NULL |
| 5350 | NeutrlConcept | 149.248.4.19 | NULL |
| 5210 | BlaGlobal2 | 188.120.243.32 | NULL |
| 5200 | Apollo | 162.213.3.221 | <hostmaster at denetron dot com> |
| 5110 | hiddenRussia | 188.243.68.220 | Random Person <host(a)m7a.ru> |
| 4900 | thedoctor | 192.44.30.40 | network at aisec dot fraunhofer dot de |
| 4900 | frell2 | 85.10.240.250 | remops(a)frell.theremailer.net |
| 4800 | eax | 50.116.42.245 | Ehsan Akhgari <ehsan dot akhgari at gmail dot com> |
| 4730 | sentinel | 147.232.191.48 | NULL |
| 4670 | tptor | 91.198.212.250 | NULL |
| 4620 | Geoff3 | 178.254.9.25 | tor at cybercyber dot wtf |
| 4470 | glorpSfo01 | 165.227.63.218 | via ProtonMail: glorp-relays |
| 4470 | Konsul13 | 91.67.4.195 | Mark H <mark.h AT web dot de> |
| 4440 | HackThisSite | 198.148.81.167 | HackThisSite.org |
| 4400 | DooTooFooBeafKnight | 213.239.214.13 | 0xE3252A69 doo.toofoo.beaf(a)protonmail.com |
| 4400 | daddycool | 54.39.148.129 | NULL |
| 4250 | InnovateTor | 212.47.230.49 | Maarten Eyskens <maarten AT innovatete dot ch> |
| 4200 | druid | 51.38.162.232 | blackdruid(a)mail.ee |
| 4200 | SAPTORNET02 | 51.38.83.228 | torrbox(a)saplingservers.net |
| 4030 | rainbownerds01 | 163.172.216.195 | Rainbownerds.de <admins (a) rainbownerds.de |
| 3800 | piriti | 204.13.164.107 | nocat(a)readthefinemanual.net |
| 3720 | ENC772461607de21c13 | 178.17.171.114 | Itzhak Daniel <itzhak+tor(a)itk98.net> |
| 3670 | ephemera | 95.216.1.161 | Thingy McThingFace <simon dot detheridge thingy g mail dot c |
| 3640 | FastTorServer | 84.53.192.243 | admin.ru |
| 3590 | lifeisabitch | 54.39.202.202 | NULL |
| 3580 | dokachin | 217.88.183.36 | Klim Dokachin <dokachin AT drwmeier dot de> |
| 3570 | ruselzusel | 79.207.77.72 | <ruselzusel AT gmail . com> |
| 3500 | MYLEX | 77.123.42.148 | NULL |
| 3470 | Unnamed | 199.127.226.61 | NULL |
| 3370 | Unnamed | 62.214.6.61 | NULL |
| 3350 | confidantmail02 | 71.165.151.35 | NULL |
| 3240 | torpidsNLserverius | 217.12.208.117 | torpids AT yahoo dot com - 1JYHfzVFVD7n2Sezz3DEHDFgGYjQWpDjq |
| 3200 | an0nym4theworld | 46.92.100.243 | NULL |
| 3190 | ThankYouEdSnowden | 104.131.149.84 | Scott Maxwell tor-contact-2015 (at) scottmaxwell (dot) org |
| 3170 | hackeriet | 185.35.202.221 | 0xdf0c3d316b7312d5 Alexander Kj\u00E4ll <alexander.kjall@gma |
| 3110 | obsd4atorrelay | 213.246.39.160 | obsd4aadmins <tor(a)obsd4a.net> |
| 3100 | Refogado | 93.108.197.92 | ga5cn0fn8ag6p11 12KSBXGhXYbQRdYhsZeUUMtBLoRQDNw37x |
| 3060 | SatoshiNakamoto | 87.247.111.222 | tomas.vanagas(a)knf.vu.lt [tor-relay.co] |
| 3030 | corsair626 | 79.120.85.102 | NULL |
| 3000 | guy1 | 96.126.122.166 | tor-relay(a)guy.net.au - 1FjYCQjLAnSMrXYxNNAFg3dugGdGboZeQ4 |
| 2910 | gordonkeybag | 91.229.20.27 | admin <tor {at] rault [POINT) me> |
| 2800 | zarvoxrelay | 192.241.233.203 | tor(a)zarvox.org |
| 2800 | Mercury | 162.213.0.243 | <hostmaster at denetron dot com> |
| 2770 | marchenr49 | 86.212.5.200 | NULL |
| 2740 | a1on | 68.129.25.138 | NULL |
| 2540 | NL1coxuEU | 5.2.67.84 | torrelays rem sh |
| 2440 | Dsystems | 217.252.178.126 | dirdante <tor2 at d-systems dot us> |
| 2430 | chanet | 104.251.250.115 | Random Person <gmail timmmmmmmmmy> |
| 2420 | RonDavis | 213.136.82.192 | NULL |
| 2400 | runninglizard | 89.191.217.1 | NULL |
| 2380 | hacktheplanet | 62.133.157.139 | ${CONTACT_GPG_FINGERPRINT} ${CONTACT_NAME} ${CONTACT_EMAIL} |
| 2380 | Unnamed | 178.207.139.146 | NULL |
| 2290 | DidItLateButNow42 | 62.72.82.222 | fn(a)radio-do.de |
| 2260 | default | 79.126.49.177 | torrelayowner-at-torbox3uiot6wchz.onion |
| 2180 | stickmanRelayKing | 193.148.69.109 | Antonio Maia <antonio.maia(a)protonmail.com> |
| 2150 | rat | 92.55.0.224 | NULL |
| 2130 | PartitoPirata | 178.62.186.155 | Info Partito Pirata <info AT partito-pirata dot it> |
| 2110 | default | 84.28.195.216 | NULL |
| 2100 | doofenschmirtz | 173.249.2.224 | halloanjedendenichkenne(a)gmail.com |
| 2100 | CastleWyvern994 | 80.86.83.11 | castlewyvern994 nightstone com |
| 2100 | Waldo | 104.186.12.32 | waldoDOTrelayATgmailDOTcom |
| 2100 | Cerebro | 85.17.194.180 | NULL |
| 2060 | halah | 80.211.211.235 | lidel <lidel AT lidel dot org> |
| 2050 | k0nslNET10 | 192.138.210.125 | 0x36A56A72 k0nsl <i.am(a)k0nsl.org> |
| 2020 | Tor4ahmeacee | 37.134.99.4 | NULL |
| 2000 | dragonfly | 192.99.13.48 | <contact AT libellules dot eu> |
| 1990 | AMMIT900 | 45.77.104.79 | NULL |
| 1950 | torstejaude | 178.63.116.157 | 0x7137AB4C Stephan Jauernick info(a)stephan-jauernick.de |
| 1940 | SCCOnion | 216.186.250.53 | SCC TOR Support <tor(a)stonycreek.chruch> |
| 1900 | ieditedtheconfig | 84.52.252.183 | Random Person <random AT person dot com> |
| 1800 | MegaRobotMecha | 45.79.92.94 | NULL |
| 1730 | freespeech4thedumb3 | 46.4.111.124 | @kosjoli |
| 1710 | Unnamed | 79.164.233.222 | NULL |
| 1700 | CountlessScarecrows | 91.219.236.250 | 0x309F635DAD1B5517 |
| 1620 | Morerelays | 92.34.152.239 | oskar_e(a)live.se |
| 1600 | fnordfnordfnordN998 | 85.214.236.207 | NULL |
| 1530 | ThatTorRelay | 23.239.22.19 | NULL |
| 1510 | cryptonanus | 80.211.192.151 | Ignitus Cryptonanus <cryptonanus AT protonmail dot com> |
| 1500 | endthefed | 46.165.253.199 | NULL |
| 1450 | niccokunzmann | 80.144.9.4 | https://niccokunzmann.github.io |
| 1430 | AgentOrange | 138.68.15.191 | AgentOrange - 19a2T2eX2QkzGxLmAr4TgoJ91pRJHMSBNp |
| 1430 | Unnamed | 199.193.14.77 | NULL |
| 1420 | SPFCFutebol | 81.17.60.24 | NULL |
| 1400 | Unnamed | 199.193.14.86 | NULL |
| 1400 | gulfdriverdan | 162.243.55.203 | tor [at] driverdan [dothere] com - 17ds28jqSFog1pV7N52vRVhPx |
| 1390 | cryptonanus | 5.249.148.182 | Ignitus Cryptonanus <cryptonanus AT protonmail dot com> |
| 1390 | kulcosictor3tag | 193.190.168.49 | Fan Yang <fan.yang2 AT student.kuleuven.be> |
| 1390 | Phillipus | 31.16.138.23 | no(at)contact(dot)com [tor-relay.co] |
| 1330 | PArelayPIT | 72.95.140.251 | NULL |
| 1310 | flaxindymedia | 66.175.221.24 | NULL |
| 1310 | BjPhviaXjv | 51.15.56.101 | NULL |
| 1300 | Thoreau | 66.155.4.213 | NULL |
| 1300 | AMMIT999 | 209.250.230.247 | NULL |
| 1300 | versiooff | 94.100.23.26 | NULL |
| 1300 | heavymetalnode | 89.245.7.22 | Random Person mail AT andrejakob dot de |
| 1300 | UnicornOrbotRelay | 84.138.59.79 | NULL |
| 1290 | london743 | 80.211.186.237 | edgar.tor.uk(a)gmail.com |
| 1290 | SpaceJam | 139.162.245.120 | NULL |
| 1270 | fructose14ellipsix | 69.164.214.250 | 5C76DAB2 David Zaslavsky <diazona(a)ellipsix.net> |
| 1230 | jdvnsjfnHBDkScf | 94.140.120.130 | jfghjgsdjghdsjgf(a)jabber.ccc.de |
| 1210 | Clevinger | 45.55.167.33 | NULL |
| 1200 | poildortie | 37.187.20.79 | Poildortie <poildortie AT gmail dot com> |
| 1200 | rocky | 46.28.68.157 | NULL |
| 1190 | Tor4shooreph | 87.140.21.102 | NULL |
| 1180 | EdDySnOwdEn | 176.9.54.142 | 0x7BF3AFF7 Halabalusa <tor AT halabalusa dot de> |
| 1170 | mort | 83.149.125.193 | NULL |
| 1170 | hightfreuiop | 144.217.65.215 | NULL |
| 1140 | supr4s | 5.135.183.210 | supr4s(a)protonmail.com |
| 1140 | Unnamed | 87.93.17.39 | NULL |
| 1130 | RunningOnFumes4 | 185.61.148.189 | NULL |
| 1120 | Nana | 167.114.103.19 | cstdenis <cstdenis AT ctgameinfo dot com> |
| 1120 | nissan | 217.64.127.174 | NULL |
| 1120 | managermanager | 95.183.55.53 | NULL |
| 1110 | Unnamed | 80.211.184.112 | NULL |
| 1100 | default | 96.253.48.129 | NULL |
| 1100 | gyuhgyug | 46.4.81.49 | NULL |
| 1100 | maltose15ellipsix | 104.237.156.214 | 5C76DAB2 David Zaslavsky <diazona(a)ellipsix.net> |
| 1100 | rottor | 192.95.25.202 | BM-2cWgYGXDaxrxohMfixvRgrPCh7RK15fAt4(a)bitmessage.ch |
| 1100 | greengreen | 5.255.82.75 | NULL |
| 1100 | toastworld | 79.140.41.117 | tor <INSERT AT SIGN HERE> toastworld.org |
| 1090 | Unnamed | 93.66.61.36 | 410b1cf207127127600d8b62b6815ebb <none(a)none.no> |
| 1080 | greybig | 185.25.48.157 | NULL |
| 1070 | Ubuntu | 146.0.32.62 | NULL |
| 1070 | mordor | 176.123.10.42 | NULL |
| 1070 | kolben | 178.63.65.179 | 0xFADF79F8 Peter McColgan <petermccolgan0 AT gmail dot com> |
| 1060 | HorstHanfblatt | 5.189.146.133 | NULL |
| 1060 | lamplamp | 46.166.162.34 | NULL |
| 1060 | Unnamed | 85.214.56.180 | NULL |
| 1050 | idaoberstein | 78.55.168.18 | NULL |
| 1050 | idideditheconfig | 83.212.105.144 | NULL |
| 1020 | Voyager | 72.5.72.227 | <hostmaster at denetron dot com> |
| 1010 | cat | 217.12.204.174 | NULL |
| 1000 | unili83682 | 51.158.76.119 | unili83682 at gmail.com |
| 1000 | sterntor | 5.9.171.38 | tor AT static.38.171.9.5.clients.your-server.de |
| 1000 | bask | 46.28.64.234 | NULL |
| 970 | Ograoum | 51.254.208.245 | tor(a)eb4.be |
| 958 | ecramrelay1 | 143.106.60.86 | ecram <ecram(a)mail2tor.com> |
| 943 | hamzelot | 92.218.60.69 | NULL |
| 940 | norco | 176.107.185.22 | NULL |
| 930 | Viscofresh05 | 145.53.186.90 | NULL |
| 925 | loli | 37.187.30.2 | NULL |
| 924 | lalanons | 87.227.174.178 | ${CONTACT_GPG_FINGERPRINT} ${CONTACT_NAME} ${CONTACT_EMAIL} |
| 923 | bisi | 89.238.178.238 | NULL |
| 910 | Potatoe | 139.162.232.28 | NULL |
| 910 | auoireafealkj | 82.128.137.60 | NULL |
| 910 | doby | 91.236.116.88 | NULL |
| 900 | marlin | 89.238.178.122 | NULL |
| 893 | cort | 91.203.147.165 | NULL |
| 889 | Kronos | 85.17.112.32 | NULL |
| 883 | rthyz | 217.20.112.213 | NULL |
| 882 | Astro | 85.17.112.163 | NULL |
| 880 | Unnamed | 108.61.182.74 | NULL |
| 880 | Tor4xohnuvae | 80.211.183.59 | NULL |
| 878 | Hagbard | 5.9.58.137 | 0x54A6F17E Georg <georg AT dichterdenker dot de> |
| 870 | finder | 82.221.131.59 | NULL |
| 870 | somerelay | 185.81.109.2 | NULL |
| 864 | gorn | 46.28.69.53 | NULL |
| 862 | Unnamed | 185.32.160.22 | NULL |
| 862 | lkjhgfdsa | 149.255.35.242 | NULL |
| 842 | Unnamed | 199.231.85.122 | NULL |
| 840 | ExitTNode2 | 5.34.183.105 | NULL |
| 830 | default | 93.197.236.236 | NULL |
| 820 | imnotarelay | 195.176.247.88 | hagc187(a)protonmail.com |
| 790 | kulcosictor | 193.190.168.53 | gacar(a)esat.kuleuven.be |
| 779 | nukeafricapls | 85.204.246.217 | inet bro 0xA8F3C90E <bro(a)freihera.us> |
| 773 | morgrelay | 88.75.80.244 | morgan(a)roderick.dk |
| 759 | bleckbox | 37.59.40.193 | Mynameis Nobody <bleckbox \u00E4t ouvaton dodt org> |
| 744 | ididnteditheconfig | 77.6.219.27 | 0xFFFFFFFF Random Person <nobody AT example dot com> |
| 742 | vultureBlack | 45.63.68.229 | vultureblack(a)protonmail.com |
| 740 | BlargServer2018 | 142.93.168.48 | NULL |
| 736 | Unnamed | 109.236.88.9 | NULL |
| 710 | manning | 47.188.193.181 | NULL |
| 707 | Nightosphere | 84.128.210.94 | none |
| 707 | nyr89 | 185.185.40.111 | nyr89(a)gmail.com |
| 686 | Unnamed | 69.164.221.65 | NULL |
| 662 | Unnamed | 59.106.220.248 | NULL |
| 660 | theiF9veephuf3ah | 94.23.18.169 | NULL |
| 645 | clifford | 97.107.138.68 | Tor Admin <tor atsignhere redvw com> |
| 640 | Torrible | 45.79.218.205 | NULL |
| 639 | SaruTorIruka | 128.199.131.168 | DannyAAMtw <tor AT saru dot moe> |
| 620 | herbst | 5.9.253.234 | 2048g/C626BC50 Sebastian Krohn <seb(a)darksystem.net> |
| 610 | accordant | 95.211.160.148 | NULL |
| 607 | sysadminrevolution | 207.6.249.192 | NULL |
| 590 | Cookie | 188.166.255.192 | NULL |
| 590 | rickmorty16 | 107.170.193.14 | NULL |
| 572 | EwigeBlumenkraft | 89.245.122.244 | NULL |
| 570 | bl1 | 139.59.10.242 | NULL |
| 562 | FieTor | 92.214.175.184 | NULL |
| 560 | brianpuccio | 198.74.56.191 | 0x1E84A9E4 Brian Puccio <brian AT brianpuccio dot net> |
| 559 | cobungo | 87.106.14.159 | Admin <root AT cobungo.de> |
| 550 | GLaDOS | 85.17.214.177 | NULL |
| 543 | TWCUGRelayNode3 | 128.199.104.226 | tor (at) wittmann (minus) it (minus) security (dot) org [tor |
| 530 | tor7andersio | 128.199.133.154 | anders.io |
| 522 | pletharoe | 150.31.38.107 | nickname at hotmail.com |
| 520 | Unnamed | 27.133.130.59 | NULL |
| 520 | GestureDevil | 108.61.250.38 | NULL |
| 510 | MeehPrivateNode1 | 51.175.128.133 | 8192R/0xB431B67770E4AA38 Mikal Villa <meeh(a)sigterm.no> - 1L |
| 507 | nuushe | 80.211.211.72 | nuushe(a)gmail.com |
| 497 | RecorderShortge | 45.32.105.155 | NULL |
| 490 | Unnamed | 59.106.219.199 | NULL |
| 489 | martzeladidit | 82.116.120.3 | NULL |
| 482 | Unnamed | 163.43.31.165 | NULL |
| 482 | Unnamed | 182.76.105.203 | NULL |
| 480 | AMMIT913 | 45.77.104.79 | NULL |
| 480 | T0rR3l4y | 93.176.178.110 | NULL |
| 476 | DataSmuggler | 139.162.191.243 | NULL |
| 461 | Unnamed | 194.150.168.108 | NULL |
| 460 | bork | 138.68.103.100 | tox: 23DB1B7EADE70D4DF45F498529377DB6273AC9396AFFBBE29ADFE72 |
| 450 | MyTorRelay002 | 223.16.247.232 | MaryX <mlamty(a)protonmail.com> |
| 449 | InterreteLiberum | 62.251.127.94 | {tor (a) eijshorst (dot) nl} [tor-relay.co] |
| 441 | Avalon | 87.167.28.53 | 0xFFFFFFFF Random Person <neutrino AT mnd dot de> |
| 430 | koopa | 95.85.2.103 | Koopa <koopa(a)mailinator.com> |
| 430 | Unnamed | 59.106.210.8 | NULL |
| 420 | Unnamed | 163.43.30.141 | NULL |
| 410 | devilbm | 139.162.67.118 | NULL |
| 410 | default | 223.132.204.159 | NULL |
| 410 | Unnamed | 27.133.128.120 | NULL |
| 406 | titanj | 172.245.24.228 | NULL |
| 398 | maggo | 78.46.253.198 | NULL |
| 390 | tor6zXLCtAn | 104.131.4.237 | mindhog(a)mindhog.org |
| 390 | hetztest | 78.46.185.234 | NULL |
| 384 | CookieNode | 89.247.43.63 | NULL |
| 367 | niarbagem | 79.111.0.58 | FirstName LastName <niarbagem AT rambler dot ru> |
| 367 | LndldySsist | 45.77.250.252 | NULL |
| 364 | ididedittheconfig42 | 109.198.181.152 | human@... |
| 360 | Unnamed | 163.43.28.21 | NULL |
| 360 | titanh | 172.245.24.228 | NULL |
| 360 | FreeSnowden | 139.162.19.233 | NULL |
| 360 | WhoopieRelay | 73.49.233.27 | kabuto721(a)gmail.com |
| 359 | undefinedname | 185.127.25.68 | NULL |
| 353 | hmator | 78.35.70.53 | huef(a)hmamail.com |
| 342 | function | 87.239.204.111 | NULL |
| 338 | jamst | 73.222.185.174 | NULL |
| 326 | zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz | 95.116.141.176 | tor(a)abc.de |
| 326 | Eigentor | 89.22.97.193 | dorian+tor (A) opstshop.ch |
| 321 | liberusnode | 79.133.210.11 | iantichy(a)mail.com |
| 321 | CommitmentTitle | 45.77.14.112 | NULL |
| 320 | EvilAnnanas | 172.103.95.106 | 0x432B02EC Gustav Wetter <gustav DOT wettter AT piratpartiet |
| 320 | freedominsteadofnsa | 136.243.102.134 | NULL |
| 318 | JMCHome | 68.171.89.42 | admin [at] jrm2k [dot] us |
| 317 | atlgonyovLi | 216.24.174.245 | NULL |
| 315 | MontserrtVerge | 66.42.56.173 | NULL |
| 314 | Unnamed | 163.43.29.72 | NULL |
| 311 | Oceanman | 5.9.152.77 | Oceanman <x8(a)biz14.com> |
| 309 | 948794crazy | 128.199.213.157 | LTC_Address: LcfRixS5CjCF7KEsapKi4c998mAdN2KLZi |
| 307 | LizardNetTorRelay | 96.126.96.9 | 0x221A627DD76E2616 Andrew \"FastLizard4\" Adams <fastlizard |
| 301 | Unnamed | 163.43.105.27 | NULL |
| 297 | saruman | 217.117.227.226 | NULL |
| 293 | Unnamed | 109.107.35.154 | 4096R/5C06D153 John Leach <john(a)johnleach.co.uk> |
| 291 | Resonance | 212.24.104.216 | NULL |
| 290 | FR0ZE | 45.58.60.127 | NULL |
| 290 | ServeBrometer | 202.182.126.246 | NULL |
| 286 | Unnamed | 212.24.110.13 | NULL |
| 286 | blinkenlights | 192.3.148.27 | NULL |
| 285 | kgb | 93.100.158.51 | NULL |
| 285 | ZcashTestnet | 45.77.2.127 | forum.z.cash - xyZcash - Zcash TESTNET addnode=tazy4us2qli2s |
| 284 | ididntedittheconfig | 198.50.147.70 | tor(a)kurty.ovh |
| 284 | PhilosofRelay | 95.71.125.74 | NULL |
| 277 | TrustIllness | 139.180.202.251 | NULL |
| 270 | avrb | 91.219.239.121 | NULL |
| 270 | ziorufus | 94.198.100.17 | Alessio P. A. <firstname at apnetwork dot it> |
| 270 | SergentHitech | 139.180.198.17 | NULL |
| 270 | sachemivoule | 209.250.229.210 | NULL |
| 270 | TorFreedom | 167.71.219.124 | NULL |
| 269 | okra | 45.63.67.113 | NULL |
| 263 | sunkenship | 66.37.77.70 | NULL |
| 260 | jay | 188.105.230.135 | NULL |
| 260 | kutor | 138.68.80.91 | Arthur Anthon <arthuranthon7 AT gmail dot com> |
| 259 | Unnamed | 178.76.251.62 | NULL |
| 255 | fuga | 209.123.162.66 | tormaster <tormaster at coldcutkitty dot com> |
| 250 | someDOrelay | 104.131.128.247 | Random Person munellprogs AT gmail dot com |
| 250 | Unnamed | 133.242.228.179 | NULL |
| 246 | Unnamed | 80.211.172.119 | NULL |
| 244 | EconomiclShopkeepe | 139.180.136.223 | NULL |
| 244 | splatter | 198.27.77.134 | NULL |
| 240 | Unnamed | 45.55.146.251 | NULL |
| 240 | EDGroup | 188.166.19.224 | NULL |
| 240 | Unnamed | 212.24.110.13 | NULL |
| 240 | gnarzkorf2 | 80.81.243.27 | NULL |
| 240 | ContemporryLtitude | 66.42.58.61 | NULL |
| 230 | kwail | 91.121.78.119 | NULL |
| 229 | DRAKKAR | 94.185.81.106 | NULL |
| 228 | TheBadBADdRAGON | 198.199.118.134 | put \"dRAGON\" or \"TORRELAY\" in subject <torrelay@pthrailk |
| 222 | HappyTreeInForest | 46.39.253.63 | NULL |
| 220 | default | 125.181.52.134 | NULL |
| 218 | glenda2 | 78.47.117.28 | tor AT r-36 D0T net |
| 216 | explorer | 46.38.241.16 | Person <tor AT michos dot net> |
| 215 | xxxBLN47xxx | 91.58.176.241 | m(at)online(dot)de [tor-relay.co] |
| 213 | Unnamed | 139.162.9.145 | NULL |
| 210 | iLikeCheese | 185.181.219.172 | Petter Blomberg <tor AT skipthisword petterblomberg dot se> |
| 200 | Unnamed | 185.76.145.109 | NULL |
| 200 | glorpBlr01 | 139.59.71.113 | via ProtonMail: glorp-relays |
| 196 | Newton | 5.45.99.31 | NULL |
| 195 | NikitaiWeb | 70.38.31.121 | NULL |
| 193 | DaGoodLobster | 176.9.85.141 | NULL |
| 193 | dogemarch | 178.209.52.47 | NULL |
| 190 | SteinTor | 2.206.133.34 | NULL |
| 190 | torexitrendrag | 221.121.153.184 | abuse(a)rendrag.net.au |
| 190 | torwh | 46.38.234.158 | NULL |
| 190 | freemind | 89.246.30.166 | NULL |
| 189 | glenda1 | 78.46.209.112 | tor AT r-36 D0T net |
| 187 | torly3relayonly | 62.113.241.182 | torly |
| 185 | ServerHome | 80.234.44.81 | NULL |
| 184 | kvail | 5.196.66.241 | NULL |
| 179 | Unnamed | 185.86.78.228 | NULL |
| 172 | anonymous | 195.201.160.211 | NULL |
| 170 | fsdlnet | 147.95.16.164 | <root AT fs-dl.net> |
| 162 | spookeyspookey | 83.212.104.124 | spook spook sp00k(a)torbox3uiot6wchz.onion |
| 162 | Axion | 174.67.216.189 | Tor Supporter <eegeq8rtig2r(a)gnom2gnom.com> |
| 160 | charlycoptor | 77.141.175.36 | NULL |
| 160 | ttnode | 95.90.125.7 | NULL |
| 159 | Unnamed | 123.198.65.83 | NULL |
| 158 | ZAPPIE01 | 185.121.168.254 | exit-node-tor(at)zappiehost(dot)com |
| 154 | Someone | 45.32.245.73 | Someone <tor_relay(a)tutanota.com> |
| 147 | RavensGate1 | 109.250.244.195 | nichts at nichts dot de |
| 147 | NorthTahoeTor2 | 71.93.76.125 | 0xFFFFFFFF Ric Steinberger <ricst(a)usa.net> |
| 146 | Zion | 95.215.44.102 | NULL |
| 140 | Unnamed | 87.70.7.77 | NULL |
| 134 | pinkrelay | 83.135.138.251 | pinkrelay <e(a)mail.de> |
| 134 | ThunderMonkey | 178.79.177.148 | LeChuck <lechuck AT witnessthepower dot net> |
| 128 | Unnamed | 185.163.45.151 | NULL |
| 128 | hauferin | 176.15.14.138 | John Doe <nobody AT example dot org> |
| 125 | Unnamed | 178.137.182.222 | NULL |
| 120 | RelayOnAsteroids | 95.143.172.188 | A2DD35E4 Kaspar <kaspar AT tuta dot io> |
| 115 | default | 46.98.204.30 | NULL |
| 112 | Unnamed | 195.181.246.105 | NULL |
| 110 | Unnamed | 185.82.201.54 | NULL |
| 110 | Narnia2 | 94.23.168.235 | NULL |
| 109 | ianus | 176.9.90.215 | Arne <caffeine AT parttimegeeks dot net> |
| 108 | Kikimore | 188.165.4.224 | NULL |
| 107 | vindland | 94.23.150.210 | NULL |
| 106 | notninja | 185.154.20.196 | NULL |
| 106 | Unnamed | 183.86.55.27 | NULL |
| 102 | Tor4sheefupo | 188.106.148.189 | NULL |
| 102 | Cheetah69 | 92.116.120.209 | NULL |
| 100 | dE0F76Hrrzii0TozuGj | 188.172.153.42 | nobody(a)example.com |
| 100 | io | 157.230.105.23 | houndbee <relays AT houndbee dot com> |
| 98 | gopherfart | 192.241.206.171 | 0xb251cf4887c1510c <chris.foo(a)gmail.com> |
| 97 | lembas | 178.32.54.103 | NULL |
| 97 | tin0 | 87.106.208.236 | Valentin Hilbig <webmaster(a)20k.de> |
| 97 | cave | 174.18.94.159 | m9wjsc4wyq at snkmail com |
| 94 | panshi | 94.23.78.159 | NULL |
| 93 | g4rl1c | 149.202.4.241 | NULL |
| 91 | Unnamed | 212.24.106.116 | NULL |
| 91 | faispasser | 92.167.145.248 | NULL |
| 89 | Teinetteiine | 203.141.154.202 | NULL |
| 88 | PLATYPUS | 91.121.218.189 | NULL |
| 88 | m0wgl33 | 188.165.27.75 | NULL |
| 88 | uflnode00 | 206.189.48.51 | Admiral Pipedrov t-rexx(a)protonmail.ch |
| 88 | KDFrelayLaguna | 68.231.202.157 | General Zod <zod(a)kdf.mil> |
| 86 | KDFrelaySanClemente | 70.187.153.51 | General Zod <zod(a)kdf.mil> |
| 85 | medidntdoit | 88.130.7.25 | NULL |
| 85 | anonymousByPDH | 163.22.17.210 | anonymous(a)ubuntu-tor-simply-setup.script.by.PeterDaveHello |
| 85 | petrosagg | 178.79.163.169 | 0x92BF1079 Petros Angelatos <petrosagg(a)gmail.com> |
| 84 | minion | 178.32.138.157 | NULL |
| 79 | IcyEgo | 208.67.1.175 | ContactInfo 0x04FAC2E9CC21424A Richard Klafter <rpklafter@ya |
| 79 | afriendoftor | 45.79.89.133 | NULL |
| 78 | md0ds | 5.9.62.17 | md0 -@t- sigaint.org |
| 77 | Wombat | 73.52.112.195 | ${email_address} |
| 76 | 3gr356 | 94.23.89.90 | NULL |
| 75 | FireBolt | 185.25.216.237 | FireBolt <firebolt AT mail2tor dot com> |
| 74 | katthult47 | 83.249.234.230 | lm7adm(a)gmail.com |
| 74 | mbdy345 | 216.126.228.62 | mbdy345 at gmail.com |
| 74 | PGSamsTorNode | 198.211.122.191 | Tor node administrator <toradmin AT paulgreeff dot com> |
| 73 | ratatouille | 205.168.84.133 | Fred Gilbert <fredglbrt1 AT gmail DOT com> |
| 73 | tw0sday | 188.165.142.97 | NULL |
| 69 | rot1000100 | 185.103.159.135 | NULL |
| 65 | ecramrelay2 | 143.106.60.70 | ecram <ecram(a)mail2tor.com> |
| 63 | default | 180.44.116.224 | NULL |
| 60 | PGSams2TorNode | 51.15.95.236 | Tor node administrator <toradmin AT paulgreeff dot com> |
| 60 | Idris | 46.38.233.242 | Admin <admin(a)vault123.net> |
| 59 | martinnimoeller | 78.46.22.23 | NULL |
| 59 | vultr | 45.76.92.184 | 0x4f88aacab1f55373 Tor Admin <tor(a)different.name> |
| 59 | baiacu | 186.195.228.138 | NULL |
| 58 | Unnamed | 83.238.130.142 | oopp(a)8bit.pl |
| 57 | xotoxot | 82.161.182.20 | xotoxot <jhh(a)xs4all.nl> |
| 57 | Traumflug | 109.193.51.203 | mah(a)jump-ing.de |
| 57 | TheKLJ | 95.216.143.188 | NULL |
| 55 | CityConnect | 91.176.5.167 | Ed dot Dyreen at gmx dot com |
| 55 | default | 46.98.202.173 | NULL |
| 54 | Unnamed | 185.86.77.23 | NULL |
| 53 | glenda0 | 176.9.157.222 | tor AT r-36 D0T net |
| 51 | FemleDiffer | 149.28.147.142 | NULL |
| 50 | UniverslGlpgos | 207.148.99.160 | NULL |
| 48 | IOShadow | 208.64.220.46 | NULL |
| 47 | FreedomOfSpeech1 | 71.57.153.243 | root(a)iris-systems.net |
| 46 | async102 | 68.142.54.38 | 1024D/102E81AD jsled <jsled(a)asynchronous.org> |
| 44 | sergiodf | 181.230.128.133 | NULL |
| 44 | default | 46.98.199.108 | NULL |
| 43 | freefortor | 220.135.161.179 | NULL |
| 41 | lz53 | 100.2.182.112 | NULL |
| 40 | anpanman97 | 36.55.243.60 | <toradm14 __AT__ lowsnr __DOT__ net> |
| 40 | TheLastQuestion | 186.177.149.78 | elestudiante(a)protonmail.com |
| 39 | gans | 178.18.83.215 | tor(a)openended.eu - 1NBKmjqCAqxtnZ5cS7gHGKFwd2arWB6oxn |
| 37 | Unnamed | 109.201.142.53 | NULL |
| 35 | Unnamed | 31.7.184.76 | NULL |
| 30 | lach | 103.250.73.218 | NULL |
| 30 | default | 62.158.192.176 | NULL |
| 27 | nagusi | 212.81.199.159 | NULL |
| 27 | AliasName | 91.34.47.72 | name AT anbieter dot de |
| 25 | forestnode1 | 185.117.69.187 | Random Person <forestnode1 AT public-files dot com> |
| 25 | Unnamed | 93.219.152.159 | NULL |
| 25 | LbDRelay | 199.255.223.88 | NULL |
| 25 | Exitnodesave1 | 77.6.184.196 | volkerwilcken at web dot de |
| 24 | tarragon | 54.187.239.16 | 0xBFD29203 William Buck <dee AT wmbuck dot net> |
| 24 | Unnamed | 47.89.179.48 | NULL |
| 24 | jugbox | 198.46.153.51 | CheeseString <nobody AT example dot com> |
| 24 | start123 | 47.89.191.36 | NULL |
| 24 | jssrelay | 199.241.29.223 | relay(a)justsoftware.org |
| 24 | DockerTorBox | 37.59.50.81 | NULL |
| 22 | 2cat | 137.135.8.233 | James Tatum <jtatum AT gmail dot com> |
| 22 | maximum | 47.89.178.105 | NULL |
| 22 | default | 220.109.21.109 | NULL |
| 21 | vpnint1 | 176.31.23.96 | NULL |
| 21 | definesum | 47.89.185.247 | NULL |
| 20 | Unnamed | 5.187.207.218 | NULL |
| 20 | default | 91.64.228.225 | NULL |
| 20 | Unnamed | 5.139.89.30 | NULL |
| 20 | default | 178.175.246.240 | NULL |
| 20 | tisiphone | 71.19.155.187 | 4096R/35F36FFACBECCA80 Andrea Shepard <andrea@persephoneslai |
| 20 | rollmops | 88.76.22.86 | Random Person <tor AT loah dot be> |
| 20 | default | 178.153.69.189 | NULL |
| 20 | wopr | 91.54.178.251 | Random Person lasse.rau(a)arcor.de |
| 19 | bwanauhuru | 92.201.44.142 | NULL |
| 19 | ididydd | 47.90.204.154 | NULL |
| 19 | londonislovely | 18.130.146.107 | tormaster at dragonscale. net |
| 19 | torrelay | 159.89.43.248 | a(at)a(dot)com |
| 19 | thathib | 47.90.204.139 | NULL |
| 18 | maschinencode | 80.142.252.241 | Maschinen Code <maschinencode AT gmail DOT com> |
| 18 | TorStinkwuselBs | 84.58.216.182 | NULL |
| 17 | greedygertie | 78.47.167.67 | 0x4D9C031B Marina Brown <catskillmarina(a)gmail.com> |
| 17 | unixvpshost | 31.6.70.229 | NULL |
| 16 | Lemongrass | 45.35.72.85 | NULL |
| 16 | MarksTorRelay | 86.21.12.83 | torrelay(a)thegibbons.me.uk |
| 16 | livefree | 72.93.237.64 | Anonymous |
| 15 | high5one | 185.26.156.45 | tor@($NICKNAME without 'one').alioth.uberspace.de |
| 15 | default | 91.68.112.240 | NULL |
| 15 | Mischmaschine | 188.40.206.5 | NULL |
| 15 | Debianer | 95.143.172.214 | Mail <tor [aet] debianer {dOt} puppis {dOt} uberspace {dOt} |
| 15 | Unnamed | 213.138.113.232 | Rob Lucas <robjlucas(a)gmail.com> |
| 15 | Unnamed | 46.43.50.92 | NULL |
| 15 | KrullTheWarriorKing | 46.38.237.111 | NULL |
| 15 | wormhole | 46.41.59.223 | NULL |
| 15 | Blockwart | 87.123.115.224 | NULL |
| 15 | elkx | 185.46.22.51 | tortip(a)protonmail.com - 19m3X5meLTXVarEwLT8SSmG2Nf5sHcPsiL |
| 15 | Unnamed | 193.104.254.82 | NULL |
| 15 | Unnamed | 94.216.17.19 | NULL |
| 14 | Unnamed | 185.48.57.200 | NULL |
| 14 | Pathfinder | 82.119.233.36 | NULL |
| 14 | totally | 139.162.130.249 | 1024D/969F3F57 Cafuego <me(a)cafuego.net> |
| 14 | wavedebi | 151.236.10.29 | NULL |
| 14 | colagioia | 72.14.179.10 | toradmin(a)colagioia.net |
| 14 | snarltorrelay | 78.46.90.23 | 0x8D52347D Hauke Altman <hauke AT haukepauke dot de> |
| 14 | titow | 89.98.197.209 | NULL |
| 14 | md0bnbr | 81.169.166.74 | md0 -@t- sigaint.org |
| 13 | Torpi | 124.177.118.88 | NULL |
| 13 | BBSTor | 52.90.84.21 | BBS <tor AT bluebytesolutions.com dot com> |
| 13 | Y32C4RDM42T3R | 37.187.4.81 | NULL |
| 13 | Torpille | 37.187.16.43 | Philippe ALEXANDRE alexandre.philippe+torrelay(a)gmail.com |
| 13 | Unnamed | 60.139.123.222 | NULL |
| 13 | PaimGochyo | 184.106.109.244 | Tor Admin <tor(a)rawmeat.org> |
| 13 | pipibaby | 46.223.249.56 | Arrr <rmkom AT web dot de> |
| 13 | AbcHostersRelay | 167.88.49.3 | tor-operator(a)abc-hosters.com |
| 13 | Kaulquappe1 | 92.63.173.28 | tor-relay(a)bunten.de |
| 13 | smurfix | 213.95.149.22 | 4096R/25B4C293 Matthias Urlichs <matthias(a)urlichs.de> |
| 13 | Unnamed | 144.76.80.68 | 0xE1769155 Tobias Florek <tob+tor(a)butter.sh> |
| 13 | AgentBolek | 37.187.59.143 | NULL |
| 13 | Unnamed | 134.101.254.231 | NULL |
| 13 | labersack | 84.182.73.63 | NULL |
| 13 | ADKP | 185.41.154.130 | NULL |
| 13 | Unnamed | 62.245.57.78 | NULL |
| 13 | BhodiSoftLinode | 69.164.207.234 | Golden_Eternity <tor AT bhodisoft dot com> |
| 13 | darkwebv1 | 73.176.222.34 | NULL |
| 12 | deHoochObscura | 52.50.118.8 | NULL |
| 12 | Sand | 80.81.17.31 | NULL |
| 12 | Unnamed | 185.86.78.159 | NULL |
| 12 | graphiclunarkid | 85.119.83.141 | 0x2227CBD64C497218 Richard King <richard(a)richardskingdom.net |
| 12 | ashley | 149.210.226.155 | 1234D/FFFFFFFF Pirate <pirate(a)xs4all.nl> |
| 12 | BelarusFreedom | 198.199.90.51 | Informer By <informer.by AT, of course, google mail> |
| 12 | BraveStarr | 87.75.98.28 | NULL |
| 12 | inotedtheconfig | 52.10.125.140 | 0xFFFFFFFF Random Person <nobody AT example dot com> |
| 12 | Rarity | 79.172.18.18 | NULL |
| 12 | Unnamed | 185.48.57.207 | NULL |
| 12 | NeedsFoodBadly | 173.255.246.162 | GauntletWizard <MyName(a)gmail.com> |
| 12 | tlf | 23.94.46.24 | NULL |
| 12 | monstermail0 | 185.10.68.76 | NULL |
| 12 | default | 83.233.76.111 | NULL |
| 11 | canuck1 | 198.91.133.5 | NULL |
| 11 | hqhtor | 92.117.56.169 | NULL |
| 11 | afdideditheconfig | 188.174.6.0 | 0x3D7724BB Anton Fraunhofer <af(a)anton-fraunhofer.de> |
| 11 | Zwiebel2 | 134.119.3.2 | NULL |
| 11 | default | 37.123.184.75 | no at mail dot no |
| 10 | stork | 46.165.141.162 | NULL |
| 10 | reAnimaTOR | 81.200.59.162 | NULL |
| 10 | Eadu | 89.236.34.117 | batjohan at gmail |
| 9 | pidshochk | 141.136.44.11 | NULL |
| 9 | default | 84.151.63.33 | NULL |
| 9 | torjittertrapnet | 52.63.134.148 | NULL |
| 9 | zz1949 | 77.148.42.134 | NULL |
| 9 | naks | 111.90.140.7 | NULL |
| 9 | Unnamed | 176.115.52.192 | NULL |
| 9 | pidprobiw | 139.162.138.208 | NULL |
| 9 | poseidon | 194.218.3.79 | 0xFFFFFFFF Random Person <abuse(a)nypasalt.se> |
| 8 | picaron | 190.210.98.90 | Ivan Ergun <mandingadiablo(a)hotmail.com> |
| 8 | gloryukraine | 77.120.137.93 | fuckyourself at i dot ua |
| 8 | ordo | 82.220.91.188 | NULL |
| 8 | a10060c393046cfd | 190.216.2.136 | ed3eb07380e9c39dfbb428ca6ef3 |
| 8 | werhqwoddlkjwodcxy | 217.224.236.105 | NULL |
| 8 | gsrv | 86.73.143.162 | NULL |
| 7 | Unnamed | 134.90.154.193 | NULL |
| 7 | default | 85.12.250.175 | NULL |
| 7 | ssrv | 83.39.104.81 | NULL |
| 7 | ownedbybillgates | 84.184.73.120 | NULL |
| 7 | aaatortest | 62.210.206.53 | aaatortest at yopmail dot com |
| 7 | tolaklas | 85.72.93.156 | NULL |
| 7 | kubernetor | 159.65.208.22 | NULL |
| 7 | BARIOPA | 82.22.246.160 | NULL |
| 7 | pidprobq | 95.175.98.203 | NULL |
| 7 | kubernetor | 139.59.54.146 | NULL |
| 6 | slntor | 212.71.253.226 | SA agarwal.shrey(a)gmail.com |
| 6 | Justanode | 176.193.178.169 | contactmyass |
| 6 | Unnamed | 108.170.31.85 | NULL |
| 6 | 343ELH05T | 97.127.97.84 | NULL |
| 6 | treeltor | 107.196.20.143 | Clyde Zuber <zfposting AT zuberfowler dot com> |
| 5 | Unnamed | 85.140.190.77 | NULL |
| 5 | mv9m288876533566 | 128.70.11.203 | NULL |
| 5 | skophitch | 52.6.9.146 | NULL |
| 5 | croft | 195.16.89.145 | NULL |
| 5 | DockerTorrelay | 72.174.14.34 | Anonymous |
| 5 | default | 60.125.245.13 | NULL |
| 5 | IQOnion | 50.193.59.193 | Sysop <sysop AT icequake dot net> |
| 4 | office110 | 93.221.158.174 | NULL |
| 4 | infogtor | 50.111.24.234 | Clyde Zuber <zfposting AT zuberfowler dot com> |
| 3 | judas | 46.163.76.170 | rudolf.loercks(a)arcor.de |
| 3 | SheragaAlpha | 185.87.185.221 | Agent725 <agent725 AT 725 dot be> |
| 2 | Unnamed | 89.108.111.156 | NULL |
| 2 | default | 83.155.27.64 | NULL |
| 2 | default | 77.152.165.154 | NULL |
| 2 | default | 118.159.26.181 | NULL |
| 2 | hottor01 | 84.31.70.198 | NULL |
| 1 | Unnamed | 178.168.15.85 | NULL |
| 1 | default | 219.206.202.230 | NULL |
| 1 | default | 94.248.1.94 | NULL |
| 1 | freeBogatov | 196.41.123.180 | NULL |
| 1 | nibiru | 186.109.119.215 | hardrive9000(a)gmail.com |
| 1 | cahoonalocee | 2.201.233.144 | cahoonalocee tor relay operator <cahoonalocee <minus> operat |
| 1 | BalderDash77 | 103.255.25.89 | NULL |
| 1 | t7 | 82.228.252.20 | Bert Bos <bert(a)phonk.net> |
| 0 | XbcesRelay | 83.165.154.147 | info(a)xbc.es |
+------------------+---------------------+-----------------+--------------------------------------------------------------+
--
https://twitter.com/nusenu
https://mastodon.social/@nusenu
5
8
Just an FYI on a problem I found with two DNS of 1and1 ionos.
The affected DNS are 212.227.123.16 and 212.227.123.17 which both are not responding to *.torproject.org domain or sub domains.
I found this out as my system reverted back to the default DNS after a system crash. I'm now using bind on the local system and all is fine.
Just thought to let all know just in case they are using these DNS.
Paul
137CF322859E400455E457DB920F65FFDD222CDF
3
2
Hi,
just letting everyone know that I've added, in total, 6 new relays to my
family:
https://metrics.torproject.org/rs.html#search/family:94C268630BEDCB64E7F888…
During the next few weeks expect around ~1,6Gbit/s total exit capacity.
On another note: Is there any update on multithreading for tor relays? I
recall sending in a trace to, I think, teor.
I know that it's probably not a feature with high priority, just asking
if the trace I sent in was useful and if you need anything else ;-)
Best Regards,
Jochen
3
2
I set up a bridge at home on my Raspberry Pi (Raspbian Buster) using [these instructions](https://community.torproject.org/relay/setup/bridge/), and I believe everything is configured correctly... But there is no activity in or out of my bridge. Here's some messages I am seeing:
> 16:31:26 [NOTICE] Heartbeat: In the last 6 hours, I have seen 0 unique clients. [2 duplicates hidden]
> 16:31:26 [NOTICE] Heartbeat: Tor's uptime is 17:59 hours, with 0 circuits open. I've sent 6.18 MB and received 25.58 MB. [2 duplicates hidden]
> 16:04:28 [NOTICE] Performing bandwidth self-test...done.
> 13:10:43 [NOTICE] No circuits are opened. Relaxed timeout for circuit 408 (a Testing circuit 3-hop circuit in state doing handshakes with channel state open) to 60000ms. However, it appears the circuit has timed out
I know bridges don't see as much activity but is this abnormal?
3
2

Re: [tor-relays] Bridge - how to configure obfs4 both: on IPv4 AND IPv6?
by Roger Dingledine 29 Sep '19
by Roger Dingledine 29 Sep '19
29 Sep '19
On Sat, Sep 28, 2019 at 08:12:43PM +0200, tschador(a)posteo.de wrote:
> But with:
>
> ServerTransportListenAddr obfs4 <ipv4-addr>:<port>
> ServerTransportListenAddr obfs4 [<ipv6-addr>]:<port>
>
> obfs4proxy is only listening on the IPv4 address!
It looks like you are encountering
https://bugs.torproject.org/11211
Alas, I suggest sticking to ipv4 for now -- I think if you got ipv6
working on your obfs4, you would next run into the problem that bridgedb
doesn't currently give out ipv6 obfs4 addresses.
There's a lot of work waiting for somebody who wants to make ipv6 more
of a proper citizen in the Tor world. There's a mention by Sarah of a
recent funding proposal which could get that restarted again:
https://lists.torproject.org/pipermail/tor-project/2019-September/002479.ht…
Thanks for running a bridge!
--Roger
2
1
$ traceroute6 2a01:4f8:1c0c:45f7::1
connect: No route to host
> On 25. Sep 2019, at 17:24, tschador(a)posteo.de wrote:
>
> Hi,
>
> after upgrading to Tor version 0.4.1.6-1~d9.stretch+1 and kernel
> 4.9.0-11-amd64 on Debian GNU/Linux 9 my relay ist listed as offline. [1]
>
> I restarted Tor several times, but no change. The log shows (CEST):
> ---
> Sep 25 13:10:29.000 [notice] Tor 0.4.1.6 opening log file.
> Sep 25 13:10:29.432 [notice] Tor 0.4.1.6 running on Linux with Libevent
> 2.0.21-stable, OpenSSL 1.1.0k, Zlib 1.2.8, Liblzma 5.2.2, and Libzstd 1.1.2.
> …
> Sep 25 13:10:33.000 [notice] Self-testing indicates your ORPort is
> reachable from the outside. Excellent.
> …
> Sep 25 13:11:35.000 [notice] Self-testing indicates your DirPort is
> reachable from the outside. Excellent. Publishing server descriptor.
> Sep 25 13:11:35.000 [notice] Performing bandwidth self-test...done.
> ---
>
> There are still 150 connects in the moment, slowly decreasing.
>
> Only two of the authorities show the 'running'-flag for my relay. What's
> going on there?
>
> Regards
>
> [1]
> https://metrics.torproject.org/rs.html#details/6A7551EEE18F78A9813096E82BF8…
> _______________________________________________
> tor-relays mailing list
> tor-relays(a)lists.torproject.org
> https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-relays
2
1

25 Sep '19
On Wed, Sep 25, 2019 at 05:24:55PM +0200, tschador(a)posteo.de wrote:
> after upgrading to Tor version 0.4.1.6-1~d9.stretch+1 and kernel
> 4.9.0-11-amd64 on Debian GNU/Linux 9 my relay ist listed as offline. [1]
>
> Only two of the authorities show the 'running'-flag for my relay. What's
> going on there?
>
> [1]
> https://metrics.torproject.org/rs.html#details/6A7551EEE18F78A9813096E82BF8…
My guess is that your ipv4 ORPort is reachable, but that your ipv6 ORPort
is not reachable.
So you're getting Running votes from the dir auths that don't test ipv6,
and the ones that do test ipv6 are declaring you down.
For those following at home, if you're in this situation, another useful
tool is to go to the search box at the bottom of
https://consensus-health.torproject.org/#relayinfo
and paste in your fingerprint, to learn more about the individual votes
from each directory authority about your relay.
Thanks!
--Roger
1
0
Hello relay operators!
I am planning on performing an experiment on the Tor network to try to gauge the accuracy of the advertised bandwidths that relays report in their server descriptors. Briefly, the experiment involves running a speed test on every relay for a short time (about 20 seconds). Details follow.
I plan to run the experiment in about 1 week. Relay operators can opt-out of the speed test by replying on this thread, and we will remove you from the list of relays to scan.
Peace, love, and positivity,
Rob
---
Measuring the Accuracy of Tor Relays' Advertised Bandwidths
Motivation
----------
The capacity of Tor relays (maximum available goodput) is an important metric. Combined with mean goodput, it allows us to compute the bandwidth utilization of individual relays as well as the entire network in aggregate. Generally, capacity is used to help balance client load across relays, and relay utilization rates help Tor make informed decisions about how to allocate resources and prioritize performance and scalability improvements.
Problem
-------
Currently, Tor uses a heuristic measure of unknown accuracy to estimate Tor relay capacity. Each relay keeps track of the maximum goodput it has achieved over any 10 second window in a 24 hour period. This is called the "observed bandwidth". Relays take the minimum of their "observed bandwidth" and their bandwidth rate-limiting configuration and reports the result as the "advertised bandwidth" in their server descriptors. We do not know how well the advertised bandwidth estimates the true relay capacity, but we do know that it represents a lower bound on capacity.
Hypothesis
----------
The advertised bandwidth significantly underestimates the true capacity of Tor relays. On average, relays with higher true capacities will be more strongly correlated with capacity underestimation (because it will be less likely that fast relays will have sustained their full capacity over a 10 second period).
Experiment
----------
A relay reports its advertised bandwidth in its server descriptor. To test how well these reported numbers represent the true capacity of a relay, we can manually perform a speed test on the relay by initiating the simultaneous download of several large data streams for a period that exceeds 10 seconds. In the report following our test, the relay will report its advertised bandwidth in its server descriptor and the results will be collected and reported by metrics.torproject.org.
The experiment involves two steps: running the speed test on a relay under our control, and running the speed test on all relays in Tor network.
We will first run the speed test on at least one relay that we control, in order to test that the method is effective and that we can in fact observe a change in the advertised bandwidth reported on metrics.torproject.org. Once we have confidence that our speed test is functioning correctly, and that the metrics pipeline will allow us to gather the results, we will repeat it on all relays in the network.
We will conduct the speed tests while minimizing network overhead. We will use a custom client that builds 2-relay circuits. The first relay will be the target relay we are speed testing, and the second relay will be a fast exit relay that we control. We will initiate data streams between a speedtest client and server running on the same machine as our exit relay.
The setup will look like:
speedtest-client <--> tor-client <--> target-relay <--> exit-relay <--> speedtest-server
All components will run on the same machine that we control except for the target-relay, which will rotate as we test different relays in the network. For each target relay, we plan to run the speedtest for 20 seconds in order to increase the probability that the 10 second mean goodput will reach the true capacity. We will measure each relay over a few days to ensure that our speedtest effects are reported by every relay.
Although we believe that the overhead of this speed test is in line with regular usage, relay operators can opt-out of the speed test by replying on this thread. Those that opt out will be removed from our list of relays to scan.
Analysis
--------
Following our speedtest, we will analyze the data collected and reported by Tor metrics. We will compared the advertised bandwidth that each relay reports before our experiment to those reported during our experiment. This will help us test our hypothesis that relays' advertised bandwidth underestimates the true capacity of relays. We will run a statistical correlation analysis on the data to test the strength of the correlation between the previously reported (estimated) relay capacity and relay capacity underestimation. We will report our results to the Tor community.
We expect that the results of our experiment will help Tor decide how to allocate resources and will help them plan and prioritize performance improvements. It will also provide insight into the operation of the current load balancing system, which uses advertised bandwidth to produce consensus weights.
12
37
I'm just curious as to why, in the bridge stats, all the country codes show a multiple of 8. Thanks for your time!
2
1