March 2013 - tor-relays - lists.torproject.org

Circuit creation "storms" overwhelming Raspberry Pi?
by torsion＠ftml.net 08 Jul '13

08 Jul '13

Hi there, I just joined the mailing list and apologized if this has been discussed before. I did find discussion of a similar issue in January 2013's archive: https://lists.torproject.org/pipermail/tor-relays/2013-January/001809.html It's important to note that I believe I've seen (but didn't save logs) a couple "circuit creation burst" events on my established relay (about 5Mbps, stable, guard, non-exit) which was mostly able to handle it without crashing as it has plenty of RAM and the above-mentioned messages - "Your computer is too slow to handle this many circuit creation requests! Please consider using the MaxAdvertisedBandwidth config option or choosing a m ore restricted exit policy." - appear only with the relay is under load for other reasons AND a large number of circuits are being suddenly created. I wondered if this was some kind of DOS attempt but didn't think much of it because my fast relay continued working fine. However, I've just set up a Raspberry Pi, the 512MB model, as a relay on a slower connection. Here are the relevant settings on this relay: RelayBandwidthRate 130 KB RelayBandwidthBurst 340 KB The Pi has a fairly slow CPU, so I'd occasionally get messages about log deduplication being too slow or something, but didn't think much of it. I finally got the relay up and left it up for over 24 hours. When I woke up this morning it had crashed. Here are the relevant log messages - note the huge jump in number of circuits between 22:35 and 04:35 (maybe I got the Stable flag), then the storm of circuit open requests starting at 05:49. Eventually I believe the Pi ran out of memory and killed the tor process. What's very interesting here is that my fast VPS relay with a RelayBandwidthRate over 5x faster is almost never handling much more than 1000 circuits, so why all of a sudden the demand on the Pi that's advertising a lower bandwidth rate? Mar 17 22:35:00.000 [notice] Heartbeat: Tor's uptime is 1 day 0:00 hours, with 26 circuits open. I've sent 974.13 MB and received 969.92 MB. Mar 18 04:35:00.000 [notice] Heartbeat: Tor's uptime is 1 day 6:00 hours, with 972 circuits open. I've sent 1.61 GB and received 1.59 GB. Mar 18 05:49:44.000 [warn] Your computer is too slow to handle this many circuit creation requests! Please consider using the MaxAdvertisedBandwidth config option or choosing a more restricted exit policy. Mar 18 05:49:44.000 [warn] Failed to hand off onionskin. Closing. Mar 18 05:50:44.000 [warn] Your computer is too slow to handle this many circuit creation requests! Please consider using the MaxAdvertisedBandwidth config option or choosing a more restricted exit policy. [5817 similar message(s) suppressed in last 60 seconds] Mar 18 05:52:30.000 [warn] Your system clock just jumped 101 seconds forward; assuming established circuits no longer work. Mar 18 05:53:51.000 [warn] Your computer is too slow to handle this many circuit creation requests! Please consider using the MaxAdvertisedBandwidth config option or choosing a more restricted exit policy. [1055 similar message(s) suppressed in last 60 seconds] Mar 18 05:55:14.000 [warn] Your computer is too slow to handle this many circuit creation requests! Please consider using the MaxAdvertisedBandwidth config option or choosing a more restricted exit policy. [329 similar message(s) suppressed in last 60 seconds] I'd like to figure out just how much the Raspberry Pi is capable of, because it could be a cheap way to build out the relay network by people who want to donate bandwidth - but of course it needs to be stable, and something about my setup is not. Also: Mar 16 20:55:33.000 [notice] No AES engine found; using AES_* functions. I have no idea if the Broadcom BCM2835 SoC (ARM1176JZF-S CPU) in the Pi has any AES capability, but it'd be great to find out.

3 4

ask
by syrus f 31 Mar '13

31 Mar '13

Hello My tor can not connect to internet in these last week. I am in Iran. and have been change my relay addresses but problem not solve what i must to do?

4 3

Re: [tor-relays] ongoing denial of service attack against Road Runner IP addresses
by Kent Backman 30 Mar '13

30 Mar '13

Quoting Rebecca Kaiser <abuse(a)wholesaleinternet.net>: Thanks, Rebecca I see no further malicious activity from DataShack and Wholesale Internet. Still ongoing attack from Limestone and Ubiquity/Nobistech and a few other US ISP's, and of course malicious traffic from IP addresses from one specific foreign country. Any explanation from your foreign customers as to why they are engaging in what appears to be illegal activity, at least as far as US laws apply? - Kent > We've received confirmation from our client that this has been shut down. > > > > From: Kent Backman [mailto:kent@kentbackman.com] > Sent: Tuesday, March 26, 2013 8:08 PM > To: abuse(a)rr.com > Cc: abuse(a)nobistech.net; security(a)datashack.net; noc(a)psychz.net; > abuse(a)limestonenetworks.com; abuse(a)wholesaleinternet.net; abuse(a)he.net > Subject: ongoing denial of service attack against Road Runner IP address > 98.150.237.177 by botnet operating out of Nobistech, Datashack, Limestone, > HE, Pegtech, WholeSale Interent, and Psychz VPS nodes > Importance: High > >

2 2

Re: [tor-relays] Ongoing denial of service attack against Tor relays by leased botnet in America and PRC (Nobistech, Datashack, Limestone, HE, Pegtech, WholeSale Internet, and Psychz VPS nodes, etc)
by Kent Backman 30 Mar '13

30 Mar '13

The list has been very helpful, and helped me gather more information. Appreciate all the responses. The botnet is certainly there, but the targets seem to be much more constrained than I first thought. It *is* just me. Only nodes that someone could associate with me are being targeted. An exit node I setup last night with a nearly default torrc file on a different ISP was clean. While unfortunately this is not better news for me, it is explainable considering what I have exposed in the past, but a false alarm for the rest of you. Thanks -----Original Message----- From: Kent Backman [mailto:kent@kentbackman.com] Sent: Thursday, March 28, 2013 12:14 AM To: 'tor-relays(a)lists.torproject.org' Subject: Ongoing denial of service attack against Tor relays by leased botnet in America and PRC (Nobistech, Datashack, Limestone, HE, Pegtech, WholeSale Interent, and Psychz VPS nodes, etc) Up front, I am not a conspiracy theorist. New to the list, I run a Tor exit node from my small cable modem connection in Honolulu, as well as for a short time on a few on VPS's to prove to myself that it wasn't "just me." Over the last several weeks, I have collected substantial evidence indicating that a botnet is degrading the Tor anonymity network in its entirety via a sustained denial of service attack. I believe it is made to blend in with all the other crazy packets that an exit node generates, but it is pretty easy to spot if you just look at the RST's or drops coming off your node, all from a static unused destination port. If you change the IP address of your node, it will take about 90 minutes before they identify your IP and you start getting attacked again. I will submit to you the headers of a few hundred packets, and the full list of perps involved in separate emails because of the size thing. Do a whois lookup on a few of those VPS IP addresses and you will see the country involved. Here are the last few hundred packet headers showing the two bigger ISP's. Wasn't able to show perp list since first two messages held for the moderator because of the size. Wondering what other folks are seeing with their relays. UTC DATE UTC TIME IP SRC-ISP SPT DST DST-ISP DPT Flags 2013-03-28 7:33:38 173.208.95.126 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2571 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:39 173.208.95.126 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2571 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:39 74.63.192.36 Limestone Networks 1274 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:39 108.177.168.156 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3471 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:39 173.208.95.126 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2571 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:39 23.19.67.28 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3866 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:40 74.63.192.36 Limestone Networks 1274 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:40 108.177.168.156 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3471 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:40 74.63.192.36 Limestone Networks 1598 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:40 23.19.67.28 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3866 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:40 108.177.168.156 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3471 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:40 74.63.192.36 Limestone Networks 1274 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:41 74.63.192.36 Limestone Networks 1598 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:41 23.19.67.28 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3866 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:41 74.63.192.36 Limestone Networks 1598 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:44 173.208.44.42 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1358 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:45 173.208.44.42 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1358 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:45 64.120.60.121 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4001 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:45 69.147.233.52 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2291 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:45 173.208.44.42 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1358 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:45 64.120.60.121 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4001 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:46 69.147.233.52 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2291 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:46 64.120.60.121 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4001 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:46 69.147.233.52 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2291 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:47 64.120.60.139 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2078 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:47 23.19.54.243 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1281 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:48 64.120.60.139 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2078 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:48 23.19.54.243 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1281 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:48 64.120.60.139 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2078 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:48 23.19.54.243 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1281 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:48 64.120.60.106 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3004 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:49 64.120.60.106 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3004 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:49 64.120.60.106 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3004 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:50 69.162.117.205 Limestone Networks 1273 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:50 23.19.63.204 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2769 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:50 69.162.117.205 Limestone Networks 1273 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:51 23.19.63.204 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2769 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:51 23.19.54.57 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2633 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:51 69.162.117.205 Limestone Networks 1273 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:51 23.19.63.204 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2769 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:51 23.19.54.57 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2633 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:52 23.19.54.57 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2633 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:53 173.208.95.106 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2337 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:53 108.62.33.54 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1322 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:54 23.19.130.121 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2389 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:54 108.62.33.54 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1322 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:54 173.208.95.106 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2337 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:54 23.19.130.121 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2389 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:54 108.62.33.54 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1322 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:54 173.234.116.251 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2873 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:54 173.208.95.106 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2337 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:55 23.19.130.121 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2389 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:55 173.234.116.251 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2873 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:56 173.234.116.251 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2873 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:56 173.234.145.205 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2549 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:56 23.19.131.10 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2273 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:56 69.147.233.52 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4112 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:57 173.234.145.205 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2549 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:57 69.147.233.52 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4112 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:57 23.19.131.10 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2273 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:57 23.19.63.204 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4430 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:57 173.234.145.205 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2549 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:58 23.19.131.10 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2273 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:58 69.147.233.52 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4112 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:58 23.19.63.204 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4430 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:58 23.19.63.204 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4430 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:59 173.208.57.54 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3250 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:59 173.208.57.54 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3250 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:00 23.19.130.91 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2751 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:00 173.208.57.54 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3250 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:00 23.19.130.91 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2751 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:01 23.19.131.11 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1828 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:01 23.19.130.91 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2751 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:01 23.19.131.11 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1828 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:02 23.19.131.11 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1828 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:02 23.19.67.28 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4607 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:03 23.19.67.28 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4607 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:03 23.19.130.92 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1398 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:04 23.19.67.28 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4607 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:04 23.19.130.92 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1398 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:04 70.32.43.188 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3669 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:04 23.19.130.92 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1398 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:05 70.32.43.188 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3669 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:05 64.120.60.122 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4518 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:05 70.32.43.188 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3669 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:06 173.234.188.204 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2505 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:06 64.120.60.122 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4518 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:06 173.208.16.248 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3296 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:06 173.234.188.204 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2505 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:06 23.19.131.10 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4396 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:07 23.19.67.28 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1378 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:07 173.208.16.248 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3296 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:07 64.120.60.122 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4518 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:07 173.234.188.204 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2505 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:07 23.19.131.10 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4396 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:07 173.208.16.248 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3296 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:07 23.19.67.28 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1378 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:07 23.19.131.10 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4396 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:08 23.19.67.28 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1378 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:09 147.255.224.134 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2361 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:09 147.255.224.134 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2361 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:10 64.120.60.106 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1518 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:10 70.32.43.190 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2963 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:10 147.255.224.134 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2361 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:10 64.120.60.106 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1518 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:10 70.32.43.190 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2963 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:11 64.120.60.106 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1518 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:11 173.234.145.205 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3493 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:11 70.32.43.190 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2963 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:11 173.234.145.206 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2492 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:11 173.234.145.205 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3493 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:12 173.234.145.206 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2492 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:12 173.234.145.205 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3493 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:12 23.19.50.46 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2827 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:12 173.234.145.206 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2492 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:13 23.19.50.46 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2827 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:13 23.19.50.46 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2827 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:13 64.120.60.105 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1194 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:14 64.120.60.105 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1194 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:14 64.120.60.105 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1194 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:15 173.234.116.237 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4363 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:16 173.234.116.237 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4363 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:16 64.120.60.174 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2369 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:17 173.234.116.237 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4363 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:17 64.120.60.174 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2369 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:17 23.19.131.10 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2648 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:17 64.120.60.174 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2369 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:17 23.19.131.10 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2648 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:18 23.19.131.10 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2648 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:18 173.234.145.206 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4154 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:19 23.19.130.121 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3782 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:19 173.234.145.206 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4154 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:19 23.19.130.121 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3782 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:19 64.120.60.122 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2141 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:19 173.234.145.206 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4154 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:20 23.19.130.121 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3782 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:20 64.120.60.122 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2141 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:21 64.120.60.122 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2141 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:21 173.208.95.126 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3208 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:21 173.208.95.126 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3208 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:21 64.120.60.174 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3193 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:22 173.208.95.126 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3208 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:22 64.120.60.174 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3193 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:22 64.120.60.174 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3193 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:22 64.120.44.150 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3211 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:23 64.120.44.150 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3211 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:23 108.62.33.51 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3383 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:23 108.62.33.51 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3383 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:23 64.120.44.150 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3211 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:24 23.19.50.46 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4534 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:24 108.62.33.51 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3383 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:24 23.19.50.46 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4534 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:25 23.19.130.86 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3654 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:25 23.19.50.46 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4534 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:25 23.19.130.86 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3654 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:25 23.19.130.93 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2090 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:26 23.19.130.86 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3654 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:26 23.19.130.93 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2090 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:26 69.147.233.52 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4623 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:26 23.19.130.93 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2090 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:26 64.120.60.121 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1486 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:27 69.147.233.52 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4623 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:27 64.120.60.121 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1486 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:27 69.162.117.206 Limestone Networks 1906 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:27 173.234.116.232 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4393 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:27 173.208.44.46 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2169 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:28 69.147.233.52 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4623 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:28 173.208.95.125 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1316 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:28 64.120.60.121 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1486 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:28 69.162.117.206 Limestone Networks 1906 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:28 173.234.116.232 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4393 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:28 173.208.44.46 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2169 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:28 108.177.157.70 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1659 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:28 173.208.95.125 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1316 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:28 69.162.117.206 Limestone Networks 1906 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:28 173.234.116.232 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4393 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:29 173.208.95.106 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1650 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:29 108.177.157.70 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1659 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:29 173.208.95.125 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1316 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:29 173.208.44.46 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2169 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:29 23.19.131.10 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1104 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:29 23.19.131.10 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1132 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:29 108.177.157.70 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1659 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:29 173.208.95.106 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1650 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:29 23.19.131.10 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1104 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:29 23.19.67.211 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1884 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:30 23.19.131.10 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1132 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:30 23.19.67.214 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1295 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:30 173.208.95.106 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1650 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:30 23.19.131.10 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1104 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:30 23.19.131.10 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1132 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:30 23.19.67.211 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1884 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:30 23.19.67.214 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1295 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:30 64.120.60.118 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2075 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:31 23.19.67.211 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1884 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:31 23.19.67.214 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1295 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:31 64.120.60.120 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4950 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:31 69.162.119.4 Limestone Networks 2862 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:31 64.120.60.118 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2075 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:31 64.120.60.120 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4950 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:31 69.162.119.4 Limestone Networks 2862 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:32 64.120.60.118 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2075 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:32 147.255.224.134 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1603 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:32 64.120.60.120 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4950 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:32 69.162.119.4 Limestone Networks 2862 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:32 147.255.224.134 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1603 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:33 173.208.44.36 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3290 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:33 147.255.224.134 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1603 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:33 64.120.60.118 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2677 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:33 173.208.44.36 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3290 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:34 173.208.44.36 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3290 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:34 64.120.60.118 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2677 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:34 173.208.16.250 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1802 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:35 173.208.16.250 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1802 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:35 64.120.60.118 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2677 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:35 173.208.16.250 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1802 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:38 108.177.168.156 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2832 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:38 108.177.168.156 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2832 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:38 23.19.130.93 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4597 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:39 108.177.168.156 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2832 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:39 23.19.130.93 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4597 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:39 69.162.117.206 Limestone Networks 3681 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:39 23.19.130.93 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4597 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:40 69.162.117.206 Limestone Networks 3681 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:40 69.162.117.206 Limestone Networks 3681 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:40 64.120.60.121 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3356 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:41 64.120.60.121 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3356 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:42 64.120.60.121 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3356 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:42 64.120.79.221 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1410 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:42 108.62.237.205 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2969 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:42 64.120.79.221 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1410 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:42 108.62.237.205 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2969 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:43 64.120.79.221 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1410 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:43 108.62.42.18 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2158 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:43 23.19.130.93 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1789 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:43 108.62.237.205 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2969 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:43 173.208.44.40 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1441 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:43 108.62.42.18 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2158 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:44 173.234.12.178 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2411 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:44 173.208.44.40 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1441 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:44 23.19.130.93 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1789 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:44 108.62.42.18 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2158 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:44 23.19.130.93 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1789 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:44 173.208.44.40 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1441 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:44 173.234.12.178 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2411 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:45 173.234.12.178 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2411 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:47 64.120.79.222 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4601 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:47 69.162.80.59 Limestone Networks 3514 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:48 69.162.80.59 Limestone Networks 3514 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:48 64.120.79.222 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4601 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:48 173.234.145.205 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4688 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:48 64.120.79.222 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4601 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:48 69.162.80.59 Limestone Networks 3514 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:48 173.208.44.46 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4835 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:49 173.234.145.205 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4688 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:49 173.208.44.46 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4835 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:49 74.63.192.36 Limestone Networks 1339 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:49 173.234.145.205 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4688 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:49 64.120.60.146 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3668 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:50 173.208.44.46 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4835 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:50 74.63.192.36 Limestone Networks 1339 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:50 23.19.131.11 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3868 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:50 64.120.60.146 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3668 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:50 74.63.192.36 Limestone Networks 1339 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:50 70.32.43.189 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4246 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:50 23.19.131.11 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3868 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:50 64.120.60.146 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3668 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:51 23.19.131.11 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3868 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:51 70.32.43.189 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4246 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:51 64.120.60.139 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1105 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S],

2 1

Ongoing denial of service attack against Tor relays by leased botnet in America and PRC (Nobistech, Datashack, Limestone, HE, Pegtech, WholeSale Interent, and Psychz VPS nodes, etc)
by Kent Backman 29 Mar '13

29 Mar '13

Up front, I am not a conspiracy theorist. New to the list, I run a Tor exit node from my small cable modem connection in Honolulu, as well as for a short time on a few on VPS's to prove to myself that it wasn't "just me." Over the last several weeks, I have collected substantial evidence indicating that a botnet is degrading the Tor anonymity network in its entirety via a sustained denial of service attack. I believe it is made to blend in with all the other crazy packets that an exit node generates, but it is pretty easy to spot if you just look at the RST's or drops coming off your node, all from a static unused destination port. If you change the IP address of your node, it will take about 90 minutes before they identify your IP and you start getting attacked again. I will submit to you the headers of a few hundred packets, and the full list of perps involved in separate emails because of the size thing. Do a whois lookup on a few of those VPS IP addresses and you will see the country involved. Here are the last few hundred packet headers showing the two bigger ISP's. Wasn't able to show perp list since first two messages held for the moderator because of the size. Wondering what other folks are seeing with their relays. UTC DATE UTC TIME IP SRC-ISP SPT DST DST-ISP DPT Flags 2013-03-28 7:33:38 173.208.95.126 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2571 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:39 173.208.95.126 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2571 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:39 74.63.192.36 Limestone Networks 1274 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:39 108.177.168.156 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3471 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:39 173.208.95.126 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2571 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:39 23.19.67.28 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3866 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:40 74.63.192.36 Limestone Networks 1274 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:40 108.177.168.156 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3471 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:40 74.63.192.36 Limestone Networks 1598 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:40 23.19.67.28 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3866 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:40 108.177.168.156 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3471 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:40 74.63.192.36 Limestone Networks 1274 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:41 74.63.192.36 Limestone Networks 1598 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:41 23.19.67.28 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3866 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:41 74.63.192.36 Limestone Networks 1598 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:44 173.208.44.42 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1358 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:45 173.208.44.42 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1358 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:45 64.120.60.121 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4001 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:45 69.147.233.52 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2291 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:45 173.208.44.42 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1358 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:45 64.120.60.121 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4001 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:46 69.147.233.52 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2291 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:46 64.120.60.121 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4001 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:46 69.147.233.52 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2291 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:47 64.120.60.139 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2078 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:47 23.19.54.243 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1281 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:48 64.120.60.139 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2078 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:48 23.19.54.243 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1281 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:48 64.120.60.139 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2078 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:48 23.19.54.243 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1281 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:48 64.120.60.106 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3004 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:49 64.120.60.106 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3004 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:49 64.120.60.106 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3004 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:50 69.162.117.205 Limestone Networks 1273 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:50 23.19.63.204 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2769 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:50 69.162.117.205 Limestone Networks 1273 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:51 23.19.63.204 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2769 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:51 23.19.54.57 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2633 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:51 69.162.117.205 Limestone Networks 1273 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:51 23.19.63.204 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2769 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:51 23.19.54.57 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2633 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:52 23.19.54.57 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2633 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:53 173.208.95.106 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2337 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:53 108.62.33.54 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1322 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:54 23.19.130.121 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2389 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:54 108.62.33.54 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1322 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:54 173.208.95.106 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2337 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:54 23.19.130.121 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2389 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:54 108.62.33.54 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1322 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:54 173.234.116.251 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2873 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:54 173.208.95.106 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2337 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:55 23.19.130.121 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2389 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:55 173.234.116.251 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2873 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:56 173.234.116.251 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2873 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:56 173.234.145.205 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2549 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:56 23.19.131.10 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2273 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:56 69.147.233.52 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4112 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:57 173.234.145.205 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2549 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:57 69.147.233.52 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4112 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:57 23.19.131.10 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2273 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:57 23.19.63.204 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4430 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:57 173.234.145.205 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2549 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:58 23.19.131.10 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2273 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:58 69.147.233.52 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4112 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:58 23.19.63.204 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4430 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:58 23.19.63.204 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4430 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:59 173.208.57.54 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3250 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:33:59 173.208.57.54 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3250 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:00 23.19.130.91 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2751 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:00 173.208.57.54 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3250 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:00 23.19.130.91 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2751 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:01 23.19.131.11 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1828 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:01 23.19.130.91 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2751 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:01 23.19.131.11 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1828 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:02 23.19.131.11 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1828 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:02 23.19.67.28 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4607 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:03 23.19.67.28 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4607 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:03 23.19.130.92 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1398 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:04 23.19.67.28 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4607 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:04 23.19.130.92 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1398 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:04 70.32.43.188 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3669 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:04 23.19.130.92 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1398 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:05 70.32.43.188 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3669 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:05 64.120.60.122 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4518 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:05 70.32.43.188 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3669 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:06 173.234.188.204 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2505 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:06 64.120.60.122 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4518 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:06 173.208.16.248 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3296 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:06 173.234.188.204 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2505 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:06 23.19.131.10 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4396 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:07 23.19.67.28 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1378 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:07 173.208.16.248 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3296 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:07 64.120.60.122 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4518 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:07 173.234.188.204 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2505 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:07 23.19.131.10 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4396 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:07 173.208.16.248 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3296 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:07 23.19.67.28 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1378 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:07 23.19.131.10 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4396 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:08 23.19.67.28 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1378 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:09 147.255.224.134 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2361 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:09 147.255.224.134 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2361 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:10 64.120.60.106 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1518 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:10 70.32.43.190 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2963 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:10 147.255.224.134 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2361 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:10 64.120.60.106 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1518 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:10 70.32.43.190 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2963 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:11 64.120.60.106 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1518 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:11 173.234.145.205 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3493 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:11 70.32.43.190 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2963 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:11 173.234.145.206 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2492 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:11 173.234.145.205 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3493 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:12 173.234.145.206 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2492 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:12 173.234.145.205 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3493 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:12 23.19.50.46 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2827 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:12 173.234.145.206 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2492 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:13 23.19.50.46 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2827 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:13 23.19.50.46 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2827 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:13 64.120.60.105 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1194 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:14 64.120.60.105 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1194 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:14 64.120.60.105 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1194 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:15 173.234.116.237 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4363 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:16 173.234.116.237 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4363 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:16 64.120.60.174 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2369 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:17 173.234.116.237 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4363 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:17 64.120.60.174 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2369 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:17 23.19.131.10 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2648 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:17 64.120.60.174 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2369 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:17 23.19.131.10 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2648 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:18 23.19.131.10 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2648 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:18 173.234.145.206 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4154 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:19 23.19.130.121 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3782 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:19 173.234.145.206 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4154 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:19 23.19.130.121 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3782 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:19 64.120.60.122 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2141 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:19 173.234.145.206 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4154 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:20 23.19.130.121 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3782 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:20 64.120.60.122 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2141 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:21 64.120.60.122 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2141 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:21 173.208.95.126 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3208 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:21 173.208.95.126 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3208 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:21 64.120.60.174 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3193 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:22 173.208.95.126 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3208 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:22 64.120.60.174 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3193 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:22 64.120.60.174 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3193 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:22 64.120.44.150 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3211 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:23 64.120.44.150 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3211 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:23 108.62.33.51 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3383 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:23 108.62.33.51 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3383 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:23 64.120.44.150 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3211 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:24 23.19.50.46 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4534 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:24 108.62.33.51 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3383 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:24 23.19.50.46 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4534 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:25 23.19.130.86 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3654 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:25 23.19.50.46 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4534 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:25 23.19.130.86 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3654 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:25 23.19.130.93 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2090 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:26 23.19.130.86 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3654 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:26 23.19.130.93 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2090 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:26 69.147.233.52 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4623 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:26 23.19.130.93 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2090 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:26 64.120.60.121 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1486 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:27 69.147.233.52 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4623 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:27 64.120.60.121 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1486 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:27 69.162.117.206 Limestone Networks 1906 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:27 173.234.116.232 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4393 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:27 173.208.44.46 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2169 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:28 69.147.233.52 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4623 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:28 173.208.95.125 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1316 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:28 64.120.60.121 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1486 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:28 69.162.117.206 Limestone Networks 1906 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:28 173.234.116.232 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4393 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:28 173.208.44.46 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2169 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:28 108.177.157.70 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1659 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:28 173.208.95.125 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1316 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:28 69.162.117.206 Limestone Networks 1906 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:28 173.234.116.232 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4393 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:29 173.208.95.106 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1650 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:29 108.177.157.70 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1659 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:29 173.208.95.125 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1316 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:29 173.208.44.46 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2169 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:29 23.19.131.10 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1104 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:29 23.19.131.10 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1132 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:29 108.177.157.70 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1659 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:29 173.208.95.106 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1650 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:29 23.19.131.10 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1104 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:29 23.19.67.211 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1884 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:30 23.19.131.10 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1132 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:30 23.19.67.214 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1295 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:30 173.208.95.106 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1650 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:30 23.19.131.10 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1104 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:30 23.19.131.10 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1132 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:30 23.19.67.211 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1884 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:30 23.19.67.214 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1295 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:30 64.120.60.118 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2075 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:31 23.19.67.211 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1884 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:31 23.19.67.214 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1295 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:31 64.120.60.120 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4950 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:31 69.162.119.4 Limestone Networks 2862 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:31 64.120.60.118 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2075 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:31 64.120.60.120 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4950 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:31 69.162.119.4 Limestone Networks 2862 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:32 64.120.60.118 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2075 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:32 147.255.224.134 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1603 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:32 64.120.60.120 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4950 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:32 69.162.119.4 Limestone Networks 2862 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:32 147.255.224.134 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1603 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:33 173.208.44.36 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3290 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:33 147.255.224.134 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1603 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:33 64.120.60.118 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2677 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:33 173.208.44.36 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3290 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:34 173.208.44.36 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3290 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:34 64.120.60.118 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2677 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:34 173.208.16.250 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1802 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:35 173.208.16.250 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1802 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:35 64.120.60.118 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2677 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:35 173.208.16.250 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1802 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:38 108.177.168.156 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2832 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:38 108.177.168.156 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2832 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:38 23.19.130.93 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4597 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:39 108.177.168.156 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2832 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:39 23.19.130.93 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4597 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:39 69.162.117.206 Limestone Networks 3681 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:39 23.19.130.93 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4597 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:40 69.162.117.206 Limestone Networks 3681 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:40 69.162.117.206 Limestone Networks 3681 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:40 64.120.60.121 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3356 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:41 64.120.60.121 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3356 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:42 64.120.60.121 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3356 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:42 64.120.79.221 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1410 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:42 108.62.237.205 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2969 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:42 64.120.79.221 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1410 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:42 108.62.237.205 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2969 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:43 64.120.79.221 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1410 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:43 108.62.42.18 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2158 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:43 23.19.130.93 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1789 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:43 108.62.237.205 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2969 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:43 173.208.44.40 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1441 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:43 108.62.42.18 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2158 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:44 173.234.12.178 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2411 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:44 173.208.44.40 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1441 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:44 23.19.130.93 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1789 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:44 108.62.42.18 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2158 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:44 23.19.130.93 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1789 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:44 173.208.44.40 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1441 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:44 173.234.12.178 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2411 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:45 173.234.12.178 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 2411 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:47 64.120.79.222 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4601 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:47 69.162.80.59 Limestone Networks 3514 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:48 69.162.80.59 Limestone Networks 3514 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:48 64.120.79.222 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4601 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:48 173.234.145.205 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4688 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:48 64.120.79.222 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4601 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:48 69.162.80.59 Limestone Networks 3514 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:48 173.208.44.46 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4835 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:49 173.234.145.205 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4688 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:49 173.208.44.46 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4835 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:49 74.63.192.36 Limestone Networks 1339 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:49 173.234.145.205 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4688 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:49 64.120.60.146 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3668 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:50 173.208.44.46 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4835 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:50 74.63.192.36 Limestone Networks 1339 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:50 23.19.131.11 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3868 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:50 64.120.60.146 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3668 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:50 74.63.192.36 Limestone Networks 1339 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:50 70.32.43.189 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4246 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:50 23.19.131.11 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3868 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:50 64.120.60.146 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3668 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:51 23.19.131.11 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 3868 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:51 70.32.43.189 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 4246 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S], 2013-03-28 7:34:51 64.120.60.139 Nobis Technology Group, LLC 1105 66.8.214.196 Road Runner 8118 [S],

5 4

Is my relay fine?
by Brandon Steele 26 Mar '13

26 Mar '13

This is my first time sending in a question in this mailing list about my relay. Here's the link to it: http://torstatus.blutmagie.de/router_detail.php?FP=c6528e10911ec94cc85430e9… I realize some of the router flags are checked. I just want someone to check it quickly to make sure that everything is all right. Thanks!

4 4

port setup
by Art 22 Mar '13

22 Mar '13

I have a Westell A90-750018-07 router and I need to set up port forwarding for port 9001 and 9030. My router won't let me do it however, saying: *Invalid End Port value of NULL Please enter a valid number* when I attempt to do so. I entered 9001 in the *Global PortStart *box and**the other empty boxes on the setup page are *Global PortEnd *and *Base HostPort.* What values do I put in the Global PortEnd and Base HostPort boxes????* * TIA. Art* *

4 5

Does obfsproxy advertise ?
by Exocet Tor Node 20 Mar '13

20 Mar '13

Hello all. Beside my relay, I'm also operating a bridge on another server. I've recently installed obfsproxy, mainly for test purpose. The obfs2 service is successfully registered (per log message) but, as of today, I've never received any connection on it (iptables rule show no packet to the dedicated port). The service is running for more than 2 weeks now. My question is : does obfsproxy advertise like the regular bridge service ? Best regards.

2 1

DMCA letters
by jvoss＠altsci.com 14 Mar '13

14 Mar '13

Hi all, I've been running a Tor exit node on my new server for 16 days. Today I received my second automated DMCA infringement notice from HBO. I sent them the boilerplate you see at the bottom of the message both times. My colo provider Hurricane Electric understands Tor, which is awesome. I don't think it'll be an issue, so I'm happy with this. I'm wondering if anyone receives a large number of DMCA infringement notices and whether there was a resolution. It would certainly make my life a little bit more difficult to send more than one of these per week. When I got my first letter I was pushing 5 Mbps (megabits) and now I'm pushing 9 Mbps. I've set the RelayBandwidthRate to 5120 KB which should give a max rate of 41 Mbps. If infringement notices increases linearly with traffic, this could become an issue. I'm happy to share the infringement notices if anyone is interested. I followed a few of the tips from https://blog.torproject.org/running-exit-node , I got a separate IP address and I reduced the exit policy. I plan to update the reverse dns. I don't feel like reducing the exit policy does anything because BitTorrent was designed to run on any high port. Also, reducing the exit policy blocks researchers who are doing port scans and header grabbing over Tor. That's a point of contention for me because I know legitimate researchers use Tor for that purpose. Does anyone have any data or anecdotes on how exit policy affects malicious use of Tor vs legitimate use of Tor? Btw, my server is 216.218.134.12. I'm running a patched version of tor 0.2.3.25 which fixes a few bugs I found in buffer events. See https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/ticket/7788 for more info. Uptime is now 6 days, 13 days without a crash. Thanks, Javantea ------------------- Dear Andrew Martin: The IP address in question is a Tor exit node. https://www.torproject.org/overview.html There is little we can do to trace this matter further. As can be seen from the overview page, the Tor network is designed to make tracing of users impossible. The Tor network is run by some 2500 volunteers who use the free software provided by the Tor Project to run Tor routers. Client connections are routed through multiple relays, and are multiplexed together on the connections between relays. The system does not record logs of client connections or previous hops. This is because the Tor network is a censorship resistance, privacy, and anonymity system used by whistle blowers, journalists, Chinese dissidents skirting the Great Firewall, abuse victims, stalker targets, the US military, and law enforcement, just to name a few. See https://www.torproject.org/about/torusers.html.en for more info. Unfortunately, some people misuse the network. However, compared to the rate of legitimate use (the IP address in question processes approximately 11 megabits of traffic per second), abuse complaints are rare. https://www.torproject.org/docs/faq-abuse.html.en This is the second e-mail from you that I am replying to. The only thing that has changed is that I have increased the bandwidth to 9 megabits per second. If you have further questions, feel free to contact me at ------------ Sincerely, -----------

5 6

Local problem or Authority problem?
by Steve Snyder 13 Mar '13

13 Mar '13

This is the 2nd time I've seen the message below in the last few days. Is this a local problem, or is this Authority server having network problems? --------------------- Mar 12 16:13:57.000 [warn] Received http status code 504 ("Gateway Time-out") from server '154.35.32.5:80' while fetching consensus directory. Mar 12 16:13:57.000 [warn] Received http status code 504 ("Gateway Time-out") from server '154.35.32.5:80' while fetching "/tor/server/d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z". I'll try again soon.

3 2