- tor-project - lists.torproject.org

October 2018 report for the ux team
by Antonela Debiasi 16 Nov '18

16 Nov '18

Hello Tor, We started October in the beautiful Mexico City. We met a lot of tor users in Mexico, and we got a lot of insightful discussions. Thanks Community team! We continued working with Tor Browser security settings. We are trying hard to make clear for our users to understand the trade-offs of picking each level. It is a work in progress now and will reach the stable channel soon. Reading the ticket could be overwhelming, but you can have an overview of our iterations looking at the attachments: https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/attachment/ticket/25658 Towards our intention to have more open conversations and share the work we are doing, we released the first documentation for one of the big projects we handled this year. Next scheduled docs include .onion security padlock and onboarding in TB8. Thanks, Pili for uploading it and Hiro for your review! https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/wiki/org/teams/UxTeam/Misc/Circuit… We are trying to find the most useful way to report the usability research we are running around the global south. As I mentioned in the previews recaps, we were using the ticket #27010 to archive our sessions. In addition to that, we put together a framework for reporting our usability testing. It captures a lot of data that shows the feature's history through development and UX. We already started to use it to inform our recent research on the Tor Browser, and we will have our first reports coming out soon. https://storm.torproject.org/shared/KaJn4JRxGajVno961aLOfqJs-8AsfIvGn-4e_5h… Also last month, we surveyed our community to pick the next Tor Browser Icon (!). The results were informed, and the applications team is already working on its implementation. Thanks all for participate! You can see the new Tor Browser icon here: https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/ticket/25702#comment:8 OONI released a newly redesigned version of Probe. We did design reviews with Elio and the OONI team to achieve the best experience for probers and researchers when they measure networks with their phones. Great work ooniers! https://lists.torproject.org/pipermail/ux/2018-October/000430.html The End of Year campaign is running, and we provided support to the Fundraising team with marketing material to promote it. We have banners running in different locales at torproject.org, Tor Browser and Tor Browser for Android. http://donate.torproject.org/ On behalf of the Tor UX team, Antonela

1 0

community team update, October 2018
by Alison Macrina 16 Nov '18

16 Nov '18

October 2018 Community Team highlights Meeting notes ================================================================== https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/wiki/org/teams/CommunityTeam#Curre… Tor Meeting ================================================================= We held the Mexico City meeting and it was amazing! You can read the notes from that meeting here [1]. Several Tor people including Gus and Antonela gave talks "Coloquio Academico Mecanismos de Privacidad y Anonimato en Redes" at UNAM after the Tor Meeting. Later in October, Alison sent out a survey for the next Tor Meeting location and dates to all core contributors (and the winner is Athens, May 2019) Community portal, support portal, and user advocacy ================================================================== We mapped out our needs for community.torproject.org and began working on outreach material for that portal along with the UX team. Maggie took on more user advocate responsibilities and continued the monthly user issues update email. Anti-censorship ================================================================== In October, Kat began work writing and aggregating reports about Tor's anti-censorship efforts. Localization ================================================================== emmapeel localized donate.torproject.org, got Chinese added to support.torproject.org, and added screenshots in Transifex. Library Freedom Institute ================================================================== Alison began migrating LFI content to a wiki. The LFI cohort completed weeks 19-22 of their training. Library Freedom also started a website redesign, which we will debut soon! Tor talks and outreach ================================================================== Maggie and Cybelle held a "Demystifying Tor" workshop at MozFest Alison submitted the CFP for the UX and community teams to talk at IFF. She also worked on planning for the two teams to attend that conference together. Roger submitted a talk to FOSDEM, Steph requested a stand, and ahf made a wiki for Tor people attending [2]. Gus is working on creating volunteer projects for students at the University of Sao Paulo (USP). Gus gave a Tor talk to students of LabJor [3] and gave a security workshop in Sao Paolo. Gus also organized travel to Guatemala to give a Tor talk and organized a security workshop at BIENAL in Sao Paolo. Relay advocacy ================================================================== Colin is working with a VPN company on deploying some exit relays. He also updated the obfsproxy bridge deployment instructions and identified primary documentation [4] and sent a moderation email to tor-relays [5]. He worked on deploying VMs for fallback directory list rebuilding and updated the fallback list in preparation for rebuild. Finally, Colin contacted operators running EOL versions of Tor and encouraged them to upgrade. ================================================================== [1] https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/wiki/org/meetings/2018MexicoCity/N… [2] https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/wiki/org/meetings/2019Brussels [3] http://www.labjor.unicamp.br/ [4] https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/wiki/doc/PluggableTransports/obfs4… [5] https://lists.torproject.org/pipermail/tor-relays/2018-October/016524.html -- Alison Macrina Community Team Lead The Tor Project

1 0

My first day as ED
by isabela 16 Nov '18

16 Nov '18

Hello Tor! We are officially done with the transition process! This means that I am now (for realz) Tor’s ED :) Shari will be in a consultant position till the end of the year, and starting 2019 she will join our Board. If you haven’t seen yet, here is her blog post on it: https://blog.torproject.org/strength-numbers-onion-blooms I wanted to write this note to you so we can review a bit of what was done during this transition period and how that lines up with some of the points I had on my (short term) vision for Tor. Some might remember the IRC chat after my nomination, where I shared a few bullet points of areas I would like Tor to focus on in the short term. Most of these are not new and are things that Tor (TPO+TPI) have been talking about for a while and know we should be doing. Let’s start with the goals related to: 1 - A Mature Tor Project (organization/community) 1.1 - Stable income flows from a diverse funding base ^ We built a Fundraising team (Sarah, Fundraising Director; and Al, Grant Writer) and equipped Sue (CFO) with a Finance team (Bekeela, Grant Manager; and Millicent, Bookkeeper) to help us achieve this goal. This is what I am calling our ‘money machine.’ They will work together with our new PMs (Gaba and Pili) on proposals and also on other sources of income for Tor (major donors, family foundations, direct donations, etc.). This team is meeting weekly to sync on all of the different grants, proposals, and fundraising campaigns we are working on or plan to do in the upcoming months. We also maintain a calendar where we will try to have at least 1 initiative per month related to bringing in money. Back in September, we created a calendar that goes till January, and in early 2019 we will have another big meeting where we will plan for the first 6 months of 2019 (the remaining time of our current fiscal year). 1.2 - Diverse and robust organization that meets our needs ^ A lot that I will be talking about in this email reflects on this goal. 1.3 - Strong organizational culture, focused on employee and volunteer happiness and stability ^ Shari did a lot of this already, from employee benefits and salary adjustments, to workshops at dev meetings (unconscious bias and the culture clash one in Mexico, for instance). A lot has been done, and of course there is still a lot to do. That is why I kept this goal here. For now I will just bring up one thing that I believe is important and we need to do. Tor has a culture, but we should be able to articulate our culture and define it so others know what it means, so most importantly, we don’t lose it as we grow. I just want to drop this here as a seed for others to think about it as well. We will resume this conversation in 2019 for sure! 1.4 - Global brand recognition - Tor means strong privacy ^ The Berkeley Group [theberkeleygroup.org] is a student organization of UC Berkeley that provides services to nonprofits for free or at a low cost. We contracted with them to research Tor’s brand perception by different demographics in the US and to provide us with suggestions of convincing points to improve our brand image, along with suggestions of channels we could use in a marketing strategy to help with that. We will be sharing all of this once it’s done, but we will use this to build a marketing strategy for 2019. Marketing means, as part of communications, how we will pitch to donors, how we do outreach, our website content, and the list goes on. It’s a bit of everything, but we should digest what The Berkeley Group delivers to us and figure out how we apply that in real life. Like the goal says, Tor should mean strong privacy for people, and all this work is to achieve that perception of our brand. Now let’s move to the other set of goals I had for product: 2 - Full Access (product) 2.1 - Any person on the planet can access the Tor Network ^There are a few things related to this goal, for instance people need to be able to bypass censorship against Tor to access the network. Also, we need to have clients that work on any device and any OS so we can really provide a way for *anyone* to access the Tor network. Of course both things are mega hard, and that’s ok. The goal here is for us to think about the challenges to get there and figure out how to get started. This year, mobile has been on our minds :) not only with releasing a mobile browser, but also with optimizing little t tor for mobile apps. We are also creating an anti-censorship team and building projects that will require different teams to work together to fix problems related to the user experience under censorship. 2.2 - Any person on the planet can use the Tor Network to access any website or online services ^Same thing, we can think of many different types of work that would help us achieve this goal. The work being done by our Community and UX teams, where folks are going to different countries, meeting communities at-risk, learning their needs, teaching them about online security and collecting their feedback on our tools is fundamental for us to achieve the *can use* part. And this goes too for the *can access* part of the goal 2.1, above this one. Goal 2.2 also is about accessing websites and online services. The painful captchas are a challenge we need to address, because this is a big complaint users have related to using Tor. At least some things have improved with CloudFlare and their alt-svc for .onion addresses solution, which is good. There is more to do, and this is a hard one to address, but we can’t ignore it just because it is hard. We should at least put our minds on it and see what can be done, and little by little we can get there. 2.3 - Ensure Tor Network is diverse, healthy, stable and scalable ^None of the above can be done if this one is not happening. To achieve this goal we will need a combination of efforts, like help from our research community and metrics and OONI teams, which can provide us with valuable information that can help us make new design decisions, monitor our network and test new code. Of course our network team is very important for this goal :) But we will need to add support for areas where we are under capacity right now, like monitoring the health of the network to make sure there is no malicious behavior or attacks on it. Sorry for the long email. Since today is considered my first day as ED, I thought it would be nice to go back to these goals and share a bit of how we can be working together to achieve those, and how the new people can help us too. I want to recognize that I am probably missing other goals we should be thinking about for the next 3 years. I would like to hear other thoughts, and I would like to do an update on this list at the meeting in Greece. This is the beginning of a conversation, not the end. I hope to have a chance to host a ‘tea time’ on irc before the end of the year for us to chat. Please hold me on that! I am mega busy, but I would really like to try that out before 2019. Cheers, Isabela PS: tons of <3 for Shari, who has been extremely amazing and who I will forever be thankful for her support, guidance, and help.

1 0

OONI Monthly Report: October 2018
by Maria Xynou 16 Nov '18

16 Nov '18

Hello Tor world, In October 2018, the OONI team co-published a new research report, in collaboration with DefendDefenders, examining Uganda's social media tax through the analysis of network measurements. We wrote new OONI Probe nettest specifications, improved our heuristics for semi-automated blockpage and blockserver detection, completed a list of improvements to the monitoring of OONI services, and released a private internal beta of the revamped OONI Probe mobile pps. We also facilitated an OONI workshop at MozFest and participated at the OTF Summit. ## Report on Uganda's Social Media Tax In collaboration with our Ugandan partners, DefendDefenders, we co-published a new research report tited: "Uganda's Social Media Tax through the lens of network measurements". Our joint report is available here: https://ooni.io/post/uganda-social-media-tax/ As part of our latest study, we examine the blocking of social media & circumvention tools across ISPs in Uganda through the analysis of OONI network measurements. Over the last months, we have published the following 5 research reports (in collaboration with our partners): 1. The State of Internet Censorship in Venezuela: https://ooni.torproject.org/post/venezuela-internet-censorship/ 2. The State of Internet Censorship in Egypt: https://ooni.torproject.org/post/egypt-internet-censorship/ 3. South Sudan: Measuring internet censorship in the world's youngest nation: https://ooni.torproject.org/post/south-sudan-censorship/ 4. Mali: Social media disruptions amid 2018 presidential election? https://ooni.torproject.org/post/mali-disruptions-amid-2018-election/ 5. Uganda's Social Media Tax through the lens of network measurements: https://ooni.io/post/uganda-social-media-tax/ More research studies are available on our website: https://ooni.torproject.org/post/ ## Revamping OONI Probe mobile apps Both Android and iOS apps have been implemented based on improvements to Measurement Kit and the finalized design and copy. We released a private internal beta to further test and polish the apps. Relevant pull requests include: * https://github.com/ooni/probe-ios/pull/187 * https://github.com/ooni/probe-ios/pull/186 * https://github.com/ooni/probe-ios/pull/185 * https://github.com/ooni/probe-ios/pull/184 * https://github.com/ooni/probe-android/pull/159 We are now preparing for a public beta release of the apps. ## Research and write specifications for new OONI Probe nettests We wrote specifications for a series of techniques that we plan on using in next generation OONI Probe nettests. These techniques will allow us to collect more rich network measurement data, further reduce the number of false positives in measurements and confirm, with a higher level of confidence, incidents of internet censorship. Our new nettest specifications are available via the following pull request: https://github.com/ooni/spec/pull/118 ## Implementation of semi-automated blockpage and blockserver detection We have added SimHash support (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SimHash) to enable the semi-automated blockpage and blockserver detection. When several unrelated URLs present a similar page, this usually means that the page is either a common web-server error page or a blockpage. Human intelligence is still required to distinguish anti-DDoS service provider captcha pages from generic "403 Forbidden" web-server errors and a "genuine" blockpage. We therefore added support for SimHash to use it as the first approximation of webpage similarity, to avoid pair-wise comparision of hundreds of millions of webpages stored in the OONI dataset. See: https://github.com/ooni/pipeline/pull/124 We also added support for the partial re-processing of data, to avoid processing the whole dataset when the list of known blockpages changes. See: https://github.com/ooni/pipeline/commit/a86e4fe42dec869b02618ba2c3e28281205… ## Improvements to the monitoring of OONI services To detect issues with our infrastructure earlier and to therefore minimise downtime and be more responsive to incidents, we have done several improvements to monitoring. We have completed all activities the aimed at improving the monitoring of OONI services, listed in the following issue: https://github.com/ooni/sysadmin/issues/226 ## Community activities ### Community meeting We held a community meeting on Slack (https://slack.openobservatory.org/) on Wednesday, 24th October 2018. As part of the meeting, the OONI team provided updates on what we worked on during the past month. We also addressed community questions pertaining to running OONI Probe on Linux and Raspberry Pis. ### OONI Probe workshop at MozFest OONI's Elio traveled to London to facilitate an OONI Probe workshop at Mozilla Festival (https://twitter.com/mozTechSpeakers/status/1056851429766414336) This provided a great opportunity to engage more community members with OONI's work. ### OTF Summit OONI's Maria traveled to Taiwan to participate at the OTF Summit (29th & 30th October) and the Open Internet Day (31st October 2018). This provided an opportunity to connect with community members, learn more about their projects, and brainstorm on potential avenues for collaboration. ## Userbase In October 2018, OONI Probe was run 391,014 times from 5,062 different vantage points in 214 countries around the world. This information can also be found through our stats: https://api.ooni.io/stats ~ The OONI team. -- Maria Xynou Research & Partnerships Director Open Observatory of Network Interference (OONI) https://ooni.torproject.org/ PGP Key Fingerprint: 2DC8 AFB6 CA11 B552 1081 FBDE 2131 B3BE 70CA 417E

1 0

Notes from November 15 2018 Vegas team meeting
by Karsten Loesing 16 Nov '18

16 Nov '18

Notes for November 15 2018 meeting: Alison: 1) still finishing LFI round 1, working on round 2 2) creating community portal content 3) working on SIDA report Mike: 1) Sponsor2 work; still ignoring most other things. Gaba: 1) Gettor coordination for next week. 2) OONI roadmap and deadlines for MOSS. 3) Slowly receiving CVs for metrics data architect position. 4) Interviews for anti-censorship position. 5) Organizing sponsors that teams are working on. Antonela: 1) working on TB security settings - http://trac.torproject.org/25658 2) working on TBA+Orbot settings and onboarding - https://bugs.torproject.org/28329 3) the first version of our series of docs is on the wiki. Thanks pili for pushing it live and hiro for the review! https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/wiki/org/teams/UxTeam/Misc/Circuit… 4) met with Ciberseguras to talk about further community outreach together. 5) sent my article for the UNAM colloquium. 6) working with the community team on our new outreach material. 7) met with Helen and Pili to define our User Testing Reporting Framework. 8) planning usability research for next month in Brazil. 9) met with Duncan, a designer from Scotland who is interested on helping the UX team. 10) synced with Alex (ahf) about snowflake. 11) reviewing OONI Explorer mockups with Elio. Georg: 1) busy with getting Tor Browser for Android alpha into shape 2) writing back to the snap mail sent by Iain today (not sure what we want to do with that in particular and with our Linux situation in general yet) Nick: 1) lots of features, lots of releases, lots of coding. 2) anticensorship dev interviews seem to be going well. Arturo: 1) Preparing for a public beta release of OONI Probe mobile 2) Published a report on Uganda with our partner defend defenders: https://ooni.torproject.org/post/uganda-social-media-tax/ 3) Getting input on OONI Explorer from UX team 4) Anticensorship dev interviews Sarah: 1) Firming up YE campaign blog/email/social media schedule (will be contacting several of you to see if you are willing to author a post) 2) Finalizing language for next round of TB banners for next release 3) Met with OTF and Sida POs over the weekend Steph: 1) announced Nighat joined the board. Published blog, sent releases, shared on social 2) writing EOY campaign post, outlining others 3) making graphics from Tor Stories quotes 4) writing feedback from The Berkeley Group’s midpoint presentation 5) coordinated an interview for Isa 6) gave edits to the blog comment policy Pili: 1) Carried on with data gathering for Sponsor 9 report 2) Sent out Visual Identity Survey - Started analysing results Shari: 1) finishing my farewell blog post; should be posted later today 2) so many loose ends with the transition, which is happening this afternoon! isabela: 1) finishing transition - getting all things flipped (financial stuff) 2) reviewing YE campaign blog posts and other copies 3) catching up on visual identity exercises 4) helping on sida report a bit 5) recreating our organogram 6) did interview to spanish tve - a bit lame tho :( they were really into metrics and dark web 7) met with Sida PM and with OTF team in DC 8) reviewing 990

1 0

October 2018 User Feedback Report
by Maggie 14 Nov '18

14 Nov '18

Hey, friends! Welcome to the October 2018 user feedback report. For more information on what users and community members were talking about this month, check out the Fall 2018 User Feedback pad [1]. TL;DR: Things seem to be going smoothly! - Users aren't talking as much this month about the user agent changes. - The most common questions are related to using Tor together with a VPN (should I use both? Is it bad to use both? How can I hide the fact that I'm using Tor?). - Regarding TBA, users are largely grateful that we're developing an official Android app, and feedback is generally very positive. Ratings on the Google Play Store are high (the app is currently rated 4.3 stars), even when users are experiencing some fairly frustrating quality-of-life issues. - In offline news, Cybelle and I ran a Demystifying Tor workshop at MozFest! There was great turnout, and lots of interest in running relays. --- Now, on to the feedback! Scroll further down to see a recap of some of the MozFest session questions, a summary of Reddit posts, some points from Google Play Store reviews, a list of the most common Stack Exchange tags from the month, and a collection of some notable issues and bugs mentioned by users in October. - One of the most common points of confusion is whether people should use a VPN together with Tor to mask the fact that they're using Tor. In conversations about this on Reddit, pluggable transports are rarely mentioned. Even though we already have some information about VPNs in the FAQ, it seems that this explanation is not extensive enough, and that the information is not visible enough. I suggest that we release a blog post or a few tweets to further address this misconception. - In general, it seems like users will go to Reddit before reading the FAQ or support.torproject.org. How can we change this flow to encourage users to check Tor resources before seeking outside advice? - People always have questions about whether doing a certain thing will allow them to be fingerprinted (i.e. relative window position, adding bookmarks, etc.). Can we add a list of things to the FAQ that might allow users to be fingerprinted? We might also consider implementing more pop-up warnings when users attempt to do something that might identify them, as we currently do when users resize the browser window. - Tor is still broken for screen readers. In addition, Gesturefy (an extension that can be used as an accessibility aid) doesn't work with Tor Browser any more. These two issues are limiting Tor's accessibility, and making it so that certain users can't use Tor at all. --- Questions from the MozFest Demystifying Tor session: - Is it ever safe to run any type of relay from my home? - How can I contribute to Tor? - What are some good ways to convince people to use Tor? --- Most common questions on Reddit (r/TOR): - How can I hide the fact that I'm using Tor; or, should I use a VPN together with Tor? - (it's worth noting that these discussions rarely mention pluggable transports as a solution.) - Tor can't connect. What do I do? - People on Reddit are generally very good about troubleshooting this one. --- TBA Reviews & Feedback on Google Play Store: - People are frustrated by the current issues with copy/paste and text selection. - TBA fails to download files, causing frustration for users. - Users are requesting that we bundle Orbot and TBA into the same app. --- Most common stack exchange tags: - tor-browser-bundle - 18 asked this month - configuration - 10 asked this month - tor-install - 7 asked this month - windows - 6 asked this month - anonymity - 5 asked this month - security - 5 asked this month - tails - 5 asked this month - help - 5 asked this month - connection - 5 asked this month --- Notable bugs, fixes, & issues: #27867 - Gesturefy doesn't work with Tor Browser - (OPEN - needs more info) [2] #27256 - Text cannot be selected, copied, or pasted as usual on TBA - (OPEN - needs more info) [3] #27701 - TBA fails to download files - (OPEN) [4] #27987 - TBA disables screenshots, with no option to enable them - (OPEN) [5] #27845 - Browser window size is 1000x998 on MacOS - differs from other OSs and allows MacOS users to be differentiated - (OPEN) [6] #27813 - Tor 0.3.4.8 is leaking memory - (CLOSED - fixed in Tor 0.3.4.9) [7] --- That's it for the month of October! For the sake of brevity I've left out some other feedback, so if you want to know more, please do check out the Fall 2018 User Feedback pad [1] or reach out to me via email (waywardwyrd at riseup dot net) or IRC (wayward). Thanks for reading! I'll see you all back here next month. - Maggie (wayward) pronouns: she/they | twitter: @meochaidha <https://www.twitter.com/meochaidha> pgp: 0626 9C68 D0CC 1A5B E41B 72F2 615E B878 975C 4CDC ------ Annotations: 1. https://storm.torproject.org/shared/-vEQadBBHb8ZOzrLMMaJNrDuFK5XxJAQXcta30-… 2. https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/ticket/27867 3. https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/ticket/27256 4. https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/ticket/27701 5. https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/ticket/27987 6. https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/ticket/27845 7. https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/ticket/27813

1 0

Tails report for October 2018
by u 13 Nov '18

13 Nov '18

Hello, we just published our monthly report: https://tails.boum.org/news/report_2018_10/ Cheers! u.

1 0

Tor Browser Release meeting - Wednesday 14th Nov @ 19:00UTC
by Pili Guerra 13 Nov '18

13 Nov '18

Hi, Just a reminder that we’ll be having our bi-weekly Tor Browser release meeting this Wednesday (14th November) at 19:00UTC. Please come with any questions, requests and comments you may have. Here is a link to the pad: https://storm.torproject.org/shared/6z9zWh3BoyCONtyeW8EcFmL5hLhw5TNxKqR2F20… Feel free to add any comments/requests/discussion points, etc… ahead of the meeting. Everyone is welcome! Pili — Project Manager: Tor Browser, UX and Community teams pili at torproject dot org gpg 3E7F A89E 2459 B6CC A62F 56B8 C6CB 772E F096 9C45

1 0

Tor Browser team meeting notes, 12 Nov 2018
by Georg Koppen 13 Nov '18

13 Nov '18

Hi! Below are our weekly Tor Browser team meeting notes. The chat log can be found at http://meetbot.debian.net/tor-meeting/2018/tor-meeting.2018-11-12-18.58.log… and our pad entries are/were: Discussion: - Tor Browser in the Snap Store? (see Iain's mail) [GeKo will reply to it on Tue or Wed] - upcoming 1:1s - Team responsibilities restructuring - things to take over from Arthur: - annual rebase - maintaining circuit display UI - optimistic SOCKS (if I don't finish it) - adding locales - Mozilla uplift coordination - things Arthur will continue to maintain: - torpat.ch - arthuredelstein.net/exits - permissions FPI uplift (with Mozilla) - IRC presence GeKo: Last week: -Jacek worked on the Windows accessibility issue, patches are up for review/merged, see: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1430149 and we probably can soon be testing them in our nightly builds -reviews (#25013, #28260, #27443, #26540, #22343) -worked on #27443 and #26483 (alas no time for the design doc update #25021) -helped with proposals -helped with the anti censorship position interviews -security controls redesign This Week: -More work to get TBA-a2 into shape (reviews, help with #27443, #26483 and other related bugs) -another round of looking into doc for #3600 -look again over the cubeb - audio files disk leak and reply to Mozilla dev mail -write mail regarding Tor Browser snap -hopefully getting back to updating the Tor Browser design doc (#25012) mcs and brade: Note: We will be away from work Tuesday, November 20 - Friday, November 23. Last week: - Finished #22074 (Review Firefox Developer Docs and Undocumented bugs since FF52esr). - Reviewed #28039 (Tor Browser log is not shown anymore in terminal since Tor Browser 8.5a2). - Reviewed #22343 (Save as... in the context menu results in using the catch-all circuit). This week: - #27239 (TB team feedback on jump-to-80% work) - #28196 (about:preferences#general is not properly translated anymore) tjr: * MinGW - Landed sandbox support on -central. x86/x64 builds on -central should be consistently runnable. - Working on getting mingw-clang tests running on -central https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1475994 - Uplifted a bunch of mingw-clang patches to esr60. Intend to figure out what else besides this we need to uplift and get it done. - Have a esr60 build of mingw-clang successfully building. Haven't tested if it runs yet. - Intend to harass people about uplifting nss patches to esr60, which would unblock uplifting the build jobs - Nothing is stopping us at this point to start bringing the mingw-clang toolchain into rbm; I'm just intimidated to start trying to do it. - Keeping an eye on the accessibility stuff! https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1430149 * Fuzzyfox - It's in Nightly. It would probably be easy enough to backport to esr60. - We had someone test it manually a bunch, and they found only one minor issue. https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1506295 - That said, I am less certain it is worry-free. I wanted to do some performance debugging locally. - We also don't know what level of security assurance it gives us at different levels, and how it compares with Tor's 100ms choice right now. * Emailed kinetik about cubeb audio files (https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/ticket/28373) - Got a response that there are temp files. I didn't fully understand his other replies. - Does anyone at Tor have the bandwidth to drive this conversation, or should I try to? [GeKo: I will get back to that one this week] * TB 8 Retrospective Followup - please help me - Tor disables the web extensions process on <platforms>. The tickets/reasons for this are <?> - [GeKo: In ESR60 this is only available on Windows (IIRC the feature landed for macOS and Linux in Firefox >= 61; The reason for this is that this breaks Torbutton/NoScript communication needed for our security slider, see: https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/ticket/27411] - [tjr] Okay, so it seems like the path forward for this is just integration them into the browser? Is relying on that for the next ESR a safe approach, or should I investigate these prefs and ensure they keep working in the next ESR just in case we need them? - I'm going to talk to #build folks about the rust stuff, continuing the conversation in https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1376621 and trying to build consensus among them on a path forward. I intend to propose this issue to the Tor Uplift Team (Ethan) as a 'must complete' by the next ESR. - I think it'd be good to get feedback from Mozilla on the strategy to import torbutton/torlauncher into the browser codebase. I am in a holding pattern for that waiting for tor browser proposals to be written. - I need to think about how to better communicate open mozilla bugs as we approach next ESR - I have been writing a WinDbg guide for trac for debugging mingw-clang builds with WinDbg * Other: I am considering writing a tbb-dev proposal to increase the max content processes from 4 to 999. This would increase memory consumption, especially for users with a lot of tabs. It would provide some small level of tab isolation at the process level, but only for new tabs opened, not tabs reused. The security gain contains a lot of "Well if the user does this, things are kinda better, but if they do this they're no better." So not sure if it's useful, the main draw is that it's a 4 character patch, so easy to do, just difficult to decide one. igt0: Last week: - First set of patches to #25013 (torbutton within torbrowser) - Rebased #27111 (about:tor on mobile) This week: - Finish #25013(add the necessary bits of code in tor browser) - Add banner on tor browser(#28093) - More TBA alpha2 stuff pospeselr: Last week: - Final patch for #26540 (pdfjs circuit isolation) - #3600 work ( doc could use some eyes: https://storm.torproject.org/shared/Kw99Ow0ExZFFC6FKD5CeryfVFAoAL9Z_iEVlflI… ): [GeKo: I'll give it another look this week] - Some more work on the brainstorming/design doc, circling in on a 'mix and match' solution here - Still some open questions here regarding user experience related to OAuth and cookie keying: - If you use an OAuth provider (say oauth.com) via foo.com, should the session cookie related to oauth.com be valid for other sites using that provider, or should that cookie be double-keyed to foo.com|oauth.com? My intuition is that oauth.com should not be treated as a first party in such a scenario. - Mozilla's Ehsan Akhgari has pointed me to some patches added in Firefox 64 that appear to be necessary for this work (determining whether domains have been interacted with by a user) - A bit of Athens travel planning This week: - Uplift #26540 - filed bug https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1506693 - Investigate per-sku app icons - Backporting user interaction patches from Firefox 64, adding debugging hooks for the various redirect entry points needed regardless of final solution here sysrqb: Last week: TBA+Orbot - #28051 A little S19 interview work rust audit TBA+tor-browser-build This week: Finish TBA+Orbot - #28051 TBA localization Review #26690 - TBA onion-padlock Review #25013 - move Torbutton into tor-browser boklm: Last week: - made two builds with `-Wl,-t` for #26148 (binutils update) and started looking at logs - updated and tested patches for #27265 (In some cases, rbm will download files in the wrong project directory) and #27045 (Add option for firefox incremental builds) - made patch for #28260 (Use Rust 1.28.0 to build Tor), with help from gk. This week: - look at the logs from `-Wl,-t` to try to understand the issue from #26148 - work on bringing back the testsuite sisbell: Last week: - # 27443 Firefox for Android - add test dependencies for gradle, testing various ndk versions, rust versions and API levels - # 28144 Update tor-browser for Android - Add extensions and repackage and debug sign apk, verified apk runs on device This Week: - # 28144 Add makefile for Android - # 27443 Investigate rust deltas between 1.26/1.28 [GeKo will find out the patch that fixes this for 1.28 and sisbell meanwhile tries to get #27977 in shape] pili: Last week: - DRL Proposal This week: - Carry on roadmapping... - OTF Engineering lab follow up - Tor Browser Release meeting this week! (just an announcement :) ) [19:00 UTC :) ] arthuredelstein: Last week: - Refactored/simplified patch for https://bugzil.la/1330467 (FPI for permissions); will post soon - Investigated https://trac.torproject.org/26498 (bn-BD not displayed in title bars) - Revised https://trac.torproject.org/22343 (Save As... FPI) - Started working again on https://trac.torproject.org/25555 (Optimistic SOCKS) - Revised https://trac.torproject.org/28187 (Change Tor Circuit display icon to an onion) This week/next week - Try to get something working for #25555 - See if it's possible to fix #26498 antonela: Last week: - Security Settings - Tor Browser Icon survey ended - https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/ticket/25702#comment:8 - when can we have it packed? [GeKo: not sure yet as we are not used to have three different icons for our release channels; pospeselr will look into the changes we'd this week] This week: - Moar Security Settings - Leading Orfox users to Tor Browser Android (27399) - Design TBA+Orbot configuration UI/UX (28329) Georg

1 0

Tor network team meeting notes, 12 Nov 2018
by Nick Mathewson 12 Nov '18

12 Nov '18

Hi! Logs here: http://meetbot.debian.net/tor-meeting/2018/tor-meeting.2018-11-12-17.59.html Pad contents below: = Network team meeting pad! = This week's team meeting is on Monday at 1800 UTC (1 hour later for daylight saving time) on #tor-meeting on OFTC. Welcome to our meeting! First meeting each month: Tuesday at 2300 UTC Other meetings each month: Mondays at 1800 UTC (1 hour later for daylight saving time) On #tor-meeting on OFTC. (This channel is logged while meetings are in progress.) (See https://lists.torproject.org/pipermail/tor-project/2017-September/001459.ht… for background.) Want to participate? Awesome! Here's what to do: 1. If you have updates, enter them below, under your name. 2. If you see anything you want to talk about in your updates, put them in boldface! 3. Show up to the IRC meeting and say hi! After each week's meetings, the contents of this pad will be sent to tor-project @ lists.torproject.org. After that is done, the pad can be used for the next week. == Previous notes == (Search the list archive for older notes.) 15 Oct: https://lists.torproject.org/pipermail/tor-project/2018-October/002027.html 22 Oct: https://lists.torproject.org/pipermail/tor-project/2018-October/002032.html 29 Oct: https://lists.torproject.org/pipermail/tor-project/2018-October/002036.html 6 Nov: https://lists.torproject.org/pipermail/tor-project/2018-November/002047.html == Stuff to do every week = * Let's check and update the roadmap. What's done, and what's coming up? url to roadmap: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Ufrun1khEo5Cwd6OwngERn829wU3W3eskdr… * Check reviewer assignments at https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Ufrun1khEo5Cwd6OwngERn829wU3W3eskdr… * Also, let's check for things we need update on our spreadsheet! Are there important documents we should link to? Things we should archive? * Check rotations at https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/wiki/org/teams/NetworkTeam/TeamRot… * Let's look at proposed tickets! 0.3.5 (bugs only): https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/query?status=accepted&status=assig… 0.4.0: https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/query?status=accepted&status=assig… == Reminders == * Remember to "/me status: foo" at least once daily. * Remember that our current code reviews should be done by end-of-week. * Make sure you are in touch with everybody with whom you are doing work for the next releases * Remember to fill up actual point when you finish a task (as well as "fix" the estimate when starting the issue). * Add planned PTO to the calendar https://storm.torproject.org/shared/ISA5L5nH0Xu88iqSCx9ZjCXYSMKOBTdbUeWarbd… << Remember that priority is Sponsor 8 - roadmap is sort out by priority >> Activity O2.5 is the one we are missing and need to be done in 2 months. * Remember that you can already book the flight to Brussels for hackweek. (Ask jon & gaba if you have any question) ------------------------------- ---- 12 November 2018 ------------------------------- == Announcements == Please don't bulk-delete all the old entries from this pad any more. Instead, delete the "planned" and "actual" for the previous week, but leave the "planned" for this week in place. Please check the dates before deleting. Check other's people call for help in their entries. Nick's upcoming release plans: Starting now: Stay up to date on backports. [See spreadsheet about backport status.] Late next week, around Nov 23: TB releases with 0.3.5.4-alpha. ~Dec 3: 0.3.5.5-(rc or alpha) [Note short window from TB release!] Dec 11: TB releases again. ~Jan 2: Release 0.3.5.6-(rc or stable). Release 0.3.4.10. Release 0.3.3.11. Jan 15: Feature freeze for 0.4.0. Later in Jan: Release 0.4.0.1-alpha. Snowflake kickoff meeting on November 27th: overview and what needs to be done. == Discussion == * sponsor 8 work O2.5 (bootstrap reporting) is most important - right now working on this: catalyst, ahf, dgoulet, teor. any of you need help with it? * Please see tickets with tag "035-rc-blocker?" -- are any of them really rc blockers? Are there any other true rc blockers? https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/query?status=accepted&status=assig… * Is our process for "proposed" working? == Recommended links == Cool talk on communication in teams http://lenareinhard.com/do-you-read-me-better-communication-for-stronger-te… == Updates == NOTE NEW FORMAT! Name: Week of XYZ (planned): - What you planned for last week. Week of XYZ (actual): - What you did last week. Week of ABC (planned): - What you're planning to do this week. Help with: - Something you may need help with. PLEASE DO NOT BULK-DELETE THE OLD ENTRIES! Leave the "Planned" parts! Leave the parts for last week and this week! Nick: Week of 11/5 (planned): - Comment on new version of crypto thing /prop295 - Review wtf-pad design and code (waiting on status update for proposal revisions) - Meet with B Bhumiratana to chat about net privacy - Plan and possibly start working on #2149 ("extra dormant") with dgoulet - Revise or merge #28226 (messaging system) - Release 0.3.5.4-alpha? - Possibly, design for testing sustems that use pub/sub. Week of 11/5 (actual) - Implemented a python version of prop295, circulated in network team. Got comments on new version's readability. - Reviewed wtf-pad design; initial architectural review of code. - Met with B Bhumiratana (Eisenhower fellow). He said he knows Haxxpop :) - Designed #28335 ("extra dormant nouveau") with dgoulet and started coding. - Released 0.3.5.4-alpha - Wrote enhancement for checkIncludes.py (#28362) to detect circular include structures among directories. Resolved the ones we have in lib. - Merge, Reveiew, etc. - Figured out OpenSSL 1.1.1/TLS 1.3 client problem (#28245) - Rearranged 035-can / 035-must tags a bit Week of 11/12 (planned): - Send comments about prop295 draft back to Tomer et al - Triage 0.3.5 must-do vs may-do stuff. - Continue revising publish/subscribe code pending comments from Taylor #28226. - Continue work on "dormant mode" logic for #28335. Hope to finish first draft, but might pend #28226 work. - Time permitting, add more tests for myfamily memory improvements (#27359) - Plan when to do next alpha/stable releases. - Write a schedule for upcoming releases - Backports to 0.3.4 etc Want help with: Mike: week of 11/5 (planned) - New GPG subkey. Kill me. - More WTF-pad proposal updates - Vanguards release? - WTF-PAD updates, fixups, tests - Datagram paper diff for nick week of 11/5 (actual) - WTF-pad proposal disussion - WTF-PAD updates, fixups (maybe 80% of the way through code review change requests) - Highlights: Supports 65532 states now with not much addtl overhead week of 11/12 (planned) - GPG? Does anyone use it? can we agree to stop? Kidding. ;) - More WTF-PAD fixups, tests - Vanguards release? - Datagram paper diff for nick help with: ahf: Week of 11/05 (planned): Sponsor 8: - Finish #28179 and get it reviewed+landed. - Talked with HC from TGP about #28409. Sponsor 19: - Continue wrapping my head around PT tasks for s19 (mostly focusing on Snowflake). - Help UX with #27385. - Anti censorship team hire. Misc: - Review #28298. - Do reimbursements from Mexico. Week of 11/05 (actually): Sponsor 8: - Got first patches for #28179 pushed to bugs/28179. Sponsor 19: - Looked at HTTPS Proxy (for the alt. PT part of S19) - Discussed #28298 with Antonela. - Interview with two candidates. Some pre-interview meetings with technical questions, etc. - Send out email to network team about S19 kick off meeting. Misc: - Reviewed #28298. - Didn't do Mexico reimbursement... Week of 11/12 (planned): Sponsor 8: - Hook up transports.c with the code from #28179 and test that it all still works on all our platforms -- begin on #28180 with David. - Begin on #27100. Sponsor 19 - One interview this week with a candidate. - Continue looking into Snowflake. Misc: - Do the Mexico reimbursement that I keep postponing. - Book flight tickets for Brussels. asn: Week of 10/29 (planned): - Continue reviewing, refactoring and testing the WTF-PAD code. - Try to come up with a useful WTF-PAD state machine that we actually want to merge. - Do reviews. Week of 10/29 (actual): - Continue reviewing, refactoring and testing the WTF-PAD branch. Passed knowledge to Nick so that he can also do some reviewing. Found some bugs and wrote some commits to improve code. - Did reviews (#28308, #28906, #28184, #28245). - Help out with the anti-censorship team hires. Week of 11/05 (planned): - Sufficient review has happenened on the WTF-PAD branch. It's now time to start working on the TODO items and wrapping this up so that we move towards merge. Coordinate this with Mike. - Do reviews. - Continue helping with the anti-censorship team hires. Help with: - Mike we should figure out next steps to move thjis to merge. dgoulet: (offline for meeting) Week of 11/5 (planned): - Planned, review and/or work on #28335 with nickm. - Available for ahf to review #28179 and then start working on the code for #28180 (s8). - Finalize whatever s8 other tasks come up this week. Week of 11/5 (actual): - Review #28330 subsystem branch from nickm. - Ticket work on HSv3 bugs: #27841, #28184. Week of 11/12 (planned): - Holiday on November 12th. - Review #28179 important s8 ticket then move on to #28180. - Help nickm with #28335 and childs. gaba: Week of 11/5 (actual): - gettor follow up - hackweek cancel KU reservation - get into ooni work/roadmap - start looking at CVs that come up for data architect position for metrics team - several weekly meetings (ooni, metrics, fundraising, las vegas) and 1:1s - work on DRL proposal that was submitted on Friday Week of 11/12 (planned): - weekly meetings (ooni, metrics, fundraising, las vegas) and 1:1s - metrics data architect position - participate in interviews for anti-censorship team developer - ooni roadmap - gettor help with: - communicating anything about sponsor8-bootstrap help/needs and progress catalyst: week of 11/05 (2018-W45) (planned): - reviews - bug triage rotation - 0.3.5 bugfixes as needed week of 11/05 (2018-W45) (actual): - bug triage - reviewed #28229 - continued reviewing #28226 -- sent comments on msg stuff - preliminary planning for Athens meeting week of 11/12 (2018-W46) (planned): - reviews - #27167 - 0.3.5 bugfixes as needed help with: haxxpop: Week of 11/5 (planned): - Probably discuss about #28275. A lot of ideas are going through. So fun :). And I will fix it if there is something to be changed. - Write the tor-keygen man page, if I have time left. help with: teor (online!): Week of 5 Nov (planned): - Pick up a s8 bootstrap ticket, and do it - Try and make progress on the s8 chutney consensus failure bugfix tickets - Defer: Make the fallback script ignore addresses in the whitelist, so we can rebuild the fallback list - Defer: Work on PrivCount in Tor prototype - merge the crypto_rand_double() C code in #23061, and write a Rust equivalent - minor fixes to privcount_shamir - finish off the travis CI config for chutney / turn it into a config to test PrivCount in Tor Week of 5 Nov (actual): - Started "pick guards from a reasonably live consensus" (#24661), found #28319 - More admin, hackfest planning - Cleared my ticket backlog, lots of little ticket updates, code reviews - Planning for s8-bootstrap - Reviewed metrics' total consensus weight and consensus weight by flag graphs - Extensive reviews on various sbws tickets - Looked at some CVs for the metrics position - Internet Freedom Hack presentation and mentoring Week of 12 Nov (planned): - Continue to work on s8 bootstrap tickets - "pick guards from a reasonably live consensus" (#24661) - do path selection from a reasonably live consensus (#28319) - Fix the s8 chutney consensus failure bugs - Do a review of the sbws specs once a week - Defer: Make the fallback script ignore addresses in the whitelist, so we can rebuild the fallback list - Defer: Work on PrivCount in Tor prototype Week of 12 Nov (actual): - sbws spec ticket review - more admin Help with: - nickm, I would like help on how to access --RUNNING-FORKED in #28096. It seems to require an abstraction layer violation: argv is in tinytest.c, but tor code is in test_common.c. Is there some simple trick I'm missing? (So, IMO it would be okay to look at the "v" argument in main in testing_common.c: it is argv. Yes, that's a layer violation, but tinytest is under our control anyway. Alternatively, we could extend tinytest, I guess? I'll be around at the patch party time to talk more if it's helpful -nickm) juga: Week of 11/05 (planned): - tor code - continue with #21377: DirAuths should expose bwauth bandwidth files - continue with #22453: Relays should regularly do a larger bandwidth self-test - start with #26698: Authorities should put a hash of the bandwidth file in their votes - undecided on trying to start some tasks that are not priority but on which the rest of the work on bandwidth stuff might depend - Week 11/05 (actual): - Tor code - serve bandwidth files used in the votes (#21377) - include the digest of the bandwidth file in the vote (#26698) - Bandwidth File specification - correct scaling methods examples (#27690) - correct key/values (#28085) - Tor Directory Protocol specification - remove bandwidth file headers key/values (#28382) - include a "bandwidth-file" item the vote documents (#28359) - updated sbws Debian package to 1.0 - started to write about the bandwidth distribution goal problem - Week 11/19 (plan): - Tor code - Relays should regularly do a larger bandwidth self-test (#22453) - bandwidth testing circuits should be allowed to use our guards (#19009) - In a private network some relays advertise zero bandwidth-observed (#24250) - sbws - Change integration tests from bash to POSIX shell (#28106) - revisions - Help with: - anyone: review my tickets in "needs_review" :)

1 0