Snowflake stats available?
Dear team, thank you for your great work. We are a tech NGO from Germany and startet a little campaign here to encourage users to run a snowflake to help circumvent cencorship (e.g. Iran, Russia): https://snowflake.fiff.de/index_en.html Now we get a lot of questions about how many ppl actually do run snowflakes, but on https://metrics.torproject.org we couldn't find any data on snowflake. Could this data be make available or are there reasons for hiding it? Thanks so much Rainer -- Forum InformatikerInnen für Frieden und gesellschaftliche Verantwortung e. V. Goetheplatz 4, D-28203 Bremen Telefon +49 421 33659255 - Fax +49 421 33659256 E-Mail: fiff@fiff.de - https://www.fiff.de - https://twitter.com/fiff_de Unterstützen und Spenden: https://www.fiff.de/about/mitgliedschaft-spenden PGP: https://keys.mailvelope.com/pks/lookup?op=get&search=rainer.rehak@fiff.de FP: 63D2 9BCB 65CB FA55 F851 BDE3 0CAA 0E82 8193 953E
Quoting Rainer Rehak (FIfF) (2022-11-25 02:19:15)
thank you for your great work. We are a tech NGO from Germany and startet a little campaign here to encourage users to run a snowflake to help circumvent cencorship (e.g. Iran, Russia): https://snowflake.fiff.de/index_en.html
Now we get a lot of questions about how many ppl actually do run snowflakes, but on https://metrics.torproject.org we couldn't find any data on snowflake.
Could this data be make available or are there reasons for hiding it?
The metrics are public, see the snowflake stadistics in collector: https://metrics.torproject.org/collector.html#snowflake-stats The last one I see is: snowflake-ips DE=9498,US=5900,NL=1397,RU=1159,FR=1066,GB=1012,BE=776,CH=669,JP=645,AT=618,CA=593,IT=511,IN=480,BR=454,PL=359,SE=331,AU=327,ES=293,RO=254,IR=2 22,CZ=209,DK=209,FI=205,MX=161,EU=154,GR=153,PT=149,NO=144,CN=128,DZ=126,MY=119,HK=117,SG=111,PH=107,TH=105,AR=104,CL=98,UA=97,ZA=97,ID=89,TR=85,TW=70,IE=69, HU=68,NZ=67,SK=67,BD=66,IL=62,??=58,KR=51,NG=42,BG=39,BY=36,LU=34,LT=32,SI=30,CO=29,YE=29,LV=28,EE=25,EG=25,RS=22,HR=21,LK=21,AE=20,MA=20,VN=20,KE=18,GH=16,I S=14,KZ=13,MD=13,PK=13,EC=12,PR=12,UY=12,CM=11,CR=11,ET=11,GE=11,NP=11,UZ=11,CY=10,NA=10,PE=10,QA=8,SA=8,SV=8,TN=8,AL=7,BJ=6,PA=6,SD=6,VE=6,BO=5,IQ=5,KG=5,MM =5,CI=4,JM=4,JO=4,KH=4,MT=4,SO=4,SY=4,BA=3,BS=3,CU=3,CW=3,LY=3,ME=3,MG=3,MK=3,MO=3,MU=3,OM=3,PS=3,PY=3,AM=2,HN=2,JE=2,LB=2,LI=2,MV=2,RE=2,ZW=2,AG=1,BB=1,BH=1 ,BW=1,GF=1,GG=1,GP=1,GU=1,HT=1,NE=1,SN=1,TC=1,TM=1,TT=1,TZ=1,UG=1,ZM=1 snowflake-ips-badge 178 snowflake-ips-iptproxy 4343 snowflake-ips-standalone 2875 snowflake-ips-webext 23388 snowflake-ips-total 30784 So there are 30k snowflakes, 23k are webextensions and just in germany ~9.5k. We haven't got the time yet to plot those data properly in metrics.torproject.org, I just created a ticket for it: https://gitlab.torproject.org/tpo/anti-censorship/pluggable-transports/snowf... Another way to access similar data is in the prometheus[0] exporter of the snowflake broker: https://snowflake-broker.torproject.net/prometheus [0] https://prometheus.io/ -- meskio | https://meskio.net/ -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- My contact info: https://meskio.net/crypto.txt -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Nos vamos a Croatan.
Quoting meskio (2022-11-29 13:33:44)
The metrics are public, see the snowflake stadistics in collector: https://metrics.torproject.org/collector.html#snowflake-stats
The last one I see is: snowflake-ips DE=9498,US=5900,NL=1397,RU=1159,FR=1066,GB=1012,BE=776,CH=669,JP=645,AT=618,CA=593,IT=511,IN=480,BR=454,PL=359,SE=331,AU=327,ES=293,RO=254,IR=2 22,CZ=209,DK=209,FI=205,MX=161,EU=154,GR=153,PT=149,NO=144,CN=128,DZ=126,MY=119,HK=117,SG=111,PH=107,TH=105,AR=104,CL=98,UA=97,ZA=97,ID=89,TR=85,TW=70,IE=69, HU=68,NZ=67,SK=67,BD=66,IL=62,??=58,KR=51,NG=42,BG=39,BY=36,LU=34,LT=32,SI=30,CO=29,YE=29,LV=28,EE=25,EG=25,RS=22,HR=21,LK=21,AE=20,MA=20,VN=20,KE=18,GH=16,I S=14,KZ=13,MD=13,PK=13,EC=12,PR=12,UY=12,CM=11,CR=11,ET=11,GE=11,NP=11,UZ=11,CY=10,NA=10,PE=10,QA=8,SA=8,SV=8,TN=8,AL=7,BJ=6,PA=6,SD=6,VE=6,BO=5,IQ=5,KG=5,MM =5,CI=4,JM=4,JO=4,KH=4,MT=4,SO=4,SY=4,BA=3,BS=3,CU=3,CW=3,LY=3,ME=3,MG=3,MK=3,MO=3,MU=3,OM=3,PS=3,PY=3,AM=2,HN=2,JE=2,LB=2,LI=2,MV=2,RE=2,ZW=2,AG=1,BB=1,BH=1 ,BW=1,GF=1,GG=1,GP=1,GU=1,HT=1,NE=1,SN=1,TC=1,TM=1,TT=1,TZ=1,UG=1,ZM=1 snowflake-ips-badge 178 snowflake-ips-iptproxy 4343 snowflake-ips-standalone 2875 snowflake-ips-webext 23388 snowflake-ips-total 30784
So there are 30k snowflakes, 23k are webextensions and just in germany ~9.5k.
Ups, I just notice this numbers are not from the latest data in collector, but from an old file I can around from June in my computer. The recent data looks like: snowflake-ips DE=63620,US=17212,IR=4835,CA=4512,AT=3501,GB=3420,CH=3183,NL=2857,FR=2621,SE=1550,IT=1370,AU=1261,BE=1076,RU=959,TR=883,JP=818,BR=806,RO=787,PL=674,ES=647,IN=611,DK=580,FI=570,CZ=482,NO=443,PT=380,EU=349,CL=309,ZA=305,GR=279,SG=214,MX=210,HK=205,NZ=196,??=185,LU=178,CN=177,IE=173,IL=164,UA=162,TW=158,TH=152,MY=151,AR=146,HU=144,PH=143,ID=142,KR=132,BG=111,AE=110,NG=110,SK=91,EE=85,LT=81,GE=78,RS=67,VN=65,CO=63,EG=62,SI=58,IQ=57,LV=55,CI=51,HR=48,PK=48,AM=47,BD=41,KZ=38,MD=36,KE=35,CY=33,KW=32,SA=31,EC=30,IS=29,AZ=27,BY=26,CR=26,MU=23,PE=23,DZ=22,ET=20,UZ=20,PY=18,GH=17,QA=16,AL=15,JO=15,YE=15,MA=14,OM=14,KG=13,LK=13,PR=13,SV=13,MK=12,MO=12,CM=11,LB=11,MT=11,NP=11,TN=11,BO=10,VU=10,BA=8,MV=8,PS=8,GA=7,NA=7,PA=7,RE=7,VE=7,LI=6,MM=6,MW=6,SO=6,BB=5,DJ=5,DO=5,KH=5,NI=5,BH=4,BS=4,TT=4,UY=4,GF=3,HN=3,TZ=3,AF=2,BJ=2,BW=2,BZ=2,CU=2,GL=2,JM=2,LR=2,LY=2,ME=2,MG=2,PG=2,RW=2,SY=2,ZM=2,AD=1,AO=1,CV=1,GD=1,GM=1,GP=1,GT=1,HT=1,JE=1,LA=1,ML=1,NC=1,SC=1,SN=1,SX=1,TG=1,UG=1,VI=1,ZW=1 snowflake-ips-standalone 4017 snowflake-ips-webext 109650 snowflake-ips-badge 4668 snowflake-ips-iptproxy 7833 snowflake-ips-total 126168 So 126k snowflakes, 109k webextensions and 63k from germany. Sorry for the wrong data. -- meskio | https://meskio.net/ -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- My contact info: https://meskio.net/crypto.txt -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Nos vamos a Croatan.
I do hope y'ep ohodi will get my thanks. Never revenge eg sish teeth here in u nitro or tin cars racer Reiner. #sos #gear read s d'aer *only.* *rem. lagam6a.doqs@wal.s.law* *"and so snowflakes fall in the sea, eventualy" * Britney rules ok?) Ivan Pavlović, prof.soc | prof.kroat uto, 29. stu 2022. 12:33 Rainer Rehak (FIfF) <rainer.rehak@fiff.de> je napisao:
Dear team,
thank you for your great work. We are a tech NGO from Germany and startet a little campaign here to encourage users to run a snowflake to help circumvent cencorship (e.g. Iran, Russia): https://snowflake.fiff.de/index_en.html
Now we get a lot of questions about how many ppl actually do run snowflakes, but on https://metrics.torproject.org we couldn't find any data on snowflake.
Could this data be make available or are there reasons for hiding it?
Thanks so much Rainer
-- Forum InformatikerInnen für Frieden und gesellschaftliche Verantwortung e. V. Goetheplatz 4, D-28203 Bremen Telefon +49 421 33659255 - Fax +49 421 33659256 E-Mail: fiff@fiff.de - https://www.fiff.de - https://twitter.com/fiff_de
Unterstützen und Spenden: https://www.fiff.de/about/mitgliedschaft-spenden
PGP: https://keys.mailvelope.com/pks/lookup?op=get&search=rainer.rehak@fiff.de FP: 63D2 9BCB 65CB FA55 F851 BDE3 0CAA 0E82 8193 953E _______________________________________________ network-health mailing list network-health@lists.torproject.org https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/network-health
participants (3)
-
Ivan Pavlovic -
meskio -
Rainer Rehak (FIfF)