On Thursday, October 23, 2014 at 10:32 AM, David Fifield wrote:
In the past few months of bridge user graphs, there is an apparent negative correlation between obfs3 users and vanilla users: when one goes up, the other goes down. If you draw a horizontal line at about 5500, they are almost mirror images of each other. I don't see it with any other transport pairs. Any idea why it might be?
I can see what could cause a simultaneous decrease in vanilla and increase in obfs3: Tor gets blocked somewhere and users switch to obfs3. But I wouldn't expect blocking events to look so smooth or happen so frequently, and it doesn't explain why the reverse change happens later (obfs3 being blocked while Tor is unblocked is less plausible). I can also understand the overall long-term trend of obfs3 increasing and vanilla decreasing. But I don't see why they should mirror each other so closely over short time periods.
Some hypotheses:
- There are lots of users who have a mix of vanilla and obfs3 bridges
configured. Their tor (randomly?) chooses one of them, which usually works. The number of such users is constant over the short term; i.e. the sum of obfs3+vanilla is constant, but the proportion of obfs3 and vanilla fluctuates randomly. 2. Maybe vanilla-down/obfs3-up is caused by blocking events, and vanilla-up/obfs3-down is caused by natural new-user churn and/or coincidence.
My guess is that there’s an order
0. vanilla 1. obfs3 2. else
and it *always* starts from the top and tries going down the list until it finds one that works.
So when vanilla is unreachable it tries obfs3. At a later date, when vanilla is no longer blocked, it moves back.
- There is something about the way BridgeDB hands out bridges, or the
way in which users use it, that causes it to give out obfs3 bridges at the expense of vanilla and vice versa. 4. Some kind of feedback loop: obfs3 bridges get used and get congested, so users switch to vanilla, which then get used and congested, etc.
David Fifield _______________________________________________ tor-dev mailing list tor-dev@lists.torproject.org (mailto:tor-dev@lists.torproject.org) https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-dev
Attachments:
- userstats-bridge-transport-<OR>-obfs3-2014-08-01-2014-10-23.png