commit 5ca9de3170e77151e02a6e5b0072a8d6b300ba82
Author: teor <teor(a)torproject.org>
Date: Mon Mar 9 15:54:42 2020 +1000
TorNet: Check each node's dir info distribution
Check that every relay has published its directory info to the
authorities, it is in the consensus, and every node has downloaded it.
Check that every bridge has published its directory info to the
bridge authority, and it is in the bridge networkstatus.
Check that every bridge client has downloaded bridge descriptors.
This code currently does not work for these chutney networks:
* bridges-min
* bridges+ipv6-min
All other networks pass the new tests.
Part of 33379.
---
lib/chutney/TorNet.py | 645 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++--
1 file changed, 631 insertions(+), 14 deletions(-)
diff --git a/lib/chutney/TorNet.py b/lib/chutney/TorNet.py
index e76d9f6..a4b3d76 100644
--- a/lib/chutney/TorNet.py
+++ b/lib/chutney/TorNet.py
@@ -853,6 +853,51 @@ class LocalNodeController(NodeController):
"""Return the nickname for this node."""
return self._env['nick']
+ def getBridge(self):
+ """Return the bridge (relay) flag for this node."""
+ try:
+ return self._env['bridge']
+ except KeyError:
+ return 0
+
+ def getBridgeClient(self):
+ """Return the bridge client flag for this node."""
+ try:
+ return self._env['bridgeclient']
+ except KeyError:
+ return 0
+
+ def getBridgeAuthority(self):
+ """Return the bridge authority flag for this node."""
+ try:
+ return self._env['bridgeauthority']
+ except KeyError:
+ return 0
+
+ def getAuthority(self):
+ """Return the authority flag for this node."""
+ try:
+ return self._env['authority']
+ except KeyError:
+ return 0
+
+ def getConsensusAuthority(self):
+ """Is this node a consensus (V2 directory) authority?"""
+ return self.getAuthority() and not self.getBridgeAuthority()
+
+ def getConsensusMember(self):
+ """Is this node listed in the consensus?"""
+ return self.getDirServer() and not self.getBridge()
+
+ def getDirServer(self):
+ """Return the relay flag for this node.
+ The relay flag is set on authorities, relays, and bridges.
+ """
+ try:
+ return self._env['relay']
+ except KeyError:
+ return 0
+
def getPid(self):
"""Assuming that this node has its pidfile in ${dir}/pid, return
the pid of the running process, or None if there is no pid in the
@@ -1070,7 +1115,512 @@ class LocalNodeController(NodeController):
"""Return true iff the logfile says that this instance is
bootstrapped."""
pct, _, _ = self.getLastBootstrapStatus()
- return pct == 100
+ return pct == LocalNodeController.SUCCESS_CODE
+
+ # There are 7 v3 directory document types, but some networks only use 6,
+ # because they don't have a bridge authority
+ DOC_TYPE_DISPLAY_LIMIT_BRIDGEAUTH = 7
+ DOC_TYPE_DISPLAY_LIMIT_NO_BRIDGEAUTH = 6
+
+ def getDocTypeDisplayLimit(self):
+ """Return the expected number of document types in this network."""
+ if _THE_NETWORK._dfltEnv['hasbridgeauth']:
+ return LocalNodeController.DOC_TYPE_DISPLAY_LIMIT_BRIDGEAUTH
+ else:
+ return LocalNodeController.DOC_TYPE_DISPLAY_LIMIT_NO_BRIDGEAUTH
+
+ def getNodeCacheDirInfoPaths(self, v2_dir_paths):
+ """Return a 2-tuple containing:
+ * a boolean indicating whether this node is a directory server,
+ (that is, an authority, relay, or bridge), and
+ * a dict with the expected paths to the consensus files for this
+ node.
+
+ If v2_dir_paths is True, returns the v3 directory paths.
+ Otherwise, returns the bridge status path.
+ If v2_dir_paths is True, but this node is not a bridge client or
+ bridge authority, returns None. (There are no paths.)
+
+ Directory servers usually have both consensus flavours.
+ Clients usually have the microdesc consensus, but they may have
+ either flavour. (Or both flavours.)
+ Only the bridge authority has the bridge networkstatus.
+
+ The dict keys are:
+ * "ns_cons", "desc", and "desc_new";
+ * "md_cons", "md", and "md_new"; and
+ * "br_status".
+ """
+ bridge_client = self.getBridgeClient()
+ bridge_auth = self.getBridgeAuthority()
+ datadir = self._env['dir']
+ is_dir_server = self.getDirServer()
+
+ desc = os.path.join(datadir, "cached-descriptors")
+ desc_new = os.path.join(datadir, "cached-descriptors.new")
+
+ paths = None
+ if v2_dir_paths:
+ ns_cons = os.path.join(datadir, "cached-consensus")
+ md_cons = os.path.join(datadir,
+ "cached-microdesc-consensus")
+ md = os.path.join(datadir, "cached-microdescs")
+ md_new = os.path.join(datadir, "cached-microdescs.new")
+
+ paths = { 'ns_cons': ns_cons,
+ 'desc': desc,
+ 'desc_new': desc_new,
+ 'md_cons': md_cons,
+ 'md': md,
+ 'md_new': md_new }
+ # the published node is a bridge
+ # bridges are only used by bridge clients and bridge authorities
+ elif bridge_client or bridge_auth:
+ # bridge descs are stored with relay descs
+ paths = { 'desc': desc,
+ 'desc_new': desc_new }
+ if bridge_auth:
+ br_status = os.path.join(datadir, "networkstatus-bridges")
+ paths['br_status'] = br_status
+ else:
+ # We're looking for bridges, but other nodes don't use bridges
+ paths = None
+
+ return (is_dir_server, paths)
+
+ def getNodePublishedDirInfoPaths(self):
+ """Return a dict of paths to consensus files, where we expect this
+ node to be published.
+
+ The dict keys are the nicks for each node.
+
+ See getNodeCacheDirInfoPaths() for the path data structure, and which
+ nodes appear in each type of directory.
+ """
+ consensus_member = self.getConsensusMember()
+ bridge_member = self.getBridge()
+ # Nodes can be a member of only one kind of directory
+ assert not (consensus_member and bridge_member)
+
+ # Clients don't appear in any consensus
+ if not consensus_member and not bridge_member:
+ return None
+
+ # at this point, consensus_member == not bridge_member
+ directory_files = dict()
+ for node in _THE_NETWORK._nodes:
+ nick = node._env['nick']
+ controller = node.getController()
+ node_files = controller.getNodeCacheDirInfoPaths(consensus_member)
+ # skip empty file lists
+ if node_files:
+ directory_files[nick] = node_files
+
+ assert len(directory_files) > 0
+ return directory_files
+
+ def getNodeDirInfoStatusPattern(self, dir_format):
+ """Returns a regular expression pattern for finding this node's entry
+ in a dir_format file.
+
+ The microdesc format is not yet implemented, because it requires
+ the ed25519 key. (Or RSA block matching, which is hard.)
+ """
+ nickname = self.getNick()
+
+ cons = dir_format in ["ns_cons",
+ "md_cons",
+ "br_status"]
+ desc = dir_format in ["desc",
+ "desc_new"]
+ md = dir_format in ["md",
+ "md_new"]
+
+ assert cons or desc or md
+
+ if cons:
+ return r'^r ' + nickname + " "
+ elif desc:
+ return r'^router ' + nickname + " "
+ elif md:
+ # Not yet implemented, see #33428
+ # r'^id ed25519 " + ed25519_identity (end of line)
+ # needs ed25519-identity from #30642
+ # or the existing keys/ed25519_master_id_public_key
+ return None
+
+ def getFileDirInfoStatus(self, dir_format, dir_path):
+ """Check dir_path, a directory path used by another node, to see if
+ this node is present. The directory path is a dir_format file.
+
+ Returns a status 3-tuple containing:
+ * an integer status code:
+ * negative numbers correspond to errors,
+ * NO_PROGRESS_CODE means "not in the directory", and
+ * SUCCESS_CODE means "in the directory";
+ * a set containing dir_format; and
+ * a status message string.
+ """
+ if not os.path.exists(dir_path):
+ return (LocalNodeController.MISSING_FILE_CODE,
+ { dir_format }, "No dir file")
+
+ dir_pattern = self.getNodeDirInfoStatusPattern(dir_format)
+ if dir_pattern is None:
+ return (LocalNodeController.NOT_YET_IMPLEMENTED_CODE,
+ { dir_format }, "Not yet implemented")
+
+ line_count = 0
+ with open(dir_path, 'r') as f:
+ for line in f:
+ line_count = line_count + 1
+ m = re.search(dir_pattern, line)
+ if m:
+ return (LocalNodeController.SUCCESS_CODE,
+ { dir_format }, "Dir info cached")
+
+ if line_count == 0:
+ return (LocalNodeController.NO_RECORDS_CODE,
+ { dir_format }, "Empty dir file")
+ elif line_count < 8:
+ # The minimum size of the bridge networkstatus is 3 lines,
+ # and the minimum size of one bridge is 5 lines
+ return (LocalNodeController.INCOMPLETE_RECORDS_CODE,
+ { dir_format }, "Minimal dir file")
+ else:
+ return (LocalNodeController.NO_PROGRESS_CODE,
+ { dir_format }, "Not in dir file")
+
+ def combineDirInfoStatuses(self, dir_status, status_key_list,
+ best=True, ignore_missing=False):
+ """Combine the directory statuses in dir_status, if their keys
+ appear in status_key_list. Keys may be directory formats, or
+ node nicks.
+
+ If best is True, choose the best status, otherwise, choose the
+ worst status.
+
+ If ignore_missing is True, ignore missing statuses, if there is any
+ other status available.
+
+ If statuses are equal, combine their format sets.
+
+ Returns None if the status list is empty.
+ """
+ dir_status_list = [ dir_status[status_key]
+ for status_key in dir_status
+ if status_key in status_key_list ]
+
+ if len(dir_status_list) == 0:
+ return None
+
+ dir_status = None
+ for new_status in dir_status_list:
+ if dir_status is None:
+ dir_status = new_status
+ continue
+
+ (old_status_code, old_flav, old_msg) = dir_status
+ (new_status_code, new_flav, new_msg) = new_status
+ if new_status_code == old_status_code:
+ # We want to know all the flavours that have an
+ # equal status, not just the latest one
+ combined_flav = old_flav.union(new_flav)
+ dir_status = (old_status_code, combined_flav, old_msg)
+ elif (old_status_code == LocalNodeController.MISSING_FILE_CODE and
+ ignore_missing):
+ # use the new status, which can't be MISSING_FILE_CODE,
+ # because they're not equal
+ dir_status = new_status
+ elif (new_status_code == LocalNodeController.MISSING_FILE_CODE and
+ ignore_missing):
+ # ignore the new status
+ pass
+ elif old_status_code == LocalNodeController.NOT_YET_IMPLEMENTED_CODE:
+ # always ignore not yet implemented
+ dir_status = new_status
+ elif new_status_code == LocalNodeController.NOT_YET_IMPLEMENTED_CODE:
+ pass
+ elif best and new_status_code > old_status_code:
+ dir_status = new_status
+ elif not best and new_status_code < old_status_code:
+ dir_status = new_status
+ return dir_status
+
+ def summariseCacheDirInfoStatus(self, dir_status, is_dir_server):
+ """Summarise the statuses for this node, among all the files used by
+ the other node. is_dir_server is True if the other node is a
+ directory server.
+
+ Combine these alternate files by choosing the best status:
+ * desc_alts: "desc" and "desc_new"
+ * md_alts: "md" and "md_new"
+
+ Handle these alternate formats by ignoring missing directory files,
+ then choosing the worst status:
+ * cons_all: "ns_cons" and "md_cons"
+ * desc_all: "desc"/"desc_new" and
+ "md"/"md_new"
+
+ Add an "node_dir" status that describes the overall status, which
+ is the worst status among descriptors, consensuses, and the bridge
+ networkstatus (if relevant). Return this status.
+
+ Returns None if no status is expected.
+ """
+ # We only need to be in one of these files to be successful
+ desc_alts = self.combineDirInfoStatuses(dir_status,
+ ["desc", "desc_new"],
+ best=True,
+ ignore_missing=True)
+ if desc_alts:
+ dir_status["desc_alts"] = desc_alts
+
+ md_alts = self.combineDirInfoStatuses(dir_status,
+ ["md",
+ "md_new"],
+ best=True,
+ ignore_missing=True)
+ if md_alts:
+ dir_status["md_alts"] = md_alts
+
+ if is_dir_server:
+ # Directory servers cache all flavours, so we want the worst
+ # combined flavour status, and we want to treat missing files as
+ # errors
+ cons_all = self.combineDirInfoStatuses(dir_status,
+ ["ns_cons",
+ "md_cons"],
+ best=False,
+ ignore_missing=False)
+ else:
+ # Clients usually only fetch one flavour, so we want the best
+ # combined flavour status, and we want to ignore missing files
+ cons_all = self.combineDirInfoStatuses(dir_status,
+ ["ns_cons",
+ "md_cons"],
+ best=True,
+ ignore_missing=True)
+ if cons_all:
+ dir_status["cons_all"] = cons_all
+
+ if is_dir_server:
+ desc_all = self.combineDirInfoStatuses(dir_status,
+ ["desc_alts",
+ "md_alts"],
+ best=False,
+ ignore_missing=False)
+ else:
+ desc_all = self.combineDirInfoStatuses(dir_status,
+ ["desc_alts",
+ "md_alts"],
+ best=True,
+ ignore_missing=True)
+ if desc_all:
+ dir_status["desc_all"] = desc_all
+
+ # Finally, get the worst status from all the combined statuses,
+ # and the bridge status (if applicable)
+ node_dir = self.combineDirInfoStatuses(dir_status,
+ ["cons_all",
+ "br_status",
+ "desc_all"],
+ best=False,
+ ignore_missing=True)
+ if node_dir:
+ dir_status["node_dir"] = node_dir
+
+ return node_dir
+
+ def getNodeCacheDirInfoStatus(self, other_node_files, is_dir_server):
+ """Check all the directory paths used by another node, to see if this
+ node is present. is_dir_server is True if the other node is a
+ directory server.
+
+ Returns a dict containing a status 3-tuple for every relevant
+ directory format. See getFileDirInfoStatus() for more details.
+
+ Returns None if the node doesn't have any directory files
+ containing published information from this node.
+ """
+ dir_status = dict()
+ assert len(other_node_files)
+ for dir_format in other_node_files:
+ dir_path = other_node_files[dir_format]
+ new_status = self.getFileDirInfoStatus(dir_format, dir_path)
+ if new_status is None:
+ continue
+ dir_status[dir_format] = new_status
+
+ if len(dir_status):
+ return self.summariseCacheDirInfoStatus(dir_status, is_dir_server)
+ else:
+ # this node must be a client, or a bridge
+ # (and the other node is not a bridge authority or bridge client)
+ consensus_member = self.getConsensusMember()
+ assert not consensus_member
+ return None
+
+ def getNodeDirInfoStatusList(self):
+ """Look through the directories on each node, and work out if
+ this node is in that directory.
+
+ Returns a dict containing a status 3-tuple for each relevant node.
+ The 3-tuple contains:
+ * a status code,
+ * a list of formats with that status, and
+ * a status message string.
+ See getNodeCacheDirInfoStatus() and getFileDirInfoStatus() for
+ more details.
+
+ If this node is a directory authority, bridge authority, or relay
+ (including exits), checks v3 directory consensuses, descriptors,
+ microdesc consensuses, and microdescriptors.
+
+ If this node is a bridge, checks bridge networkstatuses, and
+ descriptors on bridge authorities and bridge clients.
+
+ If this node is a client (including onion services), returns None.
+ """
+ dir_files = self.getNodePublishedDirInfoPaths()
+
+ if not dir_files:
+ return None
+
+ dir_statuses = dict()
+ # For all the nodes we expect will have us in their directory
+ for other_node_nick in dir_files:
+ (is_dir_server, other_node_files) = dir_files[other_node_nick]
+ assert len(other_node_files)
+ dir_statuses[other_node_nick] = \
+ self.getNodeCacheDirInfoStatus(other_node_files,
+ is_dir_server)
+
+ if len(dir_statuses):
+ return dir_statuses
+ else:
+ # this node must be a client
+ # (or a bridge in a network with no bridge authority,
+ # and no bridge clients, but chutney doesn't have networks like
+ # that)
+ consensus_member = self.getConsensusMember()
+ bridge_member = self.getBridge()
+ assert not consensus_member
+ assert not bridge_member
+ return None
+
+ def summariseNodeDirInfoStatus(self, dir_status):
+ """Summarise the statuses for this node's descriptor, among all the
+ directory files used by all other nodes.
+
+ Returns a dict containing a status 4-tuple for each status code.
+ The 4-tuple contains:
+ * a status code,
+ * a list of the other nodes which have directory files with that
+ status,
+ * a list of directory file formats which have that status, and
+ * a status message string.
+ See getNodeCacheDirInfoStatus() and getFileDirInfoStatus() for
+ more details.
+
+ Also add an "node_all" status that describes the overall status,
+ which is the worst status among all the other nodes' directory
+ files.
+
+ Returns None if no status is expected.
+ """
+ node_status = dict()
+
+ # if dir_status[other_node_nick][0] is not None ?
+ status_code_set = { dir_status[other_node_nick][0]
+ for other_node_nick in dir_status }
+ #print(self.getNick(), status_code_set)
+ for status_code in status_code_set:
+ other_node_nick_list = [
+ other_node_nick
+ for other_node_nick in dir_status
+ if dir_status[other_node_nick][0] == status_code ]
+
+ #print(self.getNick(), status_code, other_node_nick_list)
+ comb_status = self.combineDirInfoStatuses(dir_status,
+ other_node_nick_list,
+ best=False)
+
+ if comb_status is not None:
+ (comb_code, comb_format_set, comb_msg) = comb_status
+ assert comb_code == status_code
+
+ node_status[status_code] = (status_code, other_node_nick_list,
+ comb_format_set, comb_msg)
+
+ node_all = None
+ if len(node_status):
+ # Finally, get the worst status from all the other nodes
+ worst_status_code = min(status_code_set)
+ node_all = node_status[worst_status_code]
+ else:
+ # this node should be a client
+ # (or a bridge in a network with no bridge authority,
+ # and no bridge clients, but chutney doesn't have networks like
+ # that)
+ consensus_member = self.getConsensusMember()
+ bridge_member = self.getBridge()
+ if consensus_member or bridge_member:
+ node_all = (LocalNodeController.INTERNAL_ERROR_CODE,
+ set(),
+ set(),
+ "Expected {}{}{} dir info, but status is empty."
+ .format("consensus" if consensus_member else "",
+ " and " if consensus_member
+ and bridge_member else "",
+ "bridge" if bridge_member else ""))
+ else:
+ # clients don't publish dir info
+ node_all = None
+
+ if node_all:
+ node_status["node_all"] = node_all
+ return node_status
+ else:
+ # client
+ return None
+
+ def getNodeDirInfoStatus(self):
+ """Return a 4-tuple describing the status of this node's descriptor,
+ in all the directory documents across the network.
+
+ If this node does not have a descriptor, returns None.
+ """
+ dir_status = self.getNodeDirInfoStatusList()
+ if dir_status:
+ summary = self.summariseNodeDirInfoStatus(dir_status)
+ if summary:
+ return summary["node_all"]
+
+ # this node must be a client
+ # (or a bridge in a network with no bridge authority,
+ # and no bridge clients, but chutney doesn't have networks like
+ # that)
+ consensus_member = self.getConsensusMember()
+ bridge_member = self.getBridge()
+ assert not consensus_member
+ assert not bridge_member
+ return None
+
+ def isInExpectedDirInfoDocs(self):
+ """Return True if the descriptors for this node are in all expected
+ directory documents.
+
+ Return None if this node does not publish descriptors.
+ """
+ node_status = self.getNodeDirInfoStatus()
+ if node_status:
+ status_code, _, _, _ = node_status
+ return status_code == LocalDirectoryController.SUCCESS_CODE
+ else:
+ # Clients don't publish descriptors, so they are always ok.
+ # (But we shouldn't print a descriptor status for them.)
+ return None
# XXX: document these options
DEFAULTS = {
@@ -1463,19 +2013,63 @@ class Network(object):
print("Sending SIGHUP to nodes")
return all([n.getController().hup() for n in self._nodes])
- def print_bootstrap_status(self, controllers, most_recent_status,
+ def print_bootstrap_status(self,
+ controllers,
+ most_recent_bootstrap_status,
+ most_recent_desc_status,
elapsed=None,
msg="Bootstrap in progress"):
- header = "Node status:"
+ cons_auth_nick_set = set()
elapsed_msg = ""
if elapsed:
- elapsed_msg = " for {} seconds".format(int(elapsed))
+ elapsed_msg = ": {} seconds".format(int(elapsed))
if msg:
- header = "{}{}. {}".format(msg, elapsed_msg, header)
+ header = "{}{}".format(msg, elapsed_msg)
print(header)
- for c, status in zip(controllers,most_recent_status):
+ print("Node status:")
+ for c, boot_status in zip(controllers, most_recent_bootstrap_status):
c.check(listRunning=False, listNonRunning=True)
- print("{}: {}".format(c.getNick(), status))
+ nick = c.getNick()
+ if c.getConsensusAuthority():
+ cons_auth_nick_set.add(nick)
+ pct, kwd, bmsg = boot_status
+ # Support older tor versions without bootstrap keywords
+ if not kwd:
+ kwd = "None"
+ print("{:13}: {:4}, {:25}, {}".format(nick,
+ pct,
+ kwd,
+ bmsg))
+ print("Published dir info:")
+ for c in controllers:
+ nick = c.getNick()
+ if nick in most_recent_desc_status:
+ desc_status = most_recent_desc_status[nick]
+ code, nodes, docs, dmsg = desc_status
+ if len(nodes) == len(self._nodes):
+ nodes = "all nodes"
+ elif len(cons_auth_nick_set.intersection(nodes)) == 0:
+ nodes = "caches and clients"
+ else:
+ nodes = [ node.replace("test", "")
+ for node in nodes ]
+ nodes = " ".join(sorted(nodes))
+ if len(docs) >= c.getDocTypeDisplayLimit():
+ docs = "all formats"
+ else:
+ # Fold desc_new into desc, and md_new into md
+ if "desc_new" in docs:
+ docs.discard("desc_new")
+ docs.add("desc")
+ if "md_new" in docs:
+ docs.discard("md_new")
+ docs.add("md")
+ docs = " ".join(sorted(docs))
+ print("{:13}: {:4}, {:25}, {:30}, {}".format(nick,
+ code,
+ nodes,
+ docs,
+ dmsg))
print()
CHECK_NETWORK_STATUS_DELAY = 1.0
@@ -1487,31 +2081,54 @@ class Network(object):
limit = start + getenv_int("CHUTNEY_START_TIME", 60)
next_print_status = start + Network.PRINT_NETWORK_STATUS_DELAY
controllers = [n.getController() for n in self._nodes]
- most_recent_status = [ None ] * len(controllers)
+ most_recent_bootstrap_status = [ None ] * len(controllers)
+ most_recent_desc_status = dict()
while True:
all_bootstrapped = True
- most_recent_status = [ ]
+ most_recent_bootstrap_status = [ ]
+ most_recent_desc_status = dict()
for c in controllers:
- pct, kwd, msg = c.getLastBootstrapStatus()
- most_recent_status.append((pct, kwd, msg))
- if pct != 100:
+ nick = c.getNick()
+ pct, kwd, bmsg = c.getLastBootstrapStatus()
+ most_recent_bootstrap_status.append((pct, kwd, bmsg))
+
+ if pct != LocalNodeController.SUCCESS_CODE:
all_bootstrapped = False
+ desc_status = c.getNodeDirInfoStatus()
+ if desc_status:
+ code, nodes, docs, dmsg = desc_status
+ most_recent_desc_status[nick] = (code,
+ nodes,
+ docs,
+ dmsg)
+ if code != LocalNodeController.SUCCESS_CODE:
+ all_bootstrapped = False
+
now = time.time()
elapsed = now - start
if all_bootstrapped:
print("Everything bootstrapped after {} sec"
.format(int(elapsed)))
+ self.print_bootstrap_status(controllers,
+ most_recent_bootstrap_status,
+ most_recent_desc_status,
+ elapsed=elapsed,
+ msg="Bootstrap finished")
return True
if now >= limit:
break
if now >= next_print_status:
- self.print_bootstrap_status(controllers, most_recent_status,
+ self.print_bootstrap_status(controllers,
+ most_recent_bootstrap_status,
+ most_recent_desc_status,
elapsed=elapsed)
next_print_status = now + Network.PRINT_NETWORK_STATUS_DELAY
time.sleep(Network.CHECK_NETWORK_STATUS_DELAY)
- self.print_bootstrap_status(controllers, most_recent_status,
+ self.print_bootstrap_status(controllers,
+ most_recent_bootstrap_status,
+ most_recent_desc_status,
elapsed=elapsed,
msg="Bootstrap failed")
return False
