Directory authorities not giving weight to a relay
Greetings everyone! Almost three months ago I have set up my first node. Everything seemed to be going great at first and as documented in the tor lifecycle blog post. A few days after being set up the weight drastically dropped to around twenty. This seemed a bit odd since that same blog post doesn't mention anything about weight dropping so much, but it does about bandwidth, ao I just shrugged it off and assumed it was normal. Anyway, fast forward to today, and the weight hasn't really gotten above two hundred, it has been a month and a half I think since the weight drop, and it has been stale at a weight of between one hundred eighty and two hundred. I can't put my finger on what is exactly the problem, the relay currently has six flags: Fast, HSDir, Running, Stable, V2Dir and Valid. Shortly after the drop I have even seen the Guard flag for like a day. The server has capacity and is dedicated solely to being a relay, and the ISP is in the good providers list. The fingerprint of the node is ACC72E6D0FA76168AE1BA7F26996D191FEA7C9D8. Maybe someone in this list can give me a hand and point me in the right direction. Thank you in advance!
The server has capacity and is dedicated solely to being a relay, and the ISP is in the good providers list.
MDCLOUD LTD (AS203394) does not exist on the Good Bad ISPs list. In addition, the contact information provided in the `torrc` does not match the email address you used to participate in the `tor-relays` mailing list. Frank May 30, 2024, 11:23 PM by tor-relays@lists.torproject.org:
Greetings everyone!
Almost three months ago I have set up my first node. Everything seemed to be going great at first and as documented in the tor lifecycle blog post. A few days after being set up the weight drastically dropped to around twenty. This seemed a bit odd since that same blog post doesn't mention anything about weight dropping so much, but it does about bandwidth, ao I just shrugged it off and assumed it was normal.
Anyway, fast forward to today, and the weight hasn't really gotten above two hundred, it has been a month and a half I think since the weight drop, and it has been stale at a weight of between one hundred eighty and two hundred.
I can't put my finger on what is exactly the problem, the relay currently has six flags: Fast, HSDir, Running, Stable, V2Dir and Valid. Shortly after the drop I have even seen the Guard flag for like a day. The server has capacity and is dedicated solely to being a relay, and the ISP is in the good providers list.
The fingerprint of the node is ACC72E6D0FA76168AE1BA7F26996D191FEA7C9D8. Maybe someone in this list can give me a hand and point me in the right direction.
Thank you in advance!
On June 3, 2024 9:20:38 AM GMT+02:00, "Frank Lý via tor-relays" <tor-relays@lists.torproject.org> wrote:
In addition, the contact information provided in the `torrc` does not match the email address you used to participate in the `tor-relays` mailing list.
For all what I know, this shouldn't play a role. I'm also using different mail addresses in the contact info fields of my relays and on this mailing list for about one and a half year. Kind regards telekobold
On Montag, 3. Juni 2024 09:20:38 CEST Frank Lý via tor-relays wrote: .
MDCLOUD LTD (AS203394) does not exist on the Good Bad ISPs list.
But it's the only one so far in AS203394 and runs with FreeBSD, both of which are great. I think your relay runs in Ukraine. https://bgp.he.net/AS203394#_prefixes
In addition, the contact information provided in the `torrc` does not match the email address you used to participate in the `tor-relays` mailing list.
The email address in the relay list is completely irrelevant. Mine is also different on the list, the relays and in the forum.
Almost three months ago I have set up my first node. Everything seemed to be going great at first and as documented in the tor lifecycle blog post. A few days after being set up the weight drastically dropped to around twenty. This seemed a bit odd since that same blog post doesn't mention anything about weight dropping so much, but it does about bandwidth, ao I just shrugged it off and assumed it was normal.
Consensus weight is based on bandwidth observed by the relay and bandwidth measured by the directory & bw authorities. Your observed bandwidth is currently ~500 KiB/s, which is very little especially for a relay in the data center. If you do not have truly unlimited bandwidth from your provider, your bandwidth may be throttled. Or in a KVM|Cloud, the node is oversold.
Anyway, fast forward to today, and the weight hasn't really gotten above two hundred, it has been a month and a half I think since the weight drop, and it has been stale at a weight of between one hundred eighty and two hundred.
I can't put my finger on what is exactly the problem, the relay currently has six flags: Fast, HSDir, Running, Stable, V2Dir and Valid. Shortly after the drop I have even seen the Guard flag for like a day. The server has capacity and is dedicated solely to being a relay, and the ISP is in the good providers list.
I would first look at the provider's ToS. It often says something about fair usage policies vs. unlimited bandwidth and unlimited traffic. Sometimes only inbound or outbound is unlimited. Then I would install vnstatd or nload and measure the traffic for one to two months. It could be that the bw auths are not measuring properly at the moment because they are under DDoS. -- ╰_╯ Ciao Marco! Debian GNU/Linux It's free software and it gives you freedom!
participants (4)
-
boldsuck -
Frank Lý -
smoothop＠tutanota.de -
telekobold