On 09/20/2014 03:33 PM, Roger Dingledine wrote:
Check out https://compass.torproject.org/
Click on 'select only relays suitable for exit position' and then in the Country box put in United States and Canada. Then ask for 100 results. Then click submit, and scroll down, and look on the right-most column (Autonomous System).
You can click on the link in the Fingerprint column to see some of the details you list above.
This is great, thank you. Very helpful. I suppose this:
Part of the general problem though is that many Tor exit relay operators don't really want publicity about their choice
is a pretty compelling reason *not* to explicitly highlight exits run at universities (at least not without the operator's consent). Maybe something opt-in would be possible? Although it might be sort of pointless if only a couple university people/groups wanted to publicize that they run an exit.
I wonder if somebody should start doing a "highlight a Tor exit relay operator" weekly column or something, to make it more commonplace to admit that you're running an exit relay? As an additional bird to kill, putting a human face on exit relays
I'm extremely interested in ways to encourage more open conversations about exits, "normalize" the whole process a bit, and, as you say, "[put] a human face on exit relays." I think this is really important. It's amazing, and very frustrating, how much FUD, mystique, and just outright wrong information about Tor in general and exits specifically circulates among many Com Sci/engineering students (and even some professors). Nik On 09/20/2014 03:33 PM, Roger Dingledine wrote:
On Fri, Sep 19, 2014 at 11:41:24PM -0500, Nik wrote:
(A) A list of currently active exits at universities, filterable by country at least (laws/regulations are different).
It would be really great to have some sections here for each university listing like: the exit policy (or policies), the way they get around problems like journal subscriptions, how they handle abuse complaints, how long the exit has been running, etc.
Check out https://compass.torproject.org/
Click on 'select only relays suitable for exit position' and then in the Country box put in United States and Canada. Then ask for 100 results. Then click submit, and scroll down, and look on the right-most column (Autonomous System).
You can click on the link in the Fingerprint column to see some of the details you list above.
Part of the general problem though is that many Tor exit relay operators don't really want publicity about their choice -- they've gotten enough buy-in locally to run the relay, but they don't really want CNN to show up wanting to interview their dean about why she is endorsing Tor.
I wonder if somebody should start doing a "highlight a Tor exit relay operator" weekly column or something, to make it more commonplace to admit that you're running an exit relay? As an additional bird to kill, putting a human face on exit relays might help answer some of the concerns I get from people (even otherwise smart Tor fans) who say that the only people who can afford to run stable exit relays are people who are collaborating with the authorities to undermine Tor.
--Roger
_______________________________________________ tor-relays-universities mailing list tor-relays-universities@lists.torproject.org https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-relays-universitie...