tor-commits March 2011

tor-commits@lists.torproject.org

18 participants
683 discussions

[tor/maint-0.2.2] Tweak bug2716 patch a little
by nickm＠torproject.org 14 Mar '11

14 Mar '11

commit 176fde505fde38afa56ddce04606118b9080546e Author: Nick Mathewson <nickm(a)torproject.org> Date: Sat Mar 12 00:19:52 2011 -0500 Tweak bug2716 patch a little Name the magic value "10" rather than re-deriving it. Comment more. Use the pattern that works for periodic timers, not the pattern that doesn't work. ;) --- src/or/dirserv.c | 12 +++++++++--- src/or/dirserv.h | 6 +++++- src/or/main.c | 4 +++- 3 files changed, 17 insertions(+), 5 deletions(-) diff --git a/src/or/dirserv.c b/src/or/dirserv.c index 7386927..b68e005 100644 --- a/src/or/dirserv.c +++ b/src/or/dirserv.c @@ -969,11 +969,17 @@ dirserv_set_router_is_running(routerinfo_t *router, time_t now) } if (!answer && running_long_enough_to_decide_unreachable()) { - /* not considered reachable. tell rephist. */ + /* Not considered reachable. tell rephist about that. + + Because we launch a reachability test for each router every + REACHABILITY_TEST_CYCLE_PERIOD seconds, then the router has probably + been down since at least that time after we last successfully reached + it. + */ time_t when = now; if (router->last_reachable && - router->last_reachable + REACHABILITY_TEST_PERIOD < now) - when = router->last_reachable + REACHABILITY_TEST_PERIOD; + router->last_reachable + REACHABILITY_TEST_CYCLE_PERIOD < now) + when = router->last_reachable + REACHABILITY_TEST_CYCLE_PERIOD; rep_hist_note_router_unreachable(router->cache_info.identity_digest, when); } diff --git a/src/or/dirserv.h b/src/or/dirserv.h index 949482b..569abfc 100644 --- a/src/or/dirserv.h +++ b/src/or/dirserv.h @@ -17,8 +17,12 @@ * test? */ #define REACHABILITY_MODULO_PER_TEST 128 +/** How often (in seconds) do we launch reachability tests? */ +#define REACHABILITY_TEST_INTERVAL 10 + /** How many seconds apart are the reachability tests for a given relay? */ -#define REACHABILITY_TEST_PERIOD (10*REACHABILITY_MODULO_PER_TEST) +#define REACHABILITY_TEST_CYCLE_PERIOD \ + (REACHABILITY_TEST_INTERVAL*REACHABILITY_MODULO_PER_TEST) /** Maximum length of an exit policy summary. */ #define MAX_EXITPOLICY_SUMMARY_LEN 1000 diff --git a/src/or/main.c b/src/or/main.c index 558608e..214a4fa 100644 --- a/src/or/main.c +++ b/src/or/main.c @@ -872,6 +872,7 @@ run_scheduled_events(time_t now) static time_t time_to_check_for_expired_networkstatus = 0; static time_t time_to_write_stats_files = 0; static time_t time_to_write_bridge_stats = 0; + static time_t time_to_launch_reachability_tests = 0; static int should_init_bridge_stats = 1; static time_t time_to_retry_dns_init = 0; or_options_t *options = get_options(); @@ -962,9 +963,10 @@ run_scheduled_events(time_t now) if (accounting_is_enabled(options)) accounting_run_housekeeping(now); - if (now % REACHABILITY_TEST_PERIOD/REACHABILITY_MODULO_PER_TEST == 0 && + if (time_to_launch_reachability_tests < now && (authdir_mode_tests_reachability(options)) && !we_are_hibernating()) { + time_to_launch_reachability_tests = now + REACHABILITY_TEST_INTERVAL; /* try to determine reachability of the other Tor relays */ dirserv_test_reachability(now); }

1 0

[metrics-tasks/master] Add counting users tech report for #2647.
by karsten＠torproject.org 14 Mar '11

14 Mar '11

commit 75984b3dc3849903747f17497fc66c194e93b3a5 Author: Karsten Loesing <karsten.loesing(a)gmx.net> Date: Mon Mar 14 19:11:19 2011 +0100 Add counting users tech report for #2647. --- task-2647/.gitignore | 4 + task-2647/bridge-users.pdf | 981 ++++++++++++++++ task-2647/countingusers.tex | 1044 +++++++++++++++++ task-2647/dirbytes-mirrors.pdf | 1114 ++++++++++++++++++ task-2647/entrystats.pdf | 1304 ++++++++++++++++++++++ task-2647/estimated-users.pdf | 1467 ++++++++++++++++++++++++ task-2647/newusers.pdf | 1444 ++++++++++++++++++++++++ task-2647/trusted-details.pdf | 2413 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ task-2647/trusted.pdf | 912 +++++++++++++++ 9 files changed, 10683 insertions(+), 0 deletions(-) diff --git a/task-2647/.gitignore b/task-2647/.gitignore new file mode 100644 index 0000000..bc423ca --- /dev/null +++ b/task-2647/.gitignore @@ -0,0 +1,4 @@ +*.aux +*.log +countingusers.pdf + diff --git a/task-2647/bridge-users.pdf b/task-2647/bridge-users.pdf new file mode 100644 index 0000000..bd6ccc6 --- /dev/null +++ b/task-2647/bridge-users.pdf @@ -0,0 +1,981 @@ +%PDF-1.4 +%âãÏÓ\r +1 0 obj +<< +/CreationDate (D:20101104141647) +/ModDate (D:20101104141647) +/Title (R Graphics Output) +/Producer (R 2.10.0) +/Creator (R) +>> +endobj +2 0 obj +<< +/Type /Catalog +/Pages 3 0 R +>> +endobj +5 0 obj +<< +/Type /Page +/Parent 3 0 R +/Contents 6 0 R +/Resources 4 0 R +>> +endobj +6 0 obj +<< +/Length 7 0 R +>> +stream +q +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q +1.000 1.000 1.000 rg +0.00 0.00 576.00 324.00 re f +Q q +Q q +Q q +BT +0.000 0.000 0.000 rg +/F2 1 Tf 0.00 12.00 -12.00 0.00 19.42 110.96 Tm (Users $in thousands$) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 0.00 12.00 -12.00 0.00 35.26 166.31 Tm () Tj +ET +Q q +Q q 38.86 309.60 18.21 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 309.60 18.21 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q 38.86 37.28 18.21 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 23.02 18.21 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 23.02 18.21 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 309.60 504.54 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 309.60 504.54 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 37.28 504.54 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 37.28 504.54 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q 57.06 23.02 504.54 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 309.60 18.21 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 309.60 18.21 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q +0.498 0.498 0.498 RG +1.06 w +[] 0 d +1 J +1 j +10.00 M +52.81 82.75 m 57.06 82.75 l S +52.81 116.58 m 57.06 116.58 l S +52.81 150.41 m 57.06 150.41 l S +52.81 184.24 m 57.06 184.24 l S +52.81 218.08 m 57.06 218.08 l S +52.81 251.91 m 57.06 251.91 l S +52.81 285.74 m 57.06 285.74 l S +BT +0.498 0.498 0.498 rg +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 44.42 79.16 Tm (5) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 38.86 112.99 Tm (10) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 38.86 146.82 Tm (15) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 38.86 180.65 Tm (20) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 38.86 214.49 Tm (25) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 38.86 248.32 Tm (30) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 38.86 282.15 Tm (35) Tj +ET +Q q +Q q 38.86 37.28 18.21 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 23.02 18.21 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 23.02 18.21 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 309.60 504.54 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 309.60 504.54 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 37.28 504.54 272.32 re W n +0.898 0.898 0.898 rg +57.06 37.28 504.54 272.32 re f +0.949 0.949 0.949 RG +0.53 w +[] 0 d +1 J +1 j +10.00 M +57.06 48.92 m +561.60 48.92 l +S +57.06 65.83 m +561.60 65.83 l +S +57.06 82.75 m +561.60 82.75 l +S +57.06 99.66 m +561.60 99.66 l +S +57.06 116.58 m +561.60 116.58 l +S +57.06 133.50 m +561.60 133.50 l +S +57.06 150.41 m +561.60 150.41 l +S +57.06 167.33 m +561.60 167.33 l +S +57.06 184.24 m +561.60 184.24 l +S +57.06 201.16 m +561.60 201.16 l +S +57.06 218.08 m +561.60 218.08 l +S +57.06 234.99 m +561.60 234.99 l +S +57.06 251.91 m +561.60 251.91 l +S +57.06 268.82 m +561.60 268.82 l +S +57.06 285.74 m +561.60 285.74 l +S +57.06 302.66 m +561.60 302.66 l +S +80.00 37.28 m +80.00 309.60 l +S +106.98 37.28 m +106.98 309.60 l +S +134.86 37.28 m +134.86 309.60 l +S +162.74 37.28 m +162.74 309.60 l +S +189.72 37.28 m +189.72 309.60 l +S +217.60 37.28 m +217.60 309.60 l +S +244.58 37.28 m +244.58 309.60 l +S +272.46 37.28 m +272.46 309.60 l +S +300.34 37.28 m +300.34 309.60 l +S +325.52 37.28 m +325.52 309.60 l +S +353.40 37.28 m +353.40 309.60 l +S +380.38 37.28 m +380.38 309.60 l +S +408.26 37.28 m +408.26 309.60 l +S +435.24 37.28 m +435.24 309.60 l +S +463.12 37.28 m +463.12 309.60 l +S +491.00 37.28 m +491.00 309.60 l +S +517.98 37.28 m +517.98 309.60 l +S +545.86 37.28 m +545.86 309.60 l +S +1.000 1.000 1.000 RG +1.06 w +[] 0 d +57.06 82.75 m +561.60 82.75 l +S +57.06 116.58 m +561.60 116.58 l +S +57.06 150.41 m +561.60 150.41 l +S +57.06 184.24 m +561.60 184.24 l +S +57.06 218.08 m +561.60 218.08 l +S +57.06 251.91 m +561.60 251.91 l +S +57.06 285.74 m +561.60 285.74 l +S +80.00 37.28 m +80.00 309.60 l +S +162.74 37.28 m +162.74 309.60 l +S +244.58 37.28 m +244.58 309.60 l +S +325.52 37.28 m +325.52 309.60 l +S +408.26 37.28 m +408.26 309.60 l +S +491.00 37.28 m +491.00 309.60 l +S +0.000 0.000 0.000 RG +2.13 w +[] 0 d +0 J +1.00 M +80.00 49.67 m +80.90 49.66 l +81.79 49.75 l +82.69 49.71 l +83.59 49.82 l +84.49 49.69 l +85.39 49.66 l +86.29 49.75 l +87.19 49.84 l +88.09 49.98 l +88.99 50.14 l +89.89 50.14 l +90.79 50.07 l +91.69 50.29 l +92.59 50.36 l +93.49 50.32 l +94.39 50.57 l +95.29 50.60 l +96.18 50.67 l +97.08 50.78 l +97.98 50.69 l +98.88 50.95 l +99.78 51.09 l +100.68 51.37 l +101.58 51.60 l +102.48 51.55 l +103.38 51.59 l +104.28 51.49 l +105.18 51.31 l +106.08 51.38 l +106.98 51.29 l +107.88 51.13 l +108.78 50.94 l +109.67 51.03 l +110.57 51.22 l +111.47 51.28 l +112.37 51.49 l +113.27 51.52 l +114.17 51.42 l +115.07 51.81 l +115.97 51.35 l +116.87 51.46 l +117.77 51.58 l +118.67 51.69 l +119.57 51.75 l +120.47 51.65 l +121.37 51.92 l +122.27 51.85 l +123.17 51.95 l +124.06 51.94 l +124.96 52.24 l +125.86 52.11 l +126.76 51.97 l +127.66 52.20 l +128.56 51.80 l +129.46 51.70 l +130.36 51.53 l +131.26 52.08 l +132.16 52.16 l +133.06 52.05 l +133.96 52.07 l +134.86 51.85 l +135.76 51.66 l +136.66 52.11 l +137.55 52.39 l +138.45 52.43 l +139.35 52.60 l +140.25 52.32 l +141.15 52.35 l +142.05 52.37 l +142.95 52.46 l +143.85 52.90 l +144.75 52.79 l +145.65 52.90 l +146.55 52.83 l +147.45 52.86 l +148.35 52.90 l +149.25 53.00 l +150.15 53.50 l +151.05 53.38 l +151.94 53.69 l +152.84 53.46 l +153.74 52.98 l +154.64 53.02 l +155.54 53.50 l +156.44 53.65 l +157.34 53.42 l +158.24 53.37 l +159.14 53.84 l +160.04 53.69 l +160.94 53.39 l +161.84 53.61 l +162.74 53.96 l +163.64 54.18 l +164.54 54.76 l +165.43 54.63 l +166.33 53.78 l +167.23 53.60 l +168.13 54.19 l +169.03 54.57 l +169.93 54.58 l +170.83 54.84 l +171.73 53.83 l +172.63 54.67 l +173.53 54.13 l +174.43 55.51 l +175.33 55.62 l +176.23 54.97 l +177.13 55.26 l +178.03 54.95 l +178.93 54.65 l +179.82 53.75 l +180.72 54.21 l +181.62 54.29 l +182.52 54.42 l +183.42 54.24 l +184.32 56.75 l +185.22 61.19 l +186.12 70.32 l +187.02 83.93 l +187.92 94.95 l +188.82 106.94 l +189.72 116.52 l +190.62 119.83 l +191.52 120.97 l +192.42 126.36 l +193.31 132.53 l +194.21 130.95 l +195.11 139.09 l +196.01 138.86 l +196.91 145.58 l +197.81 150.80 l +198.71 158.55 l +199.61 154.15 l +200.51 162.42 l +201.41 155.02 l +202.31 158.10 l +203.21 166.43 l +204.11 163.85 l +205.01 151.59 l +205.91 162.25 l +206.80 174.43 l +207.70 167.79 l +208.60 169.99 l +209.50 174.59 l +210.40 149.80 l +211.30 165.97 l +212.20 166.38 l +213.10 174.48 l +214.00 160.45 l +214.90 169.26 l +215.80 172.31 l +216.70 174.66 l +217.60 168.55 l +218.50 159.14 l +219.40 164.23 l +220.30 158.62 l +221.19 160.00 l +222.09 162.31 l +222.99 159.77 l +223.89 162.40 l +224.79 162.98 l +225.69 163.80 l +226.59 168.05 l +227.49 161.85 l +228.39 163.15 l +229.29 160.63 l +230.19 164.52 l +231.09 161.85 l +231.99 172.61 l +232.89 169.97 l +233.79 169.49 l +234.68 171.33 l +235.58 166.86 l +236.48 163.73 l +237.38 166.24 l +238.28 179.93 l +239.18 180.50 l +240.08 177.06 l +240.98 180.83 l +241.88 181.37 l +242.78 180.91 l +243.68 184.88 l +244.58 190.51 l +245.48 184.98 l +246.38 186.61 l +247.28 176.72 l +248.18 171.67 l +249.07 178.84 l +249.97 180.73 l +250.87 181.31 l +251.77 184.45 l +252.67 182.17 l +253.57 185.26 l +254.47 196.17 l +255.37 196.14 l +256.27 193.23 l +257.17 194.37 l +258.07 191.75 l +258.97 189.58 l +259.87 166.85 l +260.77 187.77 l +261.67 182.63 l +262.56 181.63 l +263.46 185.56 l +264.36 180.65 l +265.26 188.97 l +266.16 184.99 l +267.06 186.31 l +267.96 182.69 l +268.86 185.60 l +269.76 193.77 l +270.66 200.18 l +271.56 198.42 l +272.46 205.71 l +273.36 191.36 l +274.26 200.00 l +275.16 182.02 l +276.06 217.51 l +276.95 216.96 l +277.85 210.98 l +278.75 209.65 l +279.65 202.68 l +280.55 223.59 l +281.45 218.10 l +282.35 191.50 l +283.25 234.16 l +284.15 233.39 l +285.05 252.58 l +285.95 260.74 l +286.85 254.36 l +287.75 245.32 l +288.65 257.54 l +289.55 256.66 l +290.44 245.63 l +291.34 255.99 l +292.24 246.78 l +293.14 261.21 l +294.04 254.21 l +294.94 261.98 l +295.84 268.93 l +296.74 276.60 l +297.64 267.01 l +298.54 271.98 l +299.44 261.94 l +300.34 273.90 l +301.24 278.11 l +302.14 260.66 l +303.04 267.69 l +303.94 267.84 l +304.83 261.38 l +305.73 270.19 l +306.63 265.25 l +307.53 269.75 l +308.43 256.48 l +309.33 260.93 l +310.23 246.10 l +311.13 237.70 l +312.03 229.78 l +312.93 219.14 l +313.83 217.59 l +314.73 228.08 l +315.63 232.43 l +316.53 244.66 l +317.43 256.96 l +318.32 274.36 l +319.22 292.38 l +320.12 291.65 l +321.02 286.47 l +321.92 296.29 l +322.82 293.22 l +323.72 294.52 l +324.62 282.42 l +325.52 296.73 l +326.42 297.22 l +327.32 282.53 l +328.22 258.15 l +329.12 218.26 l +330.02 163.57 l +330.92 142.64 l +331.82 128.13 l +332.71 129.36 l +333.61 129.12 l +334.51 136.64 l +335.41 142.73 l +336.31 138.08 l +337.21 144.79 l +338.11 141.80 l +339.01 137.17 l +339.91 144.15 l +340.81 161.56 l +341.71 146.16 l +342.61 139.74 l +343.51 142.46 l +344.41 137.92 l +345.31 143.67 l +346.20 134.94 l +347.10 130.24 l +348.00 124.82 l +348.90 112.52 l +349.80 109.54 l +350.70 110.54 l +351.60 151.58 l +352.50 202.81 l +353.40 223.02 l +354.30 240.33 l +355.20 243.38 l +356.10 228.21 l +357.00 218.14 l +357.90 220.18 l +358.80 240.17 l +359.70 250.59 l +360.59 259.22 l +361.49 262.50 l +362.39 257.05 l +363.29 258.82 l +364.19 269.32 l +365.09 271.36 l +365.99 269.95 l +366.89 263.97 l +367.79 256.92 l +368.69 262.67 l +369.59 267.44 l +370.49 255.62 l +371.39 270.37 l +372.29 262.29 l +373.19 270.65 l +374.08 248.06 l +374.98 248.58 l +375.88 246.79 l +376.78 243.01 l +377.68 243.65 l +378.58 235.49 l +379.48 234.06 l +380.38 238.64 l +381.28 225.85 l +382.18 222.22 l +383.08 223.64 l +383.98 191.67 l +384.88 155.10 l +385.78 125.99 l +386.68 106.28 l +387.58 101.08 l +388.47 96.73 l +389.37 97.15 l +390.27 96.06 l +391.17 118.38 l +392.07 138.27 l +392.97 152.67 l +393.87 156.93 l +394.77 180.41 l +395.67 205.91 l +396.57 203.09 l +397.47 164.05 l +398.37 121.05 l +399.27 103.16 l +400.17 92.85 l +401.07 92.53 l +401.96 90.14 l +402.86 88.82 l +403.76 90.32 l +404.66 94.08 l +405.56 95.33 l +406.46 96.27 l +407.36 103.05 l +408.26 104.77 l +409.16 100.04 l +410.06 99.58 l +410.96 97.08 l +411.86 95.99 l +412.76 93.73 l +413.66 96.31 l +414.56 100.48 l +415.46 99.09 l +416.35 103.67 l +417.25 103.26 l +418.15 100.27 l +419.05 97.78 l +419.95 97.07 l +420.85 98.66 l +421.75 97.47 l +422.65 97.47 l +423.55 97.94 l +424.45 95.06 l +425.35 95.68 l +426.25 95.83 l +427.15 93.78 l +428.05 91.60 l +428.95 95.62 l +429.84 102.53 l +430.74 103.70 l +431.64 103.83 l +432.54 103.99 l +433.44 104.28 l +434.34 99.57 l +435.24 97.78 l +436.14 99.07 l +437.04 97.99 l +437.94 98.71 l +438.84 101.09 l +439.74 101.47 l +440.64 104.86 l +441.54 104.73 l +442.44 102.34 l +443.33 99.26 l +444.23 98.20 l +445.13 101.37 l +446.03 101.27 l +446.93 90.12 l +S +458.62 92.15 m +459.52 93.22 l +460.42 97.66 l +461.32 96.71 l +462.22 97.97 l +463.12 95.76 l +464.02 96.99 l +464.92 97.50 l +465.82 98.26 l +466.72 99.46 l +467.62 100.33 l +468.52 99.89 l +469.42 99.16 l +470.32 98.68 l +471.21 98.97 l +472.11 96.79 l +473.01 97.67 l +473.91 100.39 l +474.81 102.78 l +475.71 100.10 l +476.61 99.63 l +477.51 99.47 l +478.41 102.97 l +479.31 102.99 l +480.21 102.94 l +481.11 98.80 l +482.01 101.42 l +482.91 110.27 l +483.81 117.28 l +484.71 115.62 l +485.60 108.20 l +486.50 109.85 l +487.40 112.41 l +488.30 111.97 l +489.20 111.31 l +490.10 111.37 l +491.00 108.79 l +491.90 106.32 l +492.80 105.88 l +493.70 102.99 l +494.60 102.82 l +495.50 103.73 l +496.40 104.25 l +497.30 106.79 l +498.20 116.17 l +499.09 125.75 l +499.99 134.02 l +500.89 138.07 l +501.79 145.29 l +502.69 147.06 l +503.59 126.81 l +504.49 107.36 l +505.39 102.35 l +506.29 97.41 l +507.19 98.09 l +508.09 98.87 l +508.99 98.45 l +509.89 101.11 l +510.79 100.60 l +511.69 104.96 l +512.59 125.02 l +513.48 140.42 l +514.38 151.64 l +515.28 151.66 l +516.18 144.19 l +517.08 128.64 l +517.98 112.97 l +518.88 103.24 l +519.78 102.12 l +520.68 102.33 l +521.58 101.80 l +522.48 101.17 l +523.38 103.58 l +524.28 104.68 l +525.18 108.37 l +526.08 108.50 l +526.97 109.32 l +527.87 104.10 l +528.77 97.94 l +529.67 92.17 l +530.57 93.53 l +531.47 93.36 l +532.37 94.04 l +533.27 101.74 l +534.17 101.70 l +535.07 100.02 l +535.97 97.64 l +536.87 99.95 l +537.77 97.51 l +538.67 96.44 l +S +Q q +Q q 57.06 37.28 504.54 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q +0.498 0.498 0.498 RG +1.06 w +[] 0 d +1 J +1 j +10.00 M +80.00 33.03 m 80.00 37.28 l S +162.74 33.03 m 162.74 37.28 l S +244.58 33.03 m 244.58 37.28 l S +325.52 33.03 m 325.52 37.28 l S +408.26 33.03 m 408.26 37.28 l S +491.00 33.03 m 491.00 37.28 l S +BT +0.498 0.498 0.498 rg +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 63.56 23.02 Tm [(J) 20 (un-09)] TJ +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 145.36 23.02 Tm (Sep-09) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 227.21 23.02 Tm (Dec-09) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 308.43 23.02 Tm (Mar-10) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 391.82 23.02 Tm [(J) 20 (un-10)] TJ +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 473.63 23.02 Tm (Sep-10) Tj +ET +Q q +Q q 57.06 23.02 504.54 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q +endstream +endobj +7 0 obj +13832 +endobj +3 0 obj +<< +/Type /Pages +/Kids [ +5 0 R +] +/Count 1 +/MediaBox [0 0 576 324] +>> +endobj +4 0 obj +<< +/ProcSet [/PDF /Text] +/Font <</F2 9 0 R >> +/ExtGState << >> +>> +endobj +8 0 obj +<< +/Type /Encoding +/BaseEncoding /WinAnsiEncoding +/Differences [ 45/minus 96/quoteleft +144/dotlessi /grave /acute /circumflex /tilde /macron /breve /dotaccent +/dieresis /.notdef /ring /cedilla /.notdef /hungarumlaut /ogonek /caron /space] +>> +endobj +9 0 obj << +/Type /Font +/Subtype /Type1 +/Name /F2 +/BaseFont /Helvetica +/Encoding 8 0 R +>> endobj +xref +0 10 +0000000000 65535 f +0000000021 00000 n +0000000164 00000 n +0000014199 00000 n +0000014282 00000 n +0000000213 00000 n +0000000293 00000 n +0000014178 00000 n +0000014363 00000 n +0000014620 00000 n +trailer +<< +/Size 10 +/Info 1 0 R +/Root 2 0 R +>> +startxref +14716 +%%EOF diff --git a/task-2647/countingusers.tex b/task-2647/countingusers.tex new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c05f2b5 --- /dev/null +++ b/task-2647/countingusers.tex @@ -0,0 +1,1044 @@ +\documentclass{article} +\usepackage[pdftex]{graphicx} +\usepackage{graphics} +\usepackage{color} + +\begin{document} + +\author{Sebastian Hahn and Karsten Loesing\\{\tt\{sebastian,karsten\}(a)torproject.org}} +\title{Privacy-preserving Ways to\\Estimate the Number of Tor Users} +%Counting Users in the Tor Network in a Privacy-Preserving Way +\maketitle + +\section{Introduction} + +The Tor network allows hundreds of thousands of users every day to stay +anonymous online and enables additional tens of thousands of people in +oppressed countries to circumvent local censorship. +At least, these are the orders of magnitude of Tor usage that we assume +at the time of writing this report. +Estimating the number of users in an anonymity network is a hard +problem. +On the one hand, it's important to learn something about the users of a +network to improve its service. +On the other hand, the users of an anonymity network have a high +demand for privacy, which prohibits collecting sensitive information that +is necessary to obtain exact usage statistics. +In this report we describe our approaches to collect aggregated usage +data and derive user number estimates from them. +% cite WESCR 2010 paper? + +We start with our two current approaches to estimate the number of +non-censored daily users. +These approaches are based on counting the number of directory +requests that clients make to update their network information. +Clients need to download initial network information from a small fixed +set of relays, the directory authorities, and refresh their network +information in regular intervals from a larger changing set of relays, the +directory mirrors. +We describe our current approach to estimate the number of new and +returning users from requests seen at directory authorities in +Section~\ref{sec:auths} and our estimate of recurring users based on +requests to directory mirrors in Section~\ref{sec:current}. +%from one of a few hundred relays that are configured as directory mirrors. +%We count these requests on a fast directory mirror, which also reports +%what share of the total requests in the network it thinks it has answered. +%We project the total number of requests in the network using the +%self-reported share and divide by the number of requests that each client +%makes to estimate the total number of users. + +In Section~\ref{sec:combine}, we extend our current approach to count +recurring users by combining reported directory requests from multiple +directory mirrors. +%We estimate the fraction of observed requests from the number of bytes +%that directory mirrors spend on answering directory requests instead of +%relying on self-reported expected shares. +The result is a less volatile user number estimate with fewer outliers and +missing data points. + +The previous approaches have in common that they estimate user numbers +based on the number of directory requests. +In Section~\ref{sec:entry} we discuss an estimation based on the number of +unique IP addresses seen on a fast directory mirror. +Clients open numerous connections to directory mirrors to download +updated network status information such as new consensuses and +the relay descriptors therein. +%There are roughly 2000 relays in the Tor network at the time of writing. +%Clients need to download the descriptors of all relays, so that they can, +%in theory, use any relay for building a circuit. +A quick analysis of the logs of a bootstrapping Tor client reveals that a +relay that is chosen for 5~\% of all directory requests sees at least +two-thirds of all client IP addresses. +% Explain what kind of analysis? +% +%As a result, Tor is going to introduce the concept of \emph{directory +%guards} which makes client select a fixed set of directory mirrors for all +%requests. +%But until directory guards are implemented, +We can use the number of +unique IP addresses on a fast directory mirror to estimate the number of +daily users. +The presented approach is based on data coming from a single directory +mirror. +Combining unique IP addresses from multiple directory mirrors needs to be +done very carefully and is left for future work. + +We sketch a design to introduce a new counting cell type in +Section~\ref{sec:countingcell}. +Clients would send counting cells once a day to counting authorities or +entry guards. +We discuss the attack potential and possible defenses against adversarial actions. +% TODO is there a better word than 'trick'? yes. + +In Section~\ref{sec:bridges} we describe our current approach to count +censored users. +These users cannot connect to the publicly known relays to download +directory information or establish circuits. +Therefore, censored users have to learn about one or more bridge relays +which behave in a similar manner to normal relays except that they are not listed in +the public directory. +%Clients fetch all their directory information and establish all their +%circuits with a bridge as their first entry point into the Tor network. +Bridges report the number of unique IP addresses they see every day. +Our current approach to count censored users is to simply sum up these +unique IP addresses per day. +We discuss shortcomings and propose improvements to derive a better +estimate for censored Tor users. + +We conclude with a comparison of the described approaches, identify the +most promising approaches, recommend possible improvements, and outline +future work in Section~\ref{sec:conclusion}. + +\section{Counting requests on directory authorities} +\label{sec:auths} + +As of mid 2010, we use two approaches to estimate the number of +non-censored Tor users: +The first approach captures the number of new or returning users, the +second approach counts the recurring users. +This distinction comes from the design of our estimates that are both +based on Tor's directory protocol. + +Whenever a client bootstraps or when its network information becomes +stale, the client requests a fresh network status, which is a list of all +currently running relays, from the directories. +New clients which do not have any directory information pick one of +a fixed set of hard-coded directory authorities for their request. +There are currently eight such directory authorities, but the set can be +changed whenever a new version of the Tor software is released. +Returning clients with outdated network information take the same +approach. +Recurring clients with still recent network information choose a directory +mirror for their update request. +The approach for counting new and returning users is described in this +section, the approach for counting recurring users in the next section. + +Seven out of eight directory authorities report the number of directory +requests they're answering every day. +When we started estimating new and returning users, only one or two +directory authorities were reporting these data. +That is why we weight the requests seen by a single directory authority +with the expected fraction of requests that the directory authority should +see. +In 2009, clients knew about 7 directory authorities of which on average 6 +were running at the same time. +Hence, we made the assumption that the directory authorities reporting +request numbers were picked for every sixth request by new and returning +clients. +Even though an eighth directory authority has been added in 2010, only +clients running a recent development version of Tor use this new directory +authority. +We therefore stick with our original assumption that a directory authority +sees 1 out of 6 requests. +We multiply the reported request number by 6 to obtain an estimate of +daily new or returning users. + +\begin{figure}[t] +\includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{newusers.pdf} +\caption{Estimated number of new and returning users} +\label{fig:newusers} +\end{figure} + +Figure~\ref{fig:newusers} shows the estimated number of new or returning +users based on the request numbers reported by directory authority +\texttt{gabelmoo} (black) and the average reported request numbers by all +directory authorities (gray). +The estimated user number based on the average of all directory +authorities is 20 to 25 thousand users higher than the numbers reported +by \texttt{gabelmoo}, but in general, both estimates are of the same order +of magnitude. +The peak in March 2010 results from a single directory authority reporting +ten times as many requests as the other directory authorities. +This is probably due to a bug in the Tor code and not an actual increase in +users. +The increase in April 2010 can also be explained by bugs in the Tor code +which led to overloading the network. +We therefore expect the average number of new or returning users to be +around 100 thousand. + +However, it's difficult to interpret this estimated user number in a +meaningful way. +We don't know how many hours per day a typical user is connected to the +network and after how many hours or days they typically return. +We are more interested in the total number of users connecting to the +network at least once a day. +This question can better be answered by the estimates described below +which attempt to count the number of recurring users. + +\section{Counting requests on directory mirrors} +\label{sec:current} + +Our current approach for estimating (recurring) daily users is based on +the fact that every client needs to refresh its network information every +few hours in order to make indistinguishable path selection decisions. +Clients weight their choice of a directory mirror by the relays' bandwidth +capacities in order to load-balance requests. +The idea of this approach is to infer the number of users from the number +of directory requests on a fast directory mirror and weight them with the +request share the reporting directory mirrors expects to see. + +For our user number estimation, we count the number of network status +requests on a fast directory mirror. +We first estimate how many network status requests there are in the +network by dividing the local request number by the share of requests that +this particular directory mirror thinks it should see. +As an approximation of the request share, the directory mirror reports +the probability of picking itself if it were a client. +In the second step we estimate the number of users by dividing the global +network status request numbers by 10 on the assumption that every client +makes on average 10 requests per day. +10 is probably a too high number, but one that prevents us from +over-counting our users. +% We could derive some statistics from the Torperfs running on moria to +% support our assumption that 10 is too high. + +\begin{equation} +U_t = \frac{r_t}{s_t \times 10} +\end{equation} + +\begin{center} +\begin{tabular}{p{0.75cm}p{9cm}} +$U_t$ & User number estimate based on directory requests to directory +mirror \texttt{trusted}\\ +$r_t$ & Directory requests to directory mirror \texttt{trusted}\\ +$s_t$ & Share of directory requests expected at directory mirror +\texttt{trusted}\\ +\end{tabular} +\end{center} + +\begin{figure}[t] +\includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{trusted.pdf} +\caption{User number estimate based on directory requests to directory +mirror \texttt{trusted}} +\label{fig:trusted} +\end{figure} + +\begin{figure}[t] +\includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{trusted-details.pdf} +\caption{Directory requests, shares, and user number estimate, based on +directory requests to directory mirror \texttt{trusted}} +\label{fig:trusted-details} +\end{figure} + +Figure~\ref{fig:trusted} shows the daily user number estimate based on +directory requests to the fast directory mirror \texttt{trusted}. +Evidently, this estimate is flawed by having outliers and lots of missing +values. +Some of these problems can be explained when looking at the input data. +Figure~\ref{fig:trusted-details} shows the directory requests $r_t$ and +expected share of requests $s_t$ as well as the estimated user number +$U_t$. +From these two graphs we can make a few observations: + +\begin{itemize} +\item The peaks in May 2010 and later with 1.2 million and 800 +thousand daily users (marked with gray circles) are probably not accurate user +numbers, but more likely measurement errors. +These data points result from directory request shares being slightly +higher than 1~\%. +(Data points with directory request shares of 1~\% or less are excluded +anyway; if these data points were included, there would have been even +more outliers with millions of users which are unlikely real.) +Raising the bar to 1.5~\% would eliminate these outliers, but would also +remove a lot of, apparently correct, data points. +\item In September 2009 (first dashed line), user numbers increased from +roughly 150 to 250 thousand, and volatility of user numbers increased by +factor 2 to 3. +While the request numbers remain more or less stable during this time, +the expected share of requests seen by \texttt{trusted} drops from 3.5~\% +to 2~\%. +The reason for this decrease is that more recent clients started weighting +relays by active bandwidth scanner results instead of the relays' +self-reported bandwidth claims. +However, \texttt{trusted} assumes that all clients use the bandwidth +scanner results for path selection which is not the case. +\item Beginning in June 2010 (second dashed line), shares drop to zero for +about a month, stabilize at around 1.5~\% for two months and then +oscillate between 0 and 9~\%. +The reason for this behavior is the introduction of consensus weights that further help +clients to make good path selection decisions. +Again, \texttt{trusted} bases its expected request share on the +assumption that all clients use consensus weights for their path selection +decisions which is wrong. +\end{itemize} + +In summary, the major problem with the described approach is the +approximation of the request share that a directory mirror expects to see. +The various deployed Tor versions all use different weights for picking a +directory mirror: +Clients running Tor version 0.2.0.x use the relays' self-advertised +bandwidths to decide which directory mirror to pick. +Clients on version 0.2.1.x use actively measured bandwidths from four +bandwidth scanners running on the authoritative directory servers for +their choice. +Clients running version 0.2.2.x base their decision on the measured +bandwidths, but weighted by network-wide factors depending on the assigned +relay flags of a directory mirror. +The shares reported by directory mirror \texttt{trusted} reflect a +situation in which all clients run the same Tor version as +\texttt{trusted} at the given time, which is not the case. +While we could calculate shares independent of \texttt{trusted}, we have +no reliable data about the fractions of running client versions and could +therefore not weight the calculated version-specific request shares. +In the next section we discuss an approach to combine the findings of +multiple directory mirrors and replace the expected request share by a +more reliable metric. + +% It might also be problematic that relays update their advertised +% bandwidth only every 18 hours when publishing a new descriptor. +% Likewise, bandwidth scanners scan a relay only every so often. There +% may be significant changes from one bandwidth value to the next, but +% clients take a few hours to notice that change. More research would be +% necessary, but we already know the approach is broken, so might as well +% not care. + +The second problem with the described approach is that the estimated user +number is less precise the fewer requests a directory mirror sees. +When we started estimating user numbers based on directory mirror +\texttt{trusted}, it reported shares of roughly 3.5~\% of all requests in +the network. +With the introduction of the various performance improvements and with the +recent increase in fast directory mirrors, this share has decreased to +1.5~\%. +As we can see, estimations based on a fraction of observations this small +are not very reliable. + +The third problem is that we can only guess that a client makes 10 network +status requests per day. +While this assumption may work for clients which are connected to the Tor +network all day, other clients may well send fewer requests than 10. +We do not have any data about the average hours of Tor usage per day to +come up with a better number than 10 requests. +If, for example, the real number of requests per client was 5, our +estimate would be off by a factor 2. +The good news is that, while being off by an unknown factor, we're off by +that factor all the time, so that comparisons over time are still +accurate. + +% Idea for implementing directory guards: With all relays caching +% directory information, instead of building circuits to directories +% *using* directory guards, clients could simply ask their directory +% guards for whatever directory information they want to know. + +\section{Combining requests to directory mirrors} +\label{sec:combine} + +%\paragraph{Summing up requests and shares} +% +%The first new approach combines directory requests simply by summing up +%requests and shares of all directory mirrors reporting these numbers. +%While \texttt{trusted} was the only fast directory mirror reporting +%directory requests for about a year, a couple of even faster relays +%started reporting these numbers in August 2010. +% +%\begin{equation} +%U_s = \frac{r}{s \times 10} +%\end{equation} +% +%\begin{center} +%\begin{tabular}{p{1cm}p{9cm}} +%$U_s$ & User estimate based on sums of all directory requests and shares\\ +%$r$ & Directory requests to all reporting directory mirrors\\ +%$s$ & Share of directory requests expected at all reporting directory +%mirrors\\ +%\end{tabular} +%\end{center} +% +%\begin{figure}[t] +%\includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{share.png} +%\caption{Directory requests, shares and user number estimate based on +%directory requests by all reporting directory mirrors (black), compared +%to \texttt{trusted} only (gray)} +%\label{fig:share} +%\end{figure} +% +%Figure~\ref{fig:share} shows the total requests, shares, and estimated +%users based on all reporting directory mirrors. +%The total request numbers and reported shares exceed those of +%\texttt{trusted} in May 2010 and from August 2010 on. +%The resulting user number estimate is similar to the current approach +%until May 2010, because \texttt{trusted} was reporting most of the +%requests during that time anyway. +%Beginning in May 2010, the combined numbers have by far fewer missing +%data points, because it's easier to reach shares of 1~\% or higher with +%multiple data source. +%At the same time, the estimated user numbers are lower when combining all +%available data sources. +% +%The results of this new approach are still not satisfactory. +%In particular the estimates of about 1 million users in May 2010 and later +%are hardly correct. +%In addition to that, it's unlikely that the reporting directory mirrors +%saw up to 80~\% of all requests in September and October 2010. +%In the two approaches below we drop the self-reported expected directory +%request shares completely and use different metrics to answer what +%fraction of directory requests have been reported on a given day. +% +%\paragraph{Estimating total requests using bandwidth histories} +% +%The second new approach to combine directory requests makes use of +%bandwidth histories to estimate what fraction of directory requests has +%been reported. +%Rather than resembling clients' decisions for selecting relays (which can +%be difficult with the different deployed path selection strategies), we +%use the bandwidth histories reported by relays to estimate what fraction +%of directory requests they have seen. +%If all directory mirrors reporting directory requests together have +%pushed $b_{pr}$ bytes and all directory mirrors, whether or not they +%report directory requests, have pushed $b_p$ bytes, we expect that in the +%whole network, there have been $\frac{b_p}{b_{pr}}$ as many directory +%requests as we have seen. +%The underlying assumption is that the directory mirrors reporting +%directory requests spend the same fraction of bytes on answering directory +%requests as all directory mirrors. +% +%\begin{equation} +%U_p = r \times \frac{b_p}{b_{pr} \times 10} +%\end{equation} +% +%\begin{center} +%\begin{tabular}{p{1cm}p{9cm}} +%$U_p$ & User estimate based on directory requests to all reporting +%directory mirrors, weighted by bandwidth histories\\ +%$r$ & Directory requests answered by all reporting directory mirrors\\ +%$b_p$ & Written and read bytes by all directory mirrors\\ +%$b_{pr}$ & Written and read bytes by directory mirrors that report +%directory requests\\ +%\end{tabular} +%\end{center} +% +%\begin{figure}[t] +%\includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{bwhist.png} +%\caption{Directory requests, shares and user number estimate based on +%directory requests weighted by bandwidth histories} +%\label{fig:bwhist} +%\end{figure} +% +%Figure~\ref{fig:bwhist} shows the estimated users based on directory +%requests weighted by written and read bytes of reporting directory mirrors +%compared to all directory mirrors. +%The user number estimate is less volatile than the previous two estimates +%and has no outliers in the millions. +%There are also only very few missing data points, because the share is +%above 1~\% most of the time. +% +%However, the range of 50 to 500 thousand daily users is still higher than +%expected. +%It might be that the assumption that directory mirrors reporting directory +%requests spend the same fraction of bytes on answering directory requests +%as all directory mirrors is inaccurate. +%We hope that this assumption becomes less important with an even higher +%number of directory mirrors reporting directory requests in the future. + +The major shortcomings of the approach described in the previous section +are very low request shares of 1.5~\% or less and the difficulty to +accurately estimate shares of directory requests seen at directory mirrors. +In this section we discuss a new approach to overcome these two problems. +The presented approach combines the reported directory request numbers +from multiple directory mirrors and uses the relays' bandwidth histories +to determine what fraction of the total requests in the network have been +reported. + +This new approach utilizes a recently introduced metric: bytes spent on +answering directory requests. +Directory mirrors running Tor version 0.2.2.15-alpha or higher report +how many bytes they spent on answering directory requests in addition to +the number of bytes they spent on all traffic. +By looking at the relay descriptor archives, we can estimate the number of +directory bytes written on a give day by both the relays reporting directory requests and all +directory mirrors (including those that did not report directory requests). + +As a first step we estimate the number of directory bytes written by +directory mirrors. +Only a fraction of the directory mirrors are running Tor version +0.2.2.15-alpha or higher, which is why we have to extrapolate the number +of directory bytes from the reported number. +For the first estimation we assume that every directory mirror spends the +same fraction of its total bytes on answering directory requests. +Hence, the reported number of directory bytes constitute a fraction of +total directory bytes in the network that is equal to the number of bytes +written by directory mirrors reporting directory bytes divided by the +number of bytes written by all directory mirrors. +% +%\begin{equation} +%d_p = \frac{d \times b_p}{b_d} +%\end{equation} +% +%\begin{center} +%\begin{tabular}{p{1cm}p{9cm}} +%$d_p$ & Estimated directory bytes\\ +%$d$ & Reported directory bytes\\ +%$b_p$ & Reported written bytes by all directory mirrors\\ +%$b_d$ & Reported written bytes by directory mirrors reporting directory +%bytes\\ +%\end{tabular} +%\end{center} + +For the second estimation we assume that the difference between total +written and total read bytes on directory mirrors is to a large extent the +result of answering small directory requests with large directory objects. +We observed that relays that don't mirror the directory write more bytes +than they read, too, but the difference between written and read bytes is +much smaller than on directory mirrors. +We weight the bytes written by directory mirrors with the quotient of +read and written bytes on relays that don't mirror the directory in order +to account for non-directory related factors. +We then subtract the number of bytes read by directory mirrors and obtain +an estimate of directory bytes written by directory mirrors. + +\begin{figure}[t] +\includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{dirbytes-mirrors.pdf} +\caption{Estimated directory bytes written by directory mirrors based on +the extrapolation of reported directory bytes (gray) and the difference +between written and read bytes (black)} +\label{fig:dirbytes-mirrors} +\end{figure} + +Figure~\ref{fig:dirbytes-mirrors} shows the two directory bytes +estimations. +Until mid-September 2010, the extrapolation of reported directory bytes +(gray) is slightly higher than the difference between written and read +bytes (black), but both estimates are of the same order of magnitude. +The difference of up to 4~MiB/s is not much when comparing it to the total +number of bytes written by directory mirrors, which is 300~MiB/s at the +time of writing. +With only three months of data, it is unclear which of the two estimates +is more accurate. +For the following analysis we use the difference between written and read +bytes as estimate for directory bytes, because these numbers are available +for the past 1.5 years. +Once we have a larger fraction of directory mirrors reporting directory +bytes we are going to revisit and possibly adjust this estimate. + +Now that we have an estimate of directory bytes written by all directory +mirrors and by the directory mirrors reporting directory requests, we can +extrapolate the number of observed directory requests to learn the total +number of directory requests in the network. +We assume that directory mirrors reporting directory requests spend the +same fraction of directory bytes on answering directory requests as all +directory mirrors. + +\begin{equation} +U_d = \frac{r \times (b^w_p \times \frac{b^r_n}{b^w_n} - b^r_p)}{(b^w_{pr} \times \frac{b^r_n}{b^w_n} - b^r_{pr}) \times 10} +\end{equation} + +\begin{center} +\begin{tabular}{p{0.75cm}p{9cm}} +$U_d$ & User number estimate based on multiple directory mirrors reporting +directory requests\\ +$r$ & Reported directory requests\\ +$b^w_p$ & Total bytes written by all directory mirrors\\ +$b^r_p$ & Total bytes read by all directory mirrors\\ +$b^w_n$ & Total bytes written by all relays that don't mirror the +directory\\ +$b^r_n$ & Total bytes read by all relays that don't mirror the directory\\ +$b^w_{pr}$ & Total bytes written by all directory mirrors reporting +directory requests\\ +$b^r_{pr}$ & Total bytes read by all directory mirrors reporting directory +requests\\ +\end{tabular} +\end{center} + +\begin{figure}[t] +\includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{estimated-users.pdf} +\caption{User number estimate based on all reported directory requests +weighted by estimated written directory bytes (black) compared to the +current approach based on directory requests to directory mirror +\texttt{trusted} (gray)} +\label{fig:estimated-users} +\end{figure} + +Figure~\ref{fig:estimated-users} shows the new user number estimate +(black) and compares it to the current approach (gray). +The new user number estimate is less volatile and has no outliers in the +millions. +There are also no missing data points anymore, because the combined +directory requests originate from a fraction of directory mirrors that is +greater than 1~\% in the observed time interval. + +%We recommend to increase the fraction of directory mirrors reporting +%directory requests to have a more solid data basis. +%Possible next steps are to ask relay operators running fast and stable +%relays to collect and report these aggregate statistics. +%Further, the configuration option for reporting directory requests could +%be set by default for all relays. +%Once we have more data, we are going to revisit this approach and maybe +%fine-tune it. + +%\paragraph{Projecting requests using read/written directory bytes} +% +%We need to learn two data points to calculate what fraction of directory +%bytes the directory mirrors reporting directory requests have pushed. +%First, we need to calculate the number of directory bytes that all +%directory mirrors in the network pushed. +% +%\begin{verbatim} +%We need to find out what fraction of dirreqs are reported to us. +%We assume that the number of dirreqs that a relay answers scales +%proportionally to the number of dirbytes that the relay pushes, i.e., a +%relay that pushes 10 % of all dirbytes also answers 10 % of all dirreqs. +%We need to learn two things in order to answer this question: +%First, how many dirbytes did all relays in the network push? +%Second, how many dirbytes did the relays that report dirreqs push? +% +%We'll start by answering the first subproblem. +%We'd like to learn how many dirbytes were read/written in the network, +%but not all relays report dirbytes. +%Therefore, we weight the reported dirbytes with the fraction of total +%(non-dir) bytes that the relays reporting dirbytes pushed as compared to +%all pushed bytes. +%In order to answer the first question, we count: +% +%b: total reported bytes +%d: total reported dirbytes +%b_d: bytes reported by relays reporting dirbytes +% +%We then can estimate the total number of dirbytes. +% +%D = d * b / b_d +%D: total estimated dirbytes +% +%<dirbytes-total.png> +% +%We need to make sure that enough relays report dirbytes, or our +%extrapolation is based on too few data points. +%The fraction of bytes reported by relays that report dirbytes shouldn't +% +%drop below, say, 15 %. +%The graph only shows data for the fraction being 15 % or higher. +% +%f_bd = b_d / b +%f_bd: fraction of bytes reported by relays that report dirbytes +% +%The second sub problem to solve is to find out how many dirbytes have been +%pushed by the relays that report dirreqs. +%We again use the non-dir bytes that are reported by all relays for the +%extrapolation. +%We count: +% +%d_r: dirbytes reported by relays reporting dirreqs +%b_r: bytes reported by relays reporting dirreqs +%b_dr: bytes reported by relays reporting dirbytes and dirreqs +% +%We can then estimate the number of dirbytes being pushed by all relays +%reporting dirreqs. +% +%D_r = d_r * b_r / b_dr +%D_r: total estimated dirbytes reported by relays reporting dirreqs +% +%<dirbytes-part.png> +% +%Finally, we can estimate the total number of dirreqs by using the two +%estimates calculated above. +% +%R = r * D / D_r = r * (d * b / b_d) / (d_r * b_r / b_dr) +%R: total estimated dirreqs, different approaches +% +%Finally assume that each user makes 10 requests per day: +%U = R / 10 +%U: total estimate daily users +% +%\end{verbatim} + +\section{Counting IP addresses at directory mirrors} +\label{sec:entry} + +An alternative approach to count daily users is to count unique IP +addresses on a relay that sees most of the clients at least once a day. +A fast directory mirror is such a relay. +Clients open numerous connections to directory mirrors, in addition to +downloading network statuses, to download relay descriptors. +The Tor network consists of roughly 2000 relays at the time of writing, +and clients attempt to download all relay descriptors, so that they can +build circuits with any of these relays. +Clients split downloads among directory mirrors, because requests cannot +contain more than 96 relay descriptor identifiers. + +A quick analysis shows that an always running Tor client sends out on +average 80 requests for relay descriptors per day. +The probability of a fast directory mirror, say, one that is chosen for +5~\% of all directory requests, to be contacted at least once a day is +$1-0.95^{80} = 98.3\%$. +Even a client that only connects to the network for a few minutes per day +downloads all current descriptors which takes at least +$\lceil2000 / 96\rceil = 21$ requests. +The probability of such a client contacting a directory mirror that sees +5~\% of all requests is $1-0.95^{21} = 65.9\%$. + +In the near future, Tor is going to introduce \emph{directory guards}. +The idea is that clients pick a small number of relays as their directory +guards and send all directory requests to them. +This is meant to prevent a single malicious directory mirror from learning +about many client IP addresses. +But until directory guards are implemented, we can use the number of +unique IP addresses observed on a fast directory mirror to estimate the +number of daily users. + +\begin{figure}[t] +\includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{entrystats.pdf} +\caption{User number estimates based on unique IP addresses reported by +the fast directory mirror \texttt{trusted} (black) and two other fast +directory mirrors} +\label{fig:entrystats} +\end{figure} + +Figure~\ref{fig:entrystats} shows the user number estimates +based on unique IP addresses seen on three fast directory mirrors. +The fast directory mirror {\tt trusted} reports the highest number of +unique IP addresses of all three directory mirrors. +There are two time intervals when two or all three directory mirrors +report similar numbers: from December 2009 to January 2010 and from late +April to early May 2010. +The fact that the directory mirrors report similar numbers during those +times is an indication that they all saw the majority of clients in the +network. +We therefore believe that the user number estimates of 150 to 250 thousand +daily users are accurate and pose a realistic upper bound of the real +number of daily Tor users. +These estimates are also of the same order of magnitude as the estimates +described in the previous section. + +The major shortcoming of the described approach is that there is no simple +way to combine reported unique IP addresses of two or more directory +mirrors. +Directory mirrors keep the observed client IP addresses in memory for at +most 24 hours, report the absolute number of distinct addresses, and +discard the IP addresses. +It may be possible to exchange data structures containing IP addresses +between directory mirrors in a privacy-preserving way and combine them to +learn about the union size of unique IP address sets. +Possible approaches might be based on private set intersection techniques +or probabilistic data structures like Bloom filters. +We leave these approaches as future work. + +\section{Introducing a counting cell} +\label{sec:countingcell} + +Another approach is to introduce a new cell type to the Tor protocol; the counting cell. +This approach doesn't estimate user numbers by counting directory +requests or unique IP addresses. +Under this approach, clients would send counting cells once per day to special relays, called +counting authorities. + +\subsection{Counting cell overview} +The most important statistic for Tor's user count is the number of daily +users. +Our other metrics are passive observations by certain routers, +whereas the counting cell would be an active approach. +Tor clients would send a notification of their presence once daily, so that +the presence notifications can be added together to get the user count. +Tor has a notion of different cell types to encapsulate different information +when sending it along a circuit. +A new type of cell can easily be created to transport presence information. +This presence information is then reported to the metrics engine and +aggregated to find the actual user count for one day. + +Two different approaches are examined here: +The first approach uses Tor's directory authorities as counting authorities. +Clients report their presence via an anonymized tunnel. +Picking guard nodes as counting authorities is the other possibility. +Clients would not need to create a special circuit and can instead just use +one of their regular circuits to send the counting cell to the first hop directly. + +Some general considerations are valid for both types: +Counting authorities have to be very stable and well-connected so that +clients can report their presence reliably. +The counting authorities also need to export the data they received in +some document that can be collected by the metrics engine to analyze and +present the statistics. +Tor already has an extra-info descriptor mechanism in place that can be +used. + +\subsection{Using directory authorities as counting authorities} +Directory authorities have the same requirements as outlined above: +They need to be very stable, because everyone relies on them to +generate and sign the consensus. +They also already export their votes which get collected by the metrics +engine. + +Two options are available for how clients report their presence to these +counting authorities; they can either send a counting cell to each of +them or pick one at random. +Both approaches have advantages and drawbacks, outlined below: + +Sending the cell to all authorities might raise a scalability +problem as a single counting authority might not be able to keep +up with the load if all clients make one connection per day to report +their presence. +In a network with 250,000 users, an average of almost 3 reports per +second is to be expected. +In reality, since Tor's user base isn't distributed among timezones +equally, much higher report rates per second are to be anticipated. +The load this induces on each directory authorities should be carefully +examined, because it will increase proportional to an increase in the +user base. + +The advantage of reporting presence to all counting authorities is that +if a single report fails, the others can still count the user. +If any of the counting authorities reports a much lower value than +the others for a specific day, it can be taken out of the statistics +aggregating process for that day or until the connectivity problems +are resolved. + +Sending a counting cell to just one counting authority increases the +scalability of the system, as new counting authorities +could easily be added once the others are becoming overloaded. +Another advantage is that the user doesn't have to create one circuit +per counting authority, but rather just one per day. +This means that a user who doesn't use Tor for very long on a certain +day can still be counted correctly, even if she wouldn't have had the +time to report her presence to all authorities. + + +Data loss or other malfunctions on one of the counting authorities +poses a major problem in this scheme. +Such data loss cannot be corrected, and statistics for the time period +will be inaccurate. + +\paragraph{Abuse potential and inaccuracies} + +In a system where cells are reported to all counting authorities, +there is no strong protection against a counting authority that +increases the count of users by reporting a higher number of users by +just sending counting cells to the other authorities. +It would, however, prevent an authority from under-reporting the number +of users, because the others will report a higher user count so that +the data from the dishonest authority can be discarded by the statistics +aggregator. + +When users report their presence to only one counting authority, this +counting authority can under-report the number of users, +because under-reporting cannot be distinguished from being unavailable +for a part of the day. +It is also possible to increase the count of users even without sending +counting cells to the other counting authorities. +Detection of such behavior is very difficult, as lower numbers can +always be explained to be due to network problems at the counting +authority; and only very unusually high numbers would indicate increasing +the number of users maliciously. + +It is trivial to arbitrarily increase the count of users by sending on +average more than one counting cell per 24 hour window. +Because counting cells are anonymized, there are no special resources +necessary to execute the attack, other than the ability to make circuits +to the counting authorities. +This attack needs to be continued for as long as the user count is to be +influenced. +When the attack is stopped, the result will be an apparent loss of Tor +users. + +When the scheme is newly deployed or when alternative +implementations of Tor clients that don't include counting cells are +introduced, the number of Tor users will be undercounted. +Both cases have to be taken into consideration when evaluating the +collected data. + +\paragraph{Possibility for additional statistics} +Because clients report their presence anonymously under the counting cell scheme, additional statistics +can be gathered using this approach. + +Example statistics are client version and the uptime since the last +cell was sent. +% +While adding additional statistics, care must be taken that the anonymity +set is still sufficiently large. +For the client version, we could report the accurate version while it is +still recommended or ``outdated'' as a catch-all for older versions. +% +For the uptime since the last cell was sent, reporting uptime in half-hour +time intervals could provide proficient accuracy. + +More work is necessary to evaluate the additional risks of adding more +statistics. +If these statistics are deemed important, they can +use the same infrastructure set up for user number estimation. +Directory authorities are expected to be upgraded quickly, so the +new statistics would become available as soon as enough clients +upgrade. + + +\subsection{Using entry guards as counting authorities} +To address the scalability concerns outlined above, an alternative approach +is to use the entry guards that a client connects to anyway. +Not reporting presence information via an anonymized channel to one +of the chosen guard nodes has the advantage of being more scalable +than either proposed system. +The entry guards can keep track of which IP addresses have already +reported presence information on a given day and refuse +to accept another counting cell. +Also, availability concerns are reduced because a given entry guard +will see fewer counting cells compared to a counting authority. + +Guards that support acting as counting authorities and choose to do so +should be marked as such in the consensus by a special flag +so that clients can see which relays are acting as counting authorities. + +\paragraph{Abuse potential and inaccuracies} +Using entry guards as counting authorities gives them the same +abuse abilities as directory authorities have in the system where +presence information is reported to one of them; but it could be easier +to filter out extreme values as the reported values are expected to +be generally lower. + +The directory authorities should make sure that enough guards exist +so that over and undercounting guards can be detected and excluded +by the metrics engine. + +\paragraph{Possibility for additional statistics} +Because guards know who is connecting to them, there is more concern +when adding additional statistics compared to the directory authority +approach. +By including additional information about their presence, Tor clients add +bits of information that can help identify them across IP address changes. +This must be prevented, so additional statistics can not be implemented +when using guard nodes without further analysis showing their safety. + +\subsection{Usefulness of counting cells} +Because of the presented attacks, counting cells are likely to be useful +in addition to other user number estimation schemes only. +They can, however, provide an easy way to evaluate trends and +might allow new statistics to be gathered. + +\section{Counting IP addresses at bridges} +\label{sec:bridges} + +As a special case of counting Tor users, we are interested in the number +of censored Tor users connecting via bridges. +Censored users cannot connect to the publicly known relays to download +directory information or establish circuits. +Censored users have to learn about one or more bridge relays which are +similar to normal relays except that they are not listed in the public +directory and are therefore harder to block. +Bridge clients fetch all their directory information and establish all +their circuits with a bridge as first entry point into the Tor network. +Bridges report the number of unique IP addresses they see every day. +Our current approach to count censored users is to simply sum up these +unique IP addresses per day and interpret the result as estimated user +number. + +\begin{figure} +\includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{bridge-users.pdf} +\caption{Estimated number of users connecting via bridges} +\label{fig:bridge-users} +\end{figure} + +Figure~\ref{fig:bridge-users} shows the estimated number of users +connecting via bridges. +These numbers are not expected to be as stable as the number of directly +connecting users, because some countries have successfully blocked relays or +even bridges in the past, which has led to sudden increases or decreases in +bridge user numbers. + +There are some shortcomings with this approach to count bridge users. +First, the approach makes the assumption that bridge users only connect to +a single bridge every day which is not necessarily the case. +As a result we may over-count bridge clients connecting to two or more +bridges. + +The second shortcoming is that we're excluding between 15 and 50~\% of +bridges from the statistics for various reasons: +bridges with fewer than 24 hours uptime are excluded, because bridges only +report statistics every 24 hours to hide the exact connection times and +protect the bridge users' privacy; +bridges that have been running as a non-bridge relay are excluded, because +they might report non-bridge users; +bridges without a GeoIP database are excluded, because they don't report +any statistics about connecting clients; +bridges running a few early versions of the 0.2.2 series are excluded, +because they had a bug in reporting bridge user statistics; +finally, an unknown number of bridges is excluded, because bridge +operators decide not to publish their bridge to the bridge authority and +circulate the bridge address to bridge users themselves. + +In the future, we might count the number of directory requests to bridges +in the same way as we do on directory mirrors. +Bridge clients need to refresh their view of the network at regular +intervals, too. +So, it should be possible to count bridge users in the same way as we +estimate directly connecting users. + +\section{Conclusion} +\label{sec:conclusion} + +In this report we described our current approaches to estimate daily Tor +users based on counting directory requests and unique IP addresses, and we +sketched a design to introduce special counting cells for this purpose. +We conclude with a brief summary. + +In Section~\ref{sec:auths} we discussed our current approaches for +counting new and returning as well as recurring users based on counting +directory requests. +We found that it is hard to interpret the estimate of new and returning +users without knowing how many hours per day our users are connected and +after how many hours or days they return. +We suggest discontinuance of this statistic because the rather +technical distinction between new/returning and recurring users is not +obvious. + +We described our approach to estimate recurring users based on directory +requests reported by directory mirror \texttt{trusted} in +Section~\ref{sec:current}. +We are facing two major problems with this approach, namely approximating +the request share that \texttt{trusted} can expect to see and the decrease +of said share over the past 12 months. +We recommend discontinuance of this statistic as well and recommend replacing it with a +statistic based on directory requests reported by multiple directory +mirrors. + +In Section~\ref{sec:combine} we described such an approach to combine the +directory requests from multiple directory mirrors. +This approach is based on the estimated number of directory bytes written +by directory mirrors. +We hope to gather more data from directory mirrors to improve this +promising approach. +Once we have confirmed its correctness, we propose to replace the current +two approaches to estimate direct users with this approach. + +We presented results from counting unique IP addresses on fast directory +mirrors in Section~\ref{sec:entry}. +These results are interesting, because they allow us to determine an upper +bound of daily users. +However, we did not find a simple way to combine reported unique IP +addresses of two or more directory mirrors in a privacy-preserving way. +Once the directory guard design is implemented, this approach won't +deliver useful estimates anymore. +We leave this problem as future work. + +In Section~\ref{sec:countingcell} we sketched a new design to introduce +counting cells that clients would send once a day to counting authorities +or entry guards. +Such an approach would allow us to gather better statistics about clients. +However, more work is needed to reduce the potential for abuse. + +Finally, in Section~\ref{sec:bridges} we described our current approach to +count censored users. +This statistic is based on the sum of unique IP addresses observed on +bridges with at least 24 hours uptime. +We suggest extending the statistics on bridges to count directory +requests. +We could then try to estimate the number of censored users by weighting +the observations with the bridges' reported bandwidth. +Again, we leave this extension as future work. + +\end{document} + diff --git a/task-2647/dirbytes-mirrors.pdf b/task-2647/dirbytes-mirrors.pdf new file mode 100644 index 0000000..981c74b --- /dev/null +++ b/task-2647/dirbytes-mirrors.pdf @@ -0,0 +1,1114 @@ +%PDF-1.4 +%âãÏÓ\r +1 0 obj +<< +/CreationDate (D:20101116150408) +/ModDate (D:20101116150408) +/Title (R Graphics Output) +/Producer (R 2.10.0) +/Creator (R) +>> +endobj +2 0 obj +<< +/Type /Catalog +/Pages 3 0 R +>> +endobj +5 0 obj +<< +/Type /Page +/Parent 3 0 R +/Contents 6 0 R +/Resources 4 0 R +>> +endobj +6 0 obj +<< +/Length 7 0 R +>> +stream +q +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q +1.000 1.000 1.000 rg +0.00 0.00 576.00 324.00 re f +Q q +Q q +Q q +BT +0.000 0.000 0.000 rg +/F2 1 Tf 0.00 12.00 -12.00 0.00 19.42 79.48 Tm [(Wr) -15 (itten director) -30 (y b) 20 (ytes $in MiB/s$)] TJ +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 0.00 12.00 -12.00 0.00 35.26 166.31 Tm () Tj +ET +Q q +Q q 38.86 309.60 18.21 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 309.60 18.21 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q 38.86 37.28 18.21 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 23.02 18.21 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 23.02 18.21 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 309.60 504.54 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 309.60 504.54 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 37.28 504.54 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 37.28 504.54 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q 57.06 23.02 504.54 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 309.60 18.21 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 309.60 18.21 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q +0.498 0.498 0.498 RG +1.06 w +[] 0 d +1 J +1 j +10.00 M +52.81 49.66 m 57.06 49.66 l S +52.81 85.88 m 57.06 85.88 l S +52.81 122.11 m 57.06 122.11 l S +52.81 158.33 m 57.06 158.33 l S +52.81 194.55 m 57.06 194.55 l S +52.81 230.77 m 57.06 230.77 l S +52.81 266.99 m 57.06 266.99 l S +BT +0.498 0.498 0.498 rg +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 44.42 46.07 Tm (0) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 44.42 82.29 Tm (2) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 44.42 118.52 Tm (4) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 44.42 154.74 Tm (6) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 44.42 190.96 Tm (8) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 38.86 227.18 Tm (10) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 38.86 263.40 Tm (12) Tj +ET +Q q +Q q 38.86 37.28 18.21 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 23.02 18.21 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 23.02 18.21 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 309.60 504.54 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 309.60 504.54 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 57.06 37.28 504.54 272.32 re W n +0.898 0.898 0.898 rg +57.06 37.28 504.54 272.32 re f +0.949 0.949 0.949 RG +0.53 w +[] 0 d +1 J +1 j +10.00 M +57.06 49.66 m +561.60 49.66 l +S +57.06 67.77 m +561.60 67.77 l +S +57.06 85.88 m +561.60 85.88 l +S +57.06 103.99 m +561.60 103.99 l +S +57.06 122.11 m +561.60 122.11 l +S +57.06 140.22 m +561.60 140.22 l +S +57.06 158.33 m +561.60 158.33 l +S +57.06 176.44 m +561.60 176.44 l +S +57.06 194.55 m +561.60 194.55 l +S +57.06 212.66 m +561.60 212.66 l +S +57.06 230.77 m +561.60 230.77 l +S +57.06 248.88 m +561.60 248.88 l +S +57.06 266.99 m +561.60 266.99 l +S +57.06 285.10 m +561.60 285.10 l +S +57.06 303.22 m +561.60 303.22 l +S +81.72 37.28 m +81.72 309.60 l +S +107.53 37.28 m +107.53 309.60 l +S +134.21 37.28 m +134.21 309.60 l +S +160.89 37.28 m +160.89 309.60 l +S +186.70 37.28 m +186.70 309.60 l +S +213.38 37.28 m +213.38 309.60 l +S +239.20 37.28 m +239.20 309.60 l +S +265.87 37.28 m +265.87 309.60 l +S +292.55 37.28 m +292.55 309.60 l +S +316.65 37.28 m +316.65 309.60 l +S +343.32 37.28 m +343.32 309.60 l +S +369.14 37.28 m +369.14 309.60 l +S +395.82 37.28 m +395.82 309.60 l +S +421.63 37.28 m +421.63 309.60 l +S +448.31 37.28 m +448.31 309.60 l +S +474.99 37.28 m +474.99 309.60 l +S +500.80 37.28 m +500.80 309.60 l +S +527.48 37.28 m +527.48 309.60 l +S +553.30 37.28 m +553.30 309.60 l +S +1.000 1.000 1.000 RG +1.06 w +[] 0 d +57.06 49.66 m +561.60 49.66 l +S +57.06 85.88 m +561.60 85.88 l +S +57.06 122.11 m +561.60 122.11 l +S +57.06 158.33 m +561.60 158.33 l +S +57.06 194.55 m +561.60 194.55 l +S +57.06 230.77 m +561.60 230.77 l +S +57.06 266.99 m +561.60 266.99 l +S +134.21 37.28 m +134.21 309.60 l +S +213.38 37.28 m +213.38 309.60 l +S +292.55 37.28 m +292.55 309.60 l +S +369.14 37.28 m +369.14 309.60 l +S +448.31 37.28 m +448.31 309.60 l +S +527.48 37.28 m +527.48 309.60 l +S +0.000 0.000 0.000 RG +2.13 w +[] 0 d +0 J +1.00 M +83.44 209.00 m +84.30 206.97 l +85.16 203.63 l +86.02 189.59 l +86.88 193.69 l +87.74 204.91 l +88.60 205.65 l +89.46 210.32 l +90.32 210.93 l +91.18 204.59 l +92.04 183.51 l +92.90 188.76 l +93.76 207.16 l +94.63 211.37 l +95.49 216.25 l +96.35 234.21 l +97.21 238.45 l +98.07 220.19 l +98.93 235.60 l +99.79 266.64 l +100.65 263.96 l +101.51 262.26 l +102.37 271.27 l +103.23 267.95 l +104.09 239.44 l +104.95 253.44 l +105.81 274.85 l +106.67 274.09 l +107.53 268.60 l +108.39 274.13 l +109.25 263.97 l +110.12 236.87 l +110.98 236.41 l +111.84 268.85 l +112.70 291.01 l +113.56 280.66 l +114.42 282.41 l +115.28 255.01 l +116.14 234.41 l +117.00 235.13 l +117.86 262.75 l +118.72 259.50 l +119.58 261.73 l +120.44 262.89 l +121.30 249.01 l +122.16 231.84 l +123.02 234.36 l +123.88 253.86 l +124.74 235.29 l +125.61 254.34 l +126.47 247.49 l +127.33 242.52 l +128.19 210.97 l +129.05 223.39 l +129.91 249.33 l +130.77 250.93 l +131.63 261.12 l +132.49 260.10 l +133.35 245.69 l +134.21 228.22 l +135.07 238.39 l +135.93 250.66 l +136.79 254.19 l +137.65 252.12 l +138.51 247.49 l +139.37 232.61 l +140.23 209.57 l +141.09 215.97 l +141.96 235.82 l +142.82 237.72 l +143.68 235.95 l +144.54 249.75 l +145.40 238.60 l +146.26 218.57 l +147.12 218.58 l +147.98 237.53 l +148.84 242.49 l +149.70 237.60 l +150.56 230.88 l +151.42 230.45 l +152.28 205.06 l +153.14 216.16 l +154.00 238.27 l +154.86 242.48 l +155.72 247.15 l +156.58 245.55 l +157.45 235.38 l +158.31 214.18 l +159.17 215.24 l +160.03 241.79 l +160.89 243.40 l +161.75 241.32 l +162.61 238.14 l +163.47 229.72 l +164.33 195.74 l +165.19 207.75 l +166.05 237.39 l +166.91 241.01 l +167.77 242.66 l +168.63 233.45 l +169.49 246.00 l +170.35 217.52 l +171.21 218.50 l +172.07 247.44 l +172.93 247.65 l +173.80 249.80 l +174.66 243.90 l +175.52 238.65 l +176.38 215.95 l +177.24 222.59 l +178.10 247.81 l +178.96 248.55 l +179.82 249.86 l +180.68 237.45 l +181.54 222.93 l +182.40 200.97 l +183.26 201.39 l +184.12 214.37 l +184.98 223.49 l +185.84 213.22 l +186.70 206.49 l +187.56 179.43 l +188.42 176.16 l +189.29 176.77 l +190.15 193.09 l +191.01 198.52 l +191.87 203.31 l +192.73 206.32 l +193.59 203.99 l +194.45 177.28 l +195.31 180.69 l +196.17 205.48 l +197.03 229.29 l +197.89 237.18 l +198.75 232.23 l +199.61 227.81 l +200.47 205.20 l +201.33 213.20 l +202.19 208.42 l +203.05 216.50 l +203.91 229.62 l +204.78 229.47 l +205.64 204.64 l +206.50 185.67 l +207.36 182.11 l +208.22 195.45 l +209.08 207.73 l +209.94 214.63 l +210.80 203.72 l +211.66 199.58 l +212.52 176.57 l +213.38 173.65 l +214.24 189.53 l +215.10 201.45 l +215.96 195.38 l +216.82 208.64 l +217.68 211.44 l +218.54 180.29 l +219.40 194.43 l +220.26 207.55 l +221.13 202.80 l +221.99 198.82 l +222.85 202.67 l +223.71 190.01 l +224.57 180.52 l +225.43 177.02 l +226.29 198.30 l +227.15 208.92 l +228.01 211.67 l +228.87 209.55 l +229.73 201.57 l +230.59 178.54 l +231.45 183.60 l +232.31 212.16 l +233.17 221.19 l +234.03 220.06 l +234.89 230.70 l +235.75 203.63 l +236.62 189.54 l +237.48 192.34 l +238.34 220.64 l +239.20 221.92 l +240.06 211.74 l +240.92 220.50 l +241.78 213.62 l +242.64 218.65 l +243.50 185.65 l +244.36 193.07 l +245.22 216.62 l +246.08 228.38 l +246.94 219.38 l +247.80 207.29 l +248.66 189.59 l +249.52 197.21 l +250.38 215.79 l +251.24 224.80 l +252.11 223.49 l +252.97 220.95 l +253.83 209.92 l +254.69 193.43 l +255.55 199.87 l +256.41 241.78 l +257.27 227.43 l +258.13 210.15 l +258.99 204.40 l +259.85 193.07 l +260.71 179.63 l +261.57 185.83 l +262.43 206.74 l +263.29 210.71 l +264.15 207.10 l +265.01 188.83 l +265.87 174.76 l +266.73 181.56 l +267.59 190.31 l +268.46 214.44 l +269.32 217.20 l +270.18 234.37 l +271.04 220.81 l +271.90 201.45 l +272.76 190.04 l +273.62 196.24 l +274.48 224.74 l +275.34 230.14 l +276.20 255.42 l +277.06 238.87 l +277.92 297.22 l +278.78 272.47 l +279.64 280.21 l +280.50 279.11 l +281.36 252.77 l +282.22 242.96 l +283.08 257.04 l +283.95 210.31 l +284.81 144.26 l +285.67 110.71 l +286.53 128.25 l +287.39 146.79 l +288.25 152.81 l +289.11 129.76 l +289.97 128.95 l +290.83 128.12 l +291.69 142.26 l +292.55 154.61 l +293.41 157.33 l +294.27 140.80 l +295.13 144.75 l +295.99 153.46 l +296.85 157.64 l +297.71 128.94 l +298.57 146.34 l +299.44 143.88 l +300.30 152.13 l +301.16 144.41 l +302.02 136.79 l +302.88 128.52 l +303.74 134.45 l +304.60 137.39 l +305.46 140.78 l +306.32 134.04 l +307.18 150.87 l +308.04 146.78 l +308.90 121.75 l +309.76 140.08 l +310.62 137.65 l +311.48 145.16 l +312.34 162.62 l +313.20 152.64 l +314.06 143.93 l +314.92 120.26 l +315.79 131.33 l +316.65 149.41 l +317.51 156.81 l +318.37 153.54 l +319.23 161.65 l +320.09 156.81 l +320.95 146.29 l +321.81 149.12 l +322.67 125.40 l +323.53 156.25 l +324.39 166.02 l +325.25 166.31 l +326.11 157.88 l +326.97 122.71 l +327.83 145.97 l +328.69 172.07 l +329.55 180.29 l +330.41 166.57 l +331.28 156.12 l +332.14 155.78 l +333.00 139.14 l +333.86 139.10 l +334.72 159.96 l +335.58 161.34 l +336.44 164.61 l +337.30 162.89 l +338.16 165.25 l +339.02 145.49 l +339.88 157.00 l +340.74 174.27 l +341.60 163.49 l +342.46 168.52 l +343.32 174.53 l +344.18 164.43 l +345.04 147.98 l +345.90 145.80 l +346.77 172.67 l +347.63 174.90 l +348.49 168.55 l +349.35 175.45 l +350.21 170.33 l +351.07 147.61 l +351.93 128.68 l +352.79 133.94 l +353.65 156.37 l +354.51 161.06 l +355.37 162.56 l +356.23 147.94 l +357.09 128.26 l +357.95 125.73 l +358.81 151.27 l +359.67 150.82 l +360.53 149.59 l +361.39 153.78 l +362.25 144.74 l +363.12 138.56 l +363.98 142.76 l +364.84 164.41 l +365.70 169.98 l +366.56 168.68 l +367.42 175.89 l +368.28 165.66 l +369.14 152.72 l +370.00 136.46 l +370.86 169.68 l +371.72 177.89 l +372.58 166.69 l +373.44 180.32 l +374.30 176.48 l +375.16 164.68 l +376.02 177.86 l +376.88 191.96 l +377.74 208.66 l +378.61 200.65 l +379.47 186.05 l +380.33 192.90 l +381.19 177.20 l +382.05 175.20 l +382.91 197.05 l +383.77 188.74 l +384.63 197.09 l +385.49 178.57 l +386.35 176.27 l +387.21 169.26 l +388.07 165.74 l +388.93 192.63 l +389.79 196.29 l +390.65 189.06 l +391.51 198.03 l +392.37 203.63 l +393.23 173.40 l +394.09 183.38 l +394.96 199.34 l +395.82 187.52 l +396.68 181.43 l +397.54 195.31 l +398.40 177.09 l +399.26 167.20 l +400.12 173.11 l +400.98 192.43 l +401.84 190.66 l +402.70 198.73 l +403.56 202.05 l +404.42 190.35 l +405.28 163.89 l +406.14 178.18 l +407.00 187.68 l +407.86 186.53 l +408.72 191.48 l +409.58 185.42 l +410.45 173.25 l +411.31 172.49 l +412.17 182.53 l +413.03 196.53 l +413.89 173.65 l +414.75 166.92 l +415.61 163.22 l +416.47 148.88 l +417.33 147.91 l +418.19 166.72 l +419.05 168.76 l +419.91 165.98 l +420.77 164.61 l +421.63 145.48 l +422.49 148.12 l +423.35 137.72 l +424.21 150.83 l +425.07 163.32 l +425.94 162.71 l +426.80 160.58 l +427.66 155.05 l +428.52 147.10 l +429.38 131.07 l +430.24 132.70 l +431.10 144.92 l +431.96 160.95 l +432.82 175.89 l +433.68 163.39 l +434.54 155.62 l +435.40 129.04 l +436.26 140.04 l +437.12 156.95 l +437.98 159.76 l +438.84 162.46 l +439.70 158.15 l +440.56 144.74 l +441.42 134.00 l +442.29 137.65 l +443.15 159.32 l +444.01 157.01 l +444.87 165.82 l +445.73 158.23 l +446.59 146.99 l +447.45 130.92 l +448.31 137.53 l +449.17 149.73 l +450.03 159.08 l +450.89 160.18 l +451.75 152.88 l +452.61 144.52 l +453.47 129.45 l +454.33 138.49 l +455.19 162.81 l +456.05 164.68 l +456.91 175.29 l +457.78 172.19 l +458.64 163.87 l +459.50 170.28 l +460.36 170.50 l +461.22 169.14 l +462.08 165.30 l +462.94 162.97 l +463.80 166.84 l +464.66 173.83 l +465.52 148.93 l +466.38 165.44 l +467.24 189.75 l +468.10 192.20 l +468.96 178.78 l +469.82 184.21 l +470.68 190.42 l +471.54 157.08 l +472.40 160.59 l +473.27 193.85 l +474.13 204.22 l +474.99 195.74 l +475.85 199.33 l +476.71 189.34 l +477.57 183.46 l +478.43 178.74 l +479.29 211.71 l +480.15 192.16 l +481.01 208.80 l +481.87 196.45 l +482.73 185.73 l +483.59 166.29 l +484.45 185.02 l +485.31 210.63 l +486.17 216.05 l +487.03 212.77 l +487.89 186.94 l +488.75 181.57 l +489.62 161.92 l +490.48 156.72 l +491.34 188.52 l +492.20 167.90 l +493.06 171.59 l +493.92 181.86 l +494.78 189.34 l +495.64 171.70 l +496.50 187.45 l +497.36 201.21 l +498.22 207.49 l +499.08 220.41 l +499.94 213.72 l +500.80 208.18 l +501.66 194.27 l +502.52 219.42 l +503.38 229.15 l +504.24 225.93 l +505.11 237.00 l +505.97 229.65 l +506.83 231.46 l +507.69 208.58 l +508.55 211.41 l +509.41 247.21 l +510.27 243.90 l +511.13 241.78 l +511.99 234.16 l +512.85 220.74 l +513.71 206.01 l +514.57 217.66 l +515.43 245.14 l +516.29 241.77 l +517.15 237.08 l +518.01 232.23 l +518.87 225.53 l +519.73 202.50 l +520.60 204.56 l +521.46 216.32 l +522.32 225.84 l +523.18 224.13 l +524.04 221.07 l +524.90 205.68 l +525.76 199.29 l +526.62 214.94 l +527.48 224.18 l +528.34 209.65 l +529.20 220.08 l +530.06 212.51 l +530.92 204.80 l +531.78 193.13 l +532.64 201.21 l +533.50 214.71 l +534.36 203.00 l +535.22 226.00 l +536.08 235.52 l +536.95 239.97 l +537.81 207.29 l +S +/GS1 gs +0.000 0.000 0.000 RG +469.82 203.39 m +470.68 207.98 l +471.54 210.93 l +472.40 240.92 l +473.27 255.79 l +474.13 247.49 l +474.99 248.93 l +475.85 211.26 l +476.71 251.51 l +477.57 247.14 l +478.43 246.88 l +479.29 267.75 l +480.15 215.55 l +481.01 251.24 l +481.87 242.11 l +482.73 224.83 l +483.59 210.92 l +484.45 229.43 l +485.31 249.74 l +486.17 215.57 l +487.03 223.48 l +487.89 199.96 l +488.75 219.74 l +489.62 214.37 l +490.48 194.62 l +491.34 212.04 l +492.20 199.03 l +493.06 210.10 l +493.92 212.66 l +494.78 216.63 l +495.64 206.49 l +496.50 209.59 l +497.36 222.77 l +498.22 216.07 l +499.08 202.30 l +499.94 213.26 l +500.80 234.40 l +501.66 207.70 l +502.52 238.03 l +503.38 228.10 l +504.24 235.27 l +505.11 252.26 l +505.97 256.70 l +506.83 254.31 l +507.69 235.65 l +508.55 228.98 l +509.41 257.41 l +510.27 246.99 l +511.13 253.08 l +511.99 252.37 l +512.85 241.47 l +513.71 227.83 l +514.57 238.65 l +515.43 262.72 l +516.29 256.07 l +517.15 250.39 l +518.01 228.84 l +518.87 216.45 l +519.73 204.01 l +520.60 208.78 l +521.46 224.01 l +522.32 222.80 l +523.18 224.50 l +524.04 221.42 l +524.90 205.38 l +525.76 190.48 l +526.62 200.09 l +527.48 215.95 l +528.34 203.60 l +529.20 217.12 l +530.06 201.47 l +530.92 193.18 l +531.78 194.56 l +532.64 204.86 l +533.50 205.71 l +534.36 222.98 l +535.22 255.92 l +536.08 259.88 l +536.95 237.53 l +537.81 204.46 l +S +Q q +Q q 57.06 37.28 504.54 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q +/GS2 gs +0.498 0.498 0.498 RG +1.06 w +[] 0 d +1 J +1 j +10.00 M +134.21 33.03 m 134.21 37.28 l S +213.38 33.03 m 213.38 37.28 l S +292.55 33.03 m 292.55 37.28 l S +369.14 33.03 m 369.14 37.28 l S +448.31 33.03 m 448.31 37.28 l S +527.48 33.03 m 527.48 37.28 l S +BT +/GS257 gs +0.498 0.498 0.498 rg +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 116.99 23.02 Tm [(A) 30 (ug-09)] TJ +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 196.09 23.02 Tm [(No) 15 (v-09)] TJ +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 275.61 23.02 Tm [(F) 30 (eb-10)] TJ +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 351.36 23.02 Tm [(Ma) 30 (y-10)] TJ +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 431.08 23.02 Tm [(A) 30 (ug-10)] TJ +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 510.18 23.02 Tm [(No) 15 (v-10)] TJ +ET +Q q +Q q 57.06 23.02 504.54 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q +endstream +endobj +7 0 obj +15897 +endobj +3 0 obj +<< +/Type /Pages +/Kids [ +5 0 R +] +/Count 1 +/MediaBox [0 0 576 324] +>> +endobj +4 0 obj +<< +/ProcSet [/PDF /Text] +/Font <</F2 9 0 R >> +/ExtGState << /GS1 10 0 R /GS2 11 0 R /GS257 12 0 R >> +>> +endobj +8 0 obj +<< +/Type /Encoding +/BaseEncoding /WinAnsiEncoding +/Differences [ 45/minus 96/quoteleft +144/dotlessi /grave /acute /circumflex /tilde /macron /breve /dotaccent +/dieresis /.notdef /ring /cedilla /.notdef /hungarumlaut /ogonek /caron /space] +>> +endobj +9 0 obj << +/Type /Font +/Subtype /Type1 +/Name /F2 +/BaseFont /Helvetica +/Encoding 8 0 R +>> endobj +10 0 obj +<< +/Type /ExtGState +/CA 0.502 >> +endobj +11 0 obj +<< +/Type /ExtGState +/CA 1.000 >> +endobj +12 0 obj +<< +/Type /ExtGState +/ca 1.000 +>> +endobj +xref +0 13 +0000000000 65535 f +0000000021 00000 n +0000000164 00000 n +0000016264 00000 n +0000016347 00000 n +0000000213 00000 n +0000000293 00000 n +0000016243 00000 n +0000016466 00000 n +0000016723 00000 n +0000016819 00000 n +0000016868 00000 n +0000016917 00000 n +trailer +<< +/Size 13 +/Info 1 0 R +/Root 2 0 R +>> +startxref +16966 +%%EOF diff --git a/task-2647/entrystats.pdf b/task-2647/entrystats.pdf new file mode 100644 index 0000000..9355709 --- /dev/null +++ b/task-2647/entrystats.pdf @@ -0,0 +1,1304 @@ +%PDF-1.4 +%âãÏÓ\r +1 0 obj +<< +/CreationDate (D:20101104094750) +/ModDate (D:20101104094750) +/Title (R Graphics Output) +/Producer (R 2.10.0) +/Creator (R) +>> +endobj +2 0 obj +<< +/Type /Catalog +/Pages 3 0 R +>> +endobj +5 0 obj +<< +/Type /Page +/Parent 3 0 R +/Contents 6 0 R +/Resources 4 0 R +>> +endobj +6 0 obj +<< +/Length 7 0 R +>> +stream +q +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q +1.000 1.000 1.000 rg +0.00 0.00 576.00 324.00 re f +Q q +Q q +Q q +BT +0.000 0.000 0.000 rg +/F2 1 Tf 0.00 12.00 -12.00 0.00 19.42 70.93 Tm (Unique IP addresses $in thousands$) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 0.00 12.00 -12.00 0.00 35.26 166.31 Tm () Tj +ET +Q q +Q q 38.86 309.60 23.77 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 309.60 23.77 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q 38.86 37.28 23.77 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 23.02 23.77 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 23.02 23.77 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 309.60 498.98 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 309.60 498.98 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 37.28 498.98 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 37.28 498.98 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q 62.62 23.02 498.98 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 309.60 23.77 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 309.60 23.77 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q +0.498 0.498 0.498 RG +1.06 w +[] 0 d +1 J +1 j +10.00 M +58.37 93.89 m 62.62 93.89 l S +58.37 139.67 m 62.62 139.67 l S +58.37 185.46 m 62.62 185.46 l S +58.37 231.24 m 62.62 231.24 l S +58.37 277.03 m 62.62 277.03 l S +BT +0.498 0.498 0.498 rg +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 44.42 90.30 Tm (50) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 38.86 136.08 Tm (100) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 38.86 181.87 Tm (150) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 38.86 227.65 Tm (200) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 38.86 273.44 Tm (250) Tj +ET +Q q +Q q 38.86 37.28 23.77 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 23.02 23.77 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 23.02 23.77 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 309.60 498.98 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 309.60 498.98 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 37.28 498.98 272.32 re W n +0.898 0.898 0.898 rg +62.62 37.28 498.98 272.32 re f +0.949 0.949 0.949 RG +0.53 w +[] 0 d +1 J +1 j +10.00 M +62.62 48.10 m +561.60 48.10 l +S +62.62 70.99 m +561.60 70.99 l +S +62.62 93.89 m +561.60 93.89 l +S +62.62 116.78 m +561.60 116.78 l +S +62.62 139.67 m +561.60 139.67 l +S +62.62 162.56 m +561.60 162.56 l +S +62.62 185.46 m +561.60 185.46 l +S +62.62 208.35 m +561.60 208.35 l +S +62.62 231.24 m +561.60 231.24 l +S +62.62 254.14 m +561.60 254.14 l +S +62.62 277.03 m +561.60 277.03 l +S +62.62 299.92 m +561.60 299.92 l +S +86.46 37.28 m +86.46 309.60 l +S +122.43 37.28 m +122.43 309.60 l +S +157.23 37.28 m +157.23 309.60 l +S +193.20 37.28 m +193.20 309.60 l +S +229.16 37.28 m +229.16 309.60 l +S +261.65 37.28 m +261.65 309.60 l +S +297.61 37.28 m +297.61 309.60 l +S +332.41 37.28 m +332.41 309.60 l +S +368.38 37.28 m +368.38 309.60 l +S +403.18 37.28 m +403.18 309.60 l +S +439.15 37.28 m +439.15 309.60 l +S +475.11 37.28 m +475.11 309.60 l +S +509.92 37.28 m +509.92 309.60 l +S +545.88 37.28 m +545.88 309.60 l +S +1.000 1.000 1.000 RG +1.06 w +[] 0 d +62.62 93.89 m +561.60 93.89 l +S +62.62 139.67 m +561.60 139.67 l +S +62.62 185.46 m +561.60 185.46 l +S +62.62 231.24 m +561.60 231.24 l +S +62.62 277.03 m +561.60 277.03 l +S +157.23 37.28 m +157.23 309.60 l +S +261.65 37.28 m +261.65 309.60 l +S +368.38 37.28 m +368.38 309.60 l +S +475.11 37.28 m +475.11 309.60 l +S +0.000 0.000 0.000 RG +2.13 w +[] 0 d +0 J +1.00 M +108.51 131.39 m +109.67 184.32 l +110.83 171.42 l +111.99 157.73 l +113.15 161.73 l +114.31 166.74 l +115.47 191.76 l +116.63 203.15 l +117.79 198.82 l +118.95 175.26 l +120.11 179.42 l +121.27 178.18 l +122.43 157.83 l +123.59 170.03 l +124.75 171.95 l +125.91 186.22 l +127.07 181.78 l +128.23 175.52 l +129.39 185.63 l +130.55 184.85 l +131.71 173.23 l +132.87 169.87 l +134.03 186.54 l +135.19 181.14 l +136.35 170.85 l +137.51 157.84 l +138.67 163.11 l +139.83 197.02 l +140.99 203.20 l +142.15 195.93 l +143.31 191.80 l +144.47 165.80 l +145.63 159.05 l +146.79 156.84 l +147.95 200.27 l +149.11 198.99 l +150.27 202.21 l +151.43 192.37 l +152.59 166.14 l +153.75 156.49 l +154.91 159.41 l +156.07 180.49 l +157.23 166.41 l +158.39 181.40 l +159.55 182.33 l +160.71 176.36 l +161.87 162.23 l +163.03 168.23 l +164.19 171.55 l +165.35 170.32 l +166.51 172.36 l +167.67 174.81 l +168.83 175.33 l +169.99 174.18 l +171.15 167.98 l +172.31 182.62 l +173.47 163.22 l +174.63 164.72 l +175.79 162.28 l +176.95 165.42 l +178.11 151.67 l +179.27 154.16 l +180.44 162.62 l +181.60 159.43 l +182.76 175.32 l +183.92 161.84 l +185.08 145.14 l +186.24 146.26 l +187.40 158.26 l +188.56 169.59 l +189.72 162.97 l +190.88 175.14 l +192.04 162.44 l +193.20 159.70 l +S +195.52 173.31 m +196.68 183.45 l +197.84 186.68 l +199.00 178.82 l +200.16 180.67 l +201.32 163.05 l +202.48 172.67 l +203.64 173.86 l +204.80 183.73 l +205.96 198.43 l +207.12 196.32 l +208.28 177.71 l +209.44 221.86 l +210.60 207.54 l +211.76 182.86 l +212.92 167.27 l +S +215.24 201.33 m +216.40 160.55 l +217.56 139.87 l +218.72 123.44 l +221.04 196.62 l +222.20 216.29 l +223.36 193.18 l +224.52 161.18 l +225.68 144.65 l +226.84 144.70 l +228.00 176.49 l +229.16 192.30 l +230.32 172.92 l +231.48 138.79 l +232.64 180.45 l +233.80 176.26 l +234.96 176.95 l +236.12 182.80 l +237.28 178.41 l +238.44 189.93 l +239.60 203.20 l +240.76 179.65 l +241.92 196.97 l +243.08 188.63 l +244.24 179.27 l +S +247.72 185.98 m +248.88 223.03 l +250.04 197.01 l +251.20 206.73 l +252.36 212.86 l +253.52 204.15 l +254.68 194.64 l +255.84 194.66 l +257.00 197.31 l +258.16 192.30 l +259.32 194.59 l +260.48 196.63 l +261.65 209.64 l +262.81 202.32 l +S +265.13 173.31 m +266.29 215.32 l +267.45 187.42 l +268.61 185.31 l +269.77 202.49 l +270.93 204.00 l +272.09 183.55 l +273.25 173.61 l +274.41 210.45 l +275.57 172.03 l +276.73 187.61 l +277.89 180.31 l +279.05 181.94 l +280.21 145.39 l +281.37 192.30 l +282.53 176.31 l +283.69 169.01 l +284.85 187.60 l +286.01 170.55 l +287.17 204.17 l +288.33 180.25 l +289.49 159.64 l +290.65 111.00 l +291.81 162.40 l +292.97 163.96 l +294.13 117.31 l +295.29 162.91 l +296.45 144.40 l +297.61 158.20 l +298.77 150.70 l +299.93 151.29 l +301.09 117.05 l +302.25 169.15 l +303.41 133.41 l +304.57 128.31 l +S +317.33 232.09 m +318.49 213.40 l +S +327.77 237.95 m +328.93 266.19 l +330.09 263.57 l +331.25 258.77 l +332.41 245.58 l +333.57 239.55 l +334.73 249.86 l +335.89 261.07 l +337.05 263.50 l +338.21 242.75 l +339.37 229.33 l +340.53 241.37 l +341.69 237.39 l +342.86 258.94 l +344.02 258.82 l +345.18 246.33 l +346.34 271.05 l +347.50 249.39 l +348.66 244.54 l +349.82 244.21 l +350.98 238.31 l +352.14 243.16 l +353.30 209.76 l +354.46 225.37 l +355.62 208.65 l +356.78 192.44 l +357.94 193.59 l +S +360.26 219.94 m +361.42 215.72 l +362.58 208.89 l +363.74 214.09 l +364.90 156.44 l +366.06 192.16 l +367.22 236.81 l +368.38 215.72 l +369.54 216.27 l +370.70 235.56 l +371.86 203.02 l +373.02 199.94 l +374.18 197.69 l +375.34 251.29 l +376.50 163.47 l +377.66 221.51 l +378.82 207.25 l +379.98 218.53 l +381.14 215.35 l +382.30 211.77 l +383.46 204.28 l +384.62 229.57 l +385.78 222.48 l +386.94 225.32 l +388.10 205.28 l +389.26 207.82 l +390.42 197.00 l +391.58 204.14 l +392.74 200.04 l +S +395.06 199.87 m +396.22 215.45 l +397.38 203.48 l +398.54 187.10 l +399.70 192.11 l +400.86 207.58 l +402.02 204.43 l +403.18 201.18 l +404.34 192.27 l +405.50 182.42 l +406.66 175.72 l +407.82 173.62 l +408.98 203.59 l +410.14 215.82 l +411.30 212.52 l +412.46 205.60 l +413.62 202.74 l +414.78 187.37 l +415.94 196.27 l +417.10 214.46 l +418.26 213.59 l +419.42 213.87 l +420.58 178.32 l +421.74 178.70 l +422.90 167.77 l +424.07 178.87 l +425.23 176.06 l +426.39 189.72 l +427.55 200.93 l +428.71 196.52 l +429.87 188.76 l +431.03 180.75 l +432.19 198.19 l +433.35 214.28 l +434.51 207.04 l +435.67 203.30 l +436.83 212.04 l +437.99 193.24 l +439.15 170.52 l +440.31 175.76 l +441.47 189.83 l +442.63 187.60 l +443.79 196.60 l +444.95 203.79 l +446.11 192.88 l +447.27 175.62 l +448.43 188.70 l +449.59 195.75 l +450.75 192.73 l +451.91 192.26 l +453.07 182.82 l +454.23 188.80 l +455.39 159.36 l +456.55 168.82 l +457.71 179.11 l +458.87 193.24 l +460.03 194.45 l +461.19 197.04 l +462.35 176.88 l +463.51 164.47 l +464.67 185.24 l +S +466.99 77.59 m +468.15 226.14 l +469.31 242.64 l +470.47 226.95 l +471.63 245.92 l +472.79 245.79 l +473.95 240.15 l +475.11 237.59 l +S +477.43 191.76 m +478.59 215.03 l +479.75 187.16 l +480.91 239.36 l +482.07 234.62 l +483.23 217.76 l +S +486.71 209.15 m +487.87 252.26 l +489.03 273.44 l +490.19 276.13 l +491.35 277.95 l +S +493.67 117.21 m +494.83 235.47 l +495.99 237.46 l +497.15 257.87 l +498.31 263.23 l +S +504.11 80.70 m +505.28 107.58 l +506.44 116.39 l +507.60 121.34 l +508.76 128.09 l +S +511.08 100.76 m +512.24 123.25 l +513.40 138.36 l +514.56 202.89 l +515.72 239.38 l +516.88 294.06 l +518.04 288.58 l +519.20 280.86 l +520.36 265.39 l +521.52 272.16 l +522.68 293.97 l +523.84 293.66 l +525.00 297.22 l +526.16 287.24 l +527.32 225.21 l +528.48 215.38 l +529.64 221.42 l +530.80 247.55 l +531.96 251.36 l +533.12 265.78 l +534.28 239.65 l +535.44 226.49 l +536.60 186.89 l +537.76 193.03 l +538.92 210.55 l +S +/GS1 gs +0.000 0.000 0.000 RG +85.30 49.66 m +86.46 49.99 l +87.62 50.26 l +91.10 77.59 l +92.26 89.31 l +93.42 101.77 l +94.58 111.76 l +95.74 110.06 l +96.90 105.71 l +98.06 100.49 l +99.23 105.97 l +100.39 98.76 l +101.55 98.34 l +102.71 102.64 l +103.87 102.97 l +105.03 101.09 l +106.19 101.98 l +107.35 105.18 l +108.51 111.05 l +109.67 107.49 l +110.83 111.68 l +111.99 103.51 l +113.15 87.29 l +114.31 87.26 l +115.47 84.40 l +116.63 101.63 l +S +118.95 79.90 m +120.11 88.05 l +121.27 88.98 l +122.43 89.34 l +S +124.75 95.35 m +125.91 94.41 l +127.07 108.18 l +128.23 105.90 l +129.39 99.57 l +130.55 124.09 l +131.71 84.79 l +132.87 87.49 l +134.03 99.04 l +135.19 100.97 l +136.35 94.91 l +S +139.83 107.72 m +140.99 128.32 l +142.15 133.68 l +143.31 136.00 l +144.47 115.88 l +S +149.11 82.30 m +150.27 113.88 l +151.43 133.23 l +152.59 120.22 l +153.75 113.22 l +154.91 102.17 l +156.07 140.13 l +S +161.87 136.51 m +163.03 155.43 l +164.19 176.40 l +165.35 178.53 l +166.51 178.28 l +167.67 159.66 l +168.83 164.21 l +S +171.15 133.81 m +172.31 155.95 l +173.47 175.52 l +174.63 155.76 l +175.79 166.78 l +176.95 148.78 l +178.11 163.84 l +179.27 125.90 l +180.44 153.81 l +181.60 152.50 l +182.76 149.32 l +183.92 160.21 l +185.08 142.13 l +186.24 144.67 l +187.40 139.34 l +188.56 151.68 l +189.72 168.96 l +190.88 170.10 l +192.04 156.60 l +193.20 153.42 l +194.36 151.11 l +195.52 169.61 l +196.68 189.86 l +197.84 173.69 l +199.00 138.68 l +S +201.32 173.82 m +202.48 167.46 l +203.64 174.98 l +204.80 169.84 l +205.96 182.48 l +207.12 132.54 l +S +221.04 60.60 m +222.20 53.16 l +223.36 52.22 l +224.52 51.57 l +225.68 51.46 l +226.84 51.44 l +228.00 51.37 l +229.16 51.54 l +230.32 51.67 l +231.48 51.69 l +232.64 51.77 l +S +234.96 50.63 m +236.12 51.78 l +237.28 54.65 l +238.44 54.02 l +239.60 51.79 l +240.76 54.58 l +241.92 54.73 l +243.08 55.69 l +244.24 54.46 l +245.40 56.66 l +246.56 58.90 l +247.72 60.66 l +248.88 60.91 l +250.04 60.62 l +251.20 61.21 l +252.36 61.54 l +253.52 62.13 l +254.68 63.26 l +255.84 63.82 l +257.00 64.14 l +258.16 62.61 l +259.32 62.30 l +260.48 63.56 l +261.65 63.98 l +262.81 64.64 l +263.97 64.92 l +265.13 66.37 l +266.29 66.38 l +267.45 65.43 l +268.61 64.82 l +269.77 68.01 l +270.93 74.10 l +272.09 68.83 l +273.25 68.86 l +274.41 68.69 l +275.57 67.66 l +276.73 67.34 l +277.89 68.48 l +279.05 67.87 l +280.21 69.33 l +281.37 68.81 l +282.53 71.29 l +S +286.01 50.32 m +287.17 51.22 l +288.33 51.73 l +289.49 51.64 l +290.65 51.75 l +291.81 51.64 l +292.97 51.48 l +294.13 51.68 l +295.29 51.66 l +296.45 51.57 l +297.61 51.72 l +298.77 51.50 l +299.93 56.31 l +S +302.25 50.69 m +303.41 51.03 l +304.57 51.27 l +305.73 54.41 l +S +327.77 187.64 m +328.93 220.08 l +330.09 247.86 l +331.25 237.98 l +332.41 220.76 l +333.57 220.12 l +334.73 238.13 l +335.89 234.73 l +337.05 237.48 l +338.21 211.76 l +339.37 198.67 l +340.53 199.65 l +341.69 139.71 l +S +344.02 150.53 m +345.18 225.64 l +346.34 222.70 l +347.50 194.64 l +S +/GS2 gs +0.000 0.000 0.000 RG +176.95 123.71 m +178.11 121.24 l +179.27 122.47 l +S +181.60 124.98 m +182.76 125.60 l +183.92 123.50 l +185.08 101.99 l +186.24 113.80 l +187.40 120.43 l +188.56 115.84 l +189.72 112.75 l +190.88 112.67 l +192.04 122.52 l +193.20 104.23 l +194.36 103.12 l +195.52 118.03 l +196.68 125.37 l +197.84 121.56 l +199.00 101.07 l +200.16 121.10 l +201.32 132.09 l +202.48 108.98 l +203.64 111.90 l +204.80 124.38 l +205.96 111.67 l +207.12 117.49 l +S +211.76 104.44 m +212.92 157.10 l +214.08 155.46 l +215.24 163.88 l +216.40 167.08 l +217.56 163.44 l +218.72 109.01 l +221.04 139.68 l +S +223.36 131.73 m +224.52 112.81 l +225.68 89.25 l +226.84 88.57 l +228.00 99.10 l +229.16 111.75 l +230.32 119.12 l +231.48 91.38 l +232.64 96.53 l +233.80 108.63 l +234.96 108.34 l +236.12 94.96 l +237.28 106.71 l +238.44 103.83 l +239.60 119.61 l +240.76 110.28 l +241.92 109.08 l +243.08 100.99 l +244.24 109.61 l +245.40 100.33 l +246.56 115.16 l +247.72 108.76 l +248.88 105.60 l +250.04 99.37 l +251.20 94.55 l +252.36 95.87 l +253.52 94.42 l +254.68 94.91 l +255.84 107.65 l +257.00 109.07 l +258.16 111.49 l +259.32 117.94 l +260.48 103.02 l +261.65 109.77 l +262.81 117.57 l +263.97 121.65 l +265.13 112.01 l +266.29 114.38 l +267.45 115.29 l +268.61 115.76 l +269.77 138.93 l +S +273.25 102.13 m +274.41 119.88 l +275.57 118.30 l +276.73 105.19 l +277.89 110.75 l +279.05 112.57 l +280.21 106.28 l +281.37 115.43 l +282.53 113.63 l +283.69 108.30 l +284.85 115.86 l +286.01 98.00 l +287.17 113.97 l +288.33 98.16 l +289.49 91.86 l +290.65 81.48 l +291.81 100.36 l +292.97 97.29 l +294.13 86.06 l +295.29 86.80 l +296.45 88.30 l +297.61 82.23 l +298.77 93.93 l +299.93 83.56 l +301.09 76.54 l +302.25 99.44 l +303.41 82.71 l +304.57 84.26 l +S +306.89 109.28 m +308.05 84.11 l +309.21 95.24 l +310.37 131.61 l +311.53 141.51 l +S +323.13 228.98 m +324.29 212.76 l +325.45 227.37 l +326.61 233.65 l +327.77 236.19 l +328.93 219.37 l +330.09 223.68 l +331.25 227.64 l +332.41 217.99 l +333.57 226.45 l +334.73 224.94 l +335.89 227.25 l +337.05 217.50 l +338.21 212.41 l +339.37 195.97 l +340.53 181.39 l +341.69 176.69 l +342.86 159.72 l +344.02 158.49 l +345.18 138.88 l +346.34 140.38 l +347.50 121.84 l +348.66 115.16 l +349.82 117.17 l +350.98 123.68 l +352.14 118.26 l +353.30 111.22 l +354.46 122.06 l +355.62 99.97 l +356.78 101.10 l +357.94 99.48 l +359.10 99.85 l +360.26 112.89 l +361.42 113.71 l +362.58 122.29 l +363.74 123.94 l +364.90 118.45 l +366.06 104.14 l +367.22 106.91 l +368.38 111.96 l +369.54 106.90 l +370.70 105.79 l +371.86 117.56 l +373.02 126.27 l +374.18 107.87 l +375.34 103.34 l +376.50 110.72 l +377.66 117.98 l +378.82 107.30 l +379.98 107.78 l +381.14 112.88 l +382.30 100.33 l +383.46 108.13 l +384.62 115.21 l +385.78 111.00 l +386.94 113.47 l +388.10 109.90 l +389.26 104.38 l +390.42 102.17 l +391.58 99.75 l +392.74 95.83 l +393.90 103.31 l +395.06 117.87 l +396.22 126.38 l +397.38 116.81 l +398.54 113.77 l +399.70 120.67 l +400.86 122.71 l +402.02 114.71 l +403.18 124.66 l +404.34 114.60 l +405.50 108.47 l +406.66 107.54 l +407.82 115.83 l +408.98 127.65 l +410.14 130.57 l +411.30 121.82 l +S +413.62 116.37 m +414.78 130.37 l +415.94 141.72 l +417.10 141.53 l +418.26 142.82 l +419.42 136.41 l +420.58 101.97 l +421.74 107.09 l +422.90 103.55 l +424.07 104.80 l +425.23 102.06 l +426.39 103.06 l +427.55 106.19 l +428.71 102.85 l +429.87 102.82 l +S +433.35 138.96 m +434.51 153.35 l +435.67 145.03 l +436.83 143.74 l +437.99 134.33 l +439.15 125.34 l +440.31 140.06 l +441.47 144.12 l +442.63 135.10 l +443.79 137.33 l +444.95 131.98 l +446.11 121.98 l +447.27 119.42 l +448.43 129.95 l +449.59 131.28 l +450.75 136.87 l +451.91 160.23 l +453.07 169.98 l +454.23 145.00 l +455.39 133.96 l +456.55 137.25 l +457.71 143.50 l +458.87 143.06 l +460.03 161.14 l +461.19 146.39 l +462.35 135.41 l +463.51 117.20 l +464.67 101.24 l +465.83 114.06 l +466.99 117.90 l +468.15 134.03 l +469.31 123.23 l +470.47 106.70 l +471.63 103.66 l +472.79 106.49 l +473.95 98.35 l +475.11 99.95 l +476.27 105.86 l +477.43 102.27 l +478.59 92.51 l +479.75 84.36 l +480.91 88.44 l +482.07 99.34 l +483.23 113.47 l +484.39 111.94 l +485.55 113.43 l +486.71 96.34 l +487.87 94.08 l +489.03 90.94 l +490.19 111.68 l +491.35 110.38 l +492.51 103.22 l +493.67 101.20 l +494.83 101.57 l +495.99 105.18 l +497.15 118.47 l +498.31 109.16 l +499.47 113.78 l +500.63 118.20 l +501.79 114.95 l +502.95 92.15 l +504.11 100.75 l +505.28 101.75 l +506.44 105.15 l +507.60 101.41 l +508.76 98.42 l +509.92 99.48 l +511.08 98.18 l +512.24 102.26 l +513.40 128.15 l +514.56 136.09 l +515.72 118.70 l +516.88 116.73 l +518.04 121.02 l +519.20 117.05 l +520.36 110.98 l +521.52 123.81 l +522.68 130.87 l +523.84 137.19 l +525.00 135.09 l +526.16 128.10 l +527.32 125.79 l +528.48 130.39 l +529.64 144.02 l +530.80 145.84 l +531.96 153.24 l +533.12 159.46 l +534.28 144.99 l +535.44 136.46 l +536.60 134.42 l +537.76 144.66 l +538.92 146.43 l +S +Q q +Q q 62.62 37.28 498.98 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q +/GS3 gs +0.498 0.498 0.498 RG +1.06 w +[] 0 d +1 J +1 j +10.00 M +157.23 33.03 m 157.23 37.28 l S +261.65 33.03 m 261.65 37.28 l S +368.38 33.03 m 368.38 37.28 l S +475.11 33.03 m 475.11 37.28 l S +BT +/GS257 gs +0.498 0.498 0.498 rg +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 139.86 23.02 Tm (Dec-09) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 244.56 23.02 Tm (Mar-10) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 351.94 23.02 Tm [(J) 20 (un-10)] TJ +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 457.74 23.02 Tm (Sep-10) Tj +ET +Q q +Q q 62.62 23.02 498.98 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q +endstream +endobj +7 0 obj +18207 +endobj +3 0 obj +<< +/Type /Pages +/Kids [ +5 0 R +] +/Count 1 +/MediaBox [0 0 576 324] +>> +endobj +4 0 obj +<< +/ProcSet [/PDF /Text] +/Font <</F2 9 0 R >> +/ExtGState << /GS1 10 0 R /GS2 11 0 R /GS3 12 0 R /GS257 13 0 R >> +>> +endobj +8 0 obj +<< +/Type /Encoding +/BaseEncoding /WinAnsiEncoding +/Differences [ 45/minus 96/quoteleft +144/dotlessi /grave /acute /circumflex /tilde /macron /breve /dotaccent +/dieresis /.notdef /ring /cedilla /.notdef /hungarumlaut /ogonek /caron /space] +>> +endobj +9 0 obj << +/Type /Font +/Subtype /Type1 +/Name /F2 +/BaseFont /Helvetica +/Encoding 8 0 R +>> endobj +10 0 obj +<< +/Type /ExtGState +/CA 0.302 >> +endobj +11 0 obj +<< +/Type /ExtGState +/CA 0.651 >> +endobj +12 0 obj +<< +/Type /ExtGState +/CA 1.000 >> +endobj +13 0 obj +<< +/Type /ExtGState +/ca 1.000 +>> +endobj +xref +0 14 +0000000000 65535 f +0000000021 00000 n +0000000164 00000 n +0000018574 00000 n +0000018657 00000 n +0000000213 00000 n +0000000293 00000 n +0000018553 00000 n +0000018788 00000 n +0000019045 00000 n +0000019141 00000 n +0000019190 00000 n +0000019239 00000 n +0000019288 00000 n +trailer +<< +/Size 14 +/Info 1 0 R +/Root 2 0 R +>> +startxref +19337 +%%EOF diff --git a/task-2647/estimated-users.pdf b/task-2647/estimated-users.pdf new file mode 100644 index 0000000..ff8e629 --- /dev/null +++ b/task-2647/estimated-users.pdf @@ -0,0 +1,1467 @@ +%PDF-1.4 +%âãÏÓ\r +1 0 obj +<< +/CreationDate (D:20101116150425) +/ModDate (D:20101116150425) +/Title (R Graphics Output) +/Producer (R 2.10.0) +/Creator (R) +>> +endobj +2 0 obj +<< +/Type /Catalog +/Pages 3 0 R +>> +endobj +5 0 obj +<< +/Type /Page +/Parent 3 0 R +/Contents 6 0 R +/Resources 4 0 R +>> +endobj +6 0 obj +<< +/Length 7 0 R +>> +stream +q +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q +1.000 1.000 1.000 rg +0.00 0.00 576.00 324.00 re f +Q q +Q q +Q q +BT +0.000 0.000 0.000 rg +/F2 1 Tf 0.00 12.00 -12.00 0.00 19.42 96.95 Tm (Daily users $in thousands$) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 0.00 12.00 -12.00 0.00 35.26 166.31 Tm () Tj +ET +Q q +Q q 38.86 309.60 29.33 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 309.60 29.33 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q 38.86 37.28 29.33 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 23.02 29.33 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 23.02 29.33 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 309.60 493.42 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 309.60 493.42 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 37.28 493.42 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 37.28 493.42 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q 68.18 23.02 493.42 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 309.60 29.33 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 309.60 29.33 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q +0.498 0.498 0.498 RG +1.06 w +[] 0 d +1 J +1 j +10.00 M +63.93 49.66 m 68.18 49.66 l S +63.93 91.70 m 68.18 91.70 l S +63.93 133.74 m 68.18 133.74 l S +63.93 175.78 m 68.18 175.78 l S +63.93 217.81 m 68.18 217.81 l S +63.93 259.85 m 68.18 259.85 l S +BT +0.498 0.498 0.498 rg +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 55.54 46.07 Tm (0) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 44.42 88.11 Tm (200) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 44.42 130.15 Tm (400) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 44.42 172.19 Tm (600) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 44.42 214.22 Tm (800) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 38.86 256.26 Tm (1000) Tj +ET +Q q +Q q 38.86 37.28 29.33 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 23.02 29.33 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 23.02 29.33 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 309.60 493.42 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 309.60 493.42 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 37.28 493.42 272.32 re W n +0.898 0.898 0.898 rg +68.18 37.28 493.42 272.32 re f +0.949 0.949 0.949 RG +0.53 w +[] 0 d +1 J +1 j +10.00 M +68.18 49.66 m +561.60 49.66 l +S +68.18 70.68 m +561.60 70.68 l +S +68.18 91.70 m +561.60 91.70 l +S +68.18 112.72 m +561.60 112.72 l +S +68.18 133.74 m +561.60 133.74 l +S +68.18 154.76 m +561.60 154.76 l +S +68.18 175.78 m +561.60 175.78 l +S +68.18 196.79 m +561.60 196.79 l +S +68.18 217.81 m +561.60 217.81 l +S +68.18 238.83 m +561.60 238.83 l +S +68.18 259.85 m +561.60 259.85 l +S +68.18 280.87 m +561.60 280.87 l +S +68.18 301.89 m +561.60 301.89 l +S +88.91 37.28 m +88.91 309.60 l +S +114.35 37.28 m +114.35 309.60 l +S +140.64 37.28 m +140.64 309.60 l +S +166.93 37.28 m +166.93 309.60 l +S +192.36 37.28 m +192.36 309.60 l +S +218.65 37.28 m +218.65 309.60 l +S +244.09 37.28 m +244.09 309.60 l +S +270.37 37.28 m +270.37 309.60 l +S +296.66 37.28 m +296.66 309.60 l +S +320.40 37.28 m +320.40 309.60 l +S +346.69 37.28 m +346.69 309.60 l +S +372.13 37.28 m +372.13 309.60 l +S +398.41 37.28 m +398.41 309.60 l +S +423.85 37.28 m +423.85 309.60 l +S +450.14 37.28 m +450.14 309.60 l +S +476.42 37.28 m +476.42 309.60 l +S +501.86 37.28 m +501.86 309.60 l +S +528.15 37.28 m +528.15 309.60 l +S +553.59 37.28 m +553.59 309.60 l +S +1.000 1.000 1.000 RG +1.06 w +[] 0 d +68.18 49.66 m +561.60 49.66 l +S +68.18 91.70 m +561.60 91.70 l +S +68.18 133.74 m +561.60 133.74 l +S +68.18 175.78 m +561.60 175.78 l +S +68.18 217.81 m +561.60 217.81 l +S +68.18 259.85 m +561.60 259.85 l +S +88.91 37.28 m +88.91 309.60 l +S +166.93 37.28 m +166.93 309.60 l +S +244.09 37.28 m +244.09 309.60 l +S +320.40 37.28 m +320.40 309.60 l +S +398.41 37.28 m +398.41 309.60 l +S +476.42 37.28 m +476.42 309.60 l +S +553.59 37.28 m +553.59 309.60 l +S +/GS1 gs +0.000 0.000 0.000 RG +2.13 w +[] 0 d +0 J +1.00 M +91.46 69.48 m +92.31 72.64 l +93.15 71.94 l +94.00 69.37 l +94.85 70.72 l +95.70 76.24 l +96.55 73.63 l +97.39 78.83 l +98.24 73.58 l +99.09 73.52 l +99.94 70.55 l +100.79 70.20 l +101.63 74.39 l +102.48 74.43 l +103.33 74.26 l +104.18 75.41 l +105.03 76.13 l +105.87 56.15 l +106.72 52.33 l +107.57 71.65 l +108.42 78.93 l +109.27 79.21 l +110.11 80.08 l +110.96 77.20 l +111.81 73.91 l +112.66 74.95 l +113.51 77.42 l +114.35 79.58 l +115.20 78.42 l +116.05 78.91 l +116.90 77.55 l +117.74 72.38 l +118.59 73.86 l +119.44 79.14 l +120.29 82.76 l +121.14 83.82 l +121.98 85.79 l +122.83 75.31 l +123.68 79.26 l +124.53 78.77 l +125.38 78.97 l +126.22 78.49 l +127.07 78.74 l +127.92 92.58 l +128.77 75.60 l +129.62 70.13 l +130.46 85.69 l +S +132.16 78.61 m +133.01 74.68 l +133.86 75.39 l +134.70 73.42 l +135.55 71.05 l +136.40 72.69 l +137.25 78.48 l +138.10 79.83 l +138.94 77.41 l +139.79 77.00 l +140.64 74.26 l +141.49 72.28 l +142.34 73.43 l +143.18 76.31 l +144.03 76.75 l +144.88 76.52 l +145.73 78.25 l +146.57 71.90 l +147.42 73.23 l +148.27 79.60 l +149.12 79.48 l +149.97 80.11 l +150.81 79.94 l +151.66 79.63 l +152.51 75.94 l +153.36 75.40 l +154.21 79.51 l +155.05 81.80 l +155.90 83.22 l +156.75 80.60 l +157.60 79.90 l +158.45 76.55 l +159.29 75.27 l +160.14 80.15 l +160.99 82.00 l +161.84 81.44 l +162.69 83.28 l +163.53 81.53 l +164.38 77.43 l +165.23 76.20 l +166.08 81.00 l +166.93 83.19 l +167.77 83.44 l +168.62 82.25 l +169.47 81.84 l +170.32 78.06 l +171.17 77.42 l +172.01 82.16 l +172.86 83.83 l +173.71 83.70 l +S +176.25 79.15 m +177.10 77.15 l +177.95 89.49 l +178.80 107.55 l +179.64 110.97 l +180.49 104.82 l +181.34 100.65 l +182.19 90.71 l +183.04 90.79 l +183.88 89.29 l +184.73 109.95 l +185.58 101.02 l +186.43 108.08 l +187.28 95.98 l +188.12 86.68 l +188.97 92.17 l +189.82 100.85 l +190.67 113.25 l +191.52 98.86 l +192.36 91.92 l +193.21 94.84 l +194.06 85.95 l +194.91 85.78 l +195.76 85.31 l +196.60 99.72 l +197.45 103.91 l +198.30 102.95 l +199.15 90.34 l +200.00 86.51 l +200.84 84.74 l +201.69 92.99 l +202.54 102.73 l +203.39 105.79 l +204.23 107.50 l +205.08 110.57 l +205.93 94.99 l +206.78 95.61 l +207.63 109.50 l +208.47 78.61 l +209.32 92.58 l +210.17 110.73 l +211.02 111.50 l +211.87 93.99 l +212.71 100.01 l +213.56 90.43 l +214.41 89.36 l +215.26 93.58 l +216.11 132.00 l +216.95 120.01 l +217.80 89.69 l +218.65 117.07 l +219.50 121.73 l +220.35 132.82 l +221.19 106.19 l +222.04 116.99 l +222.89 112.59 l +223.74 101.43 l +224.59 108.93 l +225.43 129.36 l +226.28 126.27 l +227.13 117.24 l +227.98 118.78 l +228.83 115.16 l +229.67 102.93 l +230.52 112.49 l +231.37 93.58 l +232.22 90.35 l +233.06 90.99 l +233.91 89.36 l +234.76 104.08 l +235.61 98.43 l +236.46 110.50 l +237.30 91.46 l +238.15 91.60 l +239.00 89.77 l +239.85 93.19 l +240.70 115.39 l +241.54 104.59 l +242.39 107.38 l +243.24 105.30 l +244.09 121.60 l +244.94 103.86 l +245.78 102.24 l +246.63 107.40 l +247.48 97.73 l +248.33 96.57 l +249.18 113.70 l +250.02 120.59 l +250.87 117.61 l +251.72 108.44 l +252.57 108.60 l +253.42 93.22 l +254.26 96.62 l +255.11 97.04 l +255.96 117.46 l +256.81 106.35 l +257.66 111.40 l +258.50 107.20 l +259.35 98.07 l +260.20 94.62 l +261.05 107.14 l +261.89 111.53 l +262.74 96.90 l +263.59 93.35 l +264.44 83.38 l +265.29 87.66 l +266.13 82.59 l +266.98 91.50 l +267.83 98.57 l +268.68 91.95 l +269.53 89.70 l +270.37 81.88 l +S +272.07 87.06 m +272.92 97.80 l +273.77 95.42 l +274.61 88.50 l +275.46 94.25 l +276.31 105.13 l +277.16 86.08 l +278.01 93.07 l +278.85 96.74 l +279.70 88.05 l +280.55 88.38 l +281.40 100.49 l +282.25 92.36 l +283.09 75.64 l +283.94 87.17 l +284.79 103.11 l +S +286.49 95.74 m +287.33 129.30 l +S +290.72 111.83 m +291.57 103.96 l +292.42 93.08 l +293.27 108.96 l +294.12 114.39 l +294.96 96.32 l +295.81 84.99 l +296.66 90.09 l +297.51 100.05 l +298.36 122.18 l +299.20 86.09 l +300.05 93.64 l +300.90 84.06 l +301.75 84.43 l +302.60 88.65 l +303.44 94.25 l +304.29 87.42 l +305.14 92.51 l +305.99 85.25 l +306.84 81.89 l +307.68 81.93 l +S +310.23 80.41 m +311.08 81.08 l +311.92 92.73 l +312.77 80.41 l +313.62 79.79 l +314.47 88.54 l +315.32 96.09 l +316.16 92.55 l +317.01 89.63 l +317.86 90.37 l +318.71 83.24 l +319.55 82.72 l +320.40 79.09 l +321.25 88.41 l +S +322.95 87.75 m +323.79 90.18 l +324.64 90.75 l +325.49 79.23 l +326.34 90.87 l +327.19 101.56 l +328.03 100.08 l +328.88 108.99 l +329.73 87.52 l +330.58 97.48 l +331.43 81.88 l +332.27 90.20 l +333.12 85.14 l +333.97 123.26 l +334.82 93.93 l +335.67 97.37 l +336.51 92.70 l +337.36 86.20 l +338.21 88.30 l +339.06 87.41 l +339.91 91.41 l +340.75 100.54 l +S +342.45 82.11 m +343.30 88.41 l +S +344.99 89.69 m +345.84 106.22 l +346.69 90.16 l +347.54 92.92 l +348.39 85.46 l +S +361.10 83.17 m +361.95 133.76 l +S +368.74 89.49 m +369.58 83.92 l +370.43 89.72 l +371.28 94.86 l +372.13 92.94 l +372.98 99.94 l +373.82 109.89 l +374.67 102.91 l +375.52 83.01 l +376.37 104.06 l +377.22 297.22 l +378.06 86.10 l +378.91 91.55 l +379.76 96.07 l +380.61 84.62 l +381.45 91.24 l +382.30 85.01 l +383.15 94.18 l +384.00 85.86 l +384.85 84.70 l +385.69 91.50 l +386.54 88.31 l +387.39 97.36 l +388.24 89.51 l +389.09 84.07 l +389.93 83.65 l +390.78 83.30 l +S +392.48 99.27 m +393.33 117.77 l +S +398.41 208.50 m +399.26 129.82 l +S +417.92 146.22 m +418.76 152.86 l +419.61 143.92 l +420.46 170.07 l +S +422.16 173.50 m +423.00 151.11 l +423.85 149.06 l +424.70 146.60 l +425.55 141.98 l +426.40 133.88 l +427.24 130.16 l +428.09 143.39 l +428.94 143.43 l +429.79 136.59 l +430.64 135.64 l +431.48 128.62 l +432.33 121.19 l +433.18 126.41 l +434.03 151.85 l +434.88 179.96 l +435.72 187.21 l +S +441.66 162.09 m +442.51 154.87 l +443.35 160.51 l +444.20 152.88 l +445.05 140.36 l +445.90 150.50 l +446.75 173.09 l +447.59 164.19 l +448.44 153.22 l +449.29 146.19 l +450.14 141.61 l +450.99 136.74 l +S +452.68 155.29 m +453.53 142.12 l +454.38 160.95 l +455.23 152.75 l +456.07 142.10 l +456.92 152.57 l +457.77 168.81 l +458.62 174.93 l +459.47 153.47 l +S +464.55 155.09 m +465.40 142.95 l +466.25 138.94 l +S +471.34 149.72 m +472.18 227.81 l +473.03 206.09 l +473.88 168.79 l +S +484.90 82.06 m +485.75 85.45 l +486.60 91.17 l +487.45 108.19 l +488.30 98.26 l +S +490.84 84.08 m +491.69 85.49 l +492.54 89.44 l +493.38 88.13 l +S +505.25 98.57 m +506.10 86.48 l +506.95 87.40 l +507.80 103.25 l +508.65 101.57 l +509.49 96.81 l +510.34 98.28 l +511.19 102.70 l +512.04 111.07 l +512.89 107.45 l +513.73 121.48 l +S +521.37 122.70 m +522.21 120.34 l +523.06 126.39 l +523.91 130.49 l +524.76 127.18 l +525.60 119.51 l +526.45 125.84 l +527.30 115.15 l +528.15 120.22 l +529.00 127.51 l +529.84 136.88 l +530.69 133.45 l +531.54 133.06 l +532.39 127.15 l +533.24 111.96 l +534.08 113.12 l +534.93 124.48 l +535.78 125.63 l +536.63 176.24 l +537.48 195.24 l +538.32 185.75 l +539.17 117.20 l +S +/GS2 gs +0.000 0.000 0.000 RG +90.61 68.95 m +91.46 77.68 l +92.31 70.39 l +93.15 78.46 l +94.00 79.23 l +94.85 80.28 l +95.70 81.02 l +96.55 81.24 l +97.39 79.50 l +98.24 76.48 l +99.09 75.89 l +99.94 77.05 l +100.79 78.95 l +101.63 78.26 l +102.48 78.74 l +103.33 83.01 l +104.18 89.34 l +S +105.87 101.78 m +106.72 86.06 l +107.57 85.80 l +108.42 91.59 l +109.27 87.32 l +110.11 86.61 l +110.96 83.63 l +111.81 84.07 l +112.66 87.25 l +113.51 87.32 l +114.35 87.64 l +115.20 88.16 l +116.05 85.54 l +116.90 83.20 l +117.74 84.60 l +118.59 86.76 l +119.44 88.17 l +120.29 89.17 l +121.14 89.11 l +121.98 88.12 l +122.83 80.23 l +123.68 89.78 l +124.53 89.64 l +125.38 88.56 l +126.22 89.45 l +127.07 83.38 l +127.92 78.58 l +128.77 86.32 l +129.62 84.63 l +130.46 68.25 l +131.31 85.32 l +132.16 89.20 l +133.01 85.77 l +133.86 84.04 l +134.70 91.34 l +135.55 93.57 l +136.40 90.39 l +137.25 88.43 l +138.10 89.34 l +138.94 89.90 l +139.79 86.52 l +140.64 87.79 l +141.49 89.25 l +142.34 89.30 l +143.18 88.64 l +144.03 88.45 l +144.88 72.04 l +145.73 82.95 l +146.57 82.06 l +147.42 86.24 l +148.27 87.61 l +149.12 88.07 l +149.97 87.12 l +150.81 88.29 l +151.66 86.20 l +152.51 84.87 l +153.36 86.69 l +154.21 85.76 l +155.05 87.77 l +155.90 86.98 l +156.75 82.25 l +157.60 89.57 l +158.45 87.94 l +159.29 91.15 l +160.14 93.61 l +160.99 92.52 l +161.84 94.91 l +162.69 95.42 l +163.53 92.27 l +164.38 91.01 l +165.23 92.42 l +166.08 92.81 l +166.93 94.19 l +167.77 94.68 l +168.62 94.27 l +169.47 91.89 l +170.32 93.65 l +171.17 90.11 l +172.01 93.07 l +172.86 95.82 l +173.71 92.56 l +174.56 88.06 l +175.40 88.46 l +176.25 89.69 l +177.10 90.43 l +177.95 93.92 l +178.80 90.94 l +179.64 91.46 l +180.49 88.40 l +181.34 85.39 l +182.19 84.20 l +183.04 81.60 l +183.88 88.20 l +184.73 90.93 l +185.58 88.23 l +186.43 81.93 l +187.28 84.57 l +188.12 81.46 l +188.97 83.95 l +189.82 85.69 l +190.67 85.55 l +191.52 89.89 l +192.36 82.64 l +193.21 82.68 l +194.06 82.98 l +194.91 80.83 l +195.76 83.08 l +196.60 82.47 l +197.45 80.09 l +198.30 83.03 l +199.15 80.77 l +200.00 79.62 l +200.84 78.07 l +201.69 81.87 l +202.54 87.09 l +203.39 83.26 l +204.23 84.16 l +205.08 82.53 l +205.93 80.40 l +206.78 84.78 l +207.63 80.47 l +208.47 79.92 l +209.32 86.55 l +210.17 84.17 l +211.02 82.29 l +211.87 78.09 l +212.71 78.40 l +213.56 82.74 l +214.41 83.94 l +215.26 87.20 l +216.11 81.83 l +216.95 81.47 l +217.80 81.05 l +218.65 74.62 l +219.50 82.75 l +220.35 82.14 l +221.19 81.34 l +222.04 83.30 l +222.89 83.15 l +223.74 77.41 l +224.59 76.04 l +225.43 83.63 l +226.28 82.02 l +227.13 81.41 l +227.98 82.24 l +228.83 82.10 l +229.67 79.36 l +230.52 80.08 l +231.37 86.00 l +232.22 80.20 l +233.06 80.91 l +233.91 80.18 l +234.76 74.14 l +235.61 65.71 l +236.46 66.66 l +237.30 76.19 l +238.15 80.00 l +239.00 79.14 l +239.85 80.67 l +240.70 73.11 l +241.54 70.39 l +242.39 69.29 l +243.24 69.05 l +244.09 72.23 l +244.94 76.68 l +245.78 71.45 l +246.63 74.28 l +247.48 75.33 l +248.33 79.42 l +249.18 81.98 l +250.02 86.34 l +250.87 84.47 l +251.72 80.08 l +252.57 72.33 l +253.42 69.81 l +254.26 75.12 l +255.11 87.77 l +255.96 85.13 l +256.81 82.64 l +257.66 79.93 l +258.50 81.32 l +259.35 79.70 l +260.20 78.23 l +261.05 88.28 l +261.89 85.39 l +262.74 81.58 l +263.59 79.92 l +264.44 76.57 l +265.29 76.70 l +266.13 76.05 l +266.98 80.35 l +267.83 72.00 l +268.68 77.99 l +269.53 75.82 l +270.37 72.02 l +271.22 66.04 l +272.07 75.40 l +272.92 81.04 l +273.77 80.29 l +274.61 76.68 l +275.46 72.07 l +276.31 77.30 l +277.16 73.98 l +278.01 76.62 l +278.85 83.16 l +279.70 92.97 l +280.55 83.50 l +281.40 81.85 l +282.25 99.47 l +283.09 95.47 l +283.94 91.13 l +284.79 86.45 l +285.64 83.55 l +286.49 79.00 l +287.33 75.78 l +288.18 88.27 l +289.03 65.44 l +289.88 71.90 l +290.72 77.40 l +291.57 103.58 l +292.42 86.96 l +293.27 78.18 l +294.12 72.91 l +294.96 73.54 l +295.81 83.19 l +296.66 84.32 l +297.51 89.95 l +298.36 81.78 l +299.20 81.26 l +300.05 86.90 l +300.90 89.71 l +301.75 83.91 l +302.60 82.94 l +303.44 86.38 l +304.29 86.55 l +305.14 81.97 l +305.99 79.86 l +306.84 81.23 l +307.68 71.92 l +308.53 81.08 l +309.38 88.59 l +310.23 77.64 l +311.08 81.56 l +311.92 87.86 l +312.77 77.51 l +313.62 80.90 l +314.47 79.99 l +315.32 83.00 l +316.16 91.71 l +317.01 85.43 l +317.86 82.24 l +318.71 77.57 l +319.55 79.24 l +320.40 83.57 l +321.25 85.45 l +322.10 85.00 l +322.95 85.62 l +323.79 87.20 l +324.64 86.16 l +325.49 82.87 l +326.34 86.53 l +327.19 92.99 l +328.03 86.10 l +328.88 91.90 l +329.73 86.19 l +330.58 113.52 l +331.43 84.54 l +332.27 91.18 l +333.12 97.01 l +333.97 109.09 l +334.82 105.69 l +335.67 98.33 l +336.51 74.98 l +337.36 76.15 l +338.21 84.22 l +339.06 88.62 l +339.91 89.21 l +340.75 75.69 l +341.60 73.46 l +342.45 92.64 l +343.30 92.07 l +344.15 71.14 l +344.99 95.15 l +345.84 92.22 l +346.69 75.94 l +347.54 67.88 l +348.39 64.87 l +349.23 67.35 l +350.08 80.78 l +350.93 82.46 l +351.78 68.54 l +352.62 67.32 l +353.47 77.39 l +354.32 68.50 l +355.17 61.87 l +356.02 149.45 l +356.86 80.91 l +357.71 81.10 l +358.56 96.68 l +359.41 122.29 l +360.26 75.11 l +361.10 104.68 l +361.95 82.83 l +362.80 60.56 l +S +364.50 70.04 m +365.34 106.06 l +366.19 102.88 l +367.04 98.13 l +367.89 99.68 l +368.74 100.76 l +369.58 93.95 l +370.43 98.79 l +371.28 95.43 l +372.13 89.40 l +372.98 97.82 l +373.82 95.44 l +374.67 96.38 l +375.52 84.55 l +376.37 94.58 l +377.22 93.96 l +378.06 94.48 l +378.91 81.80 l +379.76 105.53 l +380.61 83.35 l +381.45 104.99 l +382.30 103.25 l +383.15 90.42 l +384.00 81.55 l +384.85 90.59 l +385.69 97.95 l +386.54 102.48 l +387.39 116.72 l +388.24 98.86 l +389.09 97.68 l +389.93 100.73 l +390.78 82.14 l +391.63 73.99 l +392.48 94.68 l +393.33 90.15 l +394.17 86.52 l +395.02 95.55 l +395.87 110.29 l +396.72 93.22 l +397.57 94.89 l +398.41 82.26 l +399.26 75.60 l +400.11 92.48 l +400.96 95.72 l +401.81 85.70 l +402.65 95.29 l +403.50 94.41 l +404.35 93.07 l +405.20 86.54 l +406.05 120.10 l +406.89 92.79 l +407.74 97.34 l +408.59 91.39 l +409.44 92.24 l +410.28 97.58 l +411.13 92.05 l +411.98 86.46 l +412.83 87.26 l +413.68 87.85 l +414.52 85.31 l +415.37 89.91 l +416.22 88.32 l +417.07 79.24 l +417.92 77.79 l +418.76 76.18 l +419.61 83.62 l +420.46 81.84 l +421.31 84.30 l +422.16 79.09 l +423.00 77.61 l +423.85 76.21 l +424.70 74.61 l +425.55 70.39 l +426.40 73.19 l +427.24 79.52 l +428.09 78.86 l +428.94 80.90 l +429.79 77.39 l +430.64 77.81 l +431.48 72.98 l +432.33 72.90 l +433.18 75.22 l +434.03 81.47 l +434.88 87.17 l +435.72 84.95 l +436.57 87.79 l +437.42 116.54 l +438.27 90.66 l +439.11 87.35 l +439.96 97.88 l +440.81 92.75 l +441.66 85.89 l +442.51 88.50 l +443.35 80.89 l +444.20 87.87 l +445.05 91.88 l +445.90 99.60 l +446.75 83.84 l +447.59 78.94 l +448.44 85.28 l +449.29 90.35 l +450.14 69.32 l +450.99 72.43 l +451.83 75.04 l +452.68 77.45 l +453.53 72.88 l +454.38 73.35 l +455.23 71.03 l +456.07 75.26 l +456.92 80.17 l +457.77 80.77 l +458.62 81.17 l +459.47 82.41 l +460.31 76.53 l +461.16 79.23 l +462.01 81.02 l +462.86 78.52 l +463.71 93.59 l +464.55 92.43 l +465.40 94.51 l +466.25 98.45 l +467.10 102.82 l +467.94 94.38 l +468.79 87.24 l +469.64 91.14 l +470.49 97.27 l +471.34 90.65 l +472.18 93.70 l +473.03 81.43 l +473.88 83.02 l +474.73 91.43 l +475.58 103.07 l +476.42 99.31 l +477.27 90.48 l +478.12 90.21 l +478.97 91.03 l +479.82 93.47 l +480.66 99.58 l +481.51 73.68 l +482.36 91.88 l +483.21 76.95 l +484.06 77.02 l +484.90 86.15 l +485.75 79.00 l +486.60 94.96 l +487.45 97.74 l +488.30 96.80 l +489.14 86.98 l +489.99 83.27 l +490.84 82.07 l +491.69 94.16 l +492.54 85.64 l +493.38 79.11 l +494.23 81.55 l +495.08 75.46 l +495.93 77.73 l +496.77 84.58 l +497.62 99.90 l +498.47 92.98 l +499.32 102.83 l +500.17 106.81 l +501.01 100.08 l +501.86 105.30 l +502.71 90.16 l +503.56 99.15 l +504.41 90.20 l +505.25 94.60 l +506.10 93.17 l +506.95 93.84 l +507.80 92.44 l +508.65 86.07 l +509.49 93.97 l +510.34 91.19 l +511.19 100.84 l +512.04 99.84 l +512.89 92.83 l +513.73 90.55 l +514.58 91.08 l +515.43 101.80 l +516.28 99.21 l +517.13 109.69 l +517.97 105.46 l +518.82 102.76 l +519.67 99.16 l +520.52 92.13 l +521.37 95.78 l +522.21 91.73 l +523.06 90.75 l +523.91 98.07 l +524.76 90.87 l +525.60 97.70 l +526.45 92.47 l +527.30 96.86 l +528.15 100.51 l +529.00 104.45 l +529.84 114.53 l +530.69 95.09 l +531.54 85.69 l +532.39 74.26 l +533.24 85.66 l +534.08 88.73 l +534.93 92.80 l +535.78 93.21 l +536.63 93.53 l +537.48 97.75 l +538.32 87.11 l +S +Q q +Q q 68.18 37.28 493.42 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q +/GS2 gs +0.498 0.498 0.498 RG +1.06 w +[] 0 d +1 J +1 j +10.00 M +88.91 33.03 m 88.91 37.28 l S +166.93 33.03 m 166.93 37.28 l S +244.09 33.03 m 244.09 37.28 l S +320.40 33.03 m 320.40 37.28 l S +398.41 33.03 m 398.41 37.28 l S +476.42 33.03 m 476.42 37.28 l S +553.59 33.03 m 553.59 37.28 l S +BT +/GS257 gs +0.498 0.498 0.498 rg +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 72.47 23.02 Tm [(J) 20 (un-09)] TJ +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 149.55 23.02 Tm (Sep-09) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 226.72 23.02 Tm (Dec-09) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 303.31 23.02 Tm (Mar-10) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 381.97 23.02 Tm [(J) 20 (un-10)] TJ +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 459.05 23.02 Tm (Sep-10) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 536.22 23.02 Tm (Dec-10) Tj +ET +Q q +Q q 68.18 23.02 493.42 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q +endstream +endobj +7 0 obj +20412 +endobj +3 0 obj +<< +/Type /Pages +/Kids [ +5 0 R +] +/Count 1 +/MediaBox [0 0 576 324] +>> +endobj +4 0 obj +<< +/ProcSet [/PDF /Text] +/Font <</F2 9 0 R >> +/ExtGState << /GS1 10 0 R /GS2 11 0 R /GS257 12 0 R >> +>> +endobj +8 0 obj +<< +/Type /Encoding +/BaseEncoding /WinAnsiEncoding +/Differences [ 45/minus 96/quoteleft +144/dotlessi /grave /acute /circumflex /tilde /macron /breve /dotaccent +/dieresis /.notdef /ring /cedilla /.notdef /hungarumlaut /ogonek /caron /space] +>> +endobj +9 0 obj << +/Type /Font +/Subtype /Type1 +/Name /F2 +/BaseFont /Helvetica +/Encoding 8 0 R +>> endobj +10 0 obj +<< +/Type /ExtGState +/CA 0.400 >> +endobj +11 0 obj +<< +/Type /ExtGState +/CA 1.000 >> +endobj +12 0 obj +<< +/Type /ExtGState +/ca 1.000 +>> +endobj +xref +0 13 +0000000000 65535 f +0000000021 00000 n +0000000164 00000 n +0000020779 00000 n +0000020862 00000 n +0000000213 00000 n +0000000293 00000 n +0000020758 00000 n +0000020981 00000 n +0000021238 00000 n +0000021334 00000 n +0000021383 00000 n +0000021432 00000 n +trailer +<< +/Size 13 +/Info 1 0 R +/Root 2 0 R +>> +startxref +21481 +%%EOF diff --git a/task-2647/newusers.pdf b/task-2647/newusers.pdf new file mode 100644 index 0000000..28a11da --- /dev/null +++ b/task-2647/newusers.pdf @@ -0,0 +1,1444 @@ +%PDF-1.4 +%âãÏÓ\r +1 0 obj +<< +/CreationDate (D:20101116115119) +/ModDate (D:20101116115119) +/Title (R Graphics Output) +/Producer (R 2.10.0) +/Creator (R) +>> +endobj +2 0 obj +<< +/Type /Catalog +/Pages 3 0 R +>> +endobj +5 0 obj +<< +/Type /Page +/Parent 3 0 R +/Contents 6 0 R +/Resources 4 0 R +>> +endobj +6 0 obj +<< +/Length 7 0 R +>> +stream +q +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q +1.000 1.000 1.000 rg +0.00 0.00 576.00 324.00 re f +Q q +Q q +Q q +BT +0.000 0.000 0.000 rg +/F2 1 Tf 0.00 12.00 -12.00 0.00 19.42 96.95 Tm (Daily users $in thousands$) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 0.00 12.00 -12.00 0.00 35.26 166.31 Tm () Tj +ET +Q q +Q q 38.86 309.60 23.77 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 309.60 23.77 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q 38.86 37.28 23.77 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 23.02 23.77 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 23.02 23.77 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 309.60 498.98 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 309.60 498.98 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 37.28 498.98 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 37.28 498.98 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q 62.62 23.02 498.98 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 309.60 23.77 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 309.60 23.77 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q +0.498 0.498 0.498 RG +1.06 w +[] 0 d +1 J +1 j +10.00 M +58.37 106.47 m 62.62 106.47 l S +58.37 169.99 m 62.62 169.99 l S +58.37 233.50 m 62.62 233.50 l S +58.37 297.01 m 62.62 297.01 l S +BT +0.498 0.498 0.498 rg +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 38.86 102.88 Tm (200) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 38.86 166.40 Tm (400) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 38.86 229.91 Tm (600) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 38.86 293.42 Tm (800) Tj +ET +Q q +Q q 38.86 37.28 23.77 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 23.02 23.77 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 23.02 23.77 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 309.60 498.98 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 309.60 498.98 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 62.62 37.28 498.98 272.32 re W n +0.898 0.898 0.898 rg +62.62 37.28 498.98 272.32 re f +0.949 0.949 0.949 RG +0.53 w +[] 0 d +1 J +1 j +10.00 M +62.62 42.96 m +561.60 42.96 l +S +62.62 74.72 m +561.60 74.72 l +S +62.62 106.47 m +561.60 106.47 l +S +62.62 138.23 m +561.60 138.23 l +S +62.62 169.99 m +561.60 169.99 l +S +62.62 201.74 m +561.60 201.74 l +S +62.62 233.50 m +561.60 233.50 l +S +62.62 265.26 m +561.60 265.26 l +S +62.62 297.01 m +561.60 297.01 l +S +85.30 37.28 m +85.30 309.60 l +S +110.93 37.28 m +110.93 309.60 l +S +137.41 37.28 m +137.41 309.60 l +S +163.90 37.28 m +163.90 309.60 l +S +189.52 37.28 m +189.52 309.60 l +S +216.01 37.28 m +216.01 309.60 l +S +241.63 37.28 m +241.63 309.60 l +S +268.12 37.28 m +268.12 309.60 l +S +294.60 37.28 m +294.60 309.60 l +S +318.52 37.28 m +318.52 309.60 l +S +345.00 37.28 m +345.00 309.60 l +S +370.63 37.28 m +370.63 309.60 l +S +397.11 37.28 m +397.11 309.60 l +S +422.74 37.28 m +422.74 309.60 l +S +449.22 37.28 m +449.22 309.60 l +S +475.70 37.28 m +475.70 309.60 l +S +501.33 37.28 m +501.33 309.60 l +S +527.81 37.28 m +527.81 309.60 l +S +553.44 37.28 m +553.44 309.60 l +S +1.000 1.000 1.000 RG +1.06 w +[] 0 d +62.62 106.47 m +561.60 106.47 l +S +62.62 169.99 m +561.60 169.99 l +S +62.62 233.50 m +561.60 233.50 l +S +62.62 297.01 m +561.60 297.01 l +S +85.30 37.28 m +85.30 309.60 l +S +163.90 37.28 m +163.90 309.60 l +S +241.63 37.28 m +241.63 309.60 l +S +318.52 37.28 m +318.52 309.60 l +S +397.11 37.28 m +397.11 309.60 l +S +475.70 37.28 m +475.70 309.60 l +S +553.44 37.28 m +553.44 309.60 l +S +0.000 0.000 0.000 RG +2.13 w +[] 0 d +0 J +1.00 M +101.53 66.72 m +102.39 68.48 l +103.24 69.03 l +104.10 67.93 l +S +105.81 66.83 m +106.66 64.27 l +107.51 64.32 l +108.37 62.50 l +109.22 63.74 l +110.08 65.97 l +110.93 63.05 l +111.79 62.80 l +112.64 62.68 l +113.49 61.86 l +114.35 60.79 l +115.20 61.97 l +116.06 62.40 l +116.91 62.19 l +117.77 62.48 l +118.62 62.34 l +119.47 62.02 l +120.33 61.25 l +121.18 61.60 l +122.04 62.31 l +S +128.87 62.75 m +129.73 61.37 l +130.58 61.05 l +131.43 58.69 l +S +133.14 58.43 m +134.00 60.89 l +134.85 61.50 l +135.71 62.02 l +136.56 66.44 l +137.41 66.26 l +138.27 64.74 l +139.12 66.82 l +139.98 65.71 l +140.83 65.23 l +141.69 59.87 l +142.54 54.54 l +143.39 60.73 l +144.25 59.38 l +S +184.40 69.99 m +185.25 67.12 l +186.11 69.13 l +S +187.82 65.61 m +188.67 64.59 l +189.52 64.77 l +190.38 64.93 l +191.23 67.03 l +192.09 68.60 l +192.94 67.17 l +193.80 70.19 l +194.65 68.99 l +195.50 68.61 l +196.36 67.77 l +197.21 67.76 l +S +198.92 65.75 m +199.78 67.66 l +200.63 66.95 l +201.48 68.28 l +202.34 67.00 l +203.19 66.03 l +204.05 66.09 l +204.90 66.98 l +205.76 66.22 l +206.61 67.91 l +207.46 64.36 l +208.32 64.73 l +S +210.03 64.61 m +210.88 65.76 l +211.73 65.69 l +212.59 65.38 l +213.44 67.14 l +214.30 67.98 l +215.15 67.37 l +216.01 69.48 l +216.86 67.60 l +217.71 65.93 l +218.57 66.99 l +219.42 66.62 l +220.28 67.75 l +221.13 66.73 l +221.99 67.80 l +222.84 69.66 l +223.69 68.71 l +224.55 68.16 l +225.40 67.45 l +226.26 68.75 l +227.11 66.79 l +227.97 66.12 l +228.82 66.06 l +229.67 66.53 l +230.53 67.44 l +231.38 66.14 l +232.24 66.50 l +233.09 66.63 l +233.95 65.83 l +234.80 65.86 l +235.65 67.34 l +236.51 66.93 l +237.36 66.12 l +238.22 60.64 l +239.07 60.58 l +239.93 60.23 l +240.78 62.11 l +241.63 63.11 l +242.49 63.18 l +S +244.20 60.32 m +245.05 62.59 l +245.91 63.82 l +246.76 63.43 l +247.61 63.60 l +248.47 64.56 l +249.32 64.58 l +250.18 63.46 l +251.03 63.86 l +251.89 65.04 l +252.74 64.39 l +253.59 66.09 l +254.45 64.77 l +255.30 65.87 l +256.16 63.48 l +257.01 63.47 l +257.87 64.86 l +258.72 66.00 l +259.57 63.87 l +260.43 64.71 l +261.28 65.42 l +262.14 63.33 l +262.99 63.88 l +263.85 63.86 l +264.70 62.34 l +265.55 65.14 l +266.41 64.07 l +267.26 61.97 l +268.12 60.77 l +268.97 61.51 l +269.83 63.27 l +270.68 65.81 l +271.53 64.74 l +S +273.24 62.08 m +274.10 63.58 l +274.95 63.58 l +275.80 63.39 l +276.66 65.22 l +277.51 66.51 l +278.37 66.57 l +279.22 67.68 l +280.08 113.40 l +280.93 70.06 l +S +282.64 66.47 m +283.49 65.82 l +284.35 56.41 l +285.20 53.86 l +286.06 55.39 l +286.91 54.42 l +287.76 56.98 l +288.62 68.02 l +289.47 85.79 l +290.33 58.22 l +291.18 54.13 l +292.04 52.84 l +292.89 52.79 l +293.74 54.97 l +294.60 56.08 l +295.45 55.80 l +296.31 54.84 l +297.16 56.79 l +298.02 56.65 l +298.87 55.99 l +299.72 57.53 l +300.58 58.40 l +301.43 57.60 l +302.29 58.11 l +303.14 58.30 l +304.00 57.58 l +304.85 57.10 l +305.70 55.97 l +306.56 56.50 l +307.41 57.87 l +308.27 57.48 l +309.12 56.62 l +309.98 55.71 l +310.83 55.82 l +311.68 54.77 l +312.54 55.52 l +313.39 56.17 l +314.25 55.72 l +315.10 56.22 l +315.96 56.80 l +316.81 56.02 l +317.66 56.46 l +318.52 57.56 l +319.37 58.06 l +320.23 56.82 l +321.08 59.26 l +321.94 59.06 l +322.79 58.94 l +323.64 60.35 l +324.50 59.64 l +325.35 58.97 l +326.21 60.59 l +327.06 60.41 l +327.92 58.84 l +328.77 58.27 l +329.62 57.72 l +330.48 58.69 l +331.33 61.95 l +332.19 59.86 l +333.04 59.36 l +333.90 59.43 l +334.75 60.33 l +335.60 62.35 l +336.46 62.47 l +337.31 63.81 l +338.17 61.15 l +339.02 60.24 l +339.87 60.10 l +340.73 60.94 l +341.58 61.40 l +342.44 64.93 l +343.29 63.44 l +344.15 64.29 l +345.00 62.14 l +345.85 64.64 l +346.71 64.69 l +347.56 63.06 l +348.42 64.77 l +349.27 64.06 l +350.13 63.84 l +350.98 63.91 l +351.83 63.45 l +352.69 63.62 l +353.54 69.72 l +354.40 68.44 l +355.25 65.93 l +356.11 65.43 l +356.96 63.33 l +357.81 65.91 l +358.67 66.86 l +359.52 68.98 l +360.38 111.62 l +361.23 175.52 l +362.09 154.66 l +362.94 118.78 l +363.79 126.14 l +364.65 193.94 l +365.50 108.15 l +366.36 127.68 l +367.21 115.40 l +368.07 114.75 l +368.92 102.21 l +369.77 123.61 l +370.63 120.45 l +371.48 121.55 l +S +374.05 60.22 m +374.90 60.04 l +375.75 59.57 l +376.61 56.79 l +377.46 59.21 l +378.32 58.48 l +379.17 58.60 l +380.03 59.25 l +380.88 60.46 l +381.73 62.35 l +382.59 61.98 l +383.44 61.82 l +384.30 60.86 l +385.15 62.66 l +386.01 60.93 l +386.86 58.23 l +387.71 57.21 l +388.57 60.36 l +389.42 60.48 l +390.28 59.64 l +391.13 59.13 l +391.99 60.58 l +392.84 61.19 l +393.69 61.41 l +394.55 60.93 l +395.40 63.00 l +396.26 62.83 l +397.11 61.50 l +397.97 61.31 l +398.82 62.34 l +399.67 62.08 l +400.53 64.52 l +401.38 64.79 l +402.24 65.75 l +403.09 65.28 l +403.95 65.62 l +S +405.65 73.55 m +406.51 64.75 l +407.36 64.11 l +408.22 65.61 l +409.07 65.45 l +409.92 64.80 l +410.78 64.61 l +411.63 65.29 l +412.49 65.43 l +413.34 65.02 l +414.20 65.22 l +415.05 65.71 l +415.90 66.18 l +416.76 65.65 l +417.61 65.63 l +418.47 63.76 l +419.32 65.23 l +420.18 66.82 l +421.03 65.25 l +421.88 64.28 l +422.74 65.83 l +423.59 66.53 l +424.45 64.48 l +425.30 65.08 l +426.16 66.76 l +427.01 65.45 l +427.86 64.84 l +428.72 64.15 l +429.57 65.56 l +430.43 64.29 l +431.28 63.73 l +432.14 62.12 l +432.99 65.84 l +433.84 65.44 l +434.70 65.64 l +435.55 64.87 l +436.41 64.71 l +437.26 65.60 l +438.12 66.19 l +438.97 64.76 l +439.82 65.28 l +440.68 67.64 l +441.53 63.82 l +442.39 60.49 l +443.24 62.02 l +444.10 63.56 l +444.95 61.37 l +445.80 59.74 l +446.66 59.84 l +447.51 62.03 l +448.37 60.81 l +449.22 61.66 l +450.08 61.82 l +450.93 62.95 l +451.78 64.26 l +452.64 62.72 l +453.49 62.17 l +454.35 62.07 l +455.20 61.29 l +456.06 62.70 l +456.91 62.34 l +457.76 66.69 l +458.62 67.66 l +459.47 67.19 l +460.33 69.95 l +461.18 64.42 l +462.04 63.24 l +462.89 63.27 l +463.74 64.51 l +464.60 65.94 l +465.45 63.49 l +466.31 62.15 l +467.16 63.25 l +468.02 63.94 l +468.87 61.97 l +469.72 61.93 l +470.58 61.63 l +S +472.29 62.00 m +473.14 63.01 l +473.99 64.09 l +474.85 65.40 l +475.70 65.55 l +476.56 66.51 l +477.41 65.56 l +478.27 65.64 l +479.12 64.71 l +479.97 63.70 l +480.83 64.14 l +481.68 64.03 l +482.54 63.88 l +483.39 63.94 l +484.25 63.79 l +485.10 64.12 l +485.95 63.49 l +486.81 63.22 l +487.66 64.00 l +488.52 66.86 l +489.37 68.28 l +490.23 65.29 l +491.08 65.34 l +491.93 64.92 l +492.79 64.07 l +493.64 63.44 l +494.50 64.03 l +495.35 64.78 l +496.21 67.40 l +497.06 66.36 l +497.91 67.50 l +498.77 65.99 l +499.62 64.66 l +500.48 62.93 l +501.33 63.84 l +502.19 64.45 l +503.04 65.44 l +503.89 66.18 l +504.75 65.80 l +505.60 66.89 l +506.46 65.90 l +507.31 66.16 l +508.17 67.05 l +509.02 66.76 l +509.87 65.86 l +510.73 66.65 l +511.58 66.66 l +512.44 66.15 l +513.29 65.92 l +514.15 65.67 l +515.00 65.96 l +515.85 66.11 l +516.71 65.43 l +517.56 65.98 l +518.42 66.00 l +519.27 66.73 l +520.13 68.02 l +520.98 66.76 l +521.83 65.51 l +522.69 67.43 l +523.54 65.18 l +524.40 65.10 l +525.25 65.53 l +526.11 65.56 l +526.96 64.84 l +527.81 66.15 l +528.67 66.61 l +529.52 65.92 l +530.38 66.20 l +531.23 66.10 l +532.09 65.51 l +532.94 65.29 l +533.79 66.74 l +534.65 66.98 l +535.50 66.43 l +536.36 66.15 l +537.21 65.22 l +538.06 65.57 l +538.92 65.09 l +S +/GS1 gs +0.000 0.000 0.000 RG +85.30 76.92 m +86.16 83.32 l +87.01 83.07 l +87.87 79.96 l +88.72 79.38 l +89.57 80.70 l +90.43 79.00 l +91.28 78.39 l +92.14 79.87 l +92.99 79.96 l +93.85 78.78 l +94.70 83.10 l +95.55 83.01 l +96.41 82.27 l +97.26 84.17 l +98.12 84.45 l +98.97 83.86 l +99.83 84.92 l +100.68 85.57 l +101.53 78.70 l +102.39 81.92 l +103.24 82.46 l +104.10 80.42 l +104.95 86.55 l +105.81 81.36 l +106.66 78.70 l +107.51 76.58 l +108.37 75.75 l +109.22 75.26 l +110.08 78.68 l +110.93 73.60 l +111.79 74.37 l +112.64 73.73 l +113.49 72.92 l +114.35 71.70 l +115.20 73.00 l +116.06 74.19 l +116.91 74.25 l +117.77 74.50 l +118.62 74.13 l +119.47 73.18 l +120.33 72.50 l +121.18 72.59 l +122.04 70.97 l +122.89 78.03 l +123.75 77.27 l +124.60 76.24 l +125.45 77.20 l +126.31 76.30 l +127.16 75.19 l +128.02 75.90 l +128.87 70.95 l +129.73 71.40 l +130.58 71.07 l +131.43 71.15 l +132.29 78.59 l +133.14 71.99 l +134.00 72.83 l +134.85 68.39 l +135.71 70.50 l +136.56 76.71 l +137.41 76.73 l +138.27 75.14 l +139.12 77.74 l +139.98 77.55 l +140.83 76.66 l +141.69 74.71 l +142.54 73.08 l +143.39 73.92 l +144.25 73.19 l +145.10 73.69 l +145.96 83.26 l +146.81 81.68 l +147.66 81.94 l +148.52 81.32 l +149.37 82.25 l +150.23 80.58 l +151.08 82.75 l +151.94 87.44 l +152.79 83.92 l +153.64 86.92 l +154.50 79.21 l +155.35 81.35 l +156.21 81.10 l +157.06 83.74 l +157.92 91.77 l +158.77 92.92 l +159.62 91.44 l +160.48 88.58 l +161.33 84.27 l +162.19 84.39 l +163.04 84.42 l +163.90 82.71 l +S +184.40 77.29 m +185.25 74.70 l +186.11 77.04 l +186.96 80.72 l +187.82 73.38 l +188.67 64.59 l +189.52 72.58 l +190.38 72.08 l +191.23 75.49 l +192.09 76.80 l +192.94 75.36 l +193.80 77.64 l +194.65 77.19 l +195.50 76.77 l +196.36 76.41 l +197.21 76.31 l +198.07 84.36 l +198.92 75.20 l +199.78 75.38 l +200.63 74.85 l +201.48 76.58 l +202.34 74.50 l +203.19 74.34 l +204.05 74.98 l +204.90 76.24 l +205.76 75.27 l +206.61 76.34 l +207.46 74.02 l +208.32 74.28 l +209.17 83.45 l +210.03 73.08 l +210.88 74.61 l +211.73 73.68 l +212.59 74.20 l +213.44 75.58 l +214.30 75.80 l +215.15 71.46 l +216.01 75.64 l +216.86 74.52 l +217.71 73.99 l +218.57 74.23 l +219.42 74.97 l +220.28 75.46 l +221.13 74.71 l +221.99 77.62 l +222.84 76.22 l +223.69 75.05 l +224.55 75.51 l +225.40 76.82 l +226.26 75.63 l +227.11 77.16 l +227.97 77.13 l +228.82 75.37 l +229.67 71.13 l +230.53 74.56 l +231.38 73.65 l +232.24 74.26 l +233.09 75.05 l +233.95 75.95 l +234.80 74.91 l +235.65 75.26 l +236.51 74.37 l +237.36 73.79 l +238.22 69.65 l +239.07 69.11 l +239.93 69.26 l +240.78 70.45 l +241.63 71.85 l +242.49 71.55 l +243.34 75.68 l +244.20 66.55 l +245.05 68.25 l +245.91 73.18 l +246.76 72.65 l +247.61 72.99 l +248.47 72.72 l +249.32 72.38 l +250.18 71.29 l +251.03 71.17 l +251.89 71.80 l +252.74 72.14 l +253.59 71.49 l +254.45 71.60 l +255.30 72.98 l +256.16 70.48 l +257.01 70.78 l +257.87 72.66 l +258.72 73.01 l +259.57 71.55 l +260.43 72.00 l +261.28 72.11 l +262.14 70.18 l +262.99 70.74 l +263.85 70.71 l +264.70 69.86 l +265.55 73.09 l +266.41 68.64 l +267.26 69.59 l +268.12 67.65 l +268.97 70.07 l +269.83 70.12 l +270.68 72.46 l +271.53 72.45 l +272.39 77.32 l +273.24 72.47 l +274.10 72.21 l +274.95 71.88 l +275.80 71.84 l +276.66 73.30 l +277.51 71.77 l +278.37 71.82 l +279.22 72.72 l +280.08 113.40 l +280.93 72.24 l +281.78 75.82 l +282.64 71.18 l +283.49 70.70 l +284.35 56.41 l +285.20 63.54 l +286.06 63.96 l +286.91 61.58 l +287.76 70.97 l +288.62 59.72 l +289.47 85.79 l +290.33 53.08 l +291.18 51.03 l +292.04 60.18 l +292.89 50.54 l +293.74 61.55 l +294.60 61.18 l +295.45 52.51 l +296.31 52.90 l +297.16 50.06 l +298.02 62.95 l +298.87 49.66 l +299.72 50.44 l +300.58 50.86 l +301.43 61.82 l +302.29 62.99 l +303.14 63.46 l +304.00 63.22 l +304.85 63.00 l +305.70 72.97 l +306.56 53.65 l +307.41 55.80 l +308.27 56.47 l +309.12 56.43 l +309.98 65.11 l +310.83 55.21 l +311.68 64.38 l +312.54 66.99 l +313.39 66.08 l +314.25 66.20 l +315.10 66.09 l +315.96 66.32 l +316.81 65.41 l +317.66 67.09 l +318.52 56.80 l +319.37 66.00 l +320.23 65.66 l +321.08 59.26 l +321.94 69.74 l +322.79 69.74 l +323.64 70.32 l +324.50 78.16 l +325.35 70.05 l +326.21 70.51 l +327.06 59.81 l +327.92 69.78 l +328.77 69.97 l +329.62 70.77 l +330.48 81.85 l +331.33 169.88 l +332.19 297.22 l +333.04 71.51 l +333.90 67.15 l +334.75 66.13 l +335.60 68.37 l +336.46 66.70 l +337.31 68.22 l +338.17 67.49 l +339.02 66.90 l +339.87 65.85 l +340.73 66.08 l +341.58 66.23 l +342.44 67.18 l +343.29 67.72 l +344.15 65.59 l +345.00 66.93 l +345.85 66.76 l +346.71 66.73 l +347.56 63.16 l +348.42 66.65 l +349.27 67.51 l +350.13 67.66 l +350.98 67.30 l +351.83 67.70 l +352.69 63.78 l +353.54 71.25 l +354.40 62.36 l +355.25 70.68 l +356.11 68.87 l +356.96 68.55 l +357.81 72.39 l +358.67 70.12 l +359.52 66.30 l +360.38 77.38 l +361.23 108.82 l +362.09 109.15 l +362.94 101.04 l +363.79 99.01 l +364.65 99.47 l +365.50 74.83 l +366.36 79.30 l +367.21 78.27 l +368.07 76.47 l +368.92 74.59 l +369.77 76.71 l +370.63 75.85 l +371.48 75.82 l +372.34 68.59 l +373.19 78.67 l +374.05 71.93 l +374.90 70.39 l +375.75 68.28 l +376.61 67.12 l +377.46 67.68 l +378.32 67.85 l +379.17 67.53 l +380.03 68.10 l +380.88 68.88 l +381.73 69.54 l +382.59 69.04 l +383.44 68.58 l +384.30 69.11 l +385.15 70.35 l +386.01 69.24 l +386.86 67.53 l +387.71 66.64 l +388.57 67.74 l +389.42 68.74 l +390.28 68.57 l +391.13 71.17 l +391.99 71.48 l +392.84 71.75 l +393.69 69.90 l +394.55 70.75 l +395.40 69.99 l +396.26 71.59 l +397.11 70.84 l +397.97 70.38 l +398.82 71.22 l +399.67 73.26 l +400.53 72.63 l +401.38 72.83 l +402.24 74.43 l +403.09 73.66 l +403.95 73.80 l +404.80 76.77 l +405.65 80.21 l +406.51 72.92 l +407.36 72.58 l +408.22 73.53 l +409.07 73.35 l +409.92 73.79 l +410.78 73.24 l +411.63 74.07 l +412.49 73.38 l +413.34 73.09 l +414.20 73.90 l +415.05 73.79 l +415.90 73.76 l +416.76 73.66 l +417.61 72.97 l +418.47 71.75 l +419.32 72.69 l +420.18 74.57 l +421.03 72.66 l +421.88 72.34 l +422.74 73.26 l +423.59 72.89 l +424.45 72.47 l +425.30 72.16 l +426.16 73.74 l +427.01 74.44 l +427.86 74.19 l +428.72 73.77 l +429.57 75.05 l +430.43 72.24 l +431.28 72.87 l +432.14 72.97 l +432.99 73.22 l +433.84 73.08 l +434.70 74.03 l +435.55 73.67 l +436.41 72.61 l +437.26 72.74 l +438.12 73.84 l +438.97 73.09 l +439.82 73.17 l +440.68 74.92 l +441.53 73.04 l +442.39 68.83 l +443.24 68.85 l +444.10 71.30 l +444.95 69.96 l +445.80 70.24 l +446.66 68.58 l +447.51 68.21 l +448.37 68.72 l +449.22 67.55 l +450.08 68.46 l +450.93 70.49 l +451.78 73.00 l +452.64 71.10 l +453.49 69.18 l +454.35 69.04 l +455.20 68.73 l +456.06 70.44 l +456.91 70.03 l +457.76 70.16 l +458.62 73.15 l +459.47 68.64 l +460.33 67.45 l +461.18 71.32 l +462.04 69.10 l +462.89 69.30 l +463.74 69.53 l +464.60 72.25 l +465.45 70.27 l +466.31 68.88 l +467.16 69.42 l +468.02 71.02 l +468.87 69.29 l +469.72 70.18 l +470.58 70.32 l +471.43 72.64 l +472.29 69.62 l +473.14 68.97 l +473.99 70.96 l +474.85 74.08 l +475.70 74.65 l +476.56 74.62 l +477.41 72.80 l +478.27 72.98 l +479.12 70.88 l +479.97 71.07 l +480.83 71.17 l +481.68 71.14 l +482.54 71.58 l +483.39 70.72 l +484.25 70.45 l +485.10 70.44 l +485.95 71.58 l +486.81 71.28 l +487.66 71.38 l +488.52 73.67 l +489.37 73.19 l +490.23 72.05 l +491.08 72.07 l +491.93 74.34 l +492.79 71.56 l +493.64 71.37 l +494.50 74.14 l +495.35 78.66 l +496.21 72.31 l +497.06 72.28 l +497.91 76.54 l +498.77 72.37 l +499.62 72.85 l +500.48 72.06 l +501.33 70.71 l +502.19 72.17 l +503.04 72.58 l +503.89 71.39 l +504.75 72.64 l +505.60 74.30 l +506.46 73.16 l +507.31 72.61 l +508.17 72.66 l +509.02 74.16 l +509.87 72.47 l +510.73 73.04 l +511.58 73.16 l +512.44 73.27 l +513.29 72.50 l +514.15 72.08 l +515.00 72.41 l +515.85 72.52 l +516.71 71.95 l +517.56 72.17 l +518.42 72.49 l +519.27 74.99 l +520.13 77.60 l +520.98 73.34 l +521.83 72.65 l +522.69 72.60 l +523.54 72.11 l +524.40 71.71 l +525.25 71.43 l +526.11 71.24 l +526.96 71.67 l +527.81 72.57 l +528.67 72.78 l +529.52 73.47 l +530.38 72.24 l +531.23 70.49 l +532.09 72.52 l +532.94 71.43 l +533.79 72.54 l +534.65 72.86 l +535.50 72.00 l +536.36 72.52 l +537.21 71.76 l +538.06 72.31 l +538.92 72.01 l +S +Q q +Q q 62.62 37.28 498.98 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q +/GS2 gs +0.498 0.498 0.498 RG +1.06 w +[] 0 d +1 J +1 j +10.00 M +85.30 33.03 m 85.30 37.28 l S +163.90 33.03 m 163.90 37.28 l S +241.63 33.03 m 241.63 37.28 l S +318.52 33.03 m 318.52 37.28 l S +397.11 33.03 m 397.11 37.28 l S +475.70 33.03 m 475.70 37.28 l S +553.44 33.03 m 553.44 37.28 l S +BT +/GS257 gs +0.498 0.498 0.498 rg +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 68.86 23.02 Tm [(J) 20 (un-09)] TJ +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 146.52 23.02 Tm (Sep-09) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 224.26 23.02 Tm (Dec-09) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 301.43 23.02 Tm (Mar-10) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 380.67 23.02 Tm [(J) 20 (un-10)] TJ +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 458.33 23.02 Tm (Sep-10) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 536.07 23.02 Tm (Dec-10) Tj +ET +Q q +Q q 62.62 23.02 498.98 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q +endstream +endobj +7 0 obj +20065 +endobj +3 0 obj +<< +/Type /Pages +/Kids [ +5 0 R +] +/Count 1 +/MediaBox [0 0 576 324] +>> +endobj +4 0 obj +<< +/ProcSet [/PDF /Text] +/Font <</F2 9 0 R >> +/ExtGState << /GS1 10 0 R /GS2 11 0 R /GS257 12 0 R >> +>> +endobj +8 0 obj +<< +/Type /Encoding +/BaseEncoding /WinAnsiEncoding +/Differences [ 45/minus 96/quoteleft +144/dotlessi /grave /acute /circumflex /tilde /macron /breve /dotaccent +/dieresis /.notdef /ring /cedilla /.notdef /hungarumlaut /ogonek /caron /space] +>> +endobj +9 0 obj << +/Type /Font +/Subtype /Type1 +/Name /F2 +/BaseFont /Helvetica +/Encoding 8 0 R +>> endobj +10 0 obj +<< +/Type /ExtGState +/CA 0.400 >> +endobj +11 0 obj +<< +/Type /ExtGState +/CA 1.000 >> +endobj +12 0 obj +<< +/Type /ExtGState +/ca 1.000 +>> +endobj +xref +0 13 +0000000000 65535 f +0000000021 00000 n +0000000164 00000 n +0000020432 00000 n +0000020515 00000 n +0000000213 00000 n +0000000293 00000 n +0000020411 00000 n +0000020634 00000 n +0000020891 00000 n +0000020987 00000 n +0000021036 00000 n +0000021085 00000 n +trailer +<< +/Size 13 +/Info 1 0 R +/Root 2 0 R +>> +startxref +21134 +%%EOF diff --git a/task-2647/trusted-details.pdf b/task-2647/trusted-details.pdf new file mode 100644 index 0000000..b7ac45b --- /dev/null +++ b/task-2647/trusted-details.pdf @@ -0,0 +1,2413 @@ +%PDF-1.4 +%âãÏÓ\r +1 0 obj +<< +/CreationDate (D:20101116125849) +/ModDate (D:20101116125849) +/Title (R Graphics Output) +/Producer (R 2.10.0) +/Creator (R) +>> +endobj +2 0 obj +<< +/Type /Catalog +/Pages 3 0 R +>> +endobj +5 0 obj +<< +/Type /Page +/Parent 3 0 R +/Contents 6 0 R +/Resources 4 0 R +>> +endobj +6 0 obj +<< +/Length 7 0 R +>> +stream +q +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q +1.000 1.000 1.000 rg +0.00 0.00 576.00 432.00 re f +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q 23.02 417.60 29.33 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 23.02 417.60 29.33 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q 23.02 289.63 29.33 3.60 re W n +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q 23.02 161.66 29.33 3.60 re W n +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q 23.02 37.28 29.33 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 23.02 23.02 29.33 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 23.02 23.02 29.33 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 52.34 417.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 52.34 417.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 52.34 293.23 0.00 124.37 re W n +Q q +Q q 52.34 289.63 0.00 3.60 re W n +Q q +Q q 52.34 165.26 0.00 124.37 re W n +Q q +Q q 52.34 161.66 0.00 3.60 re W n +Q q +Q q 52.34 37.28 0.00 124.37 re W n +Q q +Q q 52.34 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 52.34 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 52.34 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 52.34 417.60 494.88 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 52.34 417.60 494.88 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 52.34 293.23 494.88 124.37 re W n +Q q +Q q 52.34 289.63 494.88 3.60 re W n +Q q +Q q 52.34 165.26 494.88 124.37 re W n +Q q +Q q 52.34 161.66 494.88 3.60 re W n +Q q +Q q 52.34 37.28 494.88 124.37 re W n +Q q +Q q 52.34 37.28 494.88 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q 52.34 23.02 494.88 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 417.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 417.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 293.23 0.00 124.37 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 289.63 0.00 3.60 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 165.26 0.00 124.37 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 161.66 0.00 3.60 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 37.28 0.00 124.37 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 417.60 14.38 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 417.60 14.38 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 293.23 14.38 124.37 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 289.63 14.38 3.60 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 165.26 14.38 124.37 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 161.66 14.38 3.60 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 37.28 14.38 124.37 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 37.28 14.38 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 23.02 14.38 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 23.02 14.38 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 417.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 417.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 293.23 0.00 124.37 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 289.63 0.00 3.60 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 165.26 0.00 124.37 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 161.66 0.00 3.60 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 124.37 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 23.02 417.60 29.33 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 23.02 417.60 29.33 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q +0.498 0.498 0.498 RG +1.06 w +[] 0 d +1 J +1 j +10.00 M +48.09 319.29 m 52.34 319.29 l S +48.09 340.27 m 52.34 340.27 l S +48.09 361.26 m 52.34 361.26 l S +48.09 382.24 m 52.34 382.24 l S +48.09 403.23 m 52.34 403.23 l S +BT +0.498 0.498 0.498 rg +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 34.14 315.70 Tm (50) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 28.58 336.68 Tm (100) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 28.58 357.67 Tm (150) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 28.58 378.65 Tm (200) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 28.58 399.64 Tm (250) Tj +ET +Q q +Q q 23.02 289.63 29.33 3.60 re W n +Q q +Q q +0.498 0.498 0.498 RG +1.06 w +[] 0 d +1 J +1 j +10.00 M +48.09 170.91 m 52.34 170.91 l S +48.09 206.02 m 52.34 206.02 l S +48.09 241.14 m 52.34 241.14 l S +48.09 276.25 m 52.34 276.25 l S +BT +0.498 0.498 0.498 rg +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 39.70 167.32 Tm (0) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 39.70 202.43 Tm (5) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 34.14 237.55 Tm (10) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 34.14 272.66 Tm (15) Tj +ET +Q q +Q q 23.02 161.66 29.33 3.60 re W n +Q q +Q q +0.498 0.498 0.498 RG +1.06 w +[] 0 d +1 J +1 j +10.00 M +48.09 61.11 m 52.34 61.11 l S +48.09 80.52 m 52.34 80.52 l S +48.09 99.93 m 52.34 99.93 l S +48.09 119.34 m 52.34 119.34 l S +48.09 138.75 m 52.34 138.75 l S +BT +0.498 0.498 0.498 rg +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 28.58 57.52 Tm (200) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 28.58 76.93 Tm (400) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 28.58 96.34 Tm (600) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 28.58 115.75 Tm (800) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 23.02 135.16 Tm (1000) Tj +ET +Q q +Q q 23.02 37.28 29.33 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 23.02 23.02 29.33 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 23.02 23.02 29.33 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 52.34 417.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 52.34 417.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 52.34 293.23 0.00 124.37 re W n +Q q +Q q 52.34 289.63 0.00 3.60 re W n +Q q +Q q 52.34 165.26 0.00 124.37 re W n +Q q +Q q 52.34 161.66 0.00 3.60 re W n +Q q +Q q 52.34 37.28 0.00 124.37 re W n +Q q +Q q 52.34 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 52.34 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 52.34 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 52.34 417.60 494.88 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 52.34 417.60 494.88 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 52.34 293.23 494.88 124.37 re W n +0.898 0.898 0.898 rg +52.34 293.23 494.88 124.37 re f +0.949 0.949 0.949 RG +0.53 w +[] 0 d +1 J +1 j +10.00 M +52.34 298.31 m +547.22 298.31 l +S +52.34 308.80 m +547.22 308.80 l +S +52.34 319.29 m +547.22 319.29 l +S +52.34 329.78 m +547.22 329.78 l +S +52.34 340.27 m +547.22 340.27 l +S +52.34 350.77 m +547.22 350.77 l +S +52.34 361.26 m +547.22 361.26 l +S +52.34 371.75 m +547.22 371.75 l +S +52.34 382.24 m +547.22 382.24 l +S +52.34 392.73 m +547.22 392.73 l +S +52.34 403.23 m +547.22 403.23 l +S +52.34 413.72 m +547.22 413.72 l +S +72.29 293.23 m +72.29 417.60 l +S +97.80 293.23 m +97.80 417.60 l +S +124.16 293.23 m +124.16 417.60 l +S +150.53 293.23 m +150.53 417.60 l +S +176.04 293.23 m +176.04 417.60 l +S +202.40 293.23 m +202.40 417.60 l +S +227.92 293.23 m +227.92 417.60 l +S +254.28 293.23 m +254.28 417.60 l +S +280.65 293.23 m +280.65 417.60 l +S +304.46 293.23 m +304.46 417.60 l +S +330.82 293.23 m +330.82 417.60 l +S +356.34 293.23 m +356.34 417.60 l +S +382.70 293.23 m +382.70 417.60 l +S +408.21 293.23 m +408.21 417.60 l +S +434.58 293.23 m +434.58 417.60 l +S +460.94 293.23 m +460.94 417.60 l +S +486.46 293.23 m +486.46 417.60 l +S +512.82 293.23 m +512.82 417.60 l +S +538.33 293.23 m +538.33 417.60 l +S +1.000 1.000 1.000 RG +1.06 w +[] 0 d +52.34 319.29 m +547.22 319.29 l +S +52.34 340.27 m +547.22 340.27 l +S +52.34 361.26 m +547.22 361.26 l +S +52.34 382.24 m +547.22 382.24 l +S +52.34 403.23 m +547.22 403.23 l +S +72.29 293.23 m +72.29 417.60 l +S +150.53 293.23 m +150.53 417.60 l +S +227.92 293.23 m +227.92 417.60 l +S +304.46 293.23 m +304.46 417.60 l +S +382.70 293.23 m +382.70 417.60 l +S +460.94 293.23 m +460.94 417.60 l +S +538.33 293.23 m +538.33 417.60 l +S +0.000 0.000 0.000 RG +2.13 w +[] 0 d +0 J +1.00 M +74.84 313.82 m +75.69 316.39 l +76.54 315.39 l +77.39 312.43 l +78.24 314.75 l +79.09 316.19 l +79.94 317.02 l +80.79 318.05 l +81.64 316.65 l +82.49 316.22 l +83.34 315.54 l +84.19 316.88 l +85.04 319.44 l +85.89 318.28 l +86.74 317.26 l +87.59 320.16 l +88.44 319.34 l +89.29 313.50 l +90.15 300.34 l +91.00 316.84 l +91.85 321.45 l +92.70 321.26 l +93.55 320.96 l +94.40 318.48 l +95.25 315.40 l +96.10 315.98 l +96.95 319.20 l +97.80 320.29 l +98.65 320.70 l +99.50 320.44 l +100.35 318.46 l +101.20 315.86 l +102.05 317.63 l +102.90 321.09 l +103.75 321.11 l +104.60 321.29 l +105.45 319.58 l +106.30 316.89 l +107.15 315.56 l +108.00 316.50 l +108.86 319.96 l +109.71 320.00 l +110.56 319.85 l +111.41 319.99 l +112.26 312.09 l +113.11 314.53 l +113.96 318.02 l +S +115.66 315.07 m +116.51 313.54 l +117.36 315.36 l +118.21 314.62 l +119.06 312.61 l +119.91 312.47 l +120.76 316.37 l +121.61 318.72 l +122.46 314.54 l +123.31 314.30 l +124.16 312.79 l +125.01 311.18 l +125.86 311.69 l +126.71 313.90 l +127.56 315.07 l +128.42 315.31 l +129.27 310.18 l +130.12 315.00 l +130.97 316.47 l +131.82 319.95 l +132.67 319.68 l +133.52 320.13 l +134.37 319.22 l +135.22 320.15 l +136.07 316.83 l +136.92 315.06 l +137.77 318.69 l +138.62 318.07 l +139.47 318.41 l +140.32 317.52 l +141.17 316.97 l +142.02 314.58 l +142.87 313.80 l +143.72 317.55 l +144.57 319.75 l +145.42 319.50 l +146.27 320.46 l +147.13 318.22 l +147.98 316.16 l +148.83 315.80 l +149.68 321.02 l +150.53 321.40 l +151.38 320.63 l +152.23 319.84 l +153.08 317.90 l +153.93 314.98 l +154.78 316.32 l +155.63 321.86 l +156.48 320.14 l +157.33 318.70 l +S +159.88 313.74 m +160.73 314.99 l +161.58 316.04 l +162.43 312.99 l +163.28 312.26 l +164.13 313.50 l +164.98 312.25 l +165.84 308.80 l +166.69 310.05 l +167.54 313.58 l +168.39 311.67 l +169.24 312.15 l +170.09 311.49 l +170.94 310.51 l +171.79 308.95 l +172.64 312.40 l +173.49 314.56 l +174.34 317.99 l +175.19 315.30 l +176.04 315.35 l +176.89 313.37 l +177.74 313.02 l +178.59 310.93 l +179.44 314.89 l +180.29 312.60 l +181.14 310.87 l +181.99 311.82 l +182.84 314.15 l +183.69 311.48 l +184.55 311.62 l +185.40 316.39 l +186.25 316.64 l +187.10 315.00 l +187.95 318.05 l +188.80 314.48 l +189.65 312.43 l +190.50 313.35 l +191.35 313.60 l +192.20 309.35 l +193.05 323.93 l +193.90 318.79 l +194.75 314.48 l +195.60 315.21 l +196.45 317.31 l +197.30 324.93 l +198.15 332.79 l +199.00 330.23 l +199.85 322.31 l +200.70 322.75 l +201.55 321.96 l +202.40 315.67 l +203.26 319.46 l +204.11 321.55 l +204.96 323.25 l +205.81 321.16 l +206.66 317.40 l +207.51 317.32 l +208.36 315.70 l +209.21 317.88 l +210.06 316.97 l +210.91 320.30 l +211.76 318.87 l +212.61 318.97 l +213.46 314.58 l +214.31 316.12 l +215.16 327.16 l +216.01 332.51 l +216.86 327.36 l +217.71 325.89 l +218.56 318.84 l +219.41 314.86 l +220.26 314.58 l +221.11 328.69 l +221.97 329.79 l +222.82 329.14 l +223.67 327.25 l +224.52 317.86 l +225.37 314.76 l +226.22 315.13 l +227.07 322.19 l +227.92 317.55 l +228.77 321.58 l +229.62 322.35 l +230.47 321.02 l +231.32 315.87 l +232.17 317.97 l +233.02 319.66 l +233.87 318.56 l +234.72 317.30 l +235.57 317.55 l +236.42 319.84 l +237.27 318.66 l +238.12 316.78 l +238.97 322.81 l +239.82 316.18 l +240.67 315.40 l +241.53 315.44 l +242.38 315.77 l +243.23 312.90 l +244.08 313.21 l +244.93 316.09 l +245.78 315.48 l +246.63 320.10 l +247.48 318.28 l +248.33 313.86 l +249.18 313.25 l +250.03 315.86 l +250.88 320.44 l +251.73 317.05 l +252.58 320.85 l +253.43 319.33 l +254.28 317.87 l +S +255.98 318.47 m +256.83 323.39 l +257.68 322.97 l +258.53 318.08 l +259.38 320.74 l +260.24 315.81 l +261.09 317.58 l +261.94 317.81 l +262.79 321.15 l +263.64 328.20 l +264.49 324.28 l +265.34 316.98 l +266.19 331.13 l +267.04 336.64 l +267.89 321.37 l +268.74 315.49 l +S +270.44 333.82 m +271.29 317.07 l +272.14 311.73 l +272.99 307.96 l +S +274.69 327.85 m +275.54 348.61 l +276.39 330.39 l +277.24 319.03 l +278.09 314.07 l +278.95 312.00 l +279.80 323.42 l +280.65 329.06 l +281.50 324.17 l +282.35 313.36 l +283.20 327.18 l +284.05 322.89 l +284.90 322.83 l +285.75 329.33 l +286.60 325.40 l +287.45 328.31 l +288.30 336.53 l +289.15 324.14 l +290.00 330.85 l +290.85 330.23 l +291.70 327.62 l +S +294.25 331.83 m +295.10 365.56 l +295.95 340.44 l +296.80 352.64 l +297.66 357.38 l +298.51 342.17 l +299.36 335.76 l +300.21 333.33 l +301.06 335.98 l +301.91 333.58 l +302.76 332.43 l +303.61 331.64 l +304.46 341.26 l +305.31 332.66 l +S +307.01 320.29 m +307.86 344.74 l +308.71 327.84 l +309.56 338.58 l +310.41 327.51 l +311.26 321.00 l +312.11 323.07 l +312.96 320.10 l +313.81 330.74 l +314.66 314.73 l +315.51 327.32 l +316.37 322.91 l +317.22 327.98 l +318.07 314.47 l +318.92 325.70 l +319.77 320.41 l +320.62 317.81 l +321.47 328.22 l +322.32 319.44 l +323.17 335.92 l +324.02 321.98 l +324.87 316.18 l +325.72 304.25 l +326.57 317.22 l +327.42 317.57 l +328.27 306.38 l +329.12 315.17 l +329.97 310.17 l +330.82 313.43 l +331.67 314.54 l +332.52 314.46 l +333.37 306.63 l +334.22 312.70 l +335.08 308.37 l +335.93 307.45 l +S +345.28 375.64 m +346.13 334.41 l +S +352.93 339.42 m +353.78 360.49 l +354.64 356.53 l +355.49 353.27 l +356.34 351.97 l +357.19 342.78 l +358.04 343.52 l +358.89 356.46 l +359.74 387.40 l +360.59 379.88 l +361.44 359.10 l +362.29 388.53 l +363.14 366.63 l +363.99 396.80 l +364.84 392.75 l +365.69 377.34 l +366.54 411.95 l +367.39 379.20 l +368.24 383.16 l +369.09 381.78 l +369.94 374.16 l +370.79 370.62 l +371.64 346.21 l +372.49 344.37 l +373.35 337.74 l +374.20 334.68 l +375.05 334.91 l +S +376.75 343.18 m +377.60 337.47 l +378.45 333.46 l +379.30 341.06 l +380.15 317.66 l +381.00 331.19 l +381.85 359.94 l +382.70 340.80 l +383.55 333.36 l +384.40 355.40 l +385.25 330.78 l +386.10 330.55 l +386.95 331.47 l +387.80 370.75 l +388.65 319.49 l +389.50 339.82 l +390.35 338.51 l +391.20 342.82 l +392.06 336.86 l +392.91 337.91 l +393.76 333.40 l +394.61 344.93 l +395.46 340.32 l +396.31 343.20 l +397.16 331.72 l +398.01 333.85 l +398.86 329.55 l +399.71 330.39 l +400.56 327.36 l +S +402.26 327.03 m +403.11 334.98 l +403.96 331.43 l +404.81 323.55 l +405.66 322.51 l +406.51 328.47 l +407.36 329.70 l +408.21 329.07 l +409.06 325.21 l +409.91 322.45 l +410.77 321.68 l +411.62 318.88 l +412.47 329.00 l +413.32 335.75 l +414.17 335.10 l +415.02 331.44 l +415.87 331.10 l +416.72 326.01 l +417.57 328.34 l +418.42 334.22 l +419.27 334.21 l +420.12 333.19 l +420.97 321.64 l +421.82 320.78 l +422.67 318.10 l +423.52 321.31 l +424.37 319.80 l +425.22 323.21 l +426.07 328.61 l +426.92 326.88 l +427.77 324.20 l +428.62 322.01 l +429.48 327.64 l +430.33 332.74 l +431.18 331.58 l +432.03 329.41 l +432.88 333.87 l +433.73 326.25 l +434.58 319.24 l +435.43 319.17 l +436.28 322.68 l +437.13 320.87 l +437.98 324.34 l +438.83 328.97 l +439.68 325.27 l +440.53 320.27 l +441.38 323.17 l +442.23 324.95 l +443.08 324.32 l +443.93 322.77 l +444.78 318.00 l +445.63 319.15 l +446.48 312.72 l +447.33 315.33 l +448.18 317.61 l +449.04 321.88 l +449.89 323.08 l +450.74 324.87 l +451.59 318.05 l +452.44 315.80 l +453.29 320.84 l +S +454.99 298.88 m +455.84 335.46 l +456.69 345.26 l +457.54 339.22 l +458.39 352.78 l +459.24 344.88 l +460.09 338.44 l +460.94 339.16 l +S +462.64 320.89 m +463.49 330.83 l +464.34 320.12 l +465.19 338.90 l +466.04 335.93 l +466.89 328.17 l +S +469.45 332.07 m +470.30 356.41 l +471.15 363.37 l +472.00 367.49 l +472.85 371.66 l +S +474.55 307.14 m +475.40 336.99 l +476.25 342.88 l +477.10 350.02 l +477.95 349.54 l +S +482.20 301.11 m +483.05 304.54 l +483.90 305.82 l +484.75 305.90 l +485.60 307.04 l +S +487.31 303.90 m +488.16 305.63 l +489.01 306.33 l +489.86 317.64 l +490.71 329.77 l +491.56 362.88 l +492.41 354.48 l +493.26 348.47 l +494.11 342.08 l +494.96 342.97 l +495.81 354.11 l +496.66 354.59 l +497.51 354.84 l +498.36 347.78 l +499.21 322.39 l +500.06 320.31 l +500.91 320.24 l +501.76 330.28 l +502.61 330.99 l +503.46 339.18 l +504.31 327.00 l +505.17 323.98 l +506.02 314.06 l +506.87 314.11 l +507.72 317.61 l +508.57 319.77 l +509.42 319.05 l +510.27 319.36 l +511.12 317.17 l +511.97 316.09 l +512.82 317.89 l +513.67 322.71 l +514.52 330.18 l +515.37 331.93 l +516.22 330.45 l +517.07 323.22 l +517.92 320.45 l +518.77 319.09 l +519.62 322.81 l +520.47 323.94 l +521.32 343.80 l +522.17 349.17 l +523.02 349.93 l +523.88 331.62 l +524.73 320.98 l +S +1.06 w +[ 3.19 5.31] 0 d +10.00 M +158.18 293.23 m 158.18 417.60 l S +386.95 293.23 m 386.95 417.60 l S +Q q +Q q 52.34 289.63 494.88 3.60 re W n +Q q +Q q 52.34 165.26 494.88 124.37 re W n +0.898 0.898 0.898 rg +52.34 165.26 494.88 124.37 re f +0.949 0.949 0.949 RG +0.53 w +[] 0 d +1 J +1 j +10.00 M +52.34 170.91 m +547.22 170.91 l +S +52.34 188.47 m +547.22 188.47 l +S +52.34 206.02 m +547.22 206.02 l +S +52.34 223.58 m +547.22 223.58 l +S +52.34 241.14 m +547.22 241.14 l +S +52.34 258.69 m +547.22 258.69 l +S +52.34 276.25 m +547.22 276.25 l +S +72.29 165.26 m +72.29 289.63 l +S +97.80 165.26 m +97.80 289.63 l +S +124.16 165.26 m +124.16 289.63 l +S +150.53 165.26 m +150.53 289.63 l +S +176.04 165.26 m +176.04 289.63 l +S +202.40 165.26 m +202.40 289.63 l +S +227.92 165.26 m +227.92 289.63 l +S +254.28 165.26 m +254.28 289.63 l +S +280.65 165.26 m +280.65 289.63 l +S +304.46 165.26 m +304.46 289.63 l +S +330.82 165.26 m +330.82 289.63 l +S +356.34 165.26 m +356.34 289.63 l +S +382.70 165.26 m +382.70 289.63 l +S +408.21 165.26 m +408.21 289.63 l +S +434.58 165.26 m +434.58 289.63 l +S +460.94 165.26 m +460.94 289.63 l +S +486.46 165.26 m +486.46 289.63 l +S +512.82 165.26 m +512.82 289.63 l +S +538.33 165.26 m +538.33 289.63 l +S +1.000 1.000 1.000 RG +1.06 w +[] 0 d +52.34 170.91 m +547.22 170.91 l +S +52.34 206.02 m +547.22 206.02 l +S +52.34 241.14 m +547.22 241.14 l +S +52.34 276.25 m +547.22 276.25 l +S +72.29 165.26 m +72.29 289.63 l +S +150.53 165.26 m +150.53 289.63 l +S +227.92 165.26 m +227.92 289.63 l +S +304.46 165.26 m +304.46 289.63 l +S +382.70 165.26 m +382.70 289.63 l +S +460.94 165.26 m +460.94 289.63 l +S +538.33 165.26 m +538.33 289.63 l +S +0.000 0.000 0.000 RG +2.13 w +[] 0 d +0 J +1.00 M +74.84 198.44 m +75.69 198.58 l +76.54 197.88 l +77.39 196.12 l +78.24 198.37 l +79.09 194.57 l +79.94 198.37 l +80.79 194.72 l +81.64 197.88 l +82.49 197.31 l +83.34 199.91 l +84.19 202.72 l +85.04 200.97 l +85.89 199.28 l +86.74 198.02 l +87.59 200.75 l +88.44 198.86 l +89.29 253.21 l +90.15 197.81 l +91.00 200.54 l +91.85 198.72 l +92.70 198.23 l +93.55 197.10 l +94.40 196.68 l +95.25 195.70 l +96.10 195.49 l +96.95 197.38 l +97.80 196.75 l +98.65 198.30 l +99.50 197.52 l +100.35 196.33 l +101.20 198.09 l +102.05 199.00 l +102.90 198.09 l +103.75 195.14 l +104.60 194.57 l +105.45 191.63 l +106.30 196.40 l +107.15 191.41 l +108.00 192.89 l +108.86 196.89 l +109.71 197.38 l +110.56 196.96 l +111.41 188.68 l +112.26 189.59 l +113.11 198.79 l +113.96 190.15 l +S +115.66 191.27 m +116.51 192.33 l +117.36 194.22 l +118.21 195.07 l +119.06 194.43 l +119.91 192.54 l +120.76 192.96 l +121.61 194.72 l +122.46 191.48 l +123.31 191.48 l +124.16 191.63 l +125.01 190.92 l +125.86 190.71 l +126.71 191.48 l +127.56 192.68 l +128.42 193.17 l +129.27 185.52 l +130.12 197.31 l +130.97 198.02 l +131.82 196.33 l +132.67 196.12 l +133.52 196.12 l +134.37 195.21 l +135.22 196.54 l +136.07 195.70 l +136.92 193.80 l +137.77 194.93 l +138.62 192.54 l +139.47 191.98 l +140.32 192.75 l +141.17 192.61 l +142.02 192.19 l +142.87 192.19 l +143.72 193.10 l +144.57 194.22 l +145.42 194.36 l +146.27 194.08 l +147.13 192.89 l +147.98 193.52 l +148.83 194.08 l +149.68 196.40 l +150.53 195.14 l +151.38 194.15 l +152.23 194.15 l +153.08 192.33 l +153.93 191.56 l +154.78 193.73 l +155.63 196.40 l +156.48 193.38 l +157.33 191.98 l +S +159.88 189.31 m +160.73 192.26 l +161.58 186.57 l +162.43 179.83 l +163.28 178.91 l +164.13 180.60 l +164.98 180.53 l +165.84 179.90 l +166.69 180.95 l +167.54 184.46 l +168.39 178.70 l +169.24 180.39 l +170.09 178.84 l +170.94 180.18 l +171.79 181.02 l +172.64 182.57 l +173.49 182.07 l +174.34 181.79 l +175.19 183.06 l +176.04 185.09 l +176.89 182.64 l +177.74 185.16 l +178.59 183.20 l +179.44 187.27 l +180.29 180.95 l +181.14 179.05 l +181.99 179.83 l +182.84 184.60 l +183.69 183.48 l +184.55 184.25 l +185.40 185.59 l +186.25 183.06 l +187.10 181.37 l +187.95 182.92 l +188.80 180.25 l +189.65 181.86 l +190.50 182.43 l +191.35 179.90 l +192.20 184.32 l +193.05 191.91 l +193.90 182.71 l +194.75 180.11 l +195.60 184.32 l +196.45 184.18 l +197.30 193.87 l +198.15 201.46 l +199.00 196.47 l +199.85 181.16 l +200.70 183.13 l +201.55 191.70 l +202.40 179.97 l +203.26 181.23 l +204.11 180.74 l +204.96 186.43 l +205.81 182.85 l +206.66 181.58 l +207.51 183.83 l +208.36 181.23 l +209.21 179.55 l +210.06 179.48 l +210.91 182.36 l +211.76 181.37 l +212.61 182.00 l +213.46 181.65 l +214.31 180.88 l +215.16 194.01 l +216.01 200.47 l +216.86 195.63 l +217.71 195.35 l +218.56 184.18 l +219.41 182.85 l +220.26 180.32 l +221.11 196.47 l +221.97 197.31 l +222.82 197.95 l +223.67 194.29 l +224.52 181.37 l +225.37 181.44 l +226.22 181.16 l +227.07 186.01 l +227.92 180.32 l +228.77 186.01 l +229.62 186.99 l +230.47 184.74 l +231.32 183.76 l +232.17 185.66 l +233.02 182.64 l +233.87 180.95 l +234.72 180.74 l +235.57 182.43 l +236.42 183.76 l +237.27 187.34 l +238.12 184.74 l +238.97 189.10 l +239.82 180.18 l +240.67 181.51 l +241.53 180.67 l +242.38 181.58 l +243.23 181.51 l +244.08 182.57 l +244.93 181.79 l +245.78 180.67 l +246.63 187.13 l +247.48 186.99 l +248.33 187.13 l +249.18 184.74 l +250.03 189.66 l +250.88 189.52 l +251.73 184.39 l +252.58 189.66 l +253.43 189.38 l +254.28 192.26 l +S +255.98 189.87 m +256.83 189.24 l +257.68 189.87 l +258.53 188.82 l +259.38 188.61 l +260.24 182.00 l +261.09 189.52 l +261.94 186.71 l +262.79 187.97 l +263.64 198.30 l +264.49 194.50 l +265.34 183.83 l +266.19 197.95 l +267.04 222.81 l +267.89 192.54 l +268.74 182.21 l +S +270.44 198.02 m +271.29 179.20 l +272.14 177.44 l +272.99 176.88 l +S +274.69 187.62 m +275.54 203.49 l +276.39 196.89 l +277.24 183.20 l +278.09 179.48 l +278.95 181.23 l +279.80 195.91 l +280.65 197.66 l +281.50 188.96 l +282.35 178.21 l +283.20 198.79 l +284.05 190.57 l +284.90 195.98 l +285.75 202.30 l +286.60 195.35 l +287.45 194.57 l +288.30 206.51 l +289.15 192.12 l +290.00 203.07 l +290.85 205.74 l +291.70 202.86 l +S +294.25 209.25 m +295.10 246.19 l +295.95 205.32 l +296.80 233.06 l +297.66 239.87 l +298.51 210.59 l +299.36 199.28 l +300.21 199.63 l +301.06 204.06 l +301.91 201.39 l +302.76 206.65 l +303.61 206.37 l +304.46 222.24 l +305.31 202.09 l +S +307.01 191.20 m +307.86 211.22 l +308.71 196.19 l +309.56 218.80 l +310.41 195.84 l +311.26 186.29 l +312.11 188.18 l +312.96 183.83 l +313.81 201.04 l +314.66 182.99 l +315.51 202.58 l +316.37 192.26 l +317.22 200.33 l +318.07 178.63 l +318.92 192.68 l +319.77 187.20 l +320.62 186.85 l +321.47 199.70 l +322.32 190.15 l +323.17 205.95 l +324.02 190.85 l +324.87 183.27 l +325.72 174.56 l +326.57 191.41 l +327.42 188.39 l +328.27 175.05 l +329.12 185.73 l +329.97 178.28 l +330.82 184.04 l +331.67 184.11 l +332.52 186.78 l +333.37 177.23 l +334.22 182.57 l +335.08 176.46 l +335.93 176.74 l +S +345.28 252.09 m +346.13 186.01 l +S +352.93 207.22 m +353.78 234.74 l +354.64 222.03 l +355.49 213.68 l +356.34 214.52 l +357.19 202.02 l +358.04 197.31 l +358.89 209.32 l +359.74 264.87 l +360.59 223.65 l +361.44 179.55 l +362.29 257.99 l +363.14 228.28 l +363.99 245.56 l +364.84 265.93 l +365.69 237.76 l +366.54 283.97 l +367.39 234.82 l +368.24 253.36 l +369.09 254.69 l +369.94 234.67 l +370.79 236.71 l +371.64 206.23 l +372.49 211.57 l +373.35 211.22 l +374.20 208.55 l +375.05 209.18 l +S +376.75 202.72 m +377.60 191.13 l +378.45 176.60 l +379.30 177.16 l +380.15 170.91 l +381.00 170.91 l +381.85 170.91 l +382.70 180.32 l +383.55 186.29 l +384.40 172.31 l +385.25 171.12 l +386.10 174.84 l +386.95 170.91 l +387.80 170.91 l +388.65 170.91 l +389.50 170.91 l +390.35 170.91 l +391.20 170.91 l +392.06 170.91 l +392.91 170.91 l +393.76 170.91 l +394.61 170.91 l +395.46 170.91 l +396.31 170.91 l +397.16 170.91 l +398.01 170.91 l +398.86 170.91 l +399.71 170.91 l +400.56 170.91 l +S +402.26 181.37 m +403.11 183.41 l +403.96 183.27 l +404.81 178.28 l +405.66 177.02 l +406.51 179.48 l +407.36 181.79 l +408.21 181.79 l +409.06 180.67 l +409.91 180.11 l +410.77 180.67 l +411.62 179.90 l +412.47 182.43 l +413.32 184.95 l +414.17 185.80 l +415.02 184.46 l +415.87 185.52 l +416.72 184.53 l +417.57 184.67 l +418.42 183.27 l +419.27 180.60 l +420.12 179.83 l +420.97 176.32 l +421.82 177.23 l +422.67 176.88 l +423.52 178.49 l +424.37 176.25 l +425.22 177.86 l +426.07 180.39 l +426.92 180.46 l +427.77 179.12 l +428.62 178.98 l +429.48 182.29 l +430.33 182.92 l +431.18 180.39 l +432.03 180.46 l +432.88 182.99 l +433.73 181.09 l +434.58 178.91 l +435.43 179.34 l +436.28 177.86 l +437.13 178.42 l +437.98 180.81 l +438.83 180.60 l +439.68 180.11 l +440.53 179.27 l +441.38 179.41 l +442.23 178.77 l +443.08 178.21 l +443.93 179.20 l +444.78 177.23 l +445.63 179.34 l +446.48 176.18 l +447.33 177.09 l +448.18 176.74 l +449.04 178.77 l +449.89 180.25 l +450.74 181.37 l +451.59 177.09 l +452.44 176.32 l +453.29 187.69 l +S +454.99 170.91 m +455.84 183.97 l +456.69 180.18 l +457.54 180.11 l +458.39 186.99 l +459.24 176.60 l +460.09 176.95 l +460.94 179.41 l +S +462.64 170.91 m +463.49 172.03 l +464.34 171.05 l +465.19 171.54 l +466.04 170.98 l +466.89 170.91 l +S +469.45 207.57 m +470.30 228.00 l +471.15 226.04 l +472.00 212.48 l +472.85 224.00 l +S +474.55 173.65 m +475.40 210.45 l +476.25 214.66 l +477.10 216.63 l +477.95 217.75 l +S +482.20 172.59 m +483.05 177.09 l +483.90 175.47 l +484.75 173.93 l +485.60 176.95 l +S +487.31 174.07 m +488.16 175.40 l +489.01 176.88 l +489.86 184.81 l +490.71 200.97 l +491.56 231.09 l +492.41 207.78 l +493.26 204.90 l +494.11 203.56 l +494.96 203.21 l +495.81 207.92 l +496.66 203.14 l +497.51 205.32 l +498.36 195.14 l +499.21 170.91 l +500.06 170.91 l +500.91 170.91 l +501.76 170.91 l +502.61 170.91 l +503.46 170.91 l +504.31 170.91 l +505.17 173.93 l +506.02 178.49 l +506.87 178.77 l +507.72 179.76 l +508.57 180.25 l +509.42 180.32 l +510.27 181.51 l +511.12 179.62 l +511.97 180.46 l +512.82 180.67 l +513.67 181.93 l +514.52 183.76 l +515.37 185.02 l +516.22 184.46 l +517.07 182.21 l +517.92 183.41 l +518.77 182.43 l +519.62 182.43 l +520.47 182.78 l +521.32 183.55 l +522.17 183.20 l +523.02 184.25 l +523.88 188.25 l +524.73 182.50 l +S +1.06 w +[ 3.19 5.31] 0 d +10.00 M +158.18 165.26 m 158.18 289.63 l S +386.95 165.26 m 386.95 289.63 l S +Q q +Q q 52.34 161.66 494.88 3.60 re W n +Q q +Q q 52.34 37.28 494.88 124.37 re W n +0.898 0.898 0.898 rg +52.34 37.28 494.88 124.37 re f +0.949 0.949 0.949 RG +0.53 w +[] 0 d +1 J +1 j +10.00 M +52.34 41.71 m +547.22 41.71 l +S +52.34 51.41 m +547.22 51.41 l +S +52.34 61.11 m +547.22 61.11 l +S +52.34 70.82 m +547.22 70.82 l +S +52.34 80.52 m +547.22 80.52 l +S +52.34 90.23 m +547.22 90.23 l +S +52.34 99.93 m +547.22 99.93 l +S +52.34 109.64 m +547.22 109.64 l +S +52.34 119.34 m +547.22 119.34 l +S +52.34 129.04 m +547.22 129.04 l +S +52.34 138.75 m +547.22 138.75 l +S +52.34 148.45 m +547.22 148.45 l +S +52.34 158.16 m +547.22 158.16 l +S +72.29 37.28 m +72.29 161.66 l +S +97.80 37.28 m +97.80 161.66 l +S +124.16 37.28 m +124.16 161.66 l +S +150.53 37.28 m +150.53 161.66 l +S +176.04 37.28 m +176.04 161.66 l +S +202.40 37.28 m +202.40 161.66 l +S +227.92 37.28 m +227.92 161.66 l +S +254.28 37.28 m +254.28 161.66 l +S +280.65 37.28 m +280.65 161.66 l +S +304.46 37.28 m +304.46 161.66 l +S +330.82 37.28 m +330.82 161.66 l +S +356.34 37.28 m +356.34 161.66 l +S +382.70 37.28 m +382.70 161.66 l +S +408.21 37.28 m +408.21 161.66 l +S +434.58 37.28 m +434.58 161.66 l +S +460.94 37.28 m +460.94 161.66 l +S +486.46 37.28 m +486.46 161.66 l +S +512.82 37.28 m +512.82 161.66 l +S +538.33 37.28 m +538.33 161.66 l +S +1.000 1.000 1.000 RG +1.06 w +[] 0 d +52.34 61.11 m +547.22 61.11 l +S +52.34 80.52 m +547.22 80.52 l +S +52.34 99.93 m +547.22 99.93 l +S +52.34 119.34 m +547.22 119.34 l +S +52.34 138.75 m +547.22 138.75 l +S +72.29 37.28 m +72.29 161.66 l +S +150.53 37.28 m +150.53 161.66 l +S +227.92 37.28 m +227.92 161.66 l +S +304.46 37.28 m +304.46 161.66 l +S +382.70 37.28 m +382.70 161.66 l +S +460.94 37.28 m +460.94 161.66 l +S +538.33 37.28 m +538.33 161.66 l +S +0.000 0.000 0.000 RG +2.13 w +[] 0 d +0 J +1.00 M +74.84 50.86 m +75.69 52.32 l +76.54 51.99 l +77.39 50.80 l +78.24 51.43 l +79.09 53.98 l +79.94 52.77 l +80.79 55.17 l +81.64 52.75 l +82.49 52.72 l +83.34 51.35 l +84.19 51.19 l +85.04 53.12 l +85.89 53.14 l +86.74 53.06 l +87.59 53.60 l +88.44 53.93 l +89.29 44.70 l +90.15 42.94 l +91.00 51.86 l +91.85 55.22 l +92.70 55.35 l +93.55 55.75 l +94.40 54.42 l +95.25 52.90 l +96.10 53.38 l +96.95 54.52 l +97.80 55.52 l +98.65 54.98 l +99.50 55.21 l +100.35 54.58 l +101.20 52.20 l +102.05 52.88 l +102.90 55.32 l +103.75 56.99 l +104.60 57.47 l +105.45 58.38 l +106.30 53.55 l +107.15 55.37 l +108.00 55.15 l +108.86 55.24 l +109.71 55.01 l +110.56 55.13 l +111.41 61.52 l +112.26 53.68 l +113.11 51.16 l +113.96 58.34 l +S +115.66 55.07 m +116.51 53.26 l +117.36 53.58 l +118.21 52.67 l +119.06 51.58 l +119.91 52.34 l +120.76 55.01 l +121.61 55.63 l +122.46 54.52 l +123.31 54.33 l +124.16 53.06 l +125.01 52.15 l +125.86 52.68 l +126.71 54.01 l +127.56 54.21 l +128.42 54.11 l +129.27 54.90 l +130.12 51.97 l +130.97 52.59 l +131.82 55.53 l +132.67 55.47 l +133.52 55.76 l +134.37 55.68 l +135.22 55.54 l +136.07 53.84 l +136.92 53.59 l +137.77 55.49 l +138.62 56.54 l +139.47 57.20 l +140.32 55.99 l +141.17 55.67 l +142.02 54.12 l +142.87 53.53 l +143.72 55.78 l +144.57 56.64 l +145.42 56.38 l +146.27 57.23 l +147.13 56.42 l +147.98 54.53 l +148.83 53.96 l +149.68 56.18 l +150.53 57.19 l +151.38 57.30 l +152.23 56.75 l +153.08 56.56 l +153.93 54.82 l +154.78 54.52 l +155.63 56.71 l +156.48 57.48 l +157.33 57.42 l +S +159.88 55.32 m +160.73 54.40 l +161.58 60.10 l +162.43 68.43 l +163.28 70.01 l +164.13 67.17 l +164.98 65.25 l +165.84 60.66 l +166.69 60.69 l +167.54 60.00 l +168.39 69.54 l +169.24 65.42 l +170.09 68.68 l +170.94 63.09 l +171.79 58.80 l +172.64 61.33 l +173.49 65.34 l +174.34 71.06 l +175.19 64.42 l +176.04 61.22 l +176.89 62.56 l +177.74 58.46 l +178.59 58.38 l +179.44 58.17 l +180.29 64.82 l +181.14 66.75 l +181.99 66.31 l +182.84 60.49 l +183.69 58.72 l +184.55 57.90 l +185.40 61.71 l +186.25 66.21 l +187.10 67.62 l +187.95 68.41 l +188.80 69.83 l +189.65 62.63 l +190.50 62.92 l +191.35 69.33 l +192.20 55.07 l +193.05 61.52 l +193.90 69.90 l +194.75 70.26 l +195.60 62.17 l +196.45 64.95 l +197.30 60.53 l +198.15 60.04 l +199.00 61.98 l +199.85 79.72 l +200.70 74.18 l +201.55 60.19 l +202.40 72.83 l +203.26 74.98 l +204.11 80.10 l +204.96 67.80 l +205.81 72.79 l +206.66 70.76 l +207.51 65.61 l +208.36 69.07 l +209.21 78.50 l +210.06 77.08 l +210.91 72.90 l +211.76 73.62 l +212.61 71.94 l +213.46 66.30 l +214.31 70.71 l +215.16 61.98 l +216.01 60.49 l +216.86 60.79 l +217.71 60.03 l +218.56 66.83 l +219.41 64.22 l +220.26 69.79 l +221.11 61.00 l +221.97 61.07 l +222.82 60.22 l +223.67 61.80 l +224.52 72.05 l +225.37 67.07 l +226.22 68.35 l +227.07 67.39 l +227.92 74.92 l +228.77 66.73 l +229.62 65.98 l +230.47 68.36 l +231.32 63.90 l +232.17 63.36 l +233.02 71.27 l +233.87 74.45 l +234.72 73.08 l +235.57 68.84 l +236.42 68.92 l +237.27 61.81 l +238.12 63.39 l +238.97 63.58 l +239.82 73.01 l +240.67 67.88 l +241.53 70.21 l +242.38 68.27 l +243.23 64.05 l +244.08 62.46 l +244.93 68.24 l +245.78 70.27 l +246.63 63.52 l +247.48 61.88 l +248.33 57.27 l +249.18 59.25 l +250.03 56.91 l +250.88 61.02 l +251.73 64.28 l +252.58 61.23 l +253.43 60.19 l +254.28 56.58 l +S +255.98 58.97 m +256.83 63.93 l +257.68 62.83 l +258.53 59.64 l +259.38 62.29 l +260.24 67.32 l +261.09 58.52 l +261.94 61.75 l +262.79 63.44 l +263.64 59.43 l +264.49 59.58 l +265.34 65.18 l +266.19 61.42 l +267.04 53.70 l +267.89 59.02 l +268.74 66.38 l +S +270.44 62.98 m +271.29 78.47 l +S +274.69 70.41 m +275.54 66.77 l +276.39 61.75 l +277.24 69.08 l +278.09 71.59 l +278.95 63.25 l +279.80 58.02 l +280.65 60.37 l +281.50 64.97 l +282.35 75.19 l +283.20 58.52 l +284.05 62.01 l +284.90 57.59 l +285.75 57.76 l +286.60 59.71 l +287.45 62.29 l +288.30 59.14 l +289.15 61.49 l +290.00 58.14 l +290.85 56.59 l +291.70 56.60 l +S +294.25 55.90 m +295.10 56.21 l +295.95 61.59 l +296.80 55.90 l +297.66 55.62 l +298.51 59.66 l +299.36 63.14 l +300.21 61.51 l +301.06 60.16 l +301.91 60.50 l +302.76 57.21 l +303.61 56.97 l +304.46 55.29 l +305.31 59.60 l +S +307.01 59.29 m +307.86 60.41 l +308.71 60.67 l +309.56 55.36 l +310.41 60.73 l +311.26 65.67 l +312.11 64.98 l +312.96 69.10 l +313.81 59.19 l +314.66 63.78 l +315.51 56.58 l +316.37 60.42 l +317.22 58.08 l +318.07 75.68 l +318.92 62.14 l +319.77 63.73 l +320.62 61.58 l +321.47 58.58 l +322.32 59.54 l +323.17 59.13 l +324.02 60.98 l +324.87 65.19 l +S +326.57 56.68 m +327.42 59.59 l +S +329.12 60.19 m +329.97 67.82 l +330.82 60.40 l +331.67 61.68 l +332.52 58.23 l +S +345.28 57.17 m +346.13 80.54 l +S +352.93 60.09 m +353.78 57.52 l +354.64 60.20 l +355.49 62.57 l +356.34 61.69 l +357.19 64.92 l +358.04 69.51 l +358.89 66.29 l +359.74 57.10 l +360.59 66.82 l +361.44 156.00 l +362.29 58.53 l +363.14 61.04 l +363.99 63.13 l +364.84 57.85 l +365.69 60.90 l +366.54 58.03 l +367.39 62.26 l +368.24 58.42 l +369.09 57.88 l +369.94 61.02 l +370.79 59.55 l +371.64 63.73 l +372.49 60.10 l +373.35 57.59 l +374.20 57.40 l +375.05 57.24 l +S +376.75 64.61 m +377.60 73.15 l +S +382.70 115.04 m +383.55 78.71 l +S +402.26 86.29 m +403.11 89.35 l +403.96 85.22 l +404.81 97.30 l +S +406.51 98.88 m +407.36 88.54 l +408.21 87.60 l +409.06 86.46 l +409.91 84.33 l +410.77 80.59 l +411.62 78.87 l +412.47 84.98 l +413.32 85.00 l +414.17 81.84 l +415.02 81.40 l +415.87 78.16 l +416.72 74.73 l +417.57 77.14 l +418.42 88.89 l +419.27 101.86 l +420.12 105.21 l +S +426.07 93.61 m +426.92 90.28 l +427.77 92.88 l +428.62 89.36 l +429.48 83.58 l +430.33 88.26 l +431.18 98.69 l +432.03 94.58 l +432.88 89.52 l +433.73 86.27 l +434.58 84.16 l +435.43 81.91 l +S +437.13 90.47 m +437.98 84.39 l +438.83 93.08 l +439.68 89.30 l +440.53 84.38 l +441.38 89.22 l +442.23 96.72 l +443.08 99.54 l +443.93 89.63 l +S +449.04 90.38 m +449.89 84.78 l +450.74 82.92 l +S +455.84 87.90 m +456.69 123.95 l +457.54 113.93 l +458.39 96.71 l +S +469.45 56.66 m +470.30 58.23 l +471.15 60.87 l +472.00 68.73 l +472.85 64.14 l +S +475.40 57.60 m +476.25 58.25 l +477.10 60.07 l +477.95 59.47 l +S +489.86 64.28 m +490.71 58.71 l +491.56 59.13 l +492.41 66.45 l +493.26 65.67 l +494.11 63.47 l +494.96 64.15 l +495.81 66.19 l +496.66 70.06 l +497.51 68.38 l +498.36 74.86 l +S +506.02 75.43 m +506.87 74.34 l +507.72 77.13 l +508.57 79.03 l +509.42 77.50 l +510.27 73.95 l +511.12 76.88 l +511.97 71.94 l +512.82 74.28 l +513.67 77.65 l +514.52 81.98 l +515.37 80.39 l +516.22 80.21 l +517.07 77.48 l +517.92 70.47 l +518.77 71.00 l +519.62 76.25 l +520.47 76.78 l +521.32 100.15 l +522.17 108.92 l +523.02 104.54 l +523.88 72.89 l +524.73 73.48 l +S +1.06 w +[ 3.19 5.31] 0 d +10.00 M +158.18 37.28 m 158.18 161.66 l S +386.95 37.28 m 386.95 161.66 l S +/GS257 gs +0.400 0.400 0.400 rg + 357.19 156.00 m + 357.19 158.34 359.10 160.25 361.44 160.25 c + 363.78 160.25 365.69 158.34 365.69 156.00 c + 365.69 153.66 363.78 151.75 361.44 151.75 c + 359.10 151.75 357.19 153.66 357.19 156.00 c +f + 452.44 123.95 m + 452.44 126.29 454.35 128.21 456.69 128.21 c + 459.03 128.21 460.94 126.29 460.94 123.95 c + 460.94 121.62 459.03 119.70 456.69 119.70 c + 454.35 119.70 452.44 121.62 452.44 123.95 c +f +Q q +Q q 52.34 37.28 494.88 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q +/GS1 gs +0.498 0.498 0.498 RG +1.06 w +[] 0 d +1 J +1 j +10.00 M +72.29 33.03 m 72.29 37.28 l S +150.53 33.03 m 150.53 37.28 l S +227.92 33.03 m 227.92 37.28 l S +304.46 33.03 m 304.46 37.28 l S +382.70 33.03 m 382.70 37.28 l S +460.94 33.03 m 460.94 37.28 l S +538.33 33.03 m 538.33 37.28 l S +BT +/GS258 gs +0.498 0.498 0.498 rg +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 55.85 23.02 Tm [(J) 20 (un-09)] TJ +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 133.15 23.02 Tm (Sep-09) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 210.55 23.02 Tm (Dec-09) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 287.37 23.02 Tm (Mar-10) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 366.26 23.02 Tm [(J) 20 (un-10)] TJ +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 443.57 23.02 Tm (Sep-10) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 520.96 23.02 Tm (Dec-10) Tj +ET +Q q +Q q 52.34 23.02 494.88 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 417.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 417.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 293.23 0.00 124.37 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 289.63 0.00 3.60 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 165.26 0.00 124.37 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 161.66 0.00 3.60 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 37.28 0.00 124.37 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 417.60 14.38 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 417.60 14.38 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 293.23 14.38 124.37 re W n +/GS258 gs +0.800 0.800 0.800 rg +547.22 293.23 14.38 124.37 re f +BT +/GS258 gs +0.000 0.000 0.000 rg +/F2 1 Tf 0.00 -10.00 10.00 0.00 550.82 409.60 Tm (Requests $in thousands$) Tj +ET +Q q +Q q 547.22 289.63 14.38 3.60 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 165.26 14.38 124.37 re W n +/GS258 gs +0.800 0.800 0.800 rg +547.22 165.26 14.38 124.37 re f +BT +/GS258 gs +0.000 0.000 0.000 rg +/F2 1 Tf 0.00 -10.00 10.00 0.00 550.82 267.46 Tm (Share $in percent$) Tj +ET +Q q +Q q 547.22 161.66 14.38 3.60 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 37.28 14.38 124.37 re W n +/GS258 gs +0.800 0.800 0.800 rg +547.22 37.28 14.38 124.37 re f +BT +/GS258 gs +0.000 0.000 0.000 rg +/F2 1 Tf 0.00 -10.00 10.00 0.00 550.82 157.26 Tm (Daily users $in thousands$) Tj +ET +Q q +Q q 547.22 37.28 14.38 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 23.02 14.38 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 547.22 23.02 14.38 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 417.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 417.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 293.23 0.00 124.37 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 289.63 0.00 3.60 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 165.26 0.00 124.37 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 161.66 0.00 3.60 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 124.37 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q +endstream +endobj +7 0 obj +34859 +endobj +3 0 obj +<< +/Type /Pages +/Kids [ +5 0 R +] +/Count 1 +/MediaBox [0 0 576 432] +>> +endobj +4 0 obj +<< +/ProcSet [/PDF /Text] +/Font <</F2 9 0 R >> +/ExtGState << /GS1 10 0 R /GS257 11 0 R /GS258 12 0 R >> +>> +endobj +8 0 obj +<< +/Type /Encoding +/BaseEncoding /WinAnsiEncoding +/Differences [ 45/minus 96/quoteleft +144/dotlessi /grave /acute /circumflex /tilde /macron /breve /dotaccent +/dieresis /.notdef /ring /cedilla /.notdef /hungarumlaut /ogonek /caron /space] +>> +endobj +9 0 obj << +/Type /Font +/Subtype /Type1 +/Name /F2 +/BaseFont /Helvetica +/Encoding 8 0 R +>> endobj +10 0 obj +<< +/Type /ExtGState +/CA 1.000 >> +endobj +11 0 obj +<< +/Type /ExtGState +/ca 0.502 +>> +endobj +12 0 obj +<< +/Type /ExtGState +/ca 1.000 +>> +endobj +xref +0 13 +0000000000 65535 f +0000000021 00000 n +0000000164 00000 n +0000035226 00000 n +0000035309 00000 n +0000000213 00000 n +0000000293 00000 n +0000035205 00000 n +0000035430 00000 n +0000035687 00000 n +0000035783 00000 n +0000035832 00000 n +0000035881 00000 n +trailer +<< +/Size 13 +/Info 1 0 R +/Root 2 0 R +>> +startxref +35930 +%%EOF diff --git a/task-2647/trusted.pdf b/task-2647/trusted.pdf new file mode 100644 index 0000000..6097dd9 --- /dev/null +++ b/task-2647/trusted.pdf @@ -0,0 +1,912 @@ +%PDF-1.4 +%âãÏÓ\r +1 0 obj +<< +/CreationDate (D:20101116125847) +/ModDate (D:20101116125847) +/Title (R Graphics Output) +/Producer (R 2.10.0) +/Creator (R) +>> +endobj +2 0 obj +<< +/Type /Catalog +/Pages 3 0 R +>> +endobj +5 0 obj +<< +/Type /Page +/Parent 3 0 R +/Contents 6 0 R +/Resources 4 0 R +>> +endobj +6 0 obj +<< +/Length 7 0 R +>> +stream +q +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q +1.000 1.000 1.000 rg +0.00 0.00 576.00 324.00 re f +Q q +Q q +Q q +BT +0.000 0.000 0.000 rg +/F2 1 Tf 0.00 12.00 -12.00 0.00 19.42 96.95 Tm (Daily users $in thousands$) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 0.00 12.00 -12.00 0.00 35.26 166.31 Tm () Tj +ET +Q q +Q q 38.86 309.60 29.33 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 309.60 29.33 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q 38.86 37.28 29.33 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 23.02 29.33 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 23.02 29.33 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 309.60 493.42 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 309.60 493.42 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 37.28 493.42 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 37.28 493.42 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q q 68.18 23.02 493.42 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 309.60 29.33 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 309.60 29.33 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q +0.498 0.498 0.498 RG +1.06 w +[] 0 d +1 J +1 j +10.00 M +63.93 49.66 m 68.18 49.66 l S +63.93 91.70 m 68.18 91.70 l S +63.93 133.74 m 68.18 133.74 l S +63.93 175.78 m 68.18 175.78 l S +63.93 217.81 m 68.18 217.81 l S +63.93 259.85 m 68.18 259.85 l S +BT +0.498 0.498 0.498 rg +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 55.54 46.07 Tm (0) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 44.42 88.11 Tm (200) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 44.42 130.15 Tm (400) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 44.42 172.19 Tm (600) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 44.42 214.22 Tm (800) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 38.86 256.26 Tm (1000) Tj +ET +Q q +Q q 38.86 37.28 29.33 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 23.02 29.33 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 38.86 23.02 29.33 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 309.60 493.42 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 309.60 493.42 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 68.18 37.28 493.42 272.32 re W n +0.898 0.898 0.898 rg +68.18 37.28 493.42 272.32 re f +0.949 0.949 0.949 RG +0.53 w +[] 0 d +1 J +1 j +10.00 M +68.18 49.66 m +561.60 49.66 l +S +68.18 70.68 m +561.60 70.68 l +S +68.18 91.70 m +561.60 91.70 l +S +68.18 112.72 m +561.60 112.72 l +S +68.18 133.74 m +561.60 133.74 l +S +68.18 154.76 m +561.60 154.76 l +S +68.18 175.78 m +561.60 175.78 l +S +68.18 196.79 m +561.60 196.79 l +S +68.18 217.81 m +561.60 217.81 l +S +68.18 238.83 m +561.60 238.83 l +S +68.18 259.85 m +561.60 259.85 l +S +68.18 280.87 m +561.60 280.87 l +S +68.18 301.89 m +561.60 301.89 l +S +88.06 37.28 m +88.06 309.60 l +S +113.55 37.28 m +113.55 309.60 l +S +139.88 37.28 m +139.88 309.60 l +S +166.22 37.28 m +166.22 309.60 l +S +191.71 37.28 m +191.71 309.60 l +S +218.04 37.28 m +218.04 309.60 l +S +243.53 37.28 m +243.53 309.60 l +S +269.87 37.28 m +269.87 309.60 l +S +296.20 37.28 m +296.20 309.60 l +S +319.99 37.28 m +319.99 309.60 l +S +346.32 37.28 m +346.32 309.60 l +S +371.81 37.28 m +371.81 309.60 l +S +398.15 37.28 m +398.15 309.60 l +S +423.63 37.28 m +423.63 309.60 l +S +449.97 37.28 m +449.97 309.60 l +S +476.31 37.28 m +476.31 309.60 l +S +501.79 37.28 m +501.79 309.60 l +S +528.13 37.28 m +528.13 309.60 l +S +553.61 37.28 m +553.61 309.60 l +S +1.000 1.000 1.000 RG +1.06 w +[] 0 d +68.18 49.66 m +561.60 49.66 l +S +68.18 91.70 m +561.60 91.70 l +S +68.18 133.74 m +561.60 133.74 l +S +68.18 175.78 m +561.60 175.78 l +S +68.18 217.81 m +561.60 217.81 l +S +68.18 259.85 m +561.60 259.85 l +S +88.06 37.28 m +88.06 309.60 l +S +166.22 37.28 m +166.22 309.60 l +S +243.53 37.28 m +243.53 309.60 l +S +319.99 37.28 m +319.99 309.60 l +S +398.15 37.28 m +398.15 309.60 l +S +476.31 37.28 m +476.31 309.60 l +S +553.61 37.28 m +553.61 309.60 l +S +0.000 0.000 0.000 RG +2.13 w +[] 0 d +0 J +1.00 M +90.61 69.48 m +91.46 72.64 l +92.31 71.94 l +93.16 69.37 l +94.01 70.72 l +94.86 76.24 l +95.71 73.63 l +96.56 78.83 l +97.41 73.58 l +98.26 73.52 l +99.11 70.55 l +99.96 70.20 l +100.81 74.39 l +101.65 74.43 l +102.50 74.26 l +103.35 75.41 l +104.20 76.13 l +105.05 56.15 l +105.90 52.33 l +106.75 71.65 l +107.60 78.93 l +108.45 79.21 l +109.30 80.08 l +110.15 77.20 l +111.00 73.91 l +111.85 74.95 l +112.70 77.42 l +113.55 79.58 l +114.40 78.42 l +115.25 78.91 l +116.10 77.55 l +116.95 72.38 l +117.80 73.86 l +118.65 79.14 l +119.50 82.76 l +120.34 83.82 l +121.19 85.79 l +122.04 75.31 l +122.89 79.26 l +123.74 78.77 l +124.59 78.97 l +125.44 78.49 l +126.29 78.74 l +127.14 92.58 l +127.99 75.60 l +128.84 70.13 l +129.69 85.69 l +S +131.39 78.61 m +132.24 74.68 l +133.09 75.39 l +133.94 73.42 l +134.79 71.05 l +135.64 72.69 l +136.49 78.48 l +137.34 79.83 l +138.19 77.41 l +139.03 77.00 l +139.88 74.26 l +140.73 72.28 l +141.58 73.43 l +142.43 76.31 l +143.28 76.75 l +144.13 76.52 l +144.98 78.25 l +145.83 71.90 l +146.68 73.23 l +147.53 79.60 l +148.38 79.48 l +149.23 80.11 l +150.08 79.94 l +150.93 79.63 l +151.78 75.94 l +152.63 75.40 l +153.48 79.51 l +154.33 81.80 l +155.18 83.22 l +156.03 80.60 l +156.88 79.90 l +157.72 76.55 l +158.57 75.27 l +159.42 80.15 l +160.27 82.00 l +161.12 81.44 l +161.97 83.28 l +162.82 81.53 l +163.67 77.43 l +164.52 76.20 l +165.37 81.00 l +166.22 83.19 l +167.07 83.44 l +167.92 82.25 l +168.77 81.84 l +169.62 78.06 l +170.47 77.42 l +171.32 82.16 l +172.17 83.83 l +173.02 83.70 l +S +175.57 79.15 m +176.42 77.15 l +177.26 89.49 l +178.11 107.55 l +178.96 110.97 l +179.81 104.82 l +180.66 100.65 l +181.51 90.71 l +182.36 90.79 l +183.21 89.29 l +184.06 109.95 l +184.91 101.02 l +185.76 108.08 l +186.61 95.98 l +187.46 86.68 l +188.31 92.17 l +189.16 100.85 l +190.01 113.25 l +190.86 98.86 l +191.71 91.92 l +192.56 94.84 l +193.41 85.95 l +194.26 85.78 l +195.11 85.31 l +195.95 99.72 l +196.80 103.91 l +197.65 102.95 l +198.50 90.34 l +199.35 86.51 l +200.20 84.74 l +201.05 92.99 l +201.90 102.73 l +202.75 105.79 l +203.60 107.50 l +204.45 110.57 l +205.30 94.99 l +206.15 95.61 l +207.00 109.50 l +207.85 78.61 l +208.70 92.58 l +209.55 110.73 l +210.40 111.50 l +211.25 93.99 l +212.10 100.01 l +212.95 90.43 l +213.80 89.36 l +214.64 93.58 l +215.49 132.00 l +216.34 120.01 l +217.19 89.69 l +218.04 117.07 l +218.89 121.73 l +219.74 132.82 l +220.59 106.19 l +221.44 116.99 l +222.29 112.59 l +223.14 101.43 l +223.99 108.93 l +224.84 129.36 l +225.69 126.27 l +226.54 117.24 l +227.39 118.78 l +228.24 115.16 l +229.09 102.93 l +229.94 112.49 l +230.79 93.58 l +231.64 90.35 l +232.49 90.99 l +233.33 89.36 l +234.18 104.08 l +235.03 98.43 l +235.88 110.50 l +236.73 91.46 l +237.58 91.60 l +238.43 89.77 l +239.28 93.19 l +240.13 115.39 l +240.98 104.59 l +241.83 107.38 l +242.68 105.30 l +243.53 121.60 l +244.38 103.86 l +245.23 102.24 l +246.08 107.40 l +246.93 97.73 l +247.78 96.57 l +248.63 113.70 l +249.48 120.59 l +250.33 117.61 l +251.18 108.44 l +252.02 108.60 l +252.87 93.22 l +253.72 96.62 l +254.57 97.04 l +255.42 117.46 l +256.27 106.35 l +257.12 111.40 l +257.97 107.20 l +258.82 98.07 l +259.67 94.62 l +260.52 107.14 l +261.37 111.53 l +262.22 96.90 l +263.07 93.35 l +263.92 83.38 l +264.77 87.66 l +265.62 82.59 l +266.47 91.50 l +267.32 98.57 l +268.17 91.95 l +269.02 89.70 l +269.87 81.88 l +S +271.56 87.06 m +272.41 97.80 l +273.26 95.42 l +274.11 88.50 l +274.96 94.25 l +275.81 105.13 l +276.66 86.08 l +277.51 93.07 l +278.36 96.74 l +279.21 88.05 l +280.06 88.38 l +280.91 100.49 l +281.76 92.36 l +282.61 75.64 l +283.46 87.17 l +284.31 103.11 l +S +286.01 95.74 m +286.86 129.30 l +S +290.25 111.83 m +291.10 103.96 l +291.95 93.08 l +292.80 108.96 l +293.65 114.39 l +294.50 96.32 l +295.35 84.99 l +296.20 90.09 l +297.05 100.05 l +297.90 122.18 l +298.75 86.09 l +299.60 93.64 l +300.45 84.06 l +301.30 84.43 l +302.15 88.65 l +303.00 94.25 l +303.85 87.42 l +304.70 92.51 l +305.55 85.25 l +306.40 81.89 l +307.25 81.93 l +S +309.79 80.41 m +310.64 81.08 l +311.49 92.73 l +312.34 80.41 l +313.19 79.79 l +314.04 88.54 l +314.89 96.09 l +315.74 92.55 l +316.59 89.63 l +317.44 90.37 l +318.29 83.24 l +319.14 82.72 l +319.99 79.09 l +320.84 88.41 l +S +322.54 87.75 m +323.39 90.18 l +324.24 90.75 l +325.09 79.23 l +325.94 90.87 l +326.78 101.56 l +327.63 100.08 l +328.48 108.99 l +329.33 87.52 l +330.18 97.48 l +331.03 81.88 l +331.88 90.20 l +332.73 85.14 l +333.58 123.26 l +334.43 93.93 l +335.28 97.37 l +336.13 92.70 l +336.98 86.20 l +337.83 88.30 l +338.68 87.41 l +339.53 91.41 l +340.38 100.54 l +S +342.08 82.11 m +342.93 88.41 l +S +344.63 89.69 m +345.48 106.22 l +346.32 90.16 l +347.17 92.92 l +348.02 85.46 l +S +360.77 83.17 m +361.62 133.76 l +S +368.41 89.49 m +369.26 83.92 l +370.11 89.72 l +370.96 94.86 l +371.81 92.94 l +372.66 99.94 l +373.51 109.89 l +374.36 102.91 l +375.21 83.01 l +376.06 104.06 l +376.91 297.22 l +377.76 86.10 l +378.61 91.55 l +379.46 96.07 l +380.31 84.62 l +381.16 91.24 l +382.01 85.01 l +382.86 94.18 l +383.70 85.86 l +384.55 84.70 l +385.40 91.50 l +386.25 88.31 l +387.10 97.36 l +387.95 89.51 l +388.80 84.07 l +389.65 83.65 l +390.50 83.30 l +S +392.20 99.27 m +393.05 117.77 l +S +398.15 208.50 m +399.00 129.82 l +S +417.69 146.22 m +418.54 152.86 l +419.39 143.92 l +420.24 170.07 l +S +421.93 173.50 m +422.78 151.11 l +423.63 149.06 l +424.48 146.60 l +425.33 141.98 l +426.18 133.88 l +427.03 130.16 l +427.88 143.39 l +428.73 143.43 l +429.58 136.59 l +430.43 135.64 l +431.28 128.62 l +432.13 121.19 l +432.98 126.41 l +433.83 151.85 l +434.68 179.96 l +435.53 187.21 l +S +441.47 162.09 m +442.32 154.87 l +443.17 160.51 l +444.02 152.88 l +444.87 140.36 l +445.72 150.50 l +446.57 173.09 l +447.42 164.19 l +448.27 153.22 l +449.12 146.19 l +449.97 141.61 l +450.82 136.74 l +S +452.52 155.29 m +453.37 142.12 l +454.22 160.95 l +455.07 152.75 l +455.92 142.10 l +456.77 152.57 l +457.62 168.81 l +458.46 174.93 l +459.31 153.47 l +S +464.41 155.09 m +465.26 142.95 l +466.11 138.94 l +S +471.21 149.72 m +472.06 227.81 l +472.91 206.09 l +473.76 168.79 l +S +484.80 82.06 m +485.65 85.45 l +486.50 91.17 l +487.35 108.19 l +488.20 98.26 l +S +490.75 84.08 m +491.60 85.49 l +492.45 89.44 l +493.30 88.13 l +S +505.19 98.57 m +506.04 86.48 l +506.89 87.40 l +507.74 103.25 l +508.59 101.57 l +509.44 96.81 l +510.29 98.28 l +511.14 102.70 l +511.99 111.07 l +512.84 107.45 l +513.69 121.48 l +S +521.33 122.70 m +522.18 120.34 l +523.03 126.39 l +523.88 130.49 l +524.73 127.18 l +525.58 119.51 l +526.43 125.84 l +527.28 115.15 l +528.13 120.22 l +528.98 127.51 l +529.83 136.88 l +530.68 133.45 l +531.53 133.06 l +532.38 127.15 l +533.23 111.96 l +534.07 113.12 l +534.92 124.48 l +535.77 125.63 l +536.62 176.24 l +537.47 195.24 l +538.32 185.75 l +S +Q q +Q q 68.18 37.28 493.42 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q +0.498 0.498 0.498 RG +1.06 w +[] 0 d +1 J +1 j +10.00 M +88.06 33.03 m 88.06 37.28 l S +166.22 33.03 m 166.22 37.28 l S +243.53 33.03 m 243.53 37.28 l S +319.99 33.03 m 319.99 37.28 l S +398.15 33.03 m 398.15 37.28 l S +476.31 33.03 m 476.31 37.28 l S +553.61 33.03 m 553.61 37.28 l S +BT +0.498 0.498 0.498 rg +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 71.62 23.02 Tm [(J) 20 (un-09)] TJ +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 148.85 23.02 Tm (Sep-09) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 226.16 23.02 Tm (Dec-09) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 302.90 23.02 Tm (Mar-10) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 381.71 23.02 Tm [(J) 20 (un-10)] TJ +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 458.93 23.02 Tm (Sep-10) Tj +ET +BT +/F2 1 Tf 10.00 0.00 -0.00 10.00 536.24 23.02 Tm (Dec-10) Tj +ET +Q q +Q q 68.18 23.02 493.42 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 309.60 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 272.32 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 37.28 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 14.27 re W n +Q q +Q q 561.60 23.02 0.00 0.00 re W n +Q q +Q q +Q q +Q +endstream +endobj +7 0 obj +12407 +endobj +3 0 obj +<< +/Type /Pages +/Kids [ +5 0 R +] +/Count 1 +/MediaBox [0 0 576 324] +>> +endobj +4 0 obj +<< +/ProcSet [/PDF /Text] +/Font <</F2 9 0 R >> +/ExtGState << >> +>> +endobj +8 0 obj +<< +/Type /Encoding +/BaseEncoding /WinAnsiEncoding +/Differences [ 45/minus 96/quoteleft +144/dotlessi /grave /acute /circumflex /tilde /macron /breve /dotaccent +/dieresis /.notdef /ring /cedilla /.notdef /hungarumlaut /ogonek /caron /space] +>> +endobj +9 0 obj << +/Type /Font +/Subtype /Type1 +/Name /F2 +/BaseFont /Helvetica +/Encoding 8 0 R +>> endobj +xref +0 10 +0000000000 65535 f +0000000021 00000 n +0000000164 00000 n +0000012774 00000 n +0000012857 00000 n +0000000213 00000 n +0000000293 00000 n +0000012753 00000 n +0000012938 00000 n +0000013195 00000 n +trailer +<< +/Size 10 +/Info 1 0 R +/Root 2 0 R +>> +startxref +13291 +%%EOF

1 0

[metrics-web/master] Update link to data tech report.
by karsten＠torproject.org 14 Mar '11

14 Mar '11

commit 9c15dd8cb1f2dc825892825e259c57651f26b410 Author: Karsten Loesing <karsten.loesing(a)gmx.net> Date: Mon Mar 14 17:45:13 2011 +0100 Update link to data tech report. --- web/WEB-INF/papers.jsp | 4 ++-- 1 files changed, 2 insertions(+), 2 deletions(-) diff --git a/web/WEB-INF/papers.jsp b/web/WEB-INF/papers.jsp index da59b27..1880483 100644 --- a/web/WEB-INF/papers.jsp +++ b/web/WEB-INF/papers.jsp @@ -45,8 +45,8 @@ daily updated <a href="graphs.html">graphs</a>. <ul> <li>Overview of Statistical Data in the Tor Network - (<a href="papers/data-2010-12-29.pdf">PDF</a>, - 164K from December 29, 2010).</li> + (<a href="papers/data-2011-03-14.pdf">PDF</a>, + 166K from March 14, 2011).</li> <li>Privacy-preserving Ways to Estimate the Number of Tor Users (<a href="papers/countingusers-2010-11-30.pdf">PDF</a>, 307K from November 30, 2010).</li>

1 0

[metrics-tasks/master] Add BridgeDB pool assignments to data tech report.
by karsten＠torproject.org 14 Mar '11

14 Mar '11

commit d24e3cbe77ba5545859fbe8da0cf445f642fed75 Author: Karsten Loesing <karsten.loesing(a)gmx.net> Date: Mon Mar 14 17:38:41 2011 +0100 Add BridgeDB pool assignments to data tech report. --- task-2754/data.tex | 57 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++- 1 files changed, 56 insertions(+), 1 deletions(-) diff --git a/task-2754/data.tex b/task-2754/data.tex index fe8e322..1a2745d 100644 --- a/task-2754/data.tex +++ b/task-2754/data.tex @@ -21,7 +21,8 @@ information in Section~\ref{sec:bridgesan}. Second, we describe the numerous aggregate statistics that relays publish about their usage \cite{loesing2010case} in Sections~\ref{sec:bytehist} to \ref{fig:connbidirect}. -Third, we delineate the output of various Tor services like GetTor or +Third, we delineate the output of various Tor services like BridgeDB, +GetTor, or Tor Check as well as specific measurement tools like Torperf in Sections~\ref{sec:torperf} to \ref{sec:exitlist}. All data described in this report are available for download on the @@ -644,6 +645,60 @@ file (reformatted and annotated with comments)} \label{fig:torperf} \end{figure} +\section{BridgeDB pool assignment files} + +BridgeDB is the software that receives bridge network statuses containing +the information which bridges are running from the bridge authority, +assigns these bridges to persistent distribution rings, and hands them out +to bridge users. +BridgeDB periodically dumps the list of running bridges with information +about the rings, subrings, and file buckets to which they are assigned to +a local file. +The sanitized versions of these lists containing SHA-1 hashes of bridge +fingerprints instead of the original fingerprints are available for +statistical analysis. + +\begin{figure} +\begin{verbatim} +bridge-pool-assignment 2011-03-13 14:38:03 +00b834117566035736fc6bd4ece950eace8e057a unallocated +00e923e7a8d87d28954fee7503e480f3a03ce4ee email port=443 + flag=stable +0103bb5b00ad3102b2dbafe9ce709a0a7c1060e4 https ring=2 port=443 + flag=stable +[...] +\end{verbatim} +%---------------------------------------------------------------- +\vspace{-1em} +\caption{BridgeDB pool assignment file from March 13, 2011} +\label{fig:bridgeassignments} +\end{figure} + +Figure~\ref{fig:bridgeassignments} shows a BridgeDB pool assignment file +from March 13, 2011. +Every such file begins with a line containing the timestamp when BridgeDB +wrote this file. +Subsequent lines always start with the SHA-1 hash of a bridge fingerprint, +followed by ring, subring, and/or file bucket information. +There are currently three distributor ring types in BridgeDB: + +\begin{enumerate} +\item \texttt{unallocated}: These bridges are not distributed by BridgeDB, +but are either reserved for manual distribution or are written to file +buckets for distribution via an external tool. +If a bridge in the \texttt{unallocated} ring is assigned to a file bucket, +this is noted by \verb+bucket=$bucketname+. +\item \texttt{email}: These bridges are distributed via an e-mail +autoresponder. Bridges can be assigned to subrings by their OR port or +relay flag which is defined by \verb+port=$port+ and/or \verb+flag=$flag+. +\item \texttt{https}: These bridges are distributed via https server. +There are multiple https rings to further distribute bridges by IP address +ranges, which is denoted by \verb+ring=$ring+. +Bridges in the \texttt{https} ring can also be assigned to subrings by +OR port or relay flag which is defined by \verb+port=$port+ and/or +\verb+flag=$flag+. +\end{enumerate} + \section{GetTor statistics file} GetTor allows users to fetch the Tor software via email.

1 0

r24354: {website} point people to the 25c3 talk too. we really ought to replac (website/trunk/docs/en)
by Roger Dingledine 14 Mar '11

14 Mar '11

Author: arma Date: 2011-03-14 16:27:00 +0000 (Mon, 14 Mar 2011) New Revision: 24354 Modified: website/trunk/docs/en/documentation.wml Log: point people to the 25c3 talk too. we really ought to replace the wth talk sometime. Modified: website/trunk/docs/en/documentation.wml =================================================================== --- website/trunk/docs/en/documentation.wml 2011-03-14 16:11:54 UTC (rev 24353) +++ website/trunk/docs/en/documentation.wml 2011-03-14 16:27:00 UTC (rev 24354) @@ -118,11 +118,15 @@ <a href="http://freehaven.net/~arma/slides-23c3.pdf">slides</a>, <a href="http://events.ccc.de/congress/2006/Fahrplan/events/1444.en.html">abstract</a>, <a href="https://svn.torproject.org/svn/projects/design-paper/blocking.html">design paper</a>), - and Roger's "Current events in 2007" talk from 24C3 in December + Roger's "Current events in 2007" talk from 24C3 in December 2007 (<a href="http://freehaven.net/~arma/24c3-2325-en-current_events_in_tor_development.m…">video</a>, <a href="http://freehaven.net/~arma/slides-24c3.pdf">slides</a>, - <a href="http://events.ccc.de/congress/2007/Fahrplan/events/2325.en.html">abstract</a>). + <a href="http://events.ccc.de/congress/2007/Fahrplan/events/2325.en.html">abstract</a>), and + Roger's "Vulnerabilities in Tor" talk from 25C3 in December + 2008 (<a + href="https://media.torproject.org/video/25c3-2977-en-security_and_anonymity_vuln…">video</a>, + <a href="http://freehaven.net/~arma/slides-25c3.pdf">slides</a>). </li> <li>

1 0

r24353: {} we were missing my 25c3 slides (projects/presentations)
by Roger Dingledine 14 Mar '11

14 Mar '11

Author: arma Date: 2011-03-14 16:11:54 +0000 (Mon, 14 Mar 2011) New Revision: 24353 Added: projects/presentations/slides-25c3.odp projects/presentations/slides-25c3.pdf Log: we were missing my 25c3 slides Added: projects/presentations/slides-25c3.odp =================================================================== (Binary files differ) Property changes on: projects/presentations/slides-25c3.odp ___________________________________________________________________ Added: svn:mime-type + application/octet-stream Added: projects/presentations/slides-25c3.pdf =================================================================== (Binary files differ) Property changes on: projects/presentations/slides-25c3.pdf ___________________________________________________________________ Added: svn:mime-type + application/octet-stream

1 0

r24352: {} the slides i used a few weeks ago at georgia tech (projects/presentations)
by Roger Dingledine 14 Mar '11

14 Mar '11

Author: arma Date: 2011-03-14 16:10:10 +0000 (Mon, 14 Mar 2011) New Revision: 24352 Added: projects/presentations/slides-gatech11.odp projects/presentations/slides-gatech11.pdf Log: the slides i used a few weeks ago at georgia tech Added: projects/presentations/slides-gatech11.odp =================================================================== (Binary files differ) Property changes on: projects/presentations/slides-gatech11.odp ___________________________________________________________________ Added: svn:mime-type + application/octet-stream Added: projects/presentations/slides-gatech11.pdf =================================================================== (Binary files differ) Property changes on: projects/presentations/slides-gatech11.pdf ___________________________________________________________________ Added: svn:mime-type + application/octet-stream

1 0

[metrics-web/master] Having no recent consensus probably means we're in trouble.
by karsten＠torproject.org 14 Mar '11

14 Mar '11

commit 19a57c6a0987f92b5d2704b7b19b42c86876b047 Author: Karsten Loesing <karsten.loesing(a)gmx.net> Date: Mon Mar 14 14:53:44 2011 +0100 Having no recent consensus probably means we're in trouble. --- .../ernie/cron/ConsensusHealthChecker.java | 2 +- 1 files changed, 1 insertions(+), 1 deletions(-) diff --git a/src/org/torproject/ernie/cron/ConsensusHealthChecker.java b/src/org/torproject/ernie/cron/ConsensusHealthChecker.java index 65a8cce..602d030 100644 --- a/src/org/torproject/ernie/cron/ConsensusHealthChecker.java +++ b/src/org/torproject/ernie/cron/ConsensusHealthChecker.java @@ -87,7 +87,7 @@ public class ConsensusHealthChecker { * with a warning, because we might just not have learned about a new * consensus in this execution. */ if (this.mostRecentConsensus == null) { - nagiosUnknowns.add("No consensus known"); + nagiosCriticals.add("No consensus known"); return; }

1 0

[metrics-tasks/master] Add bridge pool assignment file parser for #2680.
by karsten＠torproject.org 14 Mar '11

14 Mar '11

commit 1e8dbd3857c58e26f57973da4d64170eae0e1be6 Author: Karsten Loesing <karsten.loesing(a)gmx.net> Date: Mon Mar 14 14:15:33 2011 +0100 Add bridge pool assignment file parser for #2680. --- task-2680/.gitignore | 2 + task-2680/ProcessSanitizedAssignments.java | 102 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ task-2680/README | 40 ++++++++++- task-2680/verify.R | 6 ++ 4 files changed, 147 insertions(+), 3 deletions(-) diff --git a/task-2680/.gitignore b/task-2680/.gitignore index 6378a79..b394fe6 100644 --- a/task-2680/.gitignore +++ b/task-2680/.gitignore @@ -4,4 +4,6 @@ bridge-descriptors/ commons-codec-1.4.jar consensuses/ *.tar.bz2 +*.swp +bridge-pool-assignments/ diff --git a/task-2680/ProcessSanitizedAssignments.java b/task-2680/ProcessSanitizedAssignments.java new file mode 100644 index 0000000..9289aa1 --- /dev/null +++ b/task-2680/ProcessSanitizedAssignments.java @@ -0,0 +1,102 @@ +import java.io.*; +import java.util.*; + +public class ProcessSanitizedAssignments { + public static void main(String[] args) throws IOException { + + /* Validate command-line arguments. */ + if (args.length != 1 || !new File(args[0]).exists()) { + System.out.println("Usage: java ProcessSanitizedAssignments <dir>"); + System.exit(1); + } + + /* Find all files that we should parse. Somewhat fragile, but should + * work. */ + System.out.println("Creating list of files we should parse."); + SortedMap<String, File> assignments = new TreeMap<String, File>(); + Stack<File> files = new Stack<File>(); + files.add(new File(args[0])); + while (!files.isEmpty()) { + File file = files.pop(); + if (file.isDirectory()) { + files.addAll(Arrays.asList(file.listFiles())); + } else { + assignments.put(file.getName(), file); + } + } + System.out.println("We found " + assignments.size() + " bridge pool " + + "assignment files."); + + /* Parse assignments. */ + if (!assignments.isEmpty()) { + System.out.println("Parsing bridge pool assignment files."); + BufferedWriter bw = new BufferedWriter(new FileWriter( + "assignments.csv")); + bw.write("assignment,fingerprint,type,ring,port,flag,bucket\n"); + int parsedAssignments = 0, totalAssignments = assignments.size(), + writtenOutputLines = 1; + long started = System.currentTimeMillis(); + for (File file : assignments.values()) { + BufferedReader br = new BufferedReader(new FileReader(file)); + String line, assignmentTime = null; + while ((line = br.readLine()) != null) { + if (line.startsWith("bridge-pool-assignment ")) { + assignmentTime = line.substring("bridge-pool-assignment ". + length()); + } else { + String[] parts = line.split(" "); + String fingerprint = parts[0]; + String type = parts[1]; + String ring = null, port = null, flag = null, bucket = null; + for (int i = 2; i < parts.length; i++) { + String[] parts2 = parts[i].split("="); + String key = parts2[0]; + String value = parts2[1]; + if (key.equals("ring")) { + } else if (key.equals("ring")) { + ring = value; + } else if (key.equals("port")) { + port = value; + } else if (key.equals("flag")) { + flag = value; + } else if (key.equals("bucket")) { + bucket = value; + } else { + System.out.println("Unknown keyword in line '" + line + + "'. Please check. Exiting."); + System.exit(1); + } + } + bw.write(assignmentTime + "," + fingerprint + "," + type + "," + + (ring != null ? ring : "NA") + "," + + (port != null ? port : "NA") + "," + + (flag != null ? flag : "NA") + "," + + (bucket != null ? bucket : "NA") + "\n"); + writtenOutputLines++; + } + } + br.close(); + parsedAssignments++; + if (parsedAssignments % (totalAssignments / 10) == 0) { + double fractionDone = (double) (parsedAssignments) / + (double) totalAssignments; + double fractionLeft = 1.0D - fractionDone; + long now = System.currentTimeMillis(); + double millisLeft = ((double) (now - started)) * fractionLeft / + fractionDone; + long secondsLeft = (long) millisLeft / 1000L; + System.out.println(" " + (parsedAssignments / (totalAssignments + / 10)) + "0% done, " + secondsLeft + " seconds left."); + } + } + bw.close(); + System.out.println("Parsed " + parsedAssignments + " bridge pool " + + "assignment files and wrote " + writtenOutputLines + " lines " + + "to assignments.csv."); + } + + /* This is it. */ + System.out.println("Terminating."); + } +} + diff --git a/task-2680/README b/task-2680/README index a00856f..65d8b85 100644 --- a/task-2680/README +++ b/task-2680/README @@ -6,9 +6,9 @@ This ticket contains Java and R code to This README has a separate section for each Java or R code snippet. -The Java applications produce three output formats containing bridge -descriptors, bridge status lines, and hashed relay identities. The data -formats are described below. +The Java applications produce four output formats containing bridge +descriptors, bridge status lines, bridge pool assignments, and hashed +relay identities. The data formats are described below. -------------------------------------------------------------------------- @@ -33,6 +33,23 @@ ProcessSanitizedBridges.java -------------------------------------------------------------------------- +ProcessSanitizedAssignments.java + + - Download sanitized bridge pool assignments from the metrics website, + e.g., https://metrics.torproject.org/data/bridge-pool-assignments-2011-01.tar.bz2 + and extract them in a local directory, e.g., bridge-pool-assignments/. + + - Compile the Java class, e.g., + $ javac ProcessSanitizedAssignments.java + + - Run the Java class, e.g., + $ java ProcessSanitizedAssignments bridge-pool-assignments/ + + - Once the Java application is done, you'll find a file assignments.csv + in this directory. + +-------------------------------------------------------------------------- + ProcessRelayConsensuses.java - Download v3 relay consensuses from the metrics website, e.g., @@ -130,6 +147,23 @@ The columns in statuses.csv are: -------------------------------------------------------------------------- +assignments.csv + +The assignments.csv file contains one line for every running bridge and +the rings, subrings, and buckets that BridgeDB assigned it to. + +The columns in assignments.csv are: + + - assignment: ISO-formatted bridge pool assignment time + - fingerprint: Hex-formatted SHA-1 hash of identity fingerprint + - type: Name of the distributor: "https", "email", or "unallocated" + - ring: Ring number, only for distributor "https" + - port: Port subring + - flag: Flag subring + - bucket: File bucket, only for distributor "unallocated" + +-------------------------------------------------------------------------- + relays.csv The relays.csv file contains SHA-1 hashes of identity fingerprints of diff --git a/task-2680/verify.R b/task-2680/verify.R index 63ef233..241a196 100644 --- a/task-2680/verify.R +++ b/task-2680/verify.R @@ -25,3 +25,9 @@ if (file.exists("relays.csv")) { summary(as.POSIXct(r$consensus)) } +if (file.exists("assignments.csv")) { + cat("Verifying assignments.csv. This may take a while.\n") + r <- read.csv("assignments.csv", stringsAsFactors = FALSE) + summary(as.POSIXct(r$assignment)) +} +

1 0

[metrics-tasks/master] Check in data tech report w/o bridge assignments.
by karsten＠torproject.org 14 Mar '11

14 Mar '11

commit 071651c75885a21a0a40dde1dfc7808b0c27d645 Author: Karsten Loesing <karsten.loesing(a)gmx.net> Date: Mon Mar 14 12:52:31 2011 +0100 Check in data tech report w/o bridge assignments. --- task-2754/.gitignore | 6 + task-2754/data.bib | 45 ++++ task-2754/data.tex | 717 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 3 files changed, 768 insertions(+), 0 deletions(-) diff --git a/task-2754/.gitignore b/task-2754/.gitignore new file mode 100644 index 0000000..e4b915f --- /dev/null +++ b/task-2754/.gitignore @@ -0,0 +1,6 @@ +*.aux +*.bbl +*.blg +*.log +*.pdf + diff --git a/task-2754/data.bib b/task-2754/data.bib new file mode 100644 index 0000000..caec3b8 --- /dev/null +++ b/task-2754/data.bib @@ -0,0 +1,45 @@ +@misc{dirspec, + author = {Roger Dingledine and Nick Mathewson}, + title = {Tor directory protocol, version 3}, + note = {\url{https://gitweb.torproject.org/tor.git/blob_plain/HEAD:/doc/spec/dir-spec.txt}}, +} + +@inproceedings{loesing2009measuring, + title = {Measuring the {Tor} Network from Public Directory Information}, + author = {Karsten Loesing}, + booktitle = {Proc.\ HotPETS}, + year = {2009}, + month = Aug, + address = {Seattle, WA}, + note = {\url{https://metrics.torproject.org/papers/hotpets09.pdf}}, +} + +@inproceedings{loesing2010case, + title = {A Case Study on Measuring Statistical Data in the {Tor} Anonymity Network}, + author = {Karsten Loesing and Steven J. Murdoch and Roger Dingledine}, + booktitle = {Proc.\ Workshop on Ethics in Computer Security Research}, + year = {2010}, + month = Jan, + address = {Tenerife, Canary Islands, Spain}, + note = {\url{https://metrics.torproject.org/papers/wecsr10.pdf}}, +} + +@techreport{hahn2010privacy, + title = {Privacy-preserving Ways to Estimate the Number of Tor Users}, + author = {Sebastian Hahn and Karsten Loesing}, + institution = {The Tor Project}, + year = {2010}, + month = Nov, + type = {Technical Report}, + note = {\url{https://metrics.torproject.org/papers/countingusers-2010-11-30.pdf}}, +} + +@techreport{loesing2009analysis, + title = {Analysis of Circuit Queues in {Tor}}, + author = {Karsten Loesing}, + institution = {The Tor Project}, + year = {2009}, + month = Aug, + note = {\url{https://metrics.torproject.org/papers/bufferstats-2009-08-25.pdf}}, +} + diff --git a/task-2754/data.tex b/task-2754/data.tex new file mode 100644 index 0000000..fe8e322 --- /dev/null +++ b/task-2754/data.tex @@ -0,0 +1,717 @@ +\documentclass{article} +\usepackage{url} +\usepackage[pdftex]{graphicx} +\usepackage{graphics} +\usepackage{color} +\begin{document} +\title{Overview of Statistical Data in the Tor Network} +\author{Karsten Loesing} +\maketitle + +\section{Introduction} + +Statistical analysis in the Tor network can be performed using various +kinds of data. +In this report we give an overview of three major data sources for +statistics in the Tor network: +First, we recap measuring the Tor network from public directory +information \cite{loesing2009measuring} in Section~\ref{sec:serverdesc} +and explain the sanitzation process of (non-public) bridge directory +information in Section~\ref{sec:bridgesan}. +Second, we describe the numerous aggregate statistics that relays publish +about their usage \cite{loesing2010case} +in Sections~\ref{sec:bytehist} to \ref{fig:connbidirect}. +Third, we delineate the output of various Tor services like GetTor or +Tor Check as well as specific measurement tools like Torperf in +Sections~\ref{sec:torperf} to \ref{sec:exitlist}. +All data described in this report are available for download on the +metrics +website.\footnote{\texttt{https://metrics.torproject.org/data.html}} + +\section{Server descriptors and network statuses} +\label{sec:serverdesc} + +Relays in the Tor network report their capabilities by publishing server +descriptors to the directory authorities. +The directory authorities confirm reachability of relays and assign flags +to help clients make good path selections. +Every hour, the directory authorities publish a network status consensus +with all known running relays at the time. +Both server descriptors and network statuses constitute a solid data basis +for statistical analysis in the Tor network. +We described the approach to measure the Tor network from public directory +information in \cite{loesing2009measuring} and provide interactive +graphs on the metrics +website.\footnote{\texttt{https://metrics.torproject.org/graphs.html}} +In this section, we briefly describe the most interesting pieces of the +two descriptor formats that can be used for statistics. + +\paragraph{Server descriptors} + +The server descriptors published by relays at least once every 18 hours +contain the necessary information for clients to build circuits using a +given relay. +These server descriptors can also be useful for statistical analysis of +the Tor network infrastructure. + +We assume that the majority of server descriptors are correct. +But when performing statistical analysis on server descriptors, one has to +keep in mind that only a small subset of the information written to server +descriptors is confirmed by the trusted directory authorities. +In theory, relays can provide false information in their server +descriptors, even though the incentive to do so is probably low. + +Figure~\ref{fig:serverdesc} shows an example server descriptor. +The following data fields in server descriptors may be relevant to +statistical analysis: + +\begin{figure} +\begin{verbatim} +router blutmagie 192.251.226.206 443 0 80 +platform Tor 0.2.2.20-alpha on Linux x86_64 +opt protocols Link 1 2 Circuit 1 +published 2010-12-27 14:35:27 +opt fingerprint 6297 B13A 687B 521A 59C6 BD79 188A 2501 EC03 A065 +uptime 445412 +bandwidth 14336000 18432000 15905178 +opt extra-info-digest 5C1D5D6F8B243304079BC15CD96C7FCCB88322D4 +opt caches-extra-info +onion-key +[...] +signing-key +[...] +family $66CA87E164F1CFCE8C3BB5C095217A28578B8BAF + $67EC84376D9C4C467DCE8621AACA109160B5264E + $7B698D327F1695590408FED95CDEE1565774D136 +opt hidden-service-dir +contact abuse(a)blutmagie.de +reject 0.0.0.0/8:* +reject 169.254.0.0/16:* +reject 127.0.0.0/8:* +reject 192.168.0.0/16:* +reject 10.0.0.0/8:* +reject 172.16.0.0/12:* +reject 192.251.226.206:* +reject *:25 +reject *:119 +reject *:135-139 +reject *:445 +reject *:465 +reject *:563 +reject *:587 +reject *:1214 +reject *:4661-4666 +reject *:6346-6429 +reject *:6660-6999 +accept *:* +router-signature +[...] +\end{verbatim} +\vspace{-1em} +\caption{Server descriptor published by relay \texttt{blugmagie} (without +cryptographic keys and hashes)} +\label{fig:serverdesc} +%---------------------------------------------------------------- +\end{figure} + +\begin{itemize} +\item \textit{IP address and ports:} Relays provide their IP address +and ports where they accept requests to build circuits and directory +requests. +These data fields are contained in the first line of a server descriptor +starting with \verb+router+. +Note that in rare cases, the IP address provided here can be different +from the IP address used for exiting to the Internet. +The latter can be found in the exit lists produced by Tor Check as +described in Section~\ref{sec:exitlist}. +\item \textit{Operating system and Tor software version:} Relays include +their operating system and Tor software version in their server +descriptors in the \verb+platform+ line. +While this information is very likely correct in most cases, a few relay +operators may try to impede hacking attempts by providing false platform +strings. +\item \textit{Uptime:} Relays include the number of seconds since the +last restart in their server descriptor in the \verb+uptime+ line. +\item \textit{Own measured bandwidth:} Relays report the bandwidth that +they are willing to provide on average and for short periods of time. +Relays also perform periodic bandwidth self-tests and report their actual +available bandwidth. +The latter was used by clients to weight relays in the path selection +algorithm and was sometimes subject to manipulation by malicious relays. +All three bandwidth values can be found in a server descriptor's +\verb+bandwidth+ line. +With the introduction of bandwidth scanners, the self-reported relay +bandwidth in server descriptors has become less +relevant.\footnote{\url{http://gitweb.torproject.org/torflow.git/}} +\item \textit{Relay family:} Some relay operators who run more than one +relay organize their relays in relay families, so that clients don't pick +more than one of these relays for a single circuit. +Each relay belonging to a relay family lists the members of that family +either by nickname or fingerprint in its server descriptor in the +\verb+family+ line. +\item \textit{Exit policy:} Relays define their exit policy by including +firewall-like rules which outgoing connections they reject or accept in +the \verb+reject+ and \verb+accept+ lines. +\end{itemize} + +These are just a subset of the fields in a server descriptor that seem +relevant for statistical analysis. +For a complete list of fields in server descriptors, see the directory +procol specification \cite{dirspec}. + +\paragraph{Network statuses} + +Every hour, the directory authorities publish a new network status that +contains a list of all running relays. +The directory authorities confirm reachability of the contained relays and +assign flags based on the relays' characteristics. +The entries in a network status reference the last published server +descriptor of a relay. + +The network statuses are relevant for statistical analysis, because they +constitute trusted snapshots of the Tor network. +Anyone can publish as many server descriptors as they want, but only the +directory authorities can confirm that a relay was running at a given +time. +Most statistics on the Tor network infrastructure rely on network statuses +and possibly combine them with the referenced server descriptors. +Figure~\ref{fig:statusentry} shows the network status entry referencing +the server descriptor from Figure~\ref{fig:serverdesc}. +In addition to the reachability information, network statuses contain the +following fields that may be relevant for statistical analysis: + +\begin{figure} +\begin{verbatim} +r blutmagie YpexOmh7UhpZxr15GIolAewDoGU + lFY7WmD/yvVFp9drmZzNeTxZ6dw 2010-12-27 14:35:27 192.251.226.206 + 443 80 +s Exit Fast Guard HSDir Named Running Stable V2Dir Valid +v Tor 0.2.2.20-alpha +w Bandwidth=30800 +p reject 25,119,135-139,445,465,563,587,1214,4661-4666,6346-6429, + 6660-6999 +\end{verbatim} +%---------------------------------------------------------------- +\vspace{-1em} +\caption{Network status entry of relay \texttt{blutmagie}} +\label{fig:statusentry} +\end{figure} + +\begin{itemize} +\item \textit{Relay flags:} The directory authorities assign flags to +relays based on their characteristics to the line starting with \verb+s+. +Examples are the \verb+Exit+ flag if a relay permits exiting to the +Internet and the \verb+Guard+ flag if a relay is stable enough to be +picked as guard node +\item \textit{Relay version:} The directory authorities include the +version part of the platform string written to server descriptors in the +network status in the line starting with \verb+v+. +\item \textit{Bandwidth weights:} The network status contains a bandwidth +weight for every relay in the lines with \verb+w+ that clients shall use +for weighting relays in their path selection algorithm. +This bandwidth weight is either the self-reported bandwidth of the relay +or the bandwidth measured by the bandwidth scanners. +\item \textit{Exit policy summary:} Every entry in a network status +contains a summary version of a relay's exit policy in the line starting +with \verb+p+. +This summary is a list of accepted or rejected ports for exit to most IP +addresses. +\end{itemize} + +\section{Sanitized bridge descriptors} +\label{sec:bridgesan} + +Bridges in the Tor network publish server descriptors to the bridge +authority which in turn generates a bridge network status. +We cannot, however, make the bridge server descriptors and bridge network +statuses available for statistical analysis as we do with the relay server +descriptors and relay network statuses. +The problem is that bridge server descriptors and network statuses contain +bridge IP addresses and other sensitive information that shall not be made +publicly available. +We therefore sanitize bridge descriptors by removing all potentially +identifying information and publish sanitized versions of the descriptors. +The processing steps for sanitizing bridge descriptors are as follows: + +\begin{enumerate} +\item \textit{Replace the bridge identity with its SHA1 value:} Clients +can request a bridge's current descriptor by sending its identity string +to the bridge authority. +This is a feature to make bridges on dynamic IP addresses useful. +Therefore, the original identities (and anything that could be used to +derive them) need to be removed from the descriptors. +The bridge identity is replaced with its SHA1 hash value. +The idea is to have a consistent replacement that remains stable over +months or even years (without keeping a secret for a keyed hash function). +\item \textit{Remove all cryptographic keys and signatures:} It would be +straightforward to learn about the bridge identity from the bridge's +public key. +Replacing keys by newly generated ones seemed to be unnecessary (and would +involve keeping a state over months/years), so that all cryptographic +objects have simply been removed. +\item \textit{Replace IP address with IP address hash:} Of course, the IP +address needs to be removed, too. +It is replaced with \verb+10.x.x.x+ with \verb+x.x.x+ being the 3 byte +output of \verb+H(IP address | bridge identity | secret)[:3]+. +The input \verb+IP address+ is the 4-byte long binary representation of +the bridge's current IP address. +The \verb+bridge identity+ is the 20-byte long binary representation of +the bridge's long-term identity fingerprint. +The \verb+secret+ is a 31-byte long secure random string that changes once +per month for all descriptors and statuses published in that month. +\verb+H()+ is SHA-256. +The \verb+[:3]+ operator means that we pick the 3 most significant bytes +of the result. +\item \textit{Replace contact information:} If there is contact +information in a descriptor, the contact line is changed to +\verb+somebody+. +\item \textit{Replace nickname with Unnamed:} The bridge nicknames might +give hints on the location of the bridge if chosen without care; e.g.\ a +bridge nickname might be very similar to the operators' relay nicknames +which might be located on adjacent IP addresses. +All bridge nicknames are therefore replaced with the string +\verb+Unnamed+. +\end{enumerate} + +Figure~\ref{fig:bridgeserverdesc} shows an example bridge server +descriptor that is referenced from the bridge network status entry in +Figure~\ref{fig:bridgestatusentry}. +For more details about this process, see the bridge descriptor sanitizer +and the metrics database +software.\footnote{\texttt{https://metrics.torproject.org/tools.html}} + +\begin{figure} +\begin{verbatim} +router Unnamed 10.74.150.129 443 0 0 +platform Tor 0.2.2.19-alpha (git-1988927edecce4c7) on Linux i686 +opt protocols Link 1 2 Circuit 1 +published 2010-12-27 18:55:01 +opt fingerprint A5FA 7F38 B02A 415E 72FE 614C 64A1 E5A9 2BA9 9BBD +uptime 2347112 +bandwidth 5242880 10485760 1016594 +opt extra-info-digest 86E6E9E68707AF586FFD09A36FAC236ADA0D11CC +opt hidden-service-dir +contact somebody +reject *:* +\end{verbatim} +\vspace{-1em} +\caption{Sanitized bridge server descriptor} +\label{fig:bridgeserverdesc} +%---------------------------------------------------------------- +\end{figure} + +\begin{figure} +\begin{verbatim} + +r Unnamed pfp/OLAqQV5y/mFMZKHlqSupm70 dByzfWWLas9cen7PtZ3XGYIJHt4 + 2010-12-27 18:55:01 10.74.150.129 443 0 +s Fast Guard HSDir Running Stable Valid +\end{verbatim} +\vspace{-1em} +\caption{Sanitized bridge network status entry} +\label{fig:bridgestatusentry} +%---------------------------------------------------------------- +\end{figure} + +\section{Byte histories} +\label{sec:bytehist} + +Relays include aggregate statistics in their descriptors that they upload +to the directory authorities. +These aggregate statistics are contained in extra-info descriptors that +are published in companion with server descriptors. +Extra-info descriptors are not required for clients to build circuits. +An extra-info descriptor belonging to a server descriptor is referenced by +its SHA1 hash value. + +Byte histories were the first statistical data that relays published about +their usage. +Relays report the number of written and read bytes in 15-minute intervals +throughout the last 24 hours. +The extra-info descriptor in Figure~\ref{fig:extrainfo} contains the byte +histories in the two lines starting with \verb+write-history+ and +\verb+read-history+. +More details about these statistics can be found in the directory protocol +specification~\cite{dirspec}. + +\begin{figure} +\begin{verbatim} +extra-info blutmagie 6297B13A687B521A59C6BD79188A2501EC03A065 +published 2010-12-27 14:35:27 +write-history 2010-12-27 14:34:05 (900 s) 12902389760, + 12902402048,12859373568,12894131200,[...] +read-history 2010-12-27 14:34:05 (900 s) 12770249728,12833485824, + 12661140480,12872439808,[...] +dirreq-write-history 2010-12-27 14:26:13 (900 s) 51731456, + 60808192,56740864,54948864,[...] +dirreq-read-history 2010-12-27 14:26:13 (900 s) 4747264,4767744, + 4511744,4752384,[...] +dirreq-stats-end 2010-12-27 10:51:09 (86400 s) +dirreq-v3-ips us=2000,de=1344,fr=744,kr=712,[...] +dirreq-v2-ips ??=8,au=8,cn=8,cz=8,[...] +dirreq-v3-reqs us=2368,de=1680,kr=1048,fr=800,[...] +dirreq-v2-reqs id=48,??=8,au=8,cn=8,[...] +dirreq-v3-resp ok=12504,not-enough-sigs=0,unavailable=0, + not-found=0,not-modified=0,busy=128 +dirreq-v2-resp ok=64,unavailable=0,not-found=8,not-modified=0, + busy=8 +dirreq-v2-share 1.03% +dirreq-v3-share 1.03% +dirreq-v3-direct-dl complete=316,timeout=4,running=0,min=4649, + d1=36436,d2=68056,q1=76600,d3=87891,d4=131294,md=173579, + d6=229695,d7=294528,q3=332053,d8=376301,d9=530252,max=2129698 +dirreq-v2-direct-dl complete=16,timeout=52,running=0,min=9769, + d1=9769,d2=9844,q1=9981,d3=9981,d4=27297,md=33640,d6=60814, + d7=205884,q3=205884,d8=361137,d9=628256,max=956009 +dirreq-v3-tunneled-dl complete=12088,timeout=92,running=4, + min=534,d1=31351,d2=49166,q1=58490,d3=70774,d4=88192,md=109778, + d6=152389,d7=203435,q3=246377,d8=323837,d9=559237,max=26601000 +dirreq-v2-tunneled-dl complete=0,timeout=0,running=0 +entry-stats-end 2010-12-27 10:51:09 (86400 s) +entry-ips de=11024,us=10672,ir=5936,fr=5040,[...] +exit-stats-end 2010-12-27 10:51:09 (86400 s) +exit-kibibytes-written 80=6758009,443=498987,4000=227483, + 5004=1182656,11000=22767,19371=1428809,31551=8212,41500=965584, + 51413=3772428,56424=1912605,other=175227777 +exit-kibibytes-read 80=197075167,443=5954607,4000=1660990, + 5004=1808563,11000=1893893,19371=130360,31551=7588414, + 41500=756287,51413=2994144,56424=1646509,other=288412366 +exit-streams-opened 80=5095484,443=359256,4000=4508,5004=22288, + 11000=124,19371=24,31551=40,41500=96,51413=16840,56424=28, + other=1970964 +\end{verbatim} +%---------------------------------------------------------------- +\vspace{-1em} +\caption{Extra-info descriptor published by relay \texttt{blutmagie} +(without cryptographic signature and with long lines being truncated)} +\label{fig:extrainfo} +\end{figure} + +\section{Directory requests} + +The directory authorities and directory mirrors report statistical data +about processed directory requests. +Starting with Tor version 0.2.2.15-alpha, all directories report the +number of written and read bytes for answering directory requests. +The format is similar to the format of byte histories as described in the +previous section. +The relevant lines are \verb+dirreq-write-history+ and +\verb+dirreq-read-history+ in Figure~\ref{fig:extrainfo}. +These two lines contain the subset of total read and written bytes that +the directory mirror spent on responding to any kind of directory request, +including network statuses, server descriptors, extra-info descriptors, +authority certificates, etc. + +The directories further report statistics on answering directory requests +for network statuses only. +For Tor versions before 0.2.3.x, relay operators had to manually enable +these statistics, which is why only a few directories report them. +The lines starting with \verb+dirreq-v3-+ all belong to the directory +request statistics (the lines starting with \verb+dirreq-v2-+ report +similar statistics for version 2 of the directory protocol which is +deprecated at the time of writing this report). +The following fields may be relevant for statistical analysis: + +\begin{itemize} +\item \textit{Unique IP addresses:} The numbers in \verb+dirreq-v3-ips+ +denote the unique IP addresses of clients requesting network statuses by +country. +\item \textit{Network status requests:} The numbers in +\verb+dirreq-v3-reqs+ constitute the total network status requests by +country. +\item \textit{Request share:} The percentage in \verb+dirreq-v3-share+ is +an estimate of the share of directory requests that the reporting relay +expects to see in the Tor network. +In \cite{hahn2010privacy} we found that this estimate isn't very useful +for statistical analysis because of the different approaches that clients +take to select directory mirrors. +The fraction of written directory bytes (\verb+dirreq-write-history+) can +be used to derive a better metric for the share of directory requests. +\item \textit{Network status responses:} The directories also report +whether they could provide the requested network status to clients in +\verb+dirreq-v3-resp+. +This information was mostly used to diagnose error rates in version 2 of +the directory protocol where a lot of directories replied to network +status requests with \verb+503 Busy+. +In version 3 of the directory protocol, most responses contain the status +code \verb+200 OK+. +\item \textit{Network status download times:} The line +\verb+dirreq-v3-direct-dl+ contains statistics on the download of network +statuses via the relay's directory port. +The line \verb+dirreq-v3-tunneled-dl+ contains similar statistics on +downloads via a 1-hop circuit between client and directory (which is the +common approach in version 3 of the directory protocol). +Relays report how many requests have been completed, have timed out, and +are still running at the end of a 24-hour time interval as well as the +minimum, maximum, median, quartiles, and deciles of download times. +\end{itemize} +More details about these statistics can be found in the directory protocol +specification~\cite{dirspec}. + +\section{Connecting clients} + +Relays can be configured to report per-country statistics on directly +connecting clients. +This metric includes clients connecting to a relay in order to build +circuits and clients creating a 1-hop circuit to request directory +information. +In practice, the latter number outweighs the former number. +The \verb+entry-ips+ line in Figure~\ref{fig:extrainfo} shows the number +of unique IP addresses connecting to the relay by country. +More details about these statistics can be found in the directory protocol +specification~\cite{dirspec}. + +\section{Bridge users} + +Bridges report statistics on connecting bridge clients in their extra-info +descriptors. +Figure~\ref{fig:bridgeextrainfo} shows a bridge extra-info descriptor +with the bridge user statistics in the \verb+bridge-ips+ line. + +\begin{figure} +\begin{verbatim} +extra-info Unnamed A5FA7F38B02A415E72FE614C64A1E5A92BA99BBD +published 2010-12-27 18:55:01 +write-history 2010-12-27 18:43:50 (900 s) 151712768,176698368, + 180030464,163150848,[...] +read-history 2010-12-27 18:43:50 (900 s) 148109312,172274688, + 172168192,161094656,[...] +bridge-stats-end 2010-12-27 14:56:29 (86400 s) +bridge-ips sa=48,us=40,de=32,ir=32,[...] +\end{verbatim} +\vspace{-1em} +\caption{Sanitized bridge extra-info descriptor} +%---------------------------------------------------------------- +\label{fig:bridgeextrainfo} +\end{figure} + +Bridges running Tor version 0.2.2.3-alpha or earlier report bridge users +in a similar line starting with \verb+geoip-client-origins+. +The reason for switching to \verb+bridge-ips+ was that the measurement +interval in \verb+geoip-client-origins+ had a variable length, whereas the +measurement interval in 0.2.2.4-alpha and later is set to exactly +24~hours. +In order to clearly distinguish the new measurement intervals from the old +ones, the new keywords have been introduced. +More details about these statistics can be found in the directory protocol +specification~\cite{dirspec}. + +\section{Cell-queue statistics} + +Relays can be configured to report aggregate statistics on their cell +queues. +These statistics include average processed cells, average number of queued +cells, and average time that cells spend in circuits. +Circuits are split into deciles based on the number of processed cells. +The statistics are provided for circuit deciles from loudest to quietest +circuits. +Figure~\ref{fig:cellstats} shows the cell statistics contained in an +extra-info descriptor by relay \texttt{gabelmoo}. +An early analysis of cell-queue statistics can be found in +\cite{loesing2009analysis}. +More details about these statistics can be found in the directory protocol +specification~\cite{dirspec}. + +\begin{figure} +\begin{verbatim} +cell-stats-end 2010-12-27 09:59:50 (86400 s) +cell-processed-cells 4563,153,42,15,7,7,6,5,4,2 +cell-queued-cells 9.39,0.98,0.09,0.01,0.00,0.00,0.00,0.01,0.00, + 0.01 +cell-time-in-queue 2248,807,277,92,49,22,52,55,81,148 +cell-circuits-per-decile 7233 +\end{verbatim} +%---------------------------------------------------------------- +\vspace{-1em} +\caption{Cell statistics in extra-info descriptor by relay +\texttt{gabelmoo}} +\label{fig:cellstats} +\end{figure} + +\section{Exit-port statistics} + +Exit relays running Tor version 0.2.1.1-alpha or higher can be configured +to report aggregate statistics on exiting connections. +These relays report the number of opened streams, written and read bytes +by exiting port. +Until version 0.2.2.19-alpha, relays reported all ports exceeding a +threshold of 0.01~\% of all written and read exit bytes. +Starting with version 0.2.2.20-alpha, relays only report the top 10 ports +in exit-port statistics in order not to exceed the maximum extra-info +descriptor length of 50 KB. +Figure~\ref{fig:extrainfo} on page \pageref{fig:extrainfo} contains +exit-port statistics in the lines starting with \verb+exit-+. +More details about these statistics can be found in the directory protocol +specification~\cite{dirspec}. + +\section{Bidirectional connection use} +\label{sec:bidistats} + +Relays running Tor version 0.2.3.1-alpha or higher can be configured to +report what fraction of connections is used uni- or bi-directionally. +Every 10 seconds, relays determine for every connection whether they read +and wrote less than a threshold of 20 KiB. +Connections below this threshold are labeled as ``Below Threshold''. +For the remaining connections, relays report whether they read/wrote at +least 10 times as many bytes as they wrote/read. +If so, they classify a connection as ``Mostly reading'' or ``Mostly +writing,'' respectively. +All other connections are classified as ``Both reading and writing.'' +After classifying connections, read and write counters are reset for the +next 10-second interval. +Statistics are aggregated over 24 hours. +Figure~\ref{fig:connbidirect} shows the bidirectional connection use +statistics in an extra-info descriptor by relay \texttt{zweifaltigkeit}. +The four numbers denote the number of connections ``Below threshold,'' +``Mostly reading,'' ``Mostly writing,'' and ``Both reading and writing.'' +More details about these statistics can be found in the directory protocol +specification~\cite{dirspec}. + +\begin{figure} +\begin{verbatim} +conn-bi-direct 2010-12-28 15:55:11 (86400 s) 387465,45285,55361, + 81786 +\end{verbatim} +%---------------------------------------------------------------- +\vspace{-1em} +\caption{Bidirectional connection use statistic in extra-info descriptor +by relay \texttt{zweifaltigkeit}} +\label{fig:connbidirect} +\end{figure} + +\section{Torperf output files} +\label{sec:torperf} + +Torperf is a little tool that measures Tor's performance as users +experience it. +Torperf uses a trivial SOCKS client to download files of various sizes +over the Tor network and notes how long substeps take. +Torperf can be downloaded from the metrics +website.\footnote{\texttt{https://metrics.torproject.org/tools.html}} + +Torperf can produce two output files: \verb+.data+ and \verb+.extradata+. +The \verb+.data+ file contains timestamps for nine substeps and the byte +summaries for downloading a test file via Tor. +Figure~\ref{fig:torperf} shows an example output of a Torperf run. +The timestamps in the upper part of this output are seconds and +nanoseconds since 1970-01-01 00:00:00.000000. + +Torperf can be configured to write \verb+.extradata+ files by attaching +a Tor controller and writing certain controller events to disk. +The content of a \verb+.extradata+ line is shown in the lower part of +Figure~\ref{fig:torperf}. +The first column indicates if this circuit was actually used to fetch +the data (\verb+ok+) or if Tor chose a different circuit because this +circuit was problematic (\verb+error+). +For every \verb+error+ entry there should be a following \verb+ok+ entry, +unless the network of the Torperf instance is dead or the resource is +unavailable. +The circuit build completion time in the \verb+.extradata+ line is the +time between Torperf sent a SOCKS request and received a SOCKS response in +the \verb+.data+ file. +The three or more hops of the circuit are listed by relay fingerprint and +nickname. +An \verb+=+ sign between the two means that a relay has the \texttt{Named} +flag, whereas the \verb+~+ sign means it doesn't. + +\begin{figure} +\begin{verbatim} +# Timestamps and byte summaries contained in .data files: +1293543301 762678 # Connection process started +1293543301 762704 # After socket is created +1293543301 763074 # After socket is connected +1293543301 763190 # After authentication methods are negotiated + # (SOCKS 5 only) +1293543301 763816 # After SOCKS request is sent +1293543302 901783 # After SOCKS response is received +1293543302 901818 # After HTTP request is written +1293543304 445732 # After first response is received +1293543305 456664 # After payload is complete +75 # Written bytes +51442 # Read bytes + +# Path information contained in .extradata files: +ok # Status code +1293543302 # Circuit build completion time +$2F265B37920BDFE474BF795739978EEFA4427510=fejk4 # 1st hop +$66CA87E164F1CFCE8C3BB5C095217A28578B8BAF=blutmagie3 # 2nd hop +$76997E6557828E8E57F70FDFBD93FB3AA470C620~Amunet8 # 3rd hop +\end{verbatim} +%---------------------------------------------------------------- +\vspace{-1em} +\caption{Torperf output lines for a single request to download a 50~KiB +file (reformatted and annotated with comments)} +\label{fig:torperf} +\end{figure} + +\section{GetTor statistics file} + +GetTor allows users to fetch the Tor software via email. +GetTor keeps internal statistics on the number of packages requested +every day and writes these statistics to a file. +Figure~\ref{fig:gettor} shows the statistics file for December 27, 2010. +The \verb+None+ entry stands for requests that don't ask for a specific +bundle, e.g.\ requests for the bundle list. + +\begin{figure} +\begin{verbatim} +2010-12-27 - None:167 macosx-i386-bundle:0 macosx-ppc-bundle:0 + source-bundle:2 tor-browser-bundle:0 tor-browser-bundle_ar:0 + tor-browser-bundle_de:0 tor-browser-bundle_en:39 + tor-browser-bundle_es:0 tor-browser-bundle_fa:5 + tor-browser-bundle_fr:0 tor-browser-bundle_it:0 + tor-browser-bundle_nl:0 tor-browser-bundle_pl:0 + tor-browser-bundle_pt:0 tor-browser-bundle_ru:0 + tor-browser-bundle_zh_CN:77 tor-im-browser-bundle:0 + tor-im-browser-bundle_ar:0 tor-im-browser-bundle_de:0 + tor-im-browser-bundle_en:1 tor-im-browser-bundle_es:0 + tor-im-browser-bundle_fa:0 tor-im-browser-bundle_fr:0 + tor-im-browser-bundle_it:0 tor-im-browser-bundle_nl:0 + tor-im-browser-bundle_pl:0 tor-im-browser-bundle_pt:0 + tor-im-browser-bundle_ru:0 tor-im-browser-bundle_zh_CN:0 +\end{verbatim} +%---------------------------------------------------------------- +\vspace{-1em} +\caption{GetTor statistics file for December 27, 2010} +\label{fig:gettor} +\end{figure} + +\section{Tor Check exit lists} +\label{sec:exitlist} + +TorDNSEL is an implementation of the active testing, DNS-based exit list +for Tor exit +nodes.\footnote{\texttt{https://www.torproject.org/tordnsel/dist/}} +Tor Check makes the list of known exits and corresponding exit IP +addresses available in a specific format. +Figure~\ref{fig:exitlist} shows an entry of the exit list written on +December 28, 2010 at 15:21:44 UTC. +This entry means that the relay with fingerprint \verb+63Ba..+ which +published a descriptor at 07:35:55 and was contained in a version 2 +network status from 08:10:11 uses two different IP addresses for exiting. +The first address \verb+91.102.152.236+ was found in a test performed at +07:10:30. +When looking at the corresponding server descriptor, one finds that this +is also the IP address on which the relay accepts connections from inside +the Tor network. +A second test performed at 10:35:30 reveals that the relay also uses IP +address \verb+91.102.152.227+ for exiting. + +\begin{figure} +\begin{verbatim} +ExitNode 63BA28370F543D175173E414D5450590D73E22DC +Published 2010-12-28 07:35:55 +LastStatus 2010-12-28 08:10:11 +ExitAddress 91.102.152.236 2010-12-28 07:10:30 +ExitAddress 91.102.152.227 2010-12-28 10:35:30 +\end{verbatim} +\vspace{-1em} +\caption{Exit list entry written on December 28, 2010 at 15:21:44 UTC} +\label{fig:exitlist} +\end{figure} + +\bibliography{data} +\bibliographystyle{plain} + +\end{document} +

1 0

← Newer
1
...
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
...
69
Older →

Jump to page:

2024

2023

2022

2021

2020

2019

2018

2017

2016

2015

2014

2013

2012

2011

tor-commits March 2011