[tor-talk] Fwd: [tor-consensus-health] Possible Sybil Attack

Sebastian G. <bastik.tor> bastik.tor at googlemail.com
Sat Feb 1 12:34:25 UTC 2014


Hello,

the doctor tells me a lot of stuff, like
"not reporting bandwidth scanner results: turtles", what's really
annoying, but he is also telling me the following below.

I saw no talk about this at all, but think there should be at least some
confirmation or statement. It could be a false-alert after all.

There was another possible attack, but I dismissed it. This one is a lot
more obvious.

What's the course of action that is taken by anyone in charge if the
doctor reports someone's potentially messing with the network?

Is there a place where the doctors' diagnostics get confirmed or
declared false-positives?

Best,
Sebastian G. (bastik)


This is what the doctor told me:

[tor-consensus-health] Possible Sybil Attack
doctor at cappadocicum.torproject.org (doctor role account)

Over the last hour [so splitting it up to have them appear in 3 hours
doesn't trigger the alert?] [xx] new relays have appeared. [excerpt]
additions are...

* Unnamed (376B2BA389B9C38D513EB802EA92FB6BBEC3B939)
  Address: 50.7.110.98:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (5DADF53C3D5CF2D3C3C90BE26E1090D337C355A3)
  Address: 50.7.110.85:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (70AF13B9D3F76EE46306218609F82AF5337AB785)
  Address: 50.7.110.101:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (0A7C03D0A99FF8B1D05F32773AEDB1772AA6597A)
  Address: 50.7.110.117:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (E6D4CAD4CE1A09C155B1262A32E9DB990BAFE2D3)
  Address: 50.7.159.36:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (CAD6AD107F0CFFBC8CE8EDD2E237452C35919F11)
  Address: 50.7.159.20:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (5F5D396799614AF1FA94AAA04EB979DDCDAA6A77)
  Address: 50.7.110.91:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (71780CC749CE690FF9E486A3764F5B2A277F3D1C)
  Address: 50.7.110.90:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (1978B237BB37DC66B409AAB3A35D177358408B27)
  Address: 50.7.159.43:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (713AD5E923D9D90D3472022B6FD987B06C2DF8F3)
  Address: 50.7.158.93:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (62ED1808A8DF4451387ABEA2B07A3300AE23A4AC)
  Address: 50.7.159.10:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (FA580C4291EC1CB4A7C559E3A1F9C6FA5EF27201)
  Address: 50.7.159.45:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (DDE9F93043341BDABA100CDEE5D8AAAB535ED66D)
  Address: 50.7.159.35:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (92EBAFFFBDFB1117BD208753FEDDA577BD40B1F6)
  Address: 50.7.110.108:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (B7E1B15E4D8FD1B386046C97F2723BAB7B5ECFD8)
  Address: 50.7.159.11:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (FCB779433AE383011CE8F65E3BEF5A4056969D5B)
  Address: 50.7.159.14:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (6D6666B91305A305F345941461DFA4729D5CC06D)
  Address: 50.7.159.30:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (4A690482DC3BAD0B88BFB9634C4336E1C86A8107)
  Address: 50.7.159.38:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (400E38B2DF803522BDD3C531D07B6E491E522C19)
  Address: 50.7.110.92:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (33044D87463191615C8906B0B7C8C30DA59A0522)
  Address: 50.7.110.114:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (0BB92BB245CE4B97C9162106A7B19C928F151020)
  Address: 50.7.111.10:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (74BF6F272CFCB47CCB054BD25596EFC43AAFB130)
  Address: 50.7.110.84:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (99C4B88D1F917822749429072B07A070E07CAD30)
  Address: 50.7.159.12:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (539FBD959CD324D5C87637BE18397B87528BDB3B)
  Address: 50.7.159.42:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (1AB789EF6C239A2A4C59E31330B17BD141C6507C)
  Address: 50.7.159.22:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (87D4CAD83007CFCE037546D3DCA5E27C250FDF33)
  Address: 50.7.110.102:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (E56EE8C568FCDE5F7CBCE553BE83038625C1F22A)
  Address: 50.7.110.94:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (304C9496D05FB3B8B0FD24C9FB31892EC8611CC7)
  Address: 50.7.159.44:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (CF1594BDA27875650F32EAE055A99C9FFA488333)
  Address: 50.7.110.99:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (7C17AFD019AAA763D502249FB600143680B4BFCE)
  Address: 50.7.110.118:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (7550EC4D4EF0A4E192C00B778383598166F41A7E)
  Address: 50.7.110.109:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (44381AEE0CC7184FD27041035DDFC73D8A50636B)
  Address: 50.7.159.29:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (A53EC0E4A0E2D5C74D5AE8911571EBC8BCD05FC6)
  Address: 50.7.111.11:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (15EBE2E22ADC880A55DFC6F37966570503961625)
  Address: 50.7.159.18:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (424BAB646AD5A5BFFF0AF188B6616433CA50406F)
  Address: 50.7.159.34:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (EE10B29C85CDC5EED2F4D019CB7A69EA93634D5E)
  Address: 50.7.110.86:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (F89A01395B271E37AEC0D4F2EC8A3E1916B2B9FD)
  Address: 50.7.110.106:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (009D5D8CCA78E424D92030A053F77AD6A4073A44)
  Address: 50.7.159.26:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (A9F3C92F952FCFF78C279BDEA9394F247855F2E5)
  Address: 50.7.111.12:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (F76B14389AD9B4C56C707436E41FBE222711ACD7)
  Address: 50.7.158.91:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (ADF33FD9FD63D6527F28AA9B15A646E751A97750)
  Address: 50.7.110.82:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (70EEE743D4DF144365E252E306406FA29B174BC4)
  Address: 50.7.159.13:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (F63F7D19E954800575F57DAA36733E9F40C0E89B)
  Address: 50.7.159.27:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (0EFE5128850B97A4D23BF9E0200DF215AC1B0A77)
  Address: 50.7.158.90:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (5945C4ED531C23921ACE9B8DFFD71513DD4DBB25)
  Address: 50.7.159.46:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (062CC1F79B6643D0E122090EC1DB0F313876149C)
  Address: 50.7.110.115:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (513BB5EB870F86EFF2B6D624A824F9A96C363D74)
  Address: 50.7.110.107:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (055A65A17433A5072BD87AA324DD8BFB1CE444D3)
  Address: 50.7.110.93:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (0BB2C59F3A25AFDB40C5C51F273723F14C9C8BCA)
  Address: 50.7.158.92:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (0591FDFBD2990A163F53D738BA0AC67E3CFD0442)
  Address: 50.7.159.37:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (84BDD91ACAE65B31CA42FF8824A36DE9E3DE751B)
  Address: 50.7.110.83:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (A0306CADEE237E9A3CD766F9858FC73EE8D70CF2)
  Address: 50.7.159.21:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (AB1EFFD77DD75774A386627C3D18DBDE46F40141)
  Address: 50.7.159.28:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (CDB0863D7D8DC5852120ECF5C90211EEB3788430)
  Address: 50.7.110.100:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (EAB807A5EA04D56965028889BF18BE40DB70D492)
  Address: 50.7.159.19:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (E892430D61858177B3FF46E0A4416A93F843F3C9)
  Address: 50.7.111.13:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (E2D3C90D6C6CEEA2F838C257CBB7881456D85FA1)
  Address: 50.7.110.110:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None

* Unnamed (E713726E439A813832DB99095F2E2B529032201D)
  Address: 50.7.110.116:9001
  Version: 0.2.4.18-rc
  Exit Policy: None
_______________________________________________


More information about the tor-talk mailing list