French 3-Strikes Law
Niels Elgaard Larsen
elgaard at agol.dk
Sat Oct 24 10:07:33 UTC 2009
hgiuh ghj wrote:
> > The lack of anonymity will then deter users from committing crimes,
> and make it possible
> > to punish the guilty.
>
> I agree that if something goes wrong, you need to know who is
> responsible because the society needs to know. The problem is this
> system could turn into a kind of "management by terror/pressure", a kind
> of fake freedom: You can do whatever you can, but we will know in a
> second if you do something bad.
Just for the record. You are not agreeing with _me_. I was paraphrasing their flawed argument.
Basically they want to make us collect potential evidence for crimes that have not happened
yet.
> Though, I don't think anonymity will decide someone to commit a crime or
> not, it's just easier. It's not because you can you have to do it. The
> point is if it happens, we (the society) need to find someone to sustain
> its structure.
>
> > > The law isn't about country-based content filtering. To put it in a
> nutshell you can
> > > still do what you want with your internet access and the
> connections aren't restricted,
> > > but if they prove you share/download copyrighted content (mostly
> via P2P, they didn't care
> > > about streaming), you could be disconnected after 2 warnings.
> >
> > Except they do not have to actually prove it.
>
> This is the darkest point, they just have to say you did something wrong
> without tell you why and the guiltiness criteria aren't defined. Plus,
> how does a newbie could be find guilty to use WEP instead of WPA ?
>
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------
> Nouveau! Découvrez le Windows phone Samsung Omnia II disponible chez
> SFR. Cliquez ici <http://clk.atdmt.com/FRM/go/175819072/direct/01/>
***********************************************************************
To unsubscribe, send an e-mail to majordomo at torproject.org with
unsubscribe or-talk in the body. http://archives.seul.org/or/talk/
More information about the tor-talk
mailing list