[tor-relays] pinning relay keys to IPs (or not)

[nusenu]

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA512

Roger Dingledine:
> I wonder how many guards shift location significantly across the
> Internet, and how often?

For simplicity lets define 'significantly' as 'guard changed its AS'.

Taking into account data starting from first of July. There were 54
relays with the guard flag with more than one distinct AS, *but* a
manual glance on the data suggests that 30-35 of them can be ignored
(false positive) due to changes introduced by onionoo's geoip update
(where a lot of IPs changed their AS form IANA to Digital Ocean). Then
there are a few ISPs with multiple AS numbers (like Digital Ocean and
PlusServer) and ~10 of the relays are linked by Roman (according to
their contactinfo).

So nothing to worry about to much I guess.
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
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=5S3c
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----