[tor-relays] GoodBadISPs revamp?

[Thomas White]

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

I fully agree. I proposed a while back to try work on sortable tables
and to make the entire thing table based with factual information and
then have a column for anecdotal comments.

As a community I think we should also be more transparent in
communications with the ISP's in question. For example, rather than
stating a yes/no instead we find a tidy way to paste their exact
response and link it in the table so we know exactly who they talked
to, waht their question was and the reason they disallowed it.

I believe Moritz also has a private list which may be more up to date
than the GoodBadISP list (second hand information, I'll wait for his
chime on this) which we could merge.

On the thoughts of community feedback, the work of approaching
companies right now is limited to time. I think the cover letter to
ISP's could do with a revamp and made more clear where it is so people
can use it to save them having to write their own. If people know
their is a standard cover letter that they can use, they may be more
inclined to share their results.

Anyone with access to create a new page on the list and we can add
subsections to a new page containing the dated responses from each
company on their policy towards Tor hosting.

- -T

On 13/10/2014 01:56, subkeys at riseup.net wrote:
> [cross-posted on tor-talk and tor-relays]
> 
> i've found that the Tor GoodBadISPs list [1] is somewhat outdated
> on current hosts that allow Tor (exit) relays to be hosted. i'm
> trying to find a cheap host that allows exits to be operated from
> their services, and navigating the outdated list and finding an
> operator that isn't extremely expensive is time consuming (some
> entries go back to 2010!).
> 
> should the community start a revamp project (or start a whole new
> list)? i'd be willing to donate my time to help get this started if
> need be.
> 
> thanks. ---- mikael ball 0xB1910271AE8587F4 @subkeys
> 
> [1]: https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/wiki/doc/GoodBadISPs
> 
> _______________________________________________ tor-relays mailing
> list tor-relays at lists.torproject.org 
> https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-relays
> 
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v2.0.22 (MingW32)
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=fJdL
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----