[tor-dev] Can we stop sanitizing nicknames in bridge descriptors?

Sebastian G. <bastik.tor> bastik.tor at googlemail.com
Sat May 19 09:41:22 UTC 2012


Karsten Loesing, 16.05.2012 08:47:
> On 5/2/12 2:30 PM, Karsten Loesing wrote:
>> If nobody objects within the next, say, two weeks, I'm going to make an
>> old tarball from 2008 available with original nicknames.  And if nobody
>> screams, I'll provide the remaining tarballs containing original
>> nicknames another two weeks later.
> 
> Here we go.  These are the sanitized bridge descriptors from May 2008
> including original bridge nicknames:
> 
> http://freehaven.net/~karsten/volatile/bridges-2008-05-nicknames.tar.bz2
> 

Here we go with the similarities of bridge and relay nicknames. While
some are sharing names, some seem to share a naming scheme and others
could be run by the same person on an adjacent IP address.

Attached you'll see "findings.txt", which contains a bridge line,
followed by a relay line, followed by a comment line.

Each should be in another line. Windows and Linux users should see the
same as LF (Linefeed) and CR are included. That might be a problem for
other files I might release as some contain LF only, which is for Linux
and will be understood by a proper notepad even on Windows. When no one
objects I'm going to release them somewhere else, so it's possible to
check my way of doing things.

I'm not good in time tracking, but spend approx. 4-5 hours on processing
the tarballs to get the lists of names for both relays and bridges.

Shortly after I agreed to do this, I downloaded the relay tarball and
started to figure out how I would get only what I needed. After I did
that I waited for the bridge tarball and did the same to it.

Simply because I know the things I did I assume that it will be possible
to do that quicker. With other tools it might be faster. I assume it
would be much faster, when processing the tarballs could be done by a
script. Unfortunately I'm not capable of doing so.

The comparison was done manually, but I'm sure a algorithm would have
found most of the similarities anyway. I took the list of bridge names
and compared it to the list of relay names. I looked for and included
exact matches and close similarities. After that there wasn't much left
to look for on the bridge list. I looked a each bridge name and guessed
what it could be. I searched the Internet on them. I may have found
something that isn't based on a naming scheme, but can be linked in
other ways.

The worst part was to put the lines together. I underestimated the time
the plain comparison would take, but copying the lines into findings.txt
took longer as I would have imagined. I'm not sure if my provided data
are the best in how I put the lines together.

The nicest part, even if it was time consuming, was to look for other
things that could link relay and bridge names together. It wasn't as
successful as I hoped, but it was fun. Maybe because I like the universe
and mythology, which may influenced the findings to a higher degree as
useful.

The last part could be done by a script as well. It would have to look
for a bridge name in a list "moons" and when it finds one, it has to
compare the list "moons" against the relay list to find a relay that's
in the "moons" list. Of course with many lists like "freedom activists".

The comparison, including copying the line together took approx. 08-10
hours. I really expected much less as I saw the relay names.

The total time spent was 12-15 hours. I assume that this can be reduced
by using scripts and or tools with are designed to do parts of the job.

This mail is getting far too long, so all I'm going to say is that I'm
looking forward to the results.

Best regards,
bastik_tor
-------------- next part --------------
// bridge line
// relay line
// comment on why the are included or crap
000111222 DbYYYzZXHkyi/WEMI260OA0mG3g k0FtE4ZLroMUJ1KJQZlzmRpuI1s 2008-05-31 10:56:15 10.105.220.220 443 0
000111222 TdGDCy1m4Qc82IP0JqC0ro2KI3M sN/GljDnhJPSAUAEKvXPIs1KFRE 2008-05-31 11:03:22 217.98.8.46 443 9030
// same name
b0fhinukraine IMkYG6/gbSwcS2slwyCq0c5WJYU +cGsQipv2JKMe+NsJ7ievqwP9ic 2008-05-19 06:54:30 10.88.44.181 19001 0
b0 raWOeMmMZseG3FU+fhj8EvXAStw 8eHYtz7p3ALnEjqwDKliMwjuClc 2008-05-29 20:11:48 89.163.144.173 9050 0
// same begin
bizdira i0JM+or4ayGZXe99Im5UNooVFvA R9jNXFZyQaCT1ZjNohC5YOdro24 2008-05-31 16:39:53 10.30.43.220 443 9030
bizdira JRalaVbeXhSTQrdS0SQcT4nQz3U OufYXA6p3j3A0Qol9ifpaHE7d5M 2008-05-31 17:12:47 85.186.0.198 443 9030
// same name
BRETTSTORNODE EAjuUKRyHXfset2CQhvyKHHJ3L0 l4/hYZwNCCateCqTvOHmfGTaXbQ 2008-05-19 18:12:35 10.56.251.78 443 0
BRETTSTORNODE /fhMOwdlj8Tzn/EfrNl6cTU/l68 0h1rPobT19hcGsr/qYjknkiLqkA 2008-05-25 14:17:18 75.61.13.156 443 9030
// same name
BRETTSTORNODE UxU39wODFtrO0avFHSkmUwQG/m0 7jV4TMYUQ8OgIQO5zXVV9+JheXY 2008-05-19 17:56:14 10.134.201.236 443 0
BRETTSTORNODE GqT/BD29CdRb8TtkwMfpPpXs7ic deOQ0Qvw+t0i4bc6fHO2GPTEQcI 2008-05-04 20:44:32 66.142.232.219 443 9030
// same name
BRETTSTORNODE EAjuUKRyHXfset2CQhvyKHHJ3L0 l4/hYZwNCCateCqTvOHmfGTaXbQ 2008-05-19 18:12:35 10.56.251.78 443 0
BRETTSTORNODE Sn6IFSrEd9TjQXM3PVMV/6wgtZU 0dLSm3kiYwsa4NxD34h3qQRJujo 2008-05-15 19:00:05 70.230.253.218 443 9030
// same name
BRETTSTORNODE UxU39wODFtrO0avFHSkmUwQG/m0 7jV4TMYUQ8OgIQO5zXVV9+JheXY 2008-05-19 17:56:14 10.134.201.236 443 0
BRETTSTORNODE Sn6IFSrEd9TjQXM3PVMV/6wgtZU 0dLSm3kiYwsa4NxD34h3qQRJujo 2008-05-15 19:00:05 70.230.253.218 443 9030
// same name; I would scan all of them; the relay IPs are spread, but maybe bridges are "nearby"
caccabau 3ZDYlF1fEGpxoNRzWzhBe/LOMqo JhhzvVy/7Zc79z9FXp/OAUjHj/Y 2008-05-29 21:59:57 10.164.171.252 80 0
caccabau icAYqMV5buaWhg5woEsHot3Jfu4 gHLGqHeh+JDt5K+ZAgE81KCobWU 2008-05-29 21:30:06 151.77.127.117 443 9030
// same name
carlos O4+S2P86Dcs2/pG9UuWeE3/hby0 691PW30tkvj4XsTES0EHJGMnyXo 2008-05-28 07:07:08 10.146.163.39 9001 0
carlos obEVDS4hN1CWhbUu4piQ/FLOLr4 4c8wXSt2REX1/J+f12MxP5aOtPQ 2008-05-28 07:52:30 189.24.4.71 9001 0
// same name; repeated with different IPs; included only that from the same date; looks like a test
cypherpunk Unt3TEcS/rz6WXNxZHQkMcPtXQM 2bkMBQpb4HmSC+SHmthTQVVRrc8 2008-05-18 16:06:29 10.192.113.121 9001 0
cyberphunk 4oV4MAaxtxk7KWpchYuV/YVWamA /3jKj1XeTFtLEhqyeBFaWB+bmf0 2008-05-19 07:38:19 85.31.187.212 9001 9030
// close to each other
dejitaru VIOZpGIivTOQ0Y38pc3c/JbBZyI CN09JlpmyrwpzFvZmfG0tN2Mh1A 2008-05-27 17:59:25 10.88.5.91 443 0
dejitaru JqFZyEAGX2Gv+J7t9Y9zLjc8HPE 0SUgAU6ipDvxioc/rtziamn1vgk 2008-05-30 13:10:09 24.129.17.163 443 0
// same name
enigma 9V4glfQlqyw7EW43svzTosoTGJg WmkP2Mw+VaOU0amLxV1MASYTCas 2008-05-19 02:55:39 10.193.96.172 443 0
enigma SovBDOXd8Fo+B47+VKqynK6QT90 /AMNYGZTD3UvLWjMvjNWbaIV2tI 2008-05-05 05:54:51 87.104.5.150 443 9030
// same name
enigma osjxxV8Tti7DZafTXY0kX++fdKg /QJ+Foke8OOIuSdk0cwZzCyvHDU 2008-05-31 21:22:18 10.247.154.7 443 0
enigma SovBDOXd8Fo+B47+VKqynK6QT90 /AMNYGZTD3UvLWjMvjNWbaIV2tI 2008-05-05 05:54:51 87.104.5.150 443 9030
// same name
enigma 9V4glfQlqyw7EW43svzTosoTGJg WmkP2Mw+VaOU0amLxV1MASYTCas 2008-05-19 02:55:39 10.193.96.172 443 0
ENIGMA oCPVTtLVe9i2EHXTV1RISaDk+RU j27LyKiXmVgG3XX6Bce5/5CpEe0 2008-05-15 20:10:03 91.192.167.102 443 9030
// case
enigma osjxxV8Tti7DZafTXY0kX++fdKg /QJ+Foke8OOIuSdk0cwZzCyvHDU 2008-05-31 21:22:18 10.247.154.7 443 0
ENIGMA oCPVTtLVe9i2EHXTV1RISaDk+RU j27LyKiXmVgG3XX6Bce5/5CpEe0 2008-05-15 20:10:03 91.192.167.102 443 9030
// case
entscheubler2 jX07H8RG6vXhleIILnUqUA0QKsQ +scmF5J4bV9D/V+3/daGf8kkfj4 2008-05-24 22:12:38 10.66.9.192 9002 0
Entschaeubler 1oviNd8ABf22isYT++uhW1+RqH0 FmV2jIXDB+IPscukktNyac1gGGM 2008-05-22 21:38:10 77.188.215.2 9001 0
// close
entscheubler2 jX07H8RG6vXhleIILnUqUA0QKsQ +scmF5J4bV9D/V+3/daGf8kkfj4 2008-05-24 22:12:38 10.66.9.192 9002 0
Entschaeubler 1oviNd8ABf22isYT++uhW1+RqH0 wezqS/lmwtFQXVOmP89PcIgxtnA 2008-05-17 06:39:01 77.188.175.105 9001 9030
// close
Fake oB+ud5o/pj9zVcR1baJ1khxjhR0 SMe3I24H8kINu6+C0Vn+ji+8Yu4 2008-05-28 18:06:48 10.247.165.191 443 9030
Fake mLF4sxdGoohdfPe8pexJkl5CF7g QwKa5/UtgRXXXg5OZRM2bf45sxo 2008-05-28 18:07:22 81.167.202.20 443 9030
// same name
Furytear GIDwADG7lAZLoT3kXJN8YttrHmc 1EjGfm2AQotEJbmx/KY4M1rAzq4 2008-05-24 02:20:19 10.45.22.48 236 0
Furytear jEB3B+BnTZBqtfp6Tqe54m1Vlg4 2kbNnZK9pvme0OLx6GF6XsSw1QM 2008-05-04 19:44:50 68.60.183.192 236 9030
// same name
gromeo 1R16GthOOJrrK3AwRKcueksgS1E FDtRZ6lt338hcS3FjmBsajyCUXY 2008-05-17 21:50:38 10.151.216.16 443 9030
gromeo tovPMHEr+gOltlx6XOxnlakFDJU MAae3Qb8upfkkIDN2gMBx0WJX60 2008-05-17 21:33:14 77.70.68.145 443 9030
// same name, looks like a test
home drFLZ2mbeEytppKpJoNKRHiZBfY 3fY50xhKlE0cYSyQdZbHpwDP7vQ 2008-05-17 07:24:42 10.247.73.184 443 0
home yX80qvzdCwurlIqclnTpo4NX3C0 mdOWimhRjTvrty7niyn3YL8TfC4 2008-05-22 12:40:51 92.227.19.90 9001 0
// same name, relay with stable IP, bridge not, I never carred about that, including them
home drFLZ2mbeEytppKpJoNKRHiZBfY 3fY50xhKlE0cYSyQdZbHpwDP7vQ 2008-05-17 07:24:42 10.247.73.184 443 0
home04f0186cc8 Or5ZlOr6mlUgGBxuuAwH6ILqlPE O4wzsfr1YGi5tjpy5J5sobiZbCA 2008-05-14 16:52:36 89.165.69.23 9001 0
// close?, not really, false alarm
homer ut3xL3ZkV4xhFE2EwUoB0djfOCo /q12alUiP2maNo1C4azRN/ZeDfY 2008-05-30 01:09:23 10.205.207.137 9001 0
homer rsm0B6uHdMmnCnzvG3J21g5jLys 1jopqve9F48WUuRkFC1cSi8Xwoc 2008-05-31 14:39:31 84.244.189.19 9001 0
// same name, looks stable
ididnteditheconfig RWH5Mr4vL5a4XS3xD7651WjnvLM 1CHhxlwMgp/Gnufsx9PaEQwuPLk 2008-05-29 05:25:06 10.51.175.120 9001 0
iddteitecnfg333121 HFwzxTurDQA5i0H8jSLwApxVbv4 xpMRTTTHtnSW/+2t4XJqmca/c3s 2008-04-30 20:45:04 90.146.195.22 9001 0
// appears to have something, maybe it's just me
ididnteditheconfig RWH5Mr4vL5a4XS3xD7651WjnvLM 1CHhxlwMgp/Gnufsx9PaEQwuPLk 2008-05-29 05:25:06 10.51.175.120 9001 0
ididntediconfig 6RhPwakD/0WJMEsO2801vvFfG3I +Sk8KAuzBwpQMRjvAmpeNKg5F5I 2008-05-10 03:03:15 89.27.211.191 443 0
// somewhat close, right?
ididnteditheconfig RWH5Mr4vL5a4XS3xD7651WjnvLM 1CHhxlwMgp/Gnufsx9PaEQwuPLk 2008-05-29 05:25:06 10.51.175.120 9001 0
ididconfigureit ShRMnaLHt1tHD1NkMA5AHuulXhE /WKz6lI0SoS3Hbek/0t8cwbe9gE 2008-05-04 11:17:17 76.1.244.12 9001 0
// could be one solid naming scheme
ididnteditheconfig RWH5Mr4vL5a4XS3xD7651WjnvLM 1CHhxlwMgp/Gnufsx9PaEQwuPLk 2008-05-29 05:25:06 10.51.175.120 9001 0
ididediconfigtphhhh KQVPQuW3BGUPmdy2rC5z0ZO+6hQ 001fAP3r5B4A0RglRYZXtuhH3Lw 2008-05-23 16:01:44 71.43.196.173 9001 0
// "I didn't" could be common
ididnteditheconfig RWH5Mr4vL5a4XS3xD7651WjnvLM 1CHhxlwMgp/Gnufsx9PaEQwuPLk 2008-05-29 05:25:06 10.51.175.120 9001 0
idideditheconfig +FjCRqL/S9k8fkllZFdkWDxQHQY +8ZCt0z6v0CbKCt4cfO8TU1lud8 2008-05-10 16:52:24 78.52.132.111 9001 0
// could all be accident
ididnteditheconfig RWH5Mr4vL5a4XS3xD7651WjnvLM 1CHhxlwMgp/Gnufsx9PaEQwuPLk 2008-05-29 05:25:06 10.51.175.120 9001 0
idideditheconfig AEMsAoTbQkCS4gNDYECg+JTv0JQ 167YJ4Bg/XpOgXdkYnlk1MoFfLk 2008-05-09 17:41:15 87.123.81.104 9001 0
// other IP range
ididnteditheconfig RWH5Mr4vL5a4XS3xD7651WjnvLM 1CHhxlwMgp/Gnufsx9PaEQwuPLk 2008-05-29 05:25:06 10.51.175.120 9001 0
iDIDeditheconfig hqQqX9lxkxlyFLfhor4faVqBvbQ 0UIKTgE8VgC7IDiF2wqaGJCCMxs 2008-05-04 12:26:44 207.172.90.28 7009 0
// who knows
ididnteditheconfig RWH5Mr4vL5a4XS3xD7651WjnvLM 1CHhxlwMgp/Gnufsx9PaEQwuPLk 2008-05-29 05:25:06 10.51.175.120 9001 0
idideditheconfig249 sRN+91G4RnIASJnZusuoW7kvAiM 0bKoGMiXl79gCQ1NQXRqPo1t8RE 2008-05-04 05:03:24 82.6.101.217 9001 0
// I did and I didn't, don't know.
ididnteditheconfig RWH5Mr4vL5a4XS3xD7651WjnvLM 1CHhxlwMgp/Gnufsx9PaEQwuPLk 2008-05-29 05:25:06 10.51.175.120 9001 0
idideditit qcNOQp2rYeHGK723IrMTlU0xsaQ gP8Iin6OfrBqyh91z3eSSGetnQA 2008-05-28 15:58:30 212.202.35.120 59001 0
// yes you edit it
ididnteditheconfig RWH5Mr4vL5a4XS3xD7651WjnvLM 1CHhxlwMgp/Gnufsx9PaEQwuPLk 2008-05-29 05:25:06 10.51.175.120 9001 0
ididedittheconfig ywGdVZLPpOV6UfzN5hcK5FENK0Y ++LBGQrkGQrQ9w6hgnIjiowYG+Y 2008-05-30 21:04:12 74.166.30.140 8500 0
// you probably guess it
ididnteditheconfig RWH5Mr4vL5a4XS3xD7651WjnvLM 1CHhxlwMgp/Gnufsx9PaEQwuPLk 2008-05-29 05:25:06 10.51.175.120 9001 0
ididnt nKFiTrkWknidTc6e/BtRZwpTh8A N/qR3XEutgXqqQAreywnpEuEi9o 2008-05-19 00:32:03 24.147.203.84 9001 9030
// wild guess
ididnteditheconfig RWH5Mr4vL5a4XS3xD7651WjnvLM 1CHhxlwMgp/Gnufsx9PaEQwuPLk 2008-05-29 05:25:06 10.51.175.120 9001 0
ididnt3dith3config 0ouf+FWRExK3r42ifyFEW02intE TbiiTNJHO1bwauypkyU4TB4BXEI 2008-05-25 21:47:53 92.114.190.74 9001 0
// no that isn't similar the second contains numbers ;)
ididnteditheconfig RWH5Mr4vL5a4XS3xD7651WjnvLM 1CHhxlwMgp/Gnufsx9PaEQwuPLk 2008-05-29 05:25:06 10.51.175.120 9001 0
ididntdoit bH5ae6Wcsm3Bbs/P7tYmB4VuUms FDODy2ZleAqsMXWIVD28GOtkjaM 2008-05-18 19:08:11 24.147.203.84 9001 0
// Simpsons or similar?
ididnteditheconfig RWH5Mr4vL5a4XS3xD7651WjnvLM 1CHhxlwMgp/Gnufsx9PaEQwuPLk 2008-05-29 05:25:06 10.51.175.120 9001 0
ididnteditheconfig /AT4FsvIrazqItkK+RscQzLp3mY /wE9JeKM9X0haVxqYoEwrfcUhf0 2008-05-25 10:50:48 219.153.203.81 9001 0
// exact match
ididnteditheconfig RWH5Mr4vL5a4XS3xD7651WjnvLM 1CHhxlwMgp/Gnufsx9PaEQwuPLk 2008-05-29 05:25:06 10.51.175.120 9001 0
ididnteditheconfig /AT4FsvIrazqItkK+RscQzLp3mY 9uCRi2Skv6yTE1H4b7RMjHzRqAM 2008-05-27 14:06:42 222.183.170.82 9001 0
// exact match, different IP
ididnteditheconfig RWH5Mr4vL5a4XS3xD7651WjnvLM 1CHhxlwMgp/Gnufsx9PaEQwuPLk 2008-05-29 05:25:06 10.51.175.120 9001 0
ididnteditheconfig 39LsbhRsjp+kLU2Ar+RJgUv3sIs /nWGRFgz14AaYy5HcJbqSvxrWFc 2008-05-07 08:33:14 72.44.48.202 9001 0
// a stable naming scheme, exact match, different IP
ididnteditheconfig RWH5Mr4vL5a4XS3xD7651WjnvLM 1CHhxlwMgp/Gnufsx9PaEQwuPLk 2008-05-29 05:25:06 10.51.175.120 9001 0
ididnteditheconfig 4glwYDuhxg5GLAS890OCUf9WHmc 4JYljfawK2oC0hepzFux/5qJudQ 2008-05-08 17:52:28 121.32.20.196 9001 0
// rock solid scheme and only one bridge that might be in there
ididnteditheconfig RWH5Mr4vL5a4XS3xD7651WjnvLM 1CHhxlwMgp/Gnufsx9PaEQwuPLk 2008-05-29 05:25:06 10.51.175.120 9001 0
ididnteditheconfig 4glwYDuhxg5GLAS890OCUf9WHmc 9GgHKjASiXZWdm/E/2Mc4EBVA1E 2008-05-21 14:01:11 116.22.51.3 9001 0
// so many of them
ididnteditheconfig RWH5Mr4vL5a4XS3xD7651WjnvLM 1CHhxlwMgp/Gnufsx9PaEQwuPLk 2008-05-29 05:25:06 10.51.175.120 9001 0
ididnteditheconfig 4glwYDuhxg5GLAS890OCUf9WHmc aZhuvabJxMUiMmDYHhWrqj7lNnY 2008-05-09 18:27:03 58.63.36.117 9001 0
// and so many different IPs
ididnteditheconfig RWH5Mr4vL5a4XS3xD7651WjnvLM 1CHhxlwMgp/Gnufsx9PaEQwuPLk 2008-05-29 05:25:06 10.51.175.120 9001 0
ididnteditheconfig 4glwYDuhxg5GLAS890OCUf9WHmc c0vjSDr/7VaZBI6H9/BQB+TTlJ0 2008-05-04 14:10:06 61.140.101.173 9001 0
// I guess, just name is repeated over and over again, but the bridge is located anywhere
ididnteditheconfig RWH5Mr4vL5a4XS3xD7651WjnvLM 1CHhxlwMgp/Gnufsx9PaEQwuPLk 2008-05-29 05:25:06 10.51.175.120 9001 0
ididnteditheconfig 4glwYDuhxg5GLAS890OCUf9WHmc HGAEdVXpQgpshsTGbayRgR/giuw 2008-05-09 08:11:35 58.63.36.117 9001 0
// so far so good
ididnteditheconfig RWH5Mr4vL5a4XS3xD7651WjnvLM 1CHhxlwMgp/Gnufsx9PaEQwuPLk 2008-05-29 05:25:06 10.51.175.120 9001 0
ididnteditheconfig 9VTlTxIDcFLczNsJKZx/XRSIUMo WVPkR7wAD7DDYv7l/jLWvRvrCPQ 2008-05-25 19:54:38 84.249.34.89 9921 0
// or so worse
ididnteditheconfig RWH5Mr4vL5a4XS3xD7651WjnvLM 1CHhxlwMgp/Gnufsx9PaEQwuPLk 2008-05-29 05:25:06 10.51.175.120 9001 0
ididnteditheconfig b9gVbH5/VW7X78xEmGBfLY4hTck gKXgTBpbnqTk32Rcxebyi+t72aI 2008-05-28 14:29:17 125.82.137.212 9001 0
// scanning the whole IPv4 space
ididnteditheconfig RWH5Mr4vL5a4XS3xD7651WjnvLM 1CHhxlwMgp/Gnufsx9PaEQwuPLk 2008-05-29 05:25:06 10.51.175.120 9001 0
ididnteditheconfig h8VOaEvcchjoMbwVifllyJZ+U+A 0jFX+Gii16grmhuiY3R0m2Tc2yk 2008-05-19 11:56:43 62.169.225.127 9001 0
// OK
ididnteditheconfig RWH5Mr4vL5a4XS3xD7651WjnvLM 1CHhxlwMgp/Gnufsx9PaEQwuPLk 2008-05-29 05:25:06 10.51.175.120 9001 0
ididnteditheconfig HU/AKsix109Wxizm3ufkgCXhbsU /VCMygDXeOVf4jk75a7dUGYwQ6s 2008-05-04 05:37:26 68.61.156.176 443 80
// and that's just brigde to find
ididnteditheconfig RWH5Mr4vL5a4XS3xD7651WjnvLM 1CHhxlwMgp/Gnufsx9PaEQwuPLk 2008-05-29 05:25:06 10.51.175.120 9001 0
ididnteditheconfig IN4ivRSkZ75RFz87aL3cAteJ4JU +ly66RcrAfYshD1ywwNvFj0TXkY 2008-05-27 20:46:59 85.176.228.111 9001 0
// relay IPs are not located nearby
ididnteditheconfig RWH5Mr4vL5a4XS3xD7651WjnvLM 1CHhxlwMgp/Gnufsx9PaEQwuPLk 2008-05-29 05:25:06 10.51.175.120 9001 0
ididnteditheconfig IN4ivRSkZ75RFz87aL3cAteJ4JU 5NWRkw+ygy5hkmo1ouGEaKJC0pc 2008-05-28 13:13:14 92.229.220.152 9001 0
// how many are out there?
ididnteditheconfig RWH5Mr4vL5a4XS3xD7651WjnvLM 1CHhxlwMgp/Gnufsx9PaEQwuPLk 2008-05-29 05:25:06 10.51.175.120 9001 0
ididnteditheconfig iWrVMlcpQ8W1TlUS9KATzhWa7Sw 501FZ+mXrz6uXYqEzrQrpMTWXNs 2008-05-08 04:00:57 87.230.6.32 9001 0
// I guess I missed some, I may lost track
ididnteditheconfig RWH5Mr4vL5a4XS3xD7651WjnvLM 1CHhxlwMgp/Gnufsx9PaEQwuPLk 2008-05-29 05:25:06 10.51.175.120 9001 0
ididnteditheconfig lQQaPzP/Dc5EAIJix7gRaYl5WQo +LlW/7CtKmkqMR+igo/XSU/+ZlI 2008-05-09 07:30:03 77.126.203.163 9001 9030
// That's enough... I don't know if that's worth it from an adversary perspective
ididnteditheconfig RWH5Mr4vL5a4XS3xD7651WjnvLM 1CHhxlwMgp/Gnufsx9PaEQwuPLk 2008-05-29 05:25:06 10.51.175.120 9001 0
ididntelitheconfig ivgHSZ5R0X+Vbcjhi3faNyjmwao OfiocWcu17VDrOceQOwqDtGFRxw 2008-05-21 21:05:00 70.135.17.43 9001 0
// close enough
ignisfire TOkuvkl9PdEoO6s3GbA4PZeQuMM UG/hUOTGilJOz/rpteuolyOs6J8 2008-05-19 14:41:33 10.160.115.181 443 9030
ignisfire 2webITOrXAmNDuq7vynM6dOS11Q 9X7e1cJsp8yOWRY+D5kQlQIf+Rk 2008-05-19 15:38:16 151.33.84.31 443 9030
// same name
Ignisfire gmW0pJ8h0Zzz5YaCwkaUKCBymjg Y25IOvBd0SOUTanyJzRmvO1oceQ 2008-05-20 21:03:54 10.109.127.100 443 0
Ignisfire 8DYosEaQ8aj2WoL+wsPMWTlVrgk dsn5WM0lVD5EoXDnx4ldgSDKExY 2008-05-19 16:49:08 151.33.84.31 443 0
// same name
iseeipaddresses 7KDECYq/a5CCzLYGnYKh0wtFgWg 7MKHsuHPGHeaPlWzZycR0gyAzDc 2008-05-31 05:36:13 10.137.212.47 9001 9030
iseeipaddresses P2FDMcRZOOMt1dJyEzWGMfppFXw InB85ibD3reNojKieWsAzRzHQDY 2008-05-31 05:45:13 72.155.162.157 9001 9030
// looks like a test
Lurkov JbqrAHpt8rJWLuVCqnm60O2IqJQ GCk4Z9vxvgSWDECqAIHxpeap0f8 2008-05-18 06:41:58 10.209.19.129 9001 9030
Lurkov JGgwJPPbk/fs8AIHSSSlr9UBCNo 0J+rn1dy+e6nP5fnBstPK9QbqpU 2008-05-19 14:27:42 221.219.191.43 9001 9030
// same name
mfr Lrr/frpkzP9Ow4lSCiJnYVgORKU K3qDPGVzrORlFFtExvup/P77Odg 2008-05-26 06:32:04 10.195.46.58 9001 9030
mfr Z2KrJlfsXYm+P8RLgmBRZhIZZSo bIR3HeByhGpzAEzMB9KNpOvr5oo 2008-05-26 16:16:52 92.243.5.105 9001 9030
// same name
NanashiSan Y/PadgInIeW5ZBNivD+ZUq2fTQg 2ACgAMyKnLUc1YPHIpBtBmcZ4v4 2008-05-24 09:15:40 10.217.57.39 22774 0
NanashiSan 6wMm6vTuPU4Ybrl98tGONyay978 zUJ2UnOkx9fc06wYwvTKYrLBo5Y 2008-05-24 15:33:10 123.227.158.39 27743 23774
// same name
nobody g4/WlcQY19k/2d6iXmumT288Mns 3MSaHC4dGi1TRvJmDpzGB2sMqdc 2008-05-31 09:37:33 10.3.112.251 443 0
nobody d6y4xrfuHYN7CUDNpMNmSN+wKXY djzG/GMuBLe6Vah+kb6C2rMU5bY 2008-05-31 09:58:13 77.70.68.145 443 9030
// same name, but anybody is nobody
NoHarm IVc0Sa2j6hBTjCCEPMZTBJUkUPA 2Yguf3pFQ1bR/A2iX9usm5ukeHY 2008-05-19 13:16:59 10.141.2.152 443 0
NoHarm JJh4B5lcdpoADNHQ1bSz44ytzEc TvBCjQ6xEtFTkfnhLrcWHKOhmBY 2008-05-14 08:04:11 83.249.73.43 443 9030
// same name
Pluto m0ZtFHVXStckR93u7R1r20wo45k eWpkdgDTV6ArNeqFM0Cm42HUX/U 2008-05-31 06:33:13 10.23.136.248 443 9030
Pluto E9q4XHyznQ0+rDl382AKOuywqms n/y3JttUhr8kO/LrWENgU06a3cg 2008-05-30 05:33:43 213.22.34.228 443 9030
// same name
PooRNooB nv1GjJCNCWTYd/gXg9/8tpauWNM HIp5FDT5UJ1j3zPYxEuKdYpv3Js 2008-05-21 07:50:13 10.88.52.48 443 0
PooRNooB 8eiAC6ghgaB3/VsorNmtxgriBp4 ay6JOTNKfIrRkOZTmjHorlRo5JE 2008-05-21 08:44:56 201.58.23.127 443 9030
// same name
pr0b3y7h32nd aHgCbpYET9gk5QOqj3TpsK1mp/8 5wtaxJf3+UWl7/sewaWMIblAUe0 2008-05-16 13:43:41 10.35.1.7 443 65530
pr0b3y7h32nd oG6lOPEUJBpIsbxST4+55qoUym4 5a2zSCrWQWVZda8an2IAn8XDWDg 2008-05-17 04:49:57 68.227.168.162 443 65530
// same name
relay123 YPQsFAVKb5o+qILNz9/CwrAB3dA 6sKbCRhAdcVTxO1hXT9xarIsJG4 2008-05-22 08:23:15 10.128.53.226 443 9030
relay123 X54vO+WWu2sNX63bMVnUvFRgR3Q 29zWenmt2iALuHB14fg99/gApOE 2008-05-21 04:13:14 80.222.240.155 443 9030
// same name
RouterX S0bpWkjPRq306X7KwdDr030OYJY +QHI4b5JhmfwQA5QH7A7/Pkna5g 2008-05-28 07:06:12 10.52.109.109 9001 0
RouterX 25XCtl84ARgo1T/nN92eNZtlC7E CaTzOfN9FmvhR6rUufksUEXDt78 2008-05-29 05:56:24 68.40.6.83 9001 0
// same name
sebekxp igk06QpyZ04QHGQFP4svxueeVWo +G8rqTSc12W/POZi706uYGAHIkA 2008-05-30 11:31:34 10.142.35.42 443 0
sebekxp f6kydY9wVpZpPwGCfK5nfNlzXo4 3bfC9amDLBcNoLvezB6oCHF+b18 2008-05-29 10:17:29 79.163.48.20 443 9030
// same name
sebekxp igk06QpyZ04QHGQFP4svxueeVWo +G8rqTSc12W/POZi706uYGAHIkA 2008-05-30 11:31:34 10.142.35.42 443 0
sebekxp f6kydY9wVpZpPwGCfK5nfNlzXo4 lJAb5iL+9ZRZ8aqMcGD4cjqU7lU 2008-05-28 22:01:32 79.163.14.241 443 9030
// same name
StonedToad 7ljIZ2cwIz7Qq/KmRs4pcrWHoa0 McU483yfIZkEofagQ6XNFpDwPiI 2008-05-28 23:32:10 10.134.119.55 443 9030
StonedToad cCoES6RSrSgLUNHwh1jYL+5baFc bEUfYwHfNsK/+tDVJrQ3eIvhOt8 2008-05-28 23:25:07 76.125.106.24 443 9030
// same name // I decided to leave "tor" out
TorKServer FYjXtRRUrKMr5Qc7Wlx64Sr4+fw y3jlJ2vsz3S+hnTfaMU8b/E0Cy4 2008-05-20 01:01:35 10.191.69.236 8081 9030
TorKServer 0i2uMiTMVgcgNsv2Kz4CP8Yd1cQ fEky+v2nFHGAEaBPuT1+8YlLxpw 2008-05-20 21:54:25 89.102.79.197 9001 9030
// same name, up on the same day, I did not care about that
TorKServer FYjXtRRUrKMr5Qc7Wlx64Sr4+fw y3jlJ2vsz3S+hnTfaMU8b/E0Cy4 2008-05-20 01:01:35 10.191.69.236 8081 9030
TorKServer /bAucfbr39sYGj0C8x864DYB95Q H7u2cM30MZqUTPKSnvYI3d1Ce58 2008-05-11 15:43:44 68.245.116.144 9001 9030
// same name
TorKServer FYjXtRRUrKMr5Qc7Wlx64Sr4+fw y3jlJ2vsz3S+hnTfaMU8b/E0Cy4 2008-05-20 01:01:35 10.191.69.236 8081 9030
TorKServer2424 P7FpD+jWYdhh0glIJiOEvAwImuU hMeVyhPu+QXKyoizHa7lFdX42aQ 2008-05-12 10:48:48 212.41.242.231 9001 9030
// maybe
Vigilanty SJCuQLfP7YsQq54d73Kz7Zz/in4 +GK/6Mu6RBWzYU/FDdovndUY128 2008-05-19 19:08:32 10.21.229.19 443 0
Vigilanty VQHNBlk5oROzQanlG9fUtO8MaXM 1TBk8W/gMGB7EpWCrqp+0GxfKhc 2008-05-13 20:45:19 76.178.30.198 443 9030
// same name
willOtheWisp 403K1sw4I5EpE2FnNcQHxhyR6Mg 6yi31nNgxTjox2FcMUCGSWoCg4Q 2008-05-17 03:48:41 10.39.216.181 443 0
willOtheWisp rNoTPn3HnMkwavdGBajS89lQSQM /EJHSlnrpGaGc21EhLn9+L9WwTs 2008-05-17 16:10:52 77.12.24.105 443 0
// same name
LittleHelper boy9wrm9FZcP8dWNVh8Een7aPSQ +x9hK/+7P3epmuCPOrRxAHL3Bdw 2008-05-22 16:01:38 10.221.246.206 443 0
santa R07GkPHDWF96NAFO/KMbkByWhKU aUOtHd02E5kf3bw0Czs5b8EKtUI 2008-05-17 12:25:55 24.46.205.89 9001 0
// Santa's Little Helper, helper is unstable
unknownzero 0nFuUJsBMj7cNi/CoIKlWrRVBnk gjCaD3K1zun4Tkk4Bgr8YCgLcYE 2008-05-17 00:30:36 10.67.35.218 443 9030
0day 2csgkW6V/LCUKI87LpGgjrDW3i4 5vIt5fjyxZW53li8ReRF0Jwi4js 2008-05-17 15:19:21 213.216.230.217 443 80
// a zero day (0day) is unknown
pasiphae 37z0s7Y93JQa+KTiohqVf+mrzLM deeJWLg/IezJNGRQ3yuCr/eRMtk 2008-05-19 08:19:12 10.146.76.25 8080 0
Phobos ZODTfrTovydIZJz/LLwCLrpPJ90 PLyvE2QkXvebSNGV9MNa/TBZCEI 2008-05-01 08:35:31 82.95.193.137 9001 9030
// both are moons, couldn't find a mythological similarity in the first place
pasiphae 37z0s7Y93JQa+KTiohqVf+mrzLM deeJWLg/IezJNGRQ3yuCr/eRMtk 2008-05-19 08:19:12 10.146.76.25 8080 0
phobos2 /Ay8M9ptUO5Ief9axKiFnCGtW2U 01/N1rjcjU6WVSbp+hGdvmGyD04 2008-05-29 18:21:57 72.93.74.159 8443 0
// both are moons
pasiphae 37z0s7Y93JQa+KTiohqVf+mrzLM deeJWLg/IezJNGRQ3yuCr/eRMtk 2008-05-19 08:19:12 10.146.76.25 8080 0
io XITazLgww5jkxZYLIhV3xv+7s40 NMJt+NDp2iA5edllBHi/ke74Ieo 2008-05-20 15:25:57 88.198.47.72 9001 0
// both are moons
pasiphae 37z0s7Y93JQa+KTiohqVf+mrzLM deeJWLg/IezJNGRQ3yuCr/eRMtk 2008-05-19 08:19:12 10.146.76.25 8080
Hyperion 9LudBOA0ftJatlDj4z5cFGFs1No 4wan9YZnV42bN19OlkA+hs4wVHQ 2008-05-23 21:53:04 78.12.86.77 9001 0
// both are moons, included only one IP
pasiphae 37z0s7Y93JQa+KTiohqVf+mrzLM deeJWLg/IezJNGRQ3yuCr/eRMtk 2008-05-19 08:19:12 10.146.76.25 8080
janus XWYF4a9pMXpRc5rcRSzlTibLKn4 2rGjz+wmvVPAf9thzx1BzFTbWGE 2008-05-16 09:47:56 88.134.218.238 443 0
// both are moons
pasiphae 37z0s7Y93JQa+KTiohqVf+mrzLM deeJWLg/IezJNGRQ3yuCr/eRMtk 2008-05-19 08:19:12 10.146.76.25 8080
janus XWYF4a9pMXpRc5rcRSzlTibLKn4 E0LJDeNcSsB0h0tunXyZ0Cs9YgI 2008-05-22 14:38:12 91.66.120.54 443 0
// moons, Janus the two-faced roman god, different IP
pasiphae 37z0s7Y93JQa+KTiohqVf+mrzLM deeJWLg/IezJNGRQ3yuCr/eRMtk 2008-05-19 08:19:12 10.146.76.25 8080
Janus3 Jv5N881yKX/PpNl28gxZQ4hmX1Y /LVxfBBqApYuxhmhnltYy7U422U 2008-05-04 08:17:50 72.9.100.205 17401 0
// the moon and myths, might be me
pasiphae 37z0s7Y93JQa+KTiohqVf+mrzLM deeJWLg/IezJNGRQ3yuCr/eRMtk 2008-05-19 08:19:12 10.146.76.25 8080
pan ejwCZXUrfrL+PoSogcOnE95X6zQ TYyRTHkGPcSJUqSFj2xP21o/ffg 2008-05-09 22:31:26 70.245.224.123 9001 0
// it's a moon, same IP every time it was up
pasiphae 37z0s7Y93JQa+KTiohqVf+mrzLM deeJWLg/IezJNGRQ3yuCr/eRMtk 2008-05-19 08:19:12 10.146.76.25 8080
Prometheus eN4+pXzW7g8EKhIjw6b+dYqb/XA 3sMIFTQ1TsZycOS72T59ImA1s2M 2008-05-25 17:12:37 66.67.227.194 9001 0
// It's a moon. And Prometheus stole the fire from the gods and brought it to mankind.
pasiphae 37z0s7Y93JQa+KTiohqVf+mrzLM deeJWLg/IezJNGRQ3yuCr/eRMtk 2008-05-19 08:19:12 10.146.76.25 8080
Caliban by4kc/JCOhcFia+o2i4hCs7AXPc 41AwULtZfGUppyV900CoImA2ElM 2008-05-19 14:46:49 96.238.212.78 9001 0
// A moon and metal band, maybe other meanings I remember theater or something (could be wrong)
pasiphae 37z0s7Y93JQa+KTiohqVf+mrzLM deeJWLg/IezJNGRQ3yuCr/eRMtk 2008-05-19 08:19:12 10.146.76.25 8080
cordelia jAXftDaJO0OyGPGO5mq2M484DWk Wp572VVl2EkTMmfgVjBJYkUiMwI 2008-05-04 11:27:57 81.1.107.172 443 0
// A moon
pasiphae 37z0s7Y93JQa+KTiohqVf+mrzLM deeJWLg/IezJNGRQ3yuCr/eRMtk 2008-05-19 08:19:12 10.146.76.25 8080
daedalus EA6tiZFrDwa+YLjVRrUwiSBTFNg 69r8Gtfwm90SHGxIWQz1pKzeph4 2008-05-19 23:36:18 84.157.160.218 9001 9030
// greek mythology, moon crater and asteroid. I know a band with that name. Tons of meanings I guess.
pasiphae 37z0s7Y93JQa+KTiohqVf+mrzLM deeJWLg/IezJNGRQ3yuCr/eRMtk 2008-05-19 08:19:12 10.146.76.25 8080
Desdemona um/oM0ErTxczyJ2qnhVej59tlMI Hgy5k3XCFksNi3tivzj2Q7/scyw 2008-05-07 22:50:28 217.202.6.150 443 9030
// a moon
pasiphae 37z0s7Y93JQa+KTiohqVf+mrzLM deeJWLg/IezJNGRQ3yuCr/eRMtk 2008-05-19 08:19:12 10.146.76.25 8080
Desdemona um/oM0ErTxczyJ2qnhVej59tlMI sNyq4Vm1i+r6WlFUZQRPvYeqKR4 2008-05-04 21:20:58 217.201.135.177 443 9030
// same moon, different IP
// End of assumptions
// Witch hunting or resource burning mode
torayama u6mQ/oCkrIDrj/dGqcgY7Yb5sLQ /Y1s5A03YznPmNMffTgC77n8LrQ 2008-05-30 14:15:47 10.110.167.127 13666 0
torayama u6mQ/oCkrIDrj/dGqcgY7Yb5sLQ /YZUWfWDkgFX+6auP3+pu1EkpAA 2008-05-29 15:10:50 10.251.237.46 13666 0
torayama u6mQ/oCkrIDrj/dGqcgY7Yb5sLQ 0GvSGsro4OzPPBJDYujaCnTAAzs 2008-05-26 01:10:48 10.156.116.40 13666 0
torayama u6mQ/oCkrIDrj/dGqcgY7Yb5sLQ 6AMt5HDwan8cwusDBUw0h/sG5QI 2008-05-22 23:10:26 10.81.175.227 13666 0
torayama u6mQ/oCkrIDrj/dGqcgY7Yb5sLQ 72tVeJFZysz2UAgYPOUmuWWJOYM 2008-05-28 01:10:50 10.205.58.127 13666 0
torayama u6mQ/oCkrIDrj/dGqcgY7Yb5sLQ 8RicAnjJlNojpQGVkUuN8sbSFog 2008-05-28 12:26:13 10.2.44.114 13666 0
torayama u6mQ/oCkrIDrj/dGqcgY7Yb5sLQ 8xal5rnwVd1GADX3I/U7WtMP7pc 2008-05-21 01:10:50 10.76.177.5 13666 0
torayama u6mQ/oCkrIDrj/dGqcgY7Yb5sLQ 9C64zC5YjlhNnBuWNTAJUgp6exs 2008-05-24 12:26:14 10.94.17.7 13666 0
torayama u6mQ/oCkrIDrj/dGqcgY7Yb5sLQ 9oJmHuKBkrHnCF0g8xAjY+YiaXg 2008-05-21 23:17:45 10.29.250.71 13666 0
torayama u6mQ/oCkrIDrj/dGqcgY7Yb5sLQ dpCDe6PVlNIc2p43h+Op0W75ImA 2008-05-17 21:56:16 10.161.216.189 13666 0
torayama u6mQ/oCkrIDrj/dGqcgY7Yb5sLQ eorCK9S2GUzXgQFOq65kw7VZHwI 2008-05-31 01:10:46 10.106.91.83 13666 0
torayama u6mQ/oCkrIDrj/dGqcgY7Yb5sLQ EYcAor7J8UwxqFwoz1JawkorD1g 2008-05-29 12:29:31 10.57.136.5 13666 0
torayama u6mQ/oCkrIDrj/dGqcgY7Yb5sLQ H5AQmwkEyz1Zff8pM8/IHZO+HeQ 2008-05-18 12:45:37 10.149.149.32 13666 0
torayama u6mQ/oCkrIDrj/dGqcgY7Yb5sLQ HD4Mh0pu8aLhAWW0nEj+hL9B2PA 2008-05-20 01:10:41 10.190.213.221 13666 0
torayama u6mQ/oCkrIDrj/dGqcgY7Yb5sLQ Hz4OYC6iyadp6pCYR3Cp+gYXMgY 2008-05-21 15:46:13 10.158.213.69 13666 0
torayama u6mQ/oCkrIDrj/dGqcgY7Yb5sLQ I2C9P0P6ze6WLxzDuV7dcq4Dg3I 2008-05-27 01:10:53 10.154.108.6 13666 0
torayama u6mQ/oCkrIDrj/dGqcgY7Yb5sLQ Lmr+4fREGXJVP43IqQaNjhgRyuA 2008-05-31 15:16:53 10.124.2.53 13666 0
torayama u6mQ/oCkrIDrj/dGqcgY7Yb5sLQ Pm75uUnerS11XzQXnh7bHKnJSI8 2008-05-25 01:25:39 10.152.14.231 13666 0
torayama u6mQ/oCkrIDrj/dGqcgY7Yb5sLQ r62WFENJLlNtVz7sdnWvP/uhnyY 2008-05-18 00:42:52 10.194.51.207 13666 0
torayama u6mQ/oCkrIDrj/dGqcgY7Yb5sLQ SCwfMJVS0fIOtt0mJrNZAU7hvjw 2008-05-16 19:11:29 10.70.148.69 13666 0
torayama u6mQ/oCkrIDrj/dGqcgY7Yb5sLQ tirMsMIWk7kKMsKTpFXZoQwCZFc 2008-05-19 12:44:17 10.78.94.194 13666 0
// the relay torayama lives in the 91.124.xxx.xxx. space
torayama LQELBdR/9+GmrzSM92g7PQZ34L0 +2qnJ+L1nYDd9PPHIHKHyhqhCFE 2008-05-02 01:10:33 91.124.131.53 13666 0
// I couldn't see them up on the same date
// I see that 91.124. is stable for the relay
// On the bridge it isn't
// "Ididn't"... might be close, but here I see nothing to gain
// I included it anyway, to show that I hadn't missed it
// Well scanning the relay's IP space wouldn't hurt
// End of resource burning mode


More information about the tor-dev mailing list