Thoughts on changing our package names
coderman at gmail.com
Tue Nov 17 00:31:09 UTC 2009
On Fri, Nov 13, 2009 at 4:50 AM, Andrew Lewman <andrew at torproject.org> wrote:
> I've been meeting more and more tor users over the past few months who
> are confused by our package naming. They want to download a "tor
> bundle" but instead get a "vidalia bundle". They don't understand what
> the difference between vidalia, tor, polipo, and the other stuff in our
> bundles. It's all Tor to them.
> The version numbers also confuse them. They aren't sure what all the
> numbers mean, nor why they should care. From the perspective of a new
> user, they don't care about the different components of a package and
> what version each component is; they just need to know if they have the
> latest or not.
Agreed. Regardless of individual component versions I would also like
to see a single consistent version number associated with a singular
"Tor Bundle" installer.
The fact that this bundle is comprised of a number of different parts
like Polipo, Vidalia, etc. should be internal to the package and not
confusing the user.
> My next best thought is to simply name the installation bundles as such:
> Tor-Installation-Bundle-for-(Windows|OS X)-(bundle version number).
I would omit the -Installation- and -for- part for brevity and replace
Windows with Win32 as one day we may care about 64bit native builds.
That is, Tor-Bundle-Win32-1.0
Is the Installation part to distinguish from the no-install portable
Tor browser bundle? That is the extent of my bike shed commentary :)
> Only -stable versions of Tor get a bundle version number as described
> above. -alpha packages are still built the with the version numbers of
> tor and vidalia as a distinction. Alternatively, we could switch to
> some nomenclature such as odd numbered major versions as -alpha, even
> numbered major releases as -stable. However, given how fast we switch
> from -alpha to -stable, we'll be at Tor Installation Bundle for Windows
> 14.1 soon enough.
More information about the tor-dev