[tor-bugs] #32158 [Internal Services]: vanguards: 'exit circ' always only '(length 3', 'internal circ' fine with '(length 4' and 5
Tor Bug Tracker & Wiki
blackhole at torproject.org
Sat Oct 19 18:33:41 UTC 2019
#32158: vanguards: 'exit circ' always only '(length 3', 'internal circ' fine with
'(length 4' and 5
--------------------------+-----------------------------------
Reporter: cypherpunks | Owner: (none)
Type: defect | Status: new
Priority: Medium | Component: Internal Services
Version: Tor: 0.4.1.6 | Severity: Normal
Keywords: vanguards | Actual Points:
Parent ID: | Points:
Reviewer: | Sponsor:
--------------------------+-----------------------------------
Running vanguards addon in my Tor client (not server).
Dates and actual nodes (manually) scrambled.
tail -300000 log | grep -A3000 'Oct 13' | grep '(length 5\|(length
4\|(length 3' | grep 'exit circ' | grep -v '(length 3'
[no output]
tail -300000 log | grep -A3000 'Oct 13' | grep 'exit circ (length' |
head -7
Oct 13 06:59:11.900 [info] exit circ (length 3, last hop B1111111111111):
$29999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCCCCCC331(open)
$2DDAA9999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCC331(closed)
$2DDAA9911111111999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCC331(closed)
Oct 13 06:59:12.000 [info] exit circ (length 3, last hop n22222222222222):
$2DDAA9911111111999BBBBBB333333333BCCC331(open)
$2DDAA9911111111999BBBB999999999933CCC331(closed)
$2DDAA9911111111999BBBBBB3333333333CCC331(closed)
Oct 13 06:59:12.050 [info] exit circ (length 3, last hop B1111111111111):
$29999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCCCCCC331(open)
$2DDAA9999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCC331(open)
$2DDAA9911111111999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCC331(closed)
Oct 13 06:59:12.100 [info] exit circ (length 3, last hop n22222222222222):
$2DDAA9911111111999BBBBBB333333333BCCC331(open)
$2DDAA9911111111999BBBB999999999933CCC331(open)
$2DDAA9911111111999BBBBBB3333333333CCC331(closed)
Oct 13 06:59:12.150 [info] exit circ (length 3, last hop B1111111111111):
$29999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCCCCCC331(open)
$2DDAA9999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCC331(open)
$2DDAA9911111111999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCC331(open)
Oct 13 06:59:12.150 [info] exit circ (length 3):
$29999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCCCCCC331(open)
$2DDAA9999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCC331(open)
$2DDAA9911111111999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCC331(open)
Oct 13 06:59:12.250 [info] exit circ (length 3, last hop n22222222222222):
$2DDAA9911111111999BBBBBB333333333BCCC331(open)
$2DDAA9911111111999BBBB999999999933CCC331(open)
$2DDAA9911111111999BBBBBB3333333333CCC331(open)
tail -300000 log | grep -A3000 'Oct 13' | grep 'exit circ (length' |
tail -7
Oct 13 17:58:24.550 [info] exit circ (length 3):
$29999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCCCCCC331(open)
$2DDAA9911111111999BBBBBBBBB9999933CCC331open)
$1111111117777777777777788889999933CCC222(open)
Oct 13 17:58:24.700 [info] exit circ (length 3):
$29999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCCCCCC331(open)
$2DDAA9911111111999BBBBBBBBB9999933CCC331open)
$1111111117777777777777788889999933CCC222(open)
Oct 13 17:58:30.700 [info] exit circ (length 3):
$29999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCCCCCC331(open)
$2DDAA9911111111999BBBBBBBBB9999933CCC331open)
$1111111117777777777777788889999933CCC222(open)
Oct 13 17:58:30.850 [info] exit circ (length 3):
$29999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCCCCCC331(open)
$2DDAA9911111111999BBBBBBBBB9999933CCC331open)
$1111111117777777777777788889999933CCC222(open)
Oct 13 18:01:03.350 [info] exit circ (length 3, last hop Dd8d8d8):
$2DDAA9911111111999BBBBBB333333333BCCC331(open)
$2DDAA99118888888888888888889999933CCC331(closed)
$2DDAA9911111999999999B9999933CCC331(closed)
Oct 13 18:01:03.400 [info] exit circ (length 3, last hop Dd8d8d8):
$2DDAA9911111111999BBBBBB333333333BCCC331(open)
$2DDAA99118888888888888888889999933CCC331(open)
$2DDAA9911111999999999B9999933CCC331(closed)
Oct 13 18:01:03.650 [info] exit circ (length 3, last hop Dd8d8d8):
$2DDAA9911111111999BBBBBB333333333BCCC331(open)
$2DDAA99118888888888888888889999933CCC331(open)
$2DDAA9911111999999999B9999933CCC331(open)
tail -300000 log | grep -A3000 'Oct 13' | grep 'exit circ (length' | sed
's/.*\(exit circ (length.*\)/\1/' | uniq | wc -l
472
tail -300000 log | grep -A3000 'Oct 13' | grep 'exit circ (length' | sed
's/.*\(exit circ (length.*\)/\1/' | uniq
exit circ (length 3, last hop B1111111111111):
$29999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCCCCCC331(open)
$2DDAA9999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCC331(closed)
$2DDAA9911111111999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCC331(closed)
exit circ (length 3, last hop n22222222222222):
$2DDAA9911111111999BBBBBB333333333BCCC331(open)
$2DDAA9911111111999BBBB999999999933CCC331(closed)
$2DDAA9911111111999BBBBBB3333333333CCC331(closed)
exit circ (length 3, last hop B1111111111111):
$29999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCCCCCC331(open)
$2DDAA9999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCC331(open)
$2DDAA9911111111999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCC331(closed)
exit circ (length 3, last hop n22222222222222):
$2DDAA9911111111999BBBBBB333333333BCCC331(open)
$2DDAA9911111111999BBBB999999999933CCC331(open)
$2DDAA9911111111999BBBBBB3333333333CCC331(closed)
exit circ (length 3, last hop B1111111111111):
$29999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCCCCCC331(open)
$2DDAA9999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCC331(open)
$2DDAA9911111111999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCC331(open)
exit circ (length 3): $1111111118888888888888888889999933CCC331(open)
$61F3A840F61EEFFF682C6243534ECEB09ADFE3B3(open)
$1111111118888888888888888889999933CCC222(open)
exit circ (length 3): $1111111118888888888888888889999933CCC331(open)
$61F3A840F61EEFFF682C6243534ECEB09ADFE3B3(open)
$1111111118888888888888888889999933CCC222(open)
exit circ (length 3): $1111111118888888888888888889999933CCC331(open)
$61F3A840F61EEFFF682C6243534ECEB09ADFE3B3(open)
$1111111118888888888888888889999933CCC222(open)
exit circ (length 3): $1111111118888888888888888889999933CCC331(open)
$61F3A840F61EEFFF682C6243534ECEB09ADFE3B3(open)
$1111111118888888888888888889999933CCC222(open)
exit circ (length 3): $1111111118888888888888888889999933CCC331(open)
$61F3A840F61EEFFF682C6243534ECEB09ADFE3B3(open)
$1111111118888888888888888889999933CCC222(open)
exit circ (length 3): $29999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCCCCCC331(open)
$2DDAA9911111111999BBBBBBBBB9999933CCC331open)
$1111111117777777777777788889999933CCC222(open)
exit circ (length 3, last hop Dd8d8d8):
$2DDAA9911111111999BBBBBB333333333BCCC331(open)
$2DDAA99118888888888888888889999933CCC331(closed)
$2DDAA9911111999999999B9999933CCC331(closed)
exit circ (length 3, last hop Dd8d8d8):
$2DDAA9911111111999BBBBBB333333333BCCC331(open)
$2DDAA99118888888888888888889999933CCC331(open)
$2DDAA9911111999999999B9999933CCC331(closed)
exit circ (length 3, last hop Dd8d8d8):
$2DDAA9911111111999BBBBBB333333333BCCC331(open)
$2DDAA99118888888888888888889999933CCC331(open)
$2DDAA9911111999999999B9999933CCC331(open)
--------
Now grepping logs for 'internal circ'
tail -300000 log | grep -A3000 'Oct 13' | grep '(length 5\|(length
4\|(length 3' | grep 'internal circ' | grep '(length 3'
[no output, the opposite!]
tail -300000 log | grep -A3000 'Oct 13' | grep '(length 5\|(length
4\|(length 3' | grep 'internal circ' | grep '(length 4' | wc -l
2943
tail -300000 log | grep -A3000 'Oct 13' | grep '(length 5\|(length
4\|(length 3' | grep 'internal circ' | grep '(length 5' | wc -l
1759
tail -300000 log | grep -A3000 'Oct 13' | grep 'internal circ (length' |
head -7
Oct 13 06:59:11.000 [info] internal circ (length 1, last hop
B393939393939): $29999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCCCCCC331(open)
Oct 13 06:59:11.000 [info] internal circ (length 1):
$29999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCCCCCC331(open)
Oct 13 06:59:11.100 [info] internal circ (length 1):
$29999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCCCCCC331(open)
Oct 13 06:59:11.900 [info] internal circ (length 4, last hop
BobsHouseLU04): $29999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCCCCCC331(open)
$1111111117777755555555555555999933CCC222(closed)
$DBE82FA23B9FE3CB2462A6FCF5289DED3CBF4AEE(closed)
$F9A9E0968D512A22B8967C5458D5B0163C11F856(closed)
Oct 13 06:59:11.900 [info] internal circ (length 5, last hop
$111111111777775511111111111111111111C222):
$29999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCCCCCC331(open)
$C2D85BC549361717FDEFAE89607F4A9DF2D4C0E4(closed)
$FFF78C44BA6E6B6F7525095BBE14EF7CBEB89744(closed)
$AFC69ACD47E4CBD5CF8EA47F9B5622C91BF2DA60(closed)
$111111111777775511111111111111111111C222(closed)
Oct 13 06:59:12.000 [info] internal circ (length 5, last hop
$111111111777775511111111111111111111C222):
$29999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCCCCCC331(open)
$C2D85BC549361717FDEFAE89607F4A9DF2D4C0E4(open)
$FFF78C44BA6E6B6F7525095BBE14EF7CBEB89744(closed)
$AFC69ACD47E4CBD5CF8EA47F9B5622C91BF2DA60(closed)
$111111111777775511111111111111111111C222(closed)
Oct 13 06:59:12.000 [info] internal circ (length 4, last hop
BobsHouseLU04): $29999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCCCCCC331(open)
$1111111117777755555555555555999933CCC222(open)
$DBE82FA23B9FE3CB2462A6FCF5289DED3CBF4AEE(closed)
$F9A9E0968D512A22B8967C5458D5B0163C11F856(closed)
tail -300000 log | grep -A3000 'Oct 13' | grep 'exit circ (length' | sed
's/.*\(exit circ (length.*\)/\1/' | uniq | wc -l
internal circ (length 1, last hop B393939393939):
$29999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCCCCCC331(open)
internal circ (length 1): $29999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCCCCCC331(open)
internal circ (length 1): $29999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCCCCCC331(open)
internal circ (length 4, last hop BobsHouseLU04):
$29999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCCCCCC331(open)
$1111111117777755555555555555999933CCC222(closed)
$DBE82FA23B9FE3CB2462A6FCF5289DED3CBF4AEE(closed)
$F9A9E0968D512A22B8967C5458D5B0163C11F856(closed)
internal circ (length 5, last hop
$111111111777775511111111111111111111C222):
$29999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCCCCCC331(open)
$C2D85BC549361717FDEFAE89607F4A9DF2D4C0E4(closed)
$FFF78C44BA6E6B6F7525095BBE14EF7CBEB89744(closed)
$AFC69ACD47E4CBD5CF8EA47F9B5622C91BF2DA60(closed)
$111111111777775511111111111111111111C222(closed)
...
internal circ (length 4): $29999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCCCCCC331(open)
$70F09E981D6D4A34A35F248F0C873CBA356A0612(open)
$58BC63142C881F88D08E071DEB63DBA09DE62141(open)
$322C6E3A973BC10FC36DE3037AD27BC89F14723B(open)
internal circ (length 4): $29999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCCCCCC331(open)
$70F09E981D6D4A34A35F248F0C873CBA356A0612(open)
$58BC63142C881F88D08E071DEB63DBA09DE62141(open)
$322C6E3A973BC10FC36DE3037AD27BC89F14723B(open)
internal circ (length 4): $29999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCCCCCC331(open)
$70F09E981D6D4A34A35F248F0C873CBA356A0612(open)
$58BC63142C881F88D08E071DEB63DBA09DE62141(open)
$322C6E3A973BC10FC36DE3037AD27BC89F14723B(open)
internal circ (length 4): $29999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCCCCCC331(open)
$70F09E981D6D4A34A35F248F0C873CBA356A0612(open)
$58BC63142C881F88D08E071DEB63DBA09DE62141(open)
$322C6E3A973BC10FC36DE3037AD27BC89F14723B(open)
internal circ (length 4): $29999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCCCCCC331(open)
$70F09E981D6D4A34A35F248F0C873CBA356A0612(open)
$58BC63142C881F88D08E071DEB63DBA09DE62141(open)
$322C6E3A973BC10FC36DE3037AD27BC89F14723B(open)
...
internal circ (length 1): $2DDAA9911111111999BBBBBB333333333BCCC331(open)
internal circ (length 1): $2DDAA9911111111999BBBBBB333333333BCCC331(open)
internal circ (length 1, last hop B393939393939):
$29999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCCCCCC331(open)
internal circ (length 1): $29999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCCCCCC331(open)
internal circ (length 1): $29999999999999BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBCCCCCCC331(open)
I hope this is still realistic enough (I even did leave a few nodes
unmodified). I hope Mike and the Tor Team can fix this.
Regards!
--
Ticket URL: <https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/ticket/32158>
Tor Bug Tracker & Wiki <https://trac.torproject.org/>
The Tor Project: anonymity online
More information about the tor-bugs
mailing list