[tor-bugs] #27187 [Metrics/Onionoo]: Possible for inconsistency between summary and details with AS number

[Tor Bug Tracker & Wiki]

#27187: Possible for inconsistency between summary and details with AS number
---------------------------------+--------------------------
     Reporter:  irl              |      Owner:  metrics-team
         Type:  defect           |     Status:  new
     Priority:  Medium           |  Milestone:
    Component:  Metrics/Onionoo  |    Version:
     Severity:  Normal           |   Keywords:
Actual Points:                   |  Parent ID:
       Points:                   |   Reviewer:
      Sponsor:                   |
---------------------------------+--------------------------
 {{{
 {"version":"6.2",
 "next_major_version_scheduled":"2018-09-03",
 "build_revision":"79de0d2",
 "relays_published":"2018-08-17 12:00:00",
 "relays":[
 {"fingerprint":"008E7B70C3B4A7520B5BEAB8067ABCDC8E63F1FD"},
 {"fingerprint":"070A0DC5AE71D60A9567FF908A4EBFB52C670E39"},
 {"fingerprint":"0AE3AC492B709AA851488D01B1AD1EDFC040947F"},
 {"fingerprint":"0CA2FF775712F67AFFAB64CF16EA96E3D13016B4"},
 {"fingerprint":"0DE225407D80F8C1121AED264A97EBF56F31F299"},
 {"fingerprint":"11757C1EAD3BAD46D2EA2E950D5E9A34035D9B17"},
 {"fingerprint":"126B2DD209618B666FF3184EC9D50363B3FB46B7"},
 {"fingerprint":"136F9299A5009A4E0E96494E723BDB556FB0A26B"},
 {"fingerprint":"19D235674BCA4EAF55BBFFAAE5441C1E392E4C72"},
 {"fingerprint":"1CD464437CF6F0AA8B41660D74DCAB8DD7C14373"},
 {"fingerprint":"1D3174338A1131A53E098443E76E1103CDED00DC"},
 {"fingerprint":"2093B5DC4B595BFD307A26F494A4C31F455DCCCA"},
 {"fingerprint":"22E975935BA77EA59A28EA1AA8387F906034FCBE"},
 {"fingerprint":"2C8BD998EDE0C66668D7CCAA1A724BF566524395"},
 {"fingerprint":"2CDCFED0142B28B002E89D305CBA2E26063FADE2"},
 {"fingerprint":"2D74D7EFACC75DCDB3BEE9221B0BEB226754F96E"},
 {"fingerprint":"3098231A16A3661AF98A80D62D161AE7B039358E"},
 {"fingerprint":"3444F4ACA2A1AB4A5E9DC64295A6D414A03D3503"},
 {"fingerprint":"363E2F30AC9823E6094786CE0ABB64B14D2BE233"},
 {"fingerprint":"387A7D62EEC5C14FF45ED8AD9B2235BFE9FE9463"},
 {"fingerprint":"38A42B8D7C0E6346F4A4821617740AEE86EA885B"},
 {"fingerprint":"3B52392E2256C35CDCF7801FF898FC88CE6D431A"},
 {"fingerprint":"3D765C586CCA8B437B7697EA2CE6A51312530AB1"},
 {"fingerprint":"3E50CBCA98A20F637BC4551FD4F132D062DB9A51"},
 {"fingerprint":"41A3C16269C7B63DB6EB741DBDDB4E1F586B1592"},
 {"fingerprint":"4C3165B64B8237E5273D388429480080022C6481"},
 {"fingerprint":"557B274903A48A611B43B66C5761E4F0AFB248A8"},
 {"fingerprint":"55D7C9776246C3C5E683A777D97D3ECDD0C5AF37"},
 {"fingerprint":"572D22C1AF720F274D274A189EDB75C3F9BDC777"},
 {"fingerprint":"5CEF9FD40E64948093EBC041E33ED3ED12F70DFE"},
 {"fingerprint":"5CF8AFA5E4B0BB88942A44A3F3AAE08C3BDFD60B"},
 {"fingerprint":"5FAA9FC7000138C480F042DE4C602C56C5AA3C42"},
 {"fingerprint":"60D2F22EE6FB75739C1F1EF80A2D99D943F12D9E"},
 {"fingerprint":"65F260EAC76E4F72ED2F8C34CE47A8E1E0621B90"},
 {"fingerprint":"723E9B29DF0357E19B2D1C86B86A0165335BFAA9","as_number":"AS39309"},
 {"fingerprint":"728B01C767259E92262329DC148750C08A3A5259"},
 {"fingerprint":"73D6694F1E71EBD138A15091EA6CBB6F94271405"},
 {"fingerprint":"75FCFA1225B5B4B35E25DA53C8BA7545463B679E"},
 {"fingerprint":"77C99455CF6F68A7FF72F78048D1C39A4719EC59"},
 {"fingerprint":"79D41A16341822F03D11361B0A31DC9309CEB748"},
 {"fingerprint":"7A622004AE337495692986D973A62EAAF2524455"},
 {"fingerprint":"7C494B5BBC1558303DB1CFB840D980A0B4BCC324"},
 {"fingerprint":"7DBB97846CC559FDB82FDD53360127A17742C9D8"},
 {"fingerprint":"7E7006F96EF48C688EEE1B1095BEC66B4EF28029"},
 {"fingerprint":"837D5EA513DF7FDDA36BE569C646151CDA4B9935"},
 {"fingerprint":"83F03DA35C8E65474B2B9B5EF81896E12AD6282A"},
 {"fingerprint":"851491607C61F6C878FF4C92253274095FD20FBB"},
 {"fingerprint":"87EDD379CB568F65704665A291A6186006AFAF57"},
 {"fingerprint":"8CC6AAB9CBAB31EE4D9E80071F1330100A962EEF"},
 {"fingerprint":"8FA258D0E5F525F6E28E13A0BC2351F766D1DAF7"},
 {"fingerprint":"8FC24B546A3603D86901E1892270DAE9718A09A3"},
 {"fingerprint":"90352FBFD5D0BD4D6FDC867309F393A8AF99FF8A"},
 {"fingerprint":"92CFD9565B24646CAC2D172D3DB503D69E777B8A"},
 {"fingerprint":"94342E68666C1307ECC4CB083070F4DEC87408E0"},
 {"fingerprint":"95D68B64F42F27AED4CA15D0E9A1D0DA86E60339"},
 {"fingerprint":"960F231C1C2CABF752E747A57D6CDEFD13F35570"},
 {"fingerprint":"9A90F846871641CB97C70B948963FCA3F7486E5A"},
 {"fingerprint":"9B7D6254CE9C2D6EDC9A4510699ADADDF6F4D5F9"},
 {"fingerprint":"9BF565F0600126D3E2179CC933AA15E7702B4CE9"},
 {"fingerprint":"A2534EF23390CAE079B1586F0FDF9CE11F556062"},
 {"fingerprint":"A29B3032E92CB2D79903198DB36E78F848636CF4"},
 {"fingerprint":"A2DB293FFC5A76A718863BF1AEDBC8DFB1CB1097"},
 {"fingerprint":"A4C98CEA3F34E05299417E9F885A642C88EF6029"},
 {"fingerprint":"AD2060260080FE092DE928384E2514A1C596772F"},
 {"fingerprint":"AF2249FD0897A9FB961883C567309DE41472D5C6"},
 {"fingerprint":"B116D652E092760C1F1C44F4A9CA5D628D17CDE9"},
 {"fingerprint":"B44FBE5366AD98B46D829754FA4AC599BAE41A6A"},
 {"fingerprint":"B584C23DD8B22121FD1B20F926A528F4586F47E7"},
 {"fingerprint":"B7E04B6EC8F69EA05FD8CAD9B70AA76327004B13"},
 {"fingerprint":"C28B23A00EFFAD65B705601E6B7E640EB41FF2B7"},
 {"fingerprint":"C3503770F465DA6F549F6065AFF7B8CFBF62C222"},
 {"fingerprint":"C3F1DC3E6B1FDDC5B09387ACCC06CD89843DD476"},
 {"fingerprint":"C4AEA05CF380BAD2230F193E083B8869B4A29937"},
 {"fingerprint":"C55AC4238C66CE8D00838572D563A284DBEF0228"},
 {"fingerprint":"C6B684F84AEA5E5E90CD77FF1E7BD33A3B9C74B5"},
 {"fingerprint":"CA94704217260E7483DA88719CACD7A94C564D5C"},
 {"fingerprint":"CD5A298960D0BE77ABBBBBA5177CE4615A9A223B"},
 {"fingerprint":"CFA45A4739FBE477D8C6500834B59F41A749A294"},
 {"fingerprint":"CFE1359C6D1462BFA70500935AD5F2A4AD80826E"},
 {"fingerprint":"D0F09FA43F68E134B9E56743797D040F647174D1","as_number":"AS39309"},
 {"fingerprint":"D329417643EF2B0B21E9876A397967A7F190CCA1"},
 {"fingerprint":"D3C6D2828C09806AF08D120CB3565D8C41B4383F"},
 {"fingerprint":"D5FAAC4138272BEE29EA4BA3F1981B25CB6B6F5F"},
 {"fingerprint":"D623B6311821F9DB62AD370ADA0A307BA2E26BAA"},
 {"fingerprint":"D6D6B6614C9EF2DAD13AC0C94487AD8ED3B6877F"},
 {"fingerprint":"DCAFAE7D9DDFDA41959A6E64D89383F9F3CEFE48"},
 {"fingerprint":"DD9B36139A546EFB43CBE1E18F399F02ECBD4EC6"},
 {"fingerprint":"DDFD587212E4E1905114377851FFAF6659F19823"},
 {"fingerprint":"E43A346CB81DDF364B6FF68235AFADBA0E8692B8"},
 {"fingerprint":"F012AD9A08A9E0B4A5C61155284FD795B553B361"},
 {"fingerprint":"F50C39BCA90ED9B9E37FB66696D19A74530115D6"},
 {"fingerprint":"F81C9B79150D85D78B4DF5D70A1789FBE0D608A4"},
 {"fingerprint":"FA16B46809F9ABEE2DB68293E6E400D217554155"},
 {"fingerprint":"FD4D401A1D3591653B7DA868A0B4D0754C242447"},
 {"fingerprint":"FDAED15C98CFE7A416E5676F614254F78406105C"}
 ],
 "bridges_published":"2018-08-17 11:56:51",
 "bridges":[
 ]}
 }}}

 https://oo-
 hetzner-03.torproject.org/details?as=000000&fields=as_number,fingerprint

 My theory is that when the GeoIP database does not contain information on
 an IP address but it did before, that information is not cleared from the
 details status but is cleared from the summary.

 I also noticed that two less hosts were "resolved" than "looked up" in the
 output stats for geoip. Maybe it is these two hosts. I'm not sure exactly
 what this means.

--
Ticket URL: <https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/ticket/27187>
Tor Bug Tracker & Wiki <https://trac.torproject.org/>
The Tor Project: anonymity online