[tor-bugs] #20461 [Applications/Tor Browser]: Ship “static cache” of intermediate CAs

[Tor Bug Tracker & Wiki]

#20461: Ship “static cache” of intermediate CAs
--------------------------------------+--------------------------
 Reporter:  nicoo                     |          Owner:  tbb-team
     Type:  enhancement               |         Status:  new
 Priority:  Medium                    |      Milestone:
Component:  Applications/Tor Browser  |        Version:
 Severity:  Normal                    |     Resolution:
 Keywords:                            |  Actual Points:
Parent ID:                            |         Points:
 Reviewer:                            |        Sponsor:
--------------------------------------+--------------------------

Comment (by nicoo):

 Log of the (asynchronous) discussion about this on Mozilla/#security:

 {{{
 12:55:46           ⤷ │ ulfr: I wanted to enquire about using TLS
 Observatory data to find
                      │ specific misconfigurations (typically, incomplete
 cert chains) that lead
                      │ to cert errors in Tor Browser (which doesn't cache
 subCAs, since that ca
                      │ be used as a supercookie), and check if some Tor
 exit nodes (ab)use that
                      │ for stealthy MitM
 12:56:56     freddyb │ (that's interesting. what wold also be interesting:
 a prepopulated subCA
                      │ cache)
 12:57:09       nicoo │ freddyb: Oooh, great idea
 12:57:47           ⤷ │ And TLS Obs data should have the most popular-
 amongst-broken-servers
                      │ subCAs
 12:57:57           ⤷ │ (Let's Encrypt, anyone?)
 13:02:03             │ nicoo hilights GeKo, as it is topically relevant
 13:02:15       nicoo │ GeKo: Does this sound like a good/sane idea ?
 14:27:43        ulfr │ nicoo: I don't capture that data directly (that
 would require a bit of
                      │ code to detect missing intermediates), but I can
 query for certs issued
                      │ by valid intermediates that have not passed
 validation.
 14:28:17           ⤷ │ the query gets a bit complicated though
 18:01:35        GeKo │ nicoo: why not? might be interesting to look at the
 data.
 19:47:43       nicoo │ GeKo: I was more asking about pre-seeding the TBB
 with a intermediary CA
                      │ “cache” to avoid spurious cert validation errors
 with incomplete chains
                      │ (and avoid letting users get used to clicking
 through those)
 19:54:20        ulfr │ or just automate intermediate retrieval using the
 AIA extension
 20:24:41       nicoo │ ulfr: Wouldn't that be slow, without caching?
 20:25:12           ⤷ │ (And with caching, I would assume the timing
 sidechannel can be used as a
                      │ supercookie)
 20:39:13       Peng_ │ Downloading an intermediate or two would be kind of
 slow -- especially
                      │ over Tor -- but "untrusted issuer" error pages are
 infinity slow.
 20:39:52           ⤷ │ Without caching? That sounds painful.
 20:40:13       nicoo │ Peng_: And they teach users terrible security
 practices, hence why I want
                      │ to do something about it
 20:40:15           ⤷ │ :V
 20:46:35        ulfr │ there something to be said for not encouraging bad
 practices
 20:46:47           ⤷ │ admins should learn to serve intermediates
 20:49:18       nicoo │ ulfr: Yes, but I doubt that the TBB userbase is
 large enough to push
                      │ non-broken practices
 20:49:50       nicoo │ OTOH, not “fixing” it (from a user perspective)
 seems like a security
                      │ issue to me.
 20:49:44       Peng_ │ If Firefox were changed to hard fail instead of
 accepting
                      │ misconfiguration when the intermediate is already
 cached... ;-)
 20:50:41       Peng_ │ Firefox is already being semi-forgiving and semi-
 encouraging bad
                      │ practices. But TBB can't afford to cache as
 generously and is getting the
                      │ short end of the stick.
 -- Tue, 25 Oct 2016 --
 06:39:36        GeKo │ nicoo: oh, okay. file a ticket on trac and get the
 discussion going?
 06:39:54           ⤷ │ it seems worthwhile to think about
 }}}

--
Ticket URL: <https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/ticket/20461#comment:1>
Tor Bug Tracker & Wiki <https://trac.torproject.org/>
The Tor Project: anonymity online