[tor-bugs] #1926 [Tor Relay]: Extra-info descriptors have corrupt {write, read}-history lines

Thu Jan 27 10:07:28 UTC 2011

#1926: Extra-info descriptors have corrupt {write,read}-history lines
-----------------------+----------------------------------------------------
 Reporter:  karsten    |       Owner:  karsten           
     Type:  defect     |      Status:  new               
 Priority:  minor      |   Milestone:  Tor: 0.2.2.x-final
Component:  Tor Relay  |     Version:                    
 Keywords:             |      Parent:                    
-----------------------+----------------------------------------------------

Comment(by qbi):

 I looked at all available data and tried to extract wrong dates. The table
 below lists my findings. Basically I extracted the (read|write)-history
 dates from the data and threw away the correct year. So you'll find
 sometimes entries from December in January entries. Those are in my
 opinion not wrong dates.

 My script also threw away double date entries. So there are cases where a
 date occurs on my than one day. So you'll find sometimes the same days on
 entries over weeks or even moths. One case is 2009-08-12. You can find it
 on each month between August 2007 and December 2009 (18 times). Other
 "special" dates are:

  * 2035-08-28, 2009-06-03, 2009-05-03 (6 entries in the table below)
  * 2001-12-31 (5 entries in the table below)
  * 2021-01-18, 2020-08-01, 2012-04-30, 2010-03-16, 2008-12-31, 2008-08-09,
 2008-05-30 (4 entries in the table below)
  * 2014-05-27, 2007-01-24, 2002-01-01 (3 entries in the table below)

 I have now a script running which extracts all descriptors with wrong
 dates. I'll attach it when it is finished.

 The maximum and minimum date is highlighted.

 || 02 || 2005 || 2000-01-01 ||

 || 03 || 2005 || ||

 || 04 || 2005 || 2000-01-07 ||

 || 05 || 2005 || ||

 || 06 || 2005 || ||

 || 07 || 2005 || ||

 || 08 || 2005 || ||

 || 09 || 2005 || 2002-09-01 ||

 || 10 || 2005 || 2002-11-29 ||

 || 11 || 2005 || ||
 || 12 || 2005 || ||
 || 01 || 2006 || 2005-12-07, 2005-12-30, 2005-12-31 ||
 || 02 || 2006 || ||
 || 03 || 2006 || ||
 || 04 || 2006 || 2002-04-24 ||
 || 05 || 2006 || 2007-05-27 ||
 || 06 || 2006 || 2007-05-27 ||
 || 07 || 2006 || ||
 || 08 || 2006 || 2007-08-10 ||
 || 09 || 2006 || 2008-09-08 ||
 || 10 || 2006 || 2007-01-24, 2010-07-17 ||
 || 11 || 2006 || 2007-01-24, 2007-01-26, 2007-07-16, 2007-12-06,
 2010-07-17 ||
 || 12 || 2006 || 2007-01-24, 2007-12-03, 2007-12-09, 2007-12-13,
 2007-12-20 ||
 || 01 || 2007 || 2006-12-30, 2006-12-31, 2021-01-18 ||
 || 02 || 2007 || 2014-05-27, 2021-01-18 ||
 || 03 || 2007 || 2009-05-03, 2009-06-03, 2010-03-16, 2014-05-27,
 2014-11-25, '''2035-08-28''' ||
 || 04 || 2007 || 2008-04-01, 2009-04-12, 2009-05-03, 2009-06-03,
 2010-03-16, 2014-05-27, 2014-11-25, 2021-01-18, 2021-03-31,
 '''2035-08-28''' ||
 || 05 || 2007 || 2008-05-30, 2009-02-16, 2009-05-03, 2009-06-03,
 2010-03-16, 2012-04-30, 2015-05-07, 2021-05-11, 2030-05-04,
 '''2035-08-28''' ||
 || 06 || 2007 || 2008-05-30, 2008-06-21, 2009-05-03, 2009-06-03,
 2010-03-16, 2012-04-30, 2013-06-18, 2017-06-03, 2027-06-09, 2030-05-04,
 '''2035-08-28''' ||
 || 07 || 2007 || 2008-05-03, 2008-05-30, 2008-06-21, 2008-07-01,
 2009-05-03, 2009-06-03, 2012-04-30, 2013-06-18, '''2035-08-28''' ||
 || 08 || 2007 || 2008-08-09, 2009-08-12, 1999-11-13, 2008-05-03,
 2008-05-30, 2008-08-09, 2008-08-17, 2009-05-03, 2009-06-03, 2009-08-12,
 2010-08-10, 2012-04-30, 2020-08-01, 2021-01-18, 2027-07-31,
 '''2035-08-28''' ||

 || 09 || 2007 || 1985-06-11, 2008-08-09, 2008-09-15, 2009-08-12,
 2020-08-01 ||
 || 10 || 2007 || 2008-08-09, 2009-08-12, 2011-01-01 ||
 || 11 || 2007 || 2009-08-12, 2020-08-01 ||
 || 12 || 2007 || 2009-08-12, 2020-08-01 ||
 || 01 || 2008 || 2009-08-12 ||
 || 02 || 2008 || 2009-08-12 ||
 || 03 || 2008 || 2009-08-12 ||
 || 04 || 2008 || 2004-08-26, 2009-08-12 ||
 || 05 || 2008 || 2001-01-01, 2009-08-12 ||
 || 06 || 2008 || 2007-01-01, 2009-08-12 ||
 || 07 || 2008 || 2009-08-12 ||
 || 08 || 2008 || 2009-08-12 ||
 || 09 || 2008 || 2009-08-12 ||
 || 10 || 2008 || 2007-10-26, 2009-08-12, 2009-10-29, 2015-07-19 ||
 || 11 || 2008 || 2009-08-12 ||
 || 12 || 2008 || 2009-01-01, 2009-08-12 ||
 || 01 || 2009 || 2001-12-31 ||
 || 02 || 2009 || 2001-12-31 ||
 || 03 || 2009 || ||
 || 04 || 2009 || ||
 || 05 || 2009 || ||
 || 06 || 2009 || ||

 || 07 || 2009 || 2028-09-23 ||
 || 08 || 2009 || ||
 || 09 || 2009 || 2006-01-03 ||
 || 10 || 2009 || ||
 || 11 || 2009 || 2004-11-01, 2006-12-26 ||
 || 12 || 2009 || 2010-01-01 ||
 || 01 || 2010 || 2009-10-07, 2009-11-30 ||
 || 02 || 2010 || 2003-12-31 ||
 || 03 || 2010 || 2008-12-31 ||
 || 04 || 2010 || 2008-01-02 ||
 || 05 || 2010 || '''1970-01-02''', 2001-12-31, 2009-10-07 ||
 || 06 || 2010 || 2003-01-01, 2009-01-01, 2009-12-21 ||
 || 07 || 2010 || 2001-01-01, 2001-07-12 ||
 || 08 || 2010 || 2002-01-01, 2003-01-01, 2007-12-31 ||
 || 09 || 2010 || 2002-01-01, 2003-01-12, 2008-12-31 ||
 || 10 || 2010 || 2000-01-01, 2000-01-02, 2006-08-15, 2008-12-31 ||
 || 11 || 2010 || 2001-12-31, 2002-01-03, 2009-08-17 ||
 || 12 || 2010 || 2001-12-31, 2002-12-30, 2009-03-11 ||
 || 01 || 2011 || 2002-01-01, 2002-01-23, 2010-01-16, 2010-09-05,
 2010-10-15, 2010-11-19, 2010-11-22, 2010-11-24, 2012-01-17 (also many days
 in 12/2010) ||

-- 
Ticket URL: <https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/ticket/1926#comment:7>
Tor Bug Tracker & Wiki <https://trac.torproject.org/>
The Tor Project: anonymity online