Hi.
Are you sure that the Tor process is still running and the ORport is still reachable? It seems like there were two Tor processes running on the same VPS with different fingerprints but on the same port (which is not possible. You can run two processes on the same IP address, but you have to assign different ORports for both Tor instances). Was this your set-up, or did you recently delete your old fingerprint and let Tor generate a new one? That might explain the duplicate entry in the consensus database. Could you post an excerpt of the log file(s) from for example the past day?
Kind regards,
Viktor