Hello all,

I would have to agree on this it appears that the DNS failure timeout is too low. I have more then enough bandwidth to host tor exit nodes, and my own unbound full recursive relay and yet i still get the timeout message 1-1.5%. Sometimes even weird amounts such as 40-50%.

I have been working with a few people on this issue and nothing we have tried has fixed this. The other thing is that all other servers i run have no issue with DNS timeouts. It appears to only be a TOR issue. I would even say that some DNS queries that TOR makes are to taken down sites, fake sites or non-existent domains.

On 2021-11-08 06:25 PM, Anders Trier Olesen wrote:

Hi Ibex

 

There's some discussion about this issue on #tor-relays. First of all, I actually don't think there's any problem with your Exit node. IMO 1.5% is expected and the current threshold is just too low (or the timeout too low).

 

We're hosting some fairly high capacity exit nodes (around 100mbit/s each), generating about 100 DNS queries/sec in total. We're also seeing around 1.5% failed DNS queries.

 

Here's what I think is going on:

For some queries (1.5%?), the authoritative DNS servers for the requested domain are not responding. Recursive DNS resolvers are by default more patient than the Tor software. Eventually the recursive resolver will return a 'SERVFAIL' to Tor, but by then, Tor has already given up, and counts it as a timeout.

 

One example of a domain that is currently (2021-11-08T23:40+01:00) failing to resolve because of its authoritative DNS servers being down is mzfgbh.com. Try running `dig +trace +additional mzfgbh.com` (for some reason, dig ignores the 'additional' section of one of the answers. Essentially the problem is that this query (and a few others) times out: `dig mzfgbh.com @1.1.1.20`).

 

 

On a related note, when this metric was introduced, we were seeing around 5-6% failed queries. The recursive DNS resolver we were using was hosted on the same IP as a guard node. Apparently many authoritative DNS servers block traffic from all Tor relays!

 

The most extreme example of this I found, is that the authoritative DNS servers for the entire .by ccTLD (Belarus) are blocking DNS requests from guard and exit nodes. This resulted in all <domain>.by queries timing out!

 

By moving our recursive DNS resolver to an IP not used by any Tor relays, the DNS timeouts fraction reported by Tor dropped from 5-6% to 1.5%.

 

The Tor relay guide should recommend running your recursive resolver (unbound) on a different IP than your exit: https://community.torproject.org/relay/setup/exit/

 

- Anders Trier Olesen

On Sat, Nov 6, 2021 at 5:53 PM Intrepid Ibex via tor-relays <tor-relays@lists.torproject.org> wrote:

Hi everybody,

I am new to tor (as server operator) and try to support the network by operating an exit node. 

Machine is running Ubuntu 20.04 - Tor 0.4.6.8. 

nyx is giving me a notive every 10 minutes or so: [NOTICE] General overload -> DNS timeouts (6) fraction 1.4742% is above threshold of 1.0000%

DNS on this machine however works perfectly. I told my tor browser to use my specific exit node, everything works fine.

Node is running since 4 days now. Load is as expected.

Thanks in advance for any help!

Ibex

--

Sent using MsgSafe.io's Free Plan

Private, encrypted, online communication

For everyone. www.msgsafe.io

_______________________________________________
tor-relays mailing list
tor-relays@lists.torproject.org
https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-relays

_______________________________________________
tor-relays mailing list
tor-relays@lists.torproject.org
https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-relays