• The Social Contract deals mainly with tools and such, however it does not include anything specific about the governance of the Tor Community and how the Tor Project will safeguard users/contributers rights during times of "stress". How are policies changed, who will be able to participate etc it is all missing. 
• The Code of Conduct specifically references Dir-Auth operators, but does not reference the Relay operators, but references "other valued participants". Who are these, and who are these explicitly not? Why are dir-auths listed and relay operators not?
• Statement of Values: it references Core Contributors, however does not define them.
• Membership does reference core contributers, so these should either be included or SoV should reference the MP. 
• Membership Policy  does list relay operators as Community Members so do they suddenly fall under the Code of Conduct? users are also part of the (wider) Tor Community, so they are also bound by the CoC? 
• Community Councel, does require "The Community Council needs to represent the breadth of the Tor community to function effectivly", this means gender is part of 'breath', wouldn't it be more logical to ensure the different "sub-communities" (ie dir-auths/relays/network/advocacy etc are represented at the TCC (so a functional 'breath')?
• The TCC is also limited to 'contributers', as the CC has a say over the Tor Community it would be more logical to widen the pool of potential CC members? (democratise the Tor Project instead of a handful 'in-crowds' making decisions?) Users are/are-not part of the Community (depending on the document you read) having those onboard could give a fresh perspective on the needed direction of the Tor Project, maybe?

Hello Tor Community,

I'm happy to announce that the Tor Project Community Policies have a new
website! You can visit our Policies website here:
<https://community.torproject.org/policies>. The website hosts the Tor
Project Community governance policies, including our Code of Conduct,
Social Contract, Relay Operators docs, and other important documents.

The website was generated using Onion MkDocs[1] and was part of our
project at Tor Hackweek[2]. We've also updated all links directing to
the old repository (gitweb.tpo) to the new website.

If you find any issue or have suggestions for improvements, please feel
invited to open a ticket in the Community/Policies repository:
<https://gitlab.torproject.org/tpo/community/policies>.

A special thanks to Rhatto and Lavamind for their support and assistance
with the deployment. I'm very happy to have a more accessible and user
friendly page for the Tor Community.

Best regards,
Gus

[1] Onion MkDocs: https://gitlab.torproject.org/tpo/web/onion-mkdocs
[2] Tor Hackweek: https://gitlab.torproject.org/tpo/community/hackweek/-/issues/13
--
The Tor Project
Community Team Lead

_______________________________________________
tor-project mailing list
tor-project@lists.torproject.org
https://lists.torproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tor-project