- tor-consensus-health - lists.torproject.org

Consensus issues
by gk＠torproject.org 13 Nov '25

13 Nov '25

NOTICE: The certificate of the following directory authority expires within the next three weeks: maatuska (2025-12-01 22-41-03) NOTICE: The following directory authorities are not reporting bandwidth scanner results: longclaw WARNING: The following authorities are an out of date version of tor: dannenberg (0.4.8.18), maatuska (0.4.8.19), longclaw (0.4.8.16), faravahar (0.4.8.16) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 44EDA428C37E8B4C0994F70C3F9705A46C7CF328 (with flag: moria1, gabelmoo, without flag: faravahar, longclaw)

1 0

Consensus issues
by gk＠torproject.org 12 Nov '25

12 Nov '25

NOTICE: The certificate of the following directory authority expires within the next three weeks: maatuska (2025-12-01 22-41-03) NOTICE: The following directory authorities are not reporting bandwidth scanner results: longclaw WARNING: The following authorities are an out of date version of tor: dannenberg (0.4.8.18), maatuska (0.4.8.19), longclaw (0.4.8.16), faravahar (0.4.8.16) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 44EDA428C37E8B4C0994F70C3F9705A46C7CF328 (with flag: gabelmoo, moria1, without flag: faravahar, longclaw)

1 0

Consensus issues
by gk＠torproject.org 12 Nov '25

12 Nov '25

NOTICE: The certificate of the following directory authority expires within the next three weeks: maatuska (2025-12-01 22-41-03) NOTICE: The following directory authorities are not reporting bandwidth scanner results: longclaw WARNING: The following authorities are an out of date version of tor: dannenberg (0.4.8.18), maatuska (0.4.8.19), longclaw (0.4.8.16), faravahar (0.4.8.16), Serge (0.4.8.19) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 44EDA428C37E8B4C0994F70C3F9705A46C7CF328 (with flag: gabelmoo, moria1, without flag: longclaw, faravahar)

1 0

Consensus issues
by gk＠torproject.org 12 Nov '25

12 Nov '25

NOTICE: Downloading the consensus from dannenberg took 15.0s. Median download time is 1.7s: moria1 => 1.1s, dizum => 0.5s, gabelmoo => 0.4s, dannenberg => 15.0s, maatuska => 5.2s, longclaw => 1.3s, bastet => 1.7s, faravahar => 1.7s NOTICE: The following directory authorities recommend other client versions than the consensus: gabelmoo -0.4.8.8 -0.4.8.12 -0.4.8.16 -0.4.8.6 -0.4.9.1-alpha -0.4.9.2-alpha -0.4.8.10 -0.4.8.14 -0.4.8.9 -0.4.8.13 -0.4.8.17 -0.4.8.5 -0.4.8.11 -0.4.8.15 -0.4.8.7 -0.4.8.18 -0.4.8.4 NOTICE: The following directory authorities recommend other server versions than the consensus: gabelmoo -0.4.8.8 -0.4.8.12 -0.4.8.16 -0.4.8.6 -0.4.9.1-alpha -0.4.9.2-alpha -0.4.8.10 -0.4.8.14 -0.4.8.9 -0.4.8.13 -0.4.8.17 -0.4.8.5 -0.4.8.11 -0.4.8.15 -0.4.8.19 -0.4.8.7 -0.4.8.18 -0.4.8.4 NOTICE: The certificate of the following directory authority expires within the next three weeks: maatuska (2025-12-01 22-41-03) NOTICE: The following directory authorities are not reporting bandwidth scanner results: longclaw NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 6D618A0B965EEE4EC992C3B63B6FB399104AE716 (with flag: longclaw, gabelmoo, faravahar, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 44EDA428C37E8B4C0994F70C3F9705A46C7CF328 (with flag: gabelmoo, without flag: faravahar, longclaw, moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 2B51193205D091CC80B904D65721FF8DCBE51C96 (with flag: longclaw, gabelmoo, faravahar, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 5E0911B78373594A2773E64A0C2CC82297C91416 (with flag: longclaw, gabelmoo, faravahar, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 61137FAC08E0AE62165D18FE8855CCCA26B6D631 (with flag: longclaw, gabelmoo, faravahar, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 3FC352E8EC6C01B13617BFBD807085D300FF0575 (with flag: longclaw, gabelmoo, faravahar, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 42A0440D2F42A634A06551AD0E8E53E0C573D948 (with flag: longclaw, gabelmoo, faravahar, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 944D41245E892EC71D068EC273D2FDC03E979FE0 (with flag: longclaw, gabelmoo, faravahar, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for E55162720E606DC33FF591A722E142AA5DFD9C03 (with flag: longclaw, gabelmoo, faravahar, without flag: moria1)

1 0

Consensus issues
by gk＠torproject.org 12 Nov '25

12 Nov '25

NOTICE: The following directory authorities recommend other client versions than the consensus: gabelmoo -0.4.8.11 -0.4.8.13 -0.4.8.5 -0.4.8.17 -0.4.8.18 -0.4.8.15 -0.4.8.4 -0.4.8.8 -0.4.8.6 -0.4.8.7 -0.4.8.9 -0.4.8.10 -0.4.8.12 -0.4.8.14 -0.4.8.16 -0.4.9.1-alpha -0.4.9.2-alpha NOTICE: The following directory authorities recommend other server versions than the consensus: gabelmoo -0.4.8.11 -0.4.8.13 -0.4.8.5 -0.4.8.17 -0.4.8.18 -0.4.8.15 -0.4.8.19 -0.4.8.4 -0.4.8.8 -0.4.8.6 -0.4.8.7 -0.4.8.9 -0.4.8.10 -0.4.8.12 -0.4.8.14 -0.4.8.16 -0.4.9.1-alpha -0.4.9.2-alpha NOTICE: The certificate of the following directory authority expires within the next three weeks: maatuska (2025-12-01 22-41-03) NOTICE: The following directory authorities are not reporting bandwidth scanner results: longclaw NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 61137FAC08E0AE62165D18FE8855CCCA26B6D631 (with flag: gabelmoo, longclaw, faravahar, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 2B51193205D091CC80B904D65721FF8DCBE51C96 (with flag: gabelmoo, longclaw, faravahar, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 6D618A0B965EEE4EC992C3B63B6FB399104AE716 (with flag: gabelmoo, longclaw, faravahar, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 3FC352E8EC6C01B13617BFBD807085D300FF0575 (with flag: gabelmoo, longclaw, faravahar, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for E55162720E606DC33FF591A722E142AA5DFD9C03 (with flag: gabelmoo, longclaw, faravahar, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 42A0440D2F42A634A06551AD0E8E53E0C573D948 (with flag: gabelmoo, longclaw, faravahar, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 5E0911B78373594A2773E64A0C2CC82297C91416 (with flag: gabelmoo, longclaw, faravahar, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 44EDA428C37E8B4C0994F70C3F9705A46C7CF328 (with flag: gabelmoo, without flag: longclaw, moria1, faravahar) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 944D41245E892EC71D068EC273D2FDC03E979FE0 (with flag: gabelmoo, longclaw, faravahar, without flag: moria1)

1 0

Consensus issues
by gk＠torproject.org 12 Nov '25

12 Nov '25

NOTICE: The following directory authorities recommend other client versions than the consensus: gabelmoo -0.4.8.8 -0.4.8.6 -0.4.8.4 -0.4.8.12 -0.4.8.9 -0.4.8.13 -0.4.8.5 -0.4.8.10 -0.4.8.14 -0.4.8.15 -0.4.8.16 -0.4.8.17 -0.4.8.18 -0.4.9.1-alpha -0.4.9.2-alpha -0.4.8.7 -0.4.8.11 NOTICE: The following directory authorities recommend other server versions than the consensus: gabelmoo -0.4.8.8 -0.4.8.6 -0.4.8.4 -0.4.8.12 -0.4.8.9 -0.4.8.13 -0.4.8.5 -0.4.8.10 -0.4.8.14 -0.4.8.15 -0.4.8.16 -0.4.8.17 -0.4.8.18 -0.4.9.1-alpha -0.4.9.2-alpha -0.4.8.19 -0.4.8.7 -0.4.8.11 NOTICE: The certificate of the following directory authority expires within the next three weeks: maatuska (2025-12-01 22-41-03) NOTICE: The following directory authorities are not reporting bandwidth scanner results: longclaw NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 944D41245E892EC71D068EC273D2FDC03E979FE0 (with flag: gabelmoo, faravahar, longclaw, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 5E0911B78373594A2773E64A0C2CC82297C91416 (with flag: gabelmoo, faravahar, longclaw, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 6D618A0B965EEE4EC992C3B63B6FB399104AE716 (with flag: gabelmoo, faravahar, longclaw, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 61137FAC08E0AE62165D18FE8855CCCA26B6D631 (with flag: gabelmoo, faravahar, longclaw, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 3FC352E8EC6C01B13617BFBD807085D300FF0575 (with flag: gabelmoo, faravahar, longclaw, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for E55162720E606DC33FF591A722E142AA5DFD9C03 (with flag: gabelmoo, faravahar, longclaw, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 44EDA428C37E8B4C0994F70C3F9705A46C7CF328 (with flag: gabelmoo, without flag: moria1, faravahar, longclaw) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 2B51193205D091CC80B904D65721FF8DCBE51C96 (with flag: gabelmoo, faravahar, longclaw, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 42A0440D2F42A634A06551AD0E8E53E0C573D948 (with flag: gabelmoo, faravahar, longclaw, without flag: moria1)

1 0

Consensus issues
by gk＠torproject.org 12 Nov '25

12 Nov '25

NOTICE: The following directory authorities recommend other client versions than the consensus: gabelmoo -0.4.9.1-alpha -0.4.9.2-alpha -0.4.8.7 -0.4.8.17 -0.4.8.4 -0.4.8.5 -0.4.8.8 -0.4.8.9 -0.4.8.10 -0.4.8.11 -0.4.8.12 -0.4.8.13 -0.4.8.14 -0.4.8.15 -0.4.8.16 -0.4.8.18 -0.4.8.6 NOTICE: The following directory authorities recommend other server versions than the consensus: gabelmoo -0.4.9.1-alpha -0.4.9.2-alpha -0.4.8.7 -0.4.8.17 -0.4.8.4 -0.4.8.5 -0.4.8.8 -0.4.8.9 -0.4.8.10 -0.4.8.11 -0.4.8.12 -0.4.8.13 -0.4.8.14 -0.4.8.15 -0.4.8.19 -0.4.8.16 -0.4.8.18 -0.4.8.6 NOTICE: The certificate of the following directory authority expires within the next three weeks: maatuska (2025-12-01 22-41-03) NOTICE: The following directory authorities are not reporting bandwidth scanner results: longclaw NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 944D41245E892EC71D068EC273D2FDC03E979FE0 (with flag: faravahar, longclaw, gabelmoo, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 44EDA428C37E8B4C0994F70C3F9705A46C7CF328 (with flag: gabelmoo, without flag: longclaw, faravahar, moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 3FC352E8EC6C01B13617BFBD807085D300FF0575 (with flag: faravahar, longclaw, gabelmoo, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 61137FAC08E0AE62165D18FE8855CCCA26B6D631 (with flag: faravahar, longclaw, gabelmoo, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 5E0911B78373594A2773E64A0C2CC82297C91416 (with flag: faravahar, longclaw, gabelmoo, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for F1913DAA5DA1497239F977EBB618ED5CD1932443 (with flag: faravahar, longclaw, gabelmoo, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 2B51193205D091CC80B904D65721FF8DCBE51C96 (with flag: faravahar, longclaw, gabelmoo, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 6D618A0B965EEE4EC992C3B63B6FB399104AE716 (with flag: faravahar, longclaw, gabelmoo, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 42A0440D2F42A634A06551AD0E8E53E0C573D948 (with flag: faravahar, longclaw, gabelmoo, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for E55162720E606DC33FF591A722E142AA5DFD9C03 (with flag: faravahar, longclaw, gabelmoo, without flag: moria1)

1 0

Consensus issues
by gk＠torproject.org 12 Nov '25

12 Nov '25

NOTICE: The following directory authorities recommend other client versions than the consensus: gabelmoo -0.4.9.2-alpha -0.4.9.1-alpha -0.4.8.8 -0.4.8.4 -0.4.8.10 -0.4.8.14 -0.4.8.6 -0.4.8.11 -0.4.8.12 -0.4.8.15 -0.4.8.16 -0.4.8.17 -0.4.8.18 -0.4.8.7 -0.4.8.5 -0.4.8.9 -0.4.8.13 NOTICE: The following directory authorities recommend other server versions than the consensus: gabelmoo -0.4.9.2-alpha -0.4.9.1-alpha -0.4.8.8 -0.4.8.4 -0.4.8.10 -0.4.8.14 -0.4.8.6 -0.4.8.11 -0.4.8.12 -0.4.8.15 -0.4.8.16 -0.4.8.17 -0.4.8.18 -0.4.8.19 -0.4.8.7 -0.4.8.5 -0.4.8.9 -0.4.8.13 NOTICE: The certificate of the following directory authority expires within the next three weeks: maatuska (2025-12-01 22-41-03) NOTICE: The following directory authorities are not reporting bandwidth scanner results: longclaw NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 3FC352E8EC6C01B13617BFBD807085D300FF0575 (with flag: longclaw, gabelmoo, faravahar, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 44EDA428C37E8B4C0994F70C3F9705A46C7CF328 (with flag: gabelmoo, without flag: longclaw, moria1, faravahar) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 944D41245E892EC71D068EC273D2FDC03E979FE0 (with flag: longclaw, gabelmoo, faravahar, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 6D618A0B965EEE4EC992C3B63B6FB399104AE716 (with flag: longclaw, gabelmoo, faravahar, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for F1913DAA5DA1497239F977EBB618ED5CD1932443 (with flag: longclaw, gabelmoo, faravahar, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 61137FAC08E0AE62165D18FE8855CCCA26B6D631 (with flag: longclaw, gabelmoo, faravahar, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 42A0440D2F42A634A06551AD0E8E53E0C573D948 (with flag: longclaw, gabelmoo, faravahar, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 2B51193205D091CC80B904D65721FF8DCBE51C96 (with flag: longclaw, gabelmoo, faravahar, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for E55162720E606DC33FF591A722E142AA5DFD9C03 (with flag: longclaw, gabelmoo, faravahar, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 5E0911B78373594A2773E64A0C2CC82297C91416 (with flag: longclaw, gabelmoo, faravahar, without flag: moria1)

1 0

Consensus issues
by gk＠torproject.org 12 Nov '25

12 Nov '25

NOTICE: The following directory authorities recommend other client versions than the consensus: gabelmoo -0.4.8.17 -0.4.8.14 -0.4.8.18 -0.4.8.6 -0.4.8.5 -0.4.8.8 -0.4.8.7 -0.4.8.4 -0.4.8.9 -0.4.8.10 -0.4.9.1-alpha -0.4.9.2-alpha -0.4.8.11 -0.4.8.13 -0.4.8.15 -0.4.8.16 -0.4.8.12 NOTICE: The following directory authorities recommend other server versions than the consensus: gabelmoo -0.4.8.17 -0.4.8.14 -0.4.8.18 -0.4.8.6 -0.4.8.5 -0.4.8.8 -0.4.8.7 -0.4.8.4 -0.4.8.9 -0.4.8.10 -0.4.9.1-alpha -0.4.9.2-alpha -0.4.8.11 -0.4.8.13 -0.4.8.15 -0.4.8.19 -0.4.8.16 -0.4.8.12 NOTICE: The certificate of the following directory authority expires within the next three weeks: maatuska (2025-12-01 22-41-03) NOTICE: The following directory authorities are not reporting bandwidth scanner results: longclaw NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 6D618A0B965EEE4EC992C3B63B6FB399104AE716 (with flag: faravahar, gabelmoo, longclaw, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 44EDA428C37E8B4C0994F70C3F9705A46C7CF328 (with flag: gabelmoo, without flag: faravahar, longclaw, moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 3FC352E8EC6C01B13617BFBD807085D300FF0575 (with flag: faravahar, gabelmoo, longclaw, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for E55162720E606DC33FF591A722E142AA5DFD9C03 (with flag: faravahar, gabelmoo, longclaw, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 61137FAC08E0AE62165D18FE8855CCCA26B6D631 (with flag: faravahar, gabelmoo, longclaw, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 2B51193205D091CC80B904D65721FF8DCBE51C96 (with flag: faravahar, gabelmoo, longclaw, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 5E0911B78373594A2773E64A0C2CC82297C91416 (with flag: faravahar, gabelmoo, longclaw, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 944D41245E892EC71D068EC273D2FDC03E979FE0 (with flag: faravahar, gabelmoo, longclaw, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 42A0440D2F42A634A06551AD0E8E53E0C573D948 (with flag: faravahar, gabelmoo, longclaw, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for F1913DAA5DA1497239F977EBB618ED5CD1932443 (with flag: faravahar, gabelmoo, longclaw, without flag: moria1)

1 0

Consensus issues
by gk＠torproject.org 12 Nov '25

12 Nov '25

NOTICE: Downloading the consensus from maatuska took 18.2s. Median download time is 1.6s: moria1 => 1.1s, dizum => 0.4s, gabelmoo => 0.5s, dannenberg => 0.5s, maatuska => 18.2s, longclaw => 1.7s, bastet => 1.6s, faravahar => 1.7s NOTICE: The following directory authorities recommend other client versions than the consensus: gabelmoo -0.4.8.13 -0.4.8.5 -0.4.8.14 -0.4.8.15 -0.4.8.16 -0.4.8.17 -0.4.8.18 -0.4.8.6 -0.4.8.4 -0.4.8.7 -0.4.8.10 -0.4.8.8 -0.4.8.12 -0.4.9.1-alpha -0.4.8.11 -0.4.9.2-alpha -0.4.8.9 NOTICE: The following directory authorities recommend other server versions than the consensus: gabelmoo -0.4.8.13 -0.4.8.5 -0.4.8.14 -0.4.8.15 -0.4.8.16 -0.4.8.17 -0.4.8.18 -0.4.8.19 -0.4.8.6 -0.4.8.4 -0.4.8.7 -0.4.8.10 -0.4.8.8 -0.4.8.12 -0.4.9.1-alpha -0.4.8.11 -0.4.9.2-alpha -0.4.8.9 NOTICE: The certificate of the following directory authority expires within the next three weeks: maatuska (2025-12-01 22-41-03) NOTICE: The following directory authorities are not reporting bandwidth scanner results: longclaw NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 44EDA428C37E8B4C0994F70C3F9705A46C7CF328 (with flag: gabelmoo, without flag: faravahar, moria1, longclaw) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 42A0440D2F42A634A06551AD0E8E53E0C573D948 (with flag: gabelmoo, faravahar, longclaw, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 61137FAC08E0AE62165D18FE8855CCCA26B6D631 (with flag: gabelmoo, faravahar, longclaw, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for E55162720E606DC33FF591A722E142AA5DFD9C03 (with flag: gabelmoo, faravahar, longclaw, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 2B51193205D091CC80B904D65721FF8DCBE51C96 (with flag: gabelmoo, faravahar, longclaw, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 6D618A0B965EEE4EC992C3B63B6FB399104AE716 (with flag: gabelmoo, faravahar, longclaw, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 944D41245E892EC71D068EC273D2FDC03E979FE0 (with flag: gabelmoo, faravahar, longclaw, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for F1913DAA5DA1497239F977EBB618ED5CD1932443 (with flag: gabelmoo, faravahar, longclaw, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 5E0911B78373594A2773E64A0C2CC82297C91416 (with flag: gabelmoo, faravahar, longclaw, without flag: moria1) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 3FC352E8EC6C01B13617BFBD807085D300FF0575 (with flag: gabelmoo, faravahar, longclaw, without flag: moria1)

1 0