- tor-consensus-health - lists.torproject.org

Consensus issues
by gk＠torproject.org 14 May '20

14 May '20

ERROR: Unable to retrieve the consensus from dannenberg (http://193.23.244.244:80/tor/status-vote/current/consensus) Failed to download from http://193.23.244.244:80/tor/status-vote/current/consensus: 60.0 second timeout reached NOTICE: Downloading the consensus from Faravahar took 22.0s. Median download time is 1.6s: maatuska => 1.4s, longclaw => 1.6s, dizum => 0.9s, bastet => 2.1s, gabelmoo => 1.0s, moria1 => 1.8s, Faravahar => 22.0s ERROR: Unable to retrieve the vote from bastet (http://204.13.164.118:80/tor/status-vote/current/authority) Failed to download from http://204.13.164.118:80/tor/status-vote/current/authority (HTTPError): Directory busy, try again later ERROR: Unable to retrieve the vote from dannenberg (http://193.23.244.244:80/tor/status-vote/current/authority) Failed to download from http://193.23.244.244:80/tor/status-vote/current/authority: 60.0 second timeout reached NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for A5B682E846615088362A3B2BD11C353C84778659 (with flag: moria1, longclaw, maatuska, Faravahar, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 3BADB3EFFB87534736BFAC9A2024AB78401BDBC3 (with flag: moria1, longclaw, maatuska, Faravahar, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for F912C0A30DC9CBD4E7BA566C235DA194C4623EC0 (with flag: moria1, longclaw, maatuska, Faravahar, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 53FF368902D124FA9A806D149AF22C3A6357B150 (with flag: Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo, not in vote: moria1, maatuska) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 9AD12F0E3CC871D59ACA14BB4076CDD8CB28DE57 (with flag: moria1, longclaw, maatuska, Faravahar, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for FBBC3BD58B471F6227DC0F05265C6A37C770905F (with flag: moria1, longclaw, maatuska, Faravahar, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 9E9C2223EA179F52BA73A24BFDE2E44DCA468EEF (with flag: moria1, longclaw, maatuska, Faravahar, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 296B2178FD742AB35AB20C9ADF04D5DFD3D407EB (with flag: moria1, longclaw, maatuska, Faravahar, without flag: gabelmoo)

1 0

Consensus issues
by gk＠torproject.org 14 May '20

14 May '20

ERROR: Unable to retrieve the consensus from bastet (http://204.13.164.118:80/tor/status-vote/current/consensus) Failed to download from http://204.13.164.118:80/tor/status-vote/current/consensus (HTTPError): Directory busy, try again later ERROR: Unable to retrieve the consensus from moria1 (http://128.31.0.39:9131/tor/status-vote/current/consensus) Failed to download from http://128.31.0.39:9131/tor/status-vote/current/consensus (URLError): Connection refused ERROR: Unable to retrieve the vote from moria1 (http://128.31.0.39:9131/tor/status-vote/current/authority) Failed to download from http://128.31.0.39:9131/tor/status-vote/current/authority (HTTPError): Not found NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for A5B682E846615088362A3B2BD11C353C84778659 (with flag: longclaw, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 3BADB3EFFB87534736BFAC9A2024AB78401BDBC3 (with flag: longclaw, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for F912C0A30DC9CBD4E7BA566C235DA194C4623EC0 (with flag: longclaw, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 5AD1D535373C05BB1624BD2A76DDE713E974240E (with flag: longclaw, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 53FF368902D124FA9A806D149AF22C3A6357B150 (with flag: dannenberg, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo, not in vote: maatuska) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 9AD12F0E3CC871D59ACA14BB4076CDD8CB28DE57 (with flag: longclaw, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for FBBC3BD58B471F6227DC0F05265C6A37C770905F (with flag: longclaw, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 9E9C2223EA179F52BA73A24BFDE2E44DCA468EEF (with flag: longclaw, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 296B2178FD742AB35AB20C9ADF04D5DFD3D407EB (with flag: longclaw, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, without flag: gabelmoo)

1 0

Consensus issues
by gk＠torproject.org 13 May '20

13 May '20

ERROR: Unable to retrieve the consensus from bastet (http://204.13.164.118:80/tor/status-vote/current/consensus) Failed to download from http://204.13.164.118:80/tor/status-vote/current/consensus (HTTPError): Directory busy, try again later ERROR: Unable to retrieve the vote from bastet (http://204.13.164.118:80/tor/status-vote/current/authority) Failed to download from http://204.13.164.118:80/tor/status-vote/current/authority (HTTPError): Directory busy, try again later NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for A5B682E846615088362A3B2BD11C353C84778659 (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 3BADB3EFFB87534736BFAC9A2024AB78401BDBC3 (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for F912C0A30DC9CBD4E7BA566C235DA194C4623EC0 (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 5AD1D535373C05BB1624BD2A76DDE713E974240E (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 53FF368902D124FA9A806D149AF22C3A6357B150 (with flag: dannenberg, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo, not in vote: moria1, maatuska) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 9AD12F0E3CC871D59ACA14BB4076CDD8CB28DE57 (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for FBBC3BD58B471F6227DC0F05265C6A37C770905F (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 9E9C2223EA179F52BA73A24BFDE2E44DCA468EEF (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 296B2178FD742AB35AB20C9ADF04D5DFD3D407EB (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo)

1 0

Consensus issues
by gk＠torproject.org 13 May '20

13 May '20

NOTICE: Downloading the consensus from longclaw took 13.5s. Median download time is 1.6s: maatuska => 1.1s, longclaw => 13.5s, dizum => 0.9s, bastet => 1.9s, gabelmoo => 0.9s, moria1 => 1.7s, dannenberg => 1.0s, Faravahar => 1.6s ERROR: Unable to retrieve the vote from bastet (http://204.13.164.118:80/tor/status-vote/current/authority) Failed to download from http://204.13.164.118:80/tor/status-vote/current/authority (HTTPError): Directory busy, try again later NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for A5B682E846615088362A3B2BD11C353C84778659 (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 3BADB3EFFB87534736BFAC9A2024AB78401BDBC3 (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for F912C0A30DC9CBD4E7BA566C235DA194C4623EC0 (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 5AD1D535373C05BB1624BD2A76DDE713E974240E (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 53FF368902D124FA9A806D149AF22C3A6357B150 (with flag: dannenberg, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo, not in vote: moria1, maatuska) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 9AD12F0E3CC871D59ACA14BB4076CDD8CB28DE57 (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for FBBC3BD58B471F6227DC0F05265C6A37C770905F (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 9E9C2223EA179F52BA73A24BFDE2E44DCA468EEF (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 296B2178FD742AB35AB20C9ADF04D5DFD3D407EB (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo)

1 0

Consensus issues
by gk＠torproject.org 12 May '20

12 May '20

ERROR: Unable to retrieve the vote from bastet (http://204.13.164.118:80/tor/status-vote/current/authority) Failed to download from http://204.13.164.118:80/tor/status-vote/current/authority (HTTPError): Directory busy, try again later NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for A5B682E846615088362A3B2BD11C353C84778659 (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 3BADB3EFFB87534736BFAC9A2024AB78401BDBC3 (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for F912C0A30DC9CBD4E7BA566C235DA194C4623EC0 (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 5AD1D535373C05BB1624BD2A76DDE713E974240E (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 9AD12F0E3CC871D59ACA14BB4076CDD8CB28DE57 (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for FBBC3BD58B471F6227DC0F05265C6A37C770905F (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 9E9C2223EA179F52BA73A24BFDE2E44DCA468EEF (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 296B2178FD742AB35AB20C9ADF04D5DFD3D407EB (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo)

1 0

Consensus issues
by gk＠torproject.org 12 May '20

12 May '20

ERROR: Unable to retrieve the consensus from bastet (http://204.13.164.118:80/tor/status-vote/current/consensus) Failed to download from http://204.13.164.118:80/tor/status-vote/current/consensus (HTTPError): Directory busy, try again later NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for A5B682E846615088362A3B2BD11C353C84778659 (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 3BADB3EFFB87534736BFAC9A2024AB78401BDBC3 (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for F912C0A30DC9CBD4E7BA566C235DA194C4623EC0 (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 5AD1D535373C05BB1624BD2A76DDE713E974240E (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 53FF368902D124FA9A806D149AF22C3A6357B150 (with flag: dannenberg, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo, not in vote: moria1, maatuska) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 9AD12F0E3CC871D59ACA14BB4076CDD8CB28DE57 (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for FBBC3BD58B471F6227DC0F05265C6A37C770905F (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 9E9C2223EA179F52BA73A24BFDE2E44DCA468EEF (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 296B2178FD742AB35AB20C9ADF04D5DFD3D407EB (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo)

1 0

Consensus issues
by gk＠torproject.org 11 May '20

11 May '20

ERROR: Unable to retrieve the consensus from bastet (http://204.13.164.118:80/tor/status-vote/current/consensus) Failed to download from http://204.13.164.118:80/tor/status-vote/current/consensus (HTTPError): Directory busy, try again later ERROR: Unable to retrieve the vote from bastet (http://204.13.164.118:80/tor/status-vote/current/authority) Failed to download from http://204.13.164.118:80/tor/status-vote/current/authority (HTTPError): Directory busy, try again later NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for A5B682E846615088362A3B2BD11C353C84778659 (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 3BADB3EFFB87534736BFAC9A2024AB78401BDBC3 (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for F912C0A30DC9CBD4E7BA566C235DA194C4623EC0 (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 5AD1D535373C05BB1624BD2A76DDE713E974240E (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 53FF368902D124FA9A806D149AF22C3A6357B150 (with flag: dannenberg, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo, not in vote: moria1, maatuska) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 9AD12F0E3CC871D59ACA14BB4076CDD8CB28DE57 (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for FBBC3BD58B471F6227DC0F05265C6A37C770905F (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 9E9C2223EA179F52BA73A24BFDE2E44DCA468EEF (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 296B2178FD742AB35AB20C9ADF04D5DFD3D407EB (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo)

1 0

Consensus issues
by gk＠torproject.org 11 May '20

11 May '20

ERROR: Unable to retrieve the vote from bastet (http://204.13.164.118:80/tor/status-vote/current/authority) Failed to download from http://204.13.164.118:80/tor/status-vote/current/authority (HTTPError): Directory busy, try again later NOTICE: The following directory authorities recommend other client versions than the consensus: moria1 +0.4.3.5 NOTICE: The following directory authorities recommend other server versions than the consensus: moria1 +0.4.3.5 NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for A5B682E846615088362A3B2BD11C353C84778659 (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 3BADB3EFFB87534736BFAC9A2024AB78401BDBC3 (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for F912C0A30DC9CBD4E7BA566C235DA194C4623EC0 (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 5AD1D535373C05BB1624BD2A76DDE713E974240E (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 53FF368902D124FA9A806D149AF22C3A6357B150 (with flag: dannenberg, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo, not in vote: moria1, maatuska) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 9AD12F0E3CC871D59ACA14BB4076CDD8CB28DE57 (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for FBBC3BD58B471F6227DC0F05265C6A37C770905F (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 9E9C2223EA179F52BA73A24BFDE2E44DCA468EEF (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 296B2178FD742AB35AB20C9ADF04D5DFD3D407EB (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo)

1 0

Consensus issues
by gk＠torproject.org 11 May '20

11 May '20

ERROR: Unable to retrieve the vote from bastet (http://204.13.164.118:80/tor/status-vote/current/authority) Failed to download from http://204.13.164.118:80/tor/status-vote/current/authority (HTTPError): Directory busy, try again later NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for A5B682E846615088362A3B2BD11C353C84778659 (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 3BADB3EFFB87534736BFAC9A2024AB78401BDBC3 (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for F912C0A30DC9CBD4E7BA566C235DA194C4623EC0 (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 5AD1D535373C05BB1624BD2A76DDE713E974240E (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 53FF368902D124FA9A806D149AF22C3A6357B150 (with flag: dannenberg, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo, not in vote: moria1, maatuska) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 9AD12F0E3CC871D59ACA14BB4076CDD8CB28DE57 (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for FBBC3BD58B471F6227DC0F05265C6A37C770905F (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 9E9C2223EA179F52BA73A24BFDE2E44DCA468EEF (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 296B2178FD742AB35AB20C9ADF04D5DFD3D407EB (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo)

1 0

Consensus issues
by gk＠torproject.org 11 May '20

11 May '20

NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for A5B682E846615088362A3B2BD11C353C84778659 (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 3BADB3EFFB87534736BFAC9A2024AB78401BDBC3 (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for F912C0A30DC9CBD4E7BA566C235DA194C4623EC0 (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 5AD1D535373C05BB1624BD2A76DDE713E974240E (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 53FF368902D124FA9A806D149AF22C3A6357B150 (with flag: dannenberg, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo, not in vote: moria1, maatuska) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 9AD12F0E3CC871D59ACA14BB4076CDD8CB28DE57 (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for FBBC3BD58B471F6227DC0F05265C6A37C770905F (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 9E9C2223EA179F52BA73A24BFDE2E44DCA468EEF (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) NOTICE: Authorities disagree about the BadExit flag for 296B2178FD742AB35AB20C9ADF04D5DFD3D407EB (with flag: moria1, dannenberg, maatuska, Faravahar, longclaw, without flag: gabelmoo) WARNING: Unable to reach the ORPort of bastet (204.13.164.118, port 443): [Errno 110] Connection timed out

1 0