[tor-talk] Tor and Google error / CAPTCHAs.
Joe Btfsplk
joebtfsplk at gmx.com
Tue Oct 4 04:21:27 UTC 2016
On 10/3/2016 2:09 AM, Alec Muffett wrote:
> On 3 October 2016 at 01:40, <bancfc at openmailbox.org> wrote:
>
> While outreach and cooperation with some companies may work, do you not
>> consider that a sizable number of sites will always block anonymous traffic
>> simply because they can not monetize it with targeted ads?
>
>
> Ah! That delightful old argument.
>
> I've heard it a lot, and I am afraid that it is all of groundless,
> incorrect and demonstrably silly. :-)
>
>
> In three bullets:
>
> 1) If less than 0.1% of the people who use your site do so "anonymously",
> the amount of ad-revenue associated with them is negligible. There are
> bigger leaks to plug.
Possibly partly true, but I consider other reasons that sites
(essentially) block users, sometimes lumped with Tor users.
"You can't use our site unless you allow cookies" WTH - Really? Why is
that? Could it be that certain tracking - not just on that domain -
won't work unless cookies are allowed?
"You're using ad blocking software. Our site won't work correctly, if
at all." [see #3 below]
On many sites, Tor is lumped together with ad and script blocking
browsers - unprofitable and often largely untrackable. We're no longer
talking about a tiny % of users.
>
> 2) In my experience the "blocking" that companies do to Tor (and similar)
> is 100% grounded in the threats from spam, scraping, testing phished
> credentials, and other forms of bad behaviour.
Are you saying that TBB is the only browser used for malicious purposes?
:) That other browsers can't be or aren't adapted by skilled users for
similar malicious or unwanted behavior?
I don't really buy that. For one thing, it's too slow. Even using a
plain browser with a proxy - which I rarely do - I'm seldom blocked.
Disregarding financial sites. But Tor is blocked all the time on these
same sites. They don't say you're blocked, you just can't get in or use
the site - even with scripts allowed. I can use many federal govt sites
just fine with TBB, but I can't do a Google search? Talk about scraping!
>
> 3) I would bet a substantial amount of beer that anonymous proxy networks
> are negligible threats to advertising revenue in comparison to "People on
> the Clearnet who use AdBlock+".
I can't speak for everyone, but if ads were - still - presented as just
ads, and trackers weren't trying to record everything you do across the
entire internet, sell that data, provide it to the govt - on request,
for a fee, then I wouldn't mind allowing small ads. WAY back in the
day, I'd click on some ads of free sites that I wanted to support. That
was way before things got to present practices. Now, there's no way I'll
let them record every move. My medical issues, political interests,
legal matters...
More information about the tor-talk
mailing list